FM*** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@emo777 said: You are right on 6%. Yes, we had discounted payback and it was a right option. Dont remember anything on MM. Treasury bills are on discount. Jenny did you mark money deposit as wrong?Good, I'm right on the treasury bills but, because I can't remember the rest of the options I don't know whether got the answer right - I hate those MCQs!!! Which was the money deposit question? Am so gutted ACCA aren't going to publish the answers to these!!
@emo777 said: Now i see where Jenny and some others could face an issue. I think you calculated advance on trade receivables, instead of total credit salesEven if I've done that part wrong still worth 5/7 I'd presume
James, i think you mean 35/360*0.02*0.8*26500000 ? ;)
They said that money deposit are short koans between organisations such as banks
Fahad, 9.71 and 10.5 . Jenny, you agree?
@emo777 said: Now i see where Jenny and some others could face an issue. I think you calculated advance on trade receivables, instead of total credit salesThe advance was calculated at 80% of invoices raised - ie whole revenue of $27m odd. Then interest charged on that amount at 7% so cost to us is advance x 2% (ie difference between factor interest and our interest rates). I think that the problem is that past questions have stated that the factor advance is based on receivables balance - which I always thought was daft because that's not the case in real life. I'm fairly sure on this because I reread the question several times to be sure.
I give up ha!
I'm feeling a 49/100 here.
Hope my MCQ guesses were good, frustrating I made silly mistakes.
Why were MCQ's all on 1 area?
@emo777 said: They said that money deposit are short koans between organisations such as banksCan't for the life of me remember what I put for that one. Bugger!
Did you multiply it by 35/360?
@jamesuk19 said: I give up ha! I'm feeling a 49/100 here. Hope my MCQ guesses were good, frustrating I made silly mistakes. Why were MCQ's all on 1 area?Exactly!!! I thought the point was to cover a good range of the syllabus but they didn't. Loads were left out and it was all on markets etc. Nothing like practice ones - and I did plenty!!
@emo777 said: Fahad, 9.71 and 10.5 . Jenny, you agree?Bugger, can't remember my figures for that one at all!!
@emo777 said: Did you multiply it by 35/360?Multiply what by 35/360?
to get the factors advace charges I did the following;
26,500 @ 80% = 21,200
21,200 @ 2% = 424k
35/360*26500000*0.02*0.8 this is the correct solution. I just checked revision kit, i think me and james got this one right
but isn't Jenny saying that the revision kit asks you to do it on the receivables balance? whereas the exam didn't?
This was took from bpp book and revision kit, in any case, there is only one just correct solution :))
@mfc2476 said: but isn't Jenny saying that the revision kit asks you to do it on the receivables balance? whereas the exam didn't?Exactly - the whole point of these questions is not to be exactly the same each time. My calculation the same as yours.
@emo777 said: 35/360*26500000*0.02*0.8 this is the correct solution. I just checked revision kit, i think me and james got this one rightExactly what I did for the extra interest part. And I arrived at $19K net cost. Did u use a net benefit/net cost approach? I asked bcos there is another way to do it in full by calculating all the costs in full and not just the differentials. I'm sure some people mixed both methods up somehow
Really looking forward to seeing John's suggested answers on this one but we might have a wait if ACCA doesn't put the questions for Section B up til next week.
Q4 - no-one has really discussed that yet (apart from the wordy bit on capital structure theory).
I had a capital loss for shareholders - how about you all?
@afuyegallas said: Exactly what I did for the extra interest part. And I arrived at $19K net cost. Did u use a net benefit/net cost approach? I asked bcos there is another way to do it in full by calculating all the costs in full and not just the differentials. I'm sure some people mixed both methods up somehowIt's not mixing up methods - we all did a cost/benefit approach - we just have different answers for the advance interest based on either using receivables balance or invoices raised.
The only mistake i made in question 4, i got new EPS, but forgot to divide it by a new number of shares after rights issue. Will get the marks for the method though
Factor was acceptable.
Benefit 50000 Admn cost
bad debt 1×2675000×70
recevable were more then 4 million revised 35/360×26750000 the difference was above a million and multiple 5% cost of it saving.
Cost
0.0075×267500000
Revised receivable 35/360×26750000×2%
Acceptable
But why and how did you get 19k net cost?
@jenny3549 said: Exactly!!! I thought the point was to cover a good range of the syllabus but they didn't. Loads were left out and it was all on markets etc. Nothing like practice ones - and I did plenty!!You seem pretty spot on methods and marks Jenny, you'll pass comfortably! But I don't think there was 5 questions on MCQ's to do with WACC, Inventory, Working Capital, investment appraisal etc, 1 little FX. I know next time if I need to resit September, I'm going big on theory and just try to learn the textbook. Which considering it's meant to be a practical exam doesn't really help you, disappointing from acca. What's even more frustrating is they don't release the questions for section A.
@emo777 said: The only mistake i made in question 4, i got new EPS, but forgot to divide it by a new number of shares after rights issue. Will get the marks for the method thoughProbably only 1/2 mark lost. Wasn't sure on this one whether there was enough to justify 8 marks since it wasn't asking for discussion so hoping my calculations were enough.
Yeah, i divided it by old number of shares :/ then multiplied it by current p/e ration to compare with theoretical ex rights price. Because my new eps was incorrect, the comparison should be wrong as well. But this was the only issue
@jamesuk19 said: You seem pretty spot on methods and marks Jenny, you'll pass comfortably! But I don't think there was 5 questions on MCQ's to do with WACC, Inventory, Working Capital, investment appraisal etc, 1 little FX. I know next time if I need to resit September, I'm going big on theory and just try to learn the textbook. Which considering it's meant to be a practical exam doesn't really help you, disappointing from acca. What's even more frustrating is they don't release the questions for section A.True! Was so disappointed with Section A - I did the December exam as final practice yesterday and got all the MCQs right - not a chance on this one - am scoring myself 10/20 to be on the safe side as the Law of Sod says the ones I was unsure of will all be wrong! Considering what a big part of the syllabus cost of capital is I can't believe, that with no WACC in B, there was so little in A to make up for it! Nearly fell off my chair to see Baumol though instead of Miller Orr - but since the method is the EOQ basically maybe they count that as a two for one on working capital.
@jenny3549 said: It's not mixing up methods - we all did a cost/benefit approach - we just have different answers for the advance interest based on either using receivables balance or invoices raised.I definitely got the calc's wrong by the looks of it. I calculated the factoring cost on the receivables *80% - but at 7%, not 2%. Didn't think about the 5% finance cost to net against the advance from the factoring company. Although I concluded that the factoring was not worthwhile , hopefully I get some method marks for the other calculations :-)
guys i think we r just wasting time talking about part b..part b questions was easy enough depending on ones preparation. and it doesnt really matter if we get a few things wrong..as we will still get most of the marks for methods and calculations..having said that i dont know what to expect from acca anymore. so lets talk about part a guys where i think most of us had serious problem as questions were not only tricky some of them were not even in the study text.i would really appreciate if any of u think u done quite alright in sec a then pls come forward and share the answer with us. thnk u
I completely messed up Q4. Did a few calculations which I'm hoping might pick up a mark or two. I calculated a TERP, was that neccessary? worked out a P/E ratio, was that neccessary? not a clue.

