FM*** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@jenny3549 said: Exactly as I did. Equity costs more than debt so increasing equity and decreasing debt will not optimise structure according to any of the theories.I started to go on about that, MM how debt is cheaper than equity as long as you don't have too much. Could you not argue they had too much debt either, so selling the debt off is not necessarily a bad thing from the other viewpoint?
@usamaniaz said: Do u guys know when the answers will be uploaded by opentuition team. Last sitting they updated the F5 one the very next day??I suppose it depends on whether they work weekends - ACCA I mean. If they don't then the questions won't be published til next week and OT can't do suggested answers til they see the questions. Fingers crossed for ACCA working tomorrow!
1) all three choices were financial intermediaries
2) factoring improves efficiency of trade receivables management in a company
3 market segmentation explains kinks in yield curves
4) money deposits are short term loans between banks, and this option was wrong
5) beta of debt understates financial risk, this was also wrong
6) borrowers buy futures and sell them later, this option was wrong
7) share options always reward good performance, this option was also wring
8) expected net present values are used for projects with several outcomes ONCE, this was incorrect as we know that expected values fo occur during many times, not just once
@emo777 said: You already replied to Mohammed. ThanksNo worries - we cross in the ether!
@jamesuk19 said: I started to go on about that, MM how debt is cheaper than equity as long as you don't have too much. Could you not argue they had too much debt either, so selling the debt off is not necessarily a bad thing from the other viewpoint?You could - financial risk reduced could lead to fall in required return from equity investors etc. I think that often, with the discursive parts, the marking scheme says things like 'one mark per relevant point' so if the marker thinks it's relevant you get marks.
@gtavicecity said: It is surprising to see you guys are just discussing Part B, though part A is the deciding factor in your success. Lets share answers to mcqs.We are trying but they are hard to remember all the options for each answer so hard to say what was the right one. B is easier both because you can remember the questions because you spent longer on them and they weren't the nightmare A was!
Most of the mcqs were from market and treasury function :-/
29 for price
@nitrous83 said: 29 for priceQuestion 5 NPV - what was your calculation to arrive at this figure?
Hey guys, any sort of reply appreciated
for q1 I wrote so much. A page of calcs explaining and a page of info. Just hope it's enough.
Didn't like q2= think I got the theory but ok though
Q3 the factor. I said that they would be losing 33% of their income with costs from factor and that if they focused on negotiation with customers stating they need to talk credit days. Talked about the need for business to get receivables days down from 60 to 40.
Question 4 - honestly didn't mind this question.the only thing I didn't do was compare both situations. (I calculated the share rights issue and the calcs but didn't compare to not)
However I used a lot of expinaitiom (1page to explain. Capital structure. Talked traditional view, Miller and modigliani etc)
Hated Q5. Calcs are completely wrong. Lots of theory again. With the mcqs being a joke (imo) and this being a resist I just HOPE I pass. Honestly. Head is fried.
Any sort of reply etc would be cool
Thanks
Michael
@emo777 said: But why and how did you get 19k net cost?I can't remember the figures now. I suggest we wait till john puts up his answers
Yes...after adjusting probabilities it was 29 with current inflation rate of 4 percent
Yes i got 4.36m or so....
@emo777 said: I think you messed up with 5% premium :D i think it was given to mislead us. The thing you had to do is to multiply net cash raised after issue costs by 100 and then divide by 104 to find the nominal value of loan to be redeemed. The you calculate the saving on interest. They took it from bpp revision kit, and you need premium only for calculation of cost of redeemable debt, which was not relevant in this case.The premium was relevant! There was a clause in the question that the bondholders would only allow them redeem the bonds before maturity if they can pay a premium of 5% to the market value. $11,200 - the issue costs gave us the net amount remaining to use for the redemption. The next step was to calculate the MV of the loan by multiplying the nominal value by 104/100. Then you must add the premium. The next step is to deduce the nominal amount of the bonds redeemed. And this is calculated by subtracting the net proceeds of the issue from the MV(with the premium) and multiplying the result by 100/104. I got that 9,000,000 was the nominal value of the bond that was redeemed, leaving 21,000,000.
It was extremely hard
On the Question 5, it said variable costs were on nominal values, does it mean that we put the costs as they were, or we had to use the general rate of inflation , 4%??
In the receivables question did anyone get a benefit??
Hey guys. I'm new here. Will Mr. Moffat be able to post his answers of the MCQ for us or no ?
Re Q5 - I used only VC @ inflation rate of 10%. Is that incorrect ? and did we have to do 3 NPVs I hear ? :-(
Thanks in advance
Sorry I am new here. What is the name of F9 lecturer Mr. Moffat ?
Who is John ? and after how many days after the exam does he usually upload his answers.
Thanks in advance
mcqs was really hard
@alanacca said: Sorry I am new here. What is the name of F9 lecturer Mr. Moffat ? Who is John ? and after how many days after the exam does he usually upload his answers. Thanks in advanceACCA did not publish questions immediately... last year It took time.
I tried my best to answer all the multiple questions and of section B questions correctly and attempted 100% paper. I am still not sure that i could get 50 marks out of it. I think the paper was very conceptual. Lets hope for best and Good luck for every one.
yes
@afuyegallas said: The premium was relevant! There was a clause in the question that the bondholders would only allow them redeem the bonds before maturity if they can pay a premium of 5% to the market value. $11,200 - the issue costs gave us the net amount remaining to use for the redemption. The next step was to calculate the MV of the loan by multiplying the nominal value by 104/100. Then you must add the premium. The next step is to deduce the nominal amount of the bonds redeemed. And this is calculated by subtracting the net proceeds of the issue from the MV(with the premium) and multiplying the result by 100/104. I got that 9,000,000 was the nominal value of the bond that was redeemed, leaving 21,000,000.I thought it should be 105/100? May be am wrong
@emo777 said: 1) all three choices were financial intermediaries 2) factoring improves efficiency of trade receivables management in a company 3 market segmentation explains kinks in yield curves 4) money deposits are short term loans between banks, and this option was wrong 5) beta of debt understates financial risk, this was also wrong 6) borrowers buy futures and sell them later, this option was wrong 7) share options always reward good performance, this option was also wring 8) expected net present values are used for projects with several outcomes ONCE, this was incorrect as we know that expected values fo occur during many times, not just once4....the question said short term loans SUCH as banks So this was correct
yes you will. They will penalise you once for that error but mark your subsequent steps
What did you get for q17 McQueen. The 1000 euro to dollar for 12 mths . It was a confusing and stupid question
I agree the Mcqs were terrible, some of the calcs work involved was crazy and all the definitions were so confusing
Q17 was the worst
Agree totally . no Wacc and no capm is crazy,
i think the mcq were just too much. In the time allocated it was impossible to focus properly on anything. It totally threw you off. After dealing with part 1 , then question 2 and 4 in part 2...impossible to finish this paper without making many errors. too many complicated questions , not enough balance.

