FM*** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Agreed paper was harder than expected..mcq are downright unfair and I'm surprised the examiner doesn't relax them a bit following december 14 feedback alone..was looking forward to wacc calcs and cashflow and disappointed we got stuck with the harder more challenging questions in this paper..very unfair :-(
I used 29 as well but didn't finish
I didn't find it too bad..one thing got me though
MCQ no. 19 seemed easy enough but i just couldn't calculate WACC..the information given seemed to suggest the use of CAPM to calculate cost of equity but i just kept on getting answers that were way off.
Anybody??
No, you are wrong. Money depodits are between banks and depoditors, not between banks
I did, a benefit of 87000
Banks borrow from one another in an inter bank Libor market, no relevant to money market deposits
The statement said that money market deposits are loans between organizations such as banks...actually, the loans between organizations are called commercial papers...deposits are between banks and depositors.. How can you have deposits without depositors???
same here 29 n then the inflation for each year
I work in a treasury department for a bank and we use the money market daily for short term borrowing and/or short term lending.
One party's loan is another party's deposit! (Regardless if both counterparty's are banks or not)
But you have to follow up with bpp book, which clearly stated that money market deposits are between banks and depositors. Check up the wording please
What you mean is inter bank libor market. Also, the question stated the word organizations... This is relevant for commercial papers
There's no such thing as a libor market!
Libor is a reference rate and is calculated from banks' perceived borrowing rates from one another.
Borrowing from one another on the money market!
ok now i am a little confused about FRA question. did it say receipt or payment? n what was the amount to convert i cant recall
Anyone can be a depositor....even banks. Where do you think they deposit their surplus cash?
Robert, they said that deposits are short term loans between various organizations... Money market deposits are either loans between banks, or between banks and depositors, not between organisations
Anyone can access the money market. You and I could, if we had a big enough short term deposit or wanted a short term loan. We would just go through a broker to arrange this.
I think this is when actual knowledge and experience is greater than a textbook.
Im an ungraduate student, but i think, acca relies on book knowledge
Bpp did not tell anything about this when discussing money market deposits btw
Do you agree on other questions though? The beta of debt was tricky
I totally agree with you on that.
Some of the MCQs required calculations which were a bit long winded.
Bring back the old format id say!
Yeah that one was tough, if I had more time I would have tried to work it out.
I remember that question had two other statements that were correct. So the answer was either all of them correct or just the other two statements.
I put all of them as correct
Do you mean question 19- capm on the MCQs.
I did the calc and could find it! Ended up guessing
I think beta of debt was wrong, because it understates business risk, we use beta of debt to calculate asset beta, we do not use it in gearing back
No, we mean true false questions
In open question 2, to find out the total dividends in both years, you just multiply earnings by divided payout ratio and then easily find the dividend growth rate
Also, in open question 2, i wrote that dividend growth model is useful for valuing minority shareholding, discussed some of the drawbacks and assumptions as well. Regarding the earnings yield, i said that it is the reciprocal of p/e ration, and in the question they used ey of other listed company, i said that , being a listed company as well, they have to use their own ey, because another company can have different operating characteristics
Me too though I added that being listed you would assume that the market is efficient so the market price reflects the company's value
in question 2 they have asked for advantages for DVM and EY based on the calculated values if we write assumptions and drawbacks will they give marks???
They did not ask to write about advantages specifically. But of course you ill get marks, you gave a relevant answer
Robert, regarding beta of debt, i think it understates financial risk during ungearing, but not during gearing back, as the exam stated

