FM*** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
They gave you the actual figure for current trade receivables, thats how Dhaval calculated 60 days.. No one used 40 days
Part B Q5. I explained sensitivity analysis, then calculated the sensitivity of the selling price which was about 10%. Which meant if the weak SP came to pass (35% probability), then the NPV would be negative.
So, guys, my solution to question 3:
1) saving in finance cost: 60-35/360*26500000*0.05 = 92014
2) advance cost: 35/360*0.08*26500000*(0.07-0.05) = 41222
3) cost of factor: 26500000*0.75/100 = 198750
4) bad debt saving: 26500000*0.01*0.7 = 185500
5) 50000 saving in admin costs
Thats how i got my positive benefit of 87000
Michael, i fear we were not asked to calculate sensitivity in part b of question 5. Just definition
Use boumal model to calculate cost???1 percent should be less or not from 5 percent??
Why boumal model? Where? If you mean mvq, the answer was 57000 smth
Mcq difficult. The rest are fair. But not sure if I will pass????
@Gvtftf give your question 3 some rest now lol, you will find out what the solution is when the questions are up ;)
Fahad, the solution was this question was straightforward.
I just copied it from bpp for your consideration
And, Fahad, font show yourself as an answer guru who knows everything and keeps it in secret. I have already seen your solution of question 5...
Gvtftf you're right, but it did say to critically discuss in terms of the project. So I thought it would help having a figure to discuss.
I think most people did ok in part B, just need some luck in the MCQ's!
Michael, will we be penalized if we dont calculate the figure though?
I don't think I'll get any extra for doing it as they didn't ask for a calculation
In the question where we had the Dividend growth model, could we not have calculated the growth rate from g= ROE * Retained earnings?
ROE was given I believe at 12.5% and Retained earning could be taken as 1 - % Div payout ratio?
Mark, did they ask to calculate market value per share or what?
Yes, the market value per share or the whole market cap/
So, it was per share or the whole market cap? :D cause this makes difference after you use the formula
I remember calculating overall value, then saw they ask per share and thought that the overall value i got was too big for price per share, so divided by the number of shares in the end
@emo777 said: So, guys, my solution to question 3: 1) saving in finance cost: 60-35/360*26500000*0.05 = 92014 2) advance cost: 35/360*0.08*26500000*(0.07-0.05) = 41222 3) cost of factor: 26500000*0.75/100 = 198750 4) bad debt saving: 26500000*0.01*0.7 = 185500 5) 50000 saving in admin costs Thats how i got my positive benefit of 87000Our answers only differ on the bad debt saving. What was the instruction? Thought they said bad debt was reduced by 30%? If that is the case, you shouldn't have calculated the new level of bad debts. You should have calculated 30% * .01 * 2,650,000
Ok would you kindly enlighten me then, I calculated the the whole market cap?
Hmm, i remember they said bad debts were reduced by 70%.. Thats why i multiplied it by 0.7
No, what you did is you just used gordon growth approximation...they didnt require it thought. And to find market value per share, you just divide market cap by number of shares and vide versa..as Jenny said, max one mark will be lost
Jenny, bad debts were reduced by 70%, werent they?
@emo777 said: Jenny, bad debts were reduced by 70%, werent they?Yes, definitely remember 70% reduction in bad debts. In terms of of the DGM value however it doesn't matter which method you use to approximate dividend growth - either would be valid. I can't remember if the info was in the question to use Gordon but, if it was, then the value calculated using that growth would be equally valid.
Too bad ACCA won't be uploading Section A for F9. I noticed they only uploaded Section B for F5 and F7. They uploaded section A for F6 as this was the first timw. So we can only deliberate on Section B.
yeah i got 47779300 positive
Did like you, the offer was not viable
The paper was so tricky that all ideas we thought seemed sensible but only one was correct.

