Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin11y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the F9 June 2015 Exam.

*** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Please note, the ACCA have asked us to allow posting comments only after 5pm UK time.
GGvtftf11y ago#151
There was a point in mcq, where they claimed that borrower can buy futures and then sell them, it was false, am i right?
Oolanrewaju11y ago#152
Does that mean we would have had to inflate the selling three different times inorder to calculate 3 NPVs? All for 8 marks? I don't think so
Jjenny354911y ago#153
Well, that wasn't quite what I was expecting! I thought Section B was very fair but the MCQs - my god, in all the millions of practice ones I did - none were like that. Instead of covering the rest of the syllabus they seemed to focus solely on markets etc. Think I've done far worse on the MCQs than I expected but better on Section B. Can anyone let me know what on earth the answer to the MCQ with the fx rates was? Could not figure that out to save my life!
EElitsa11y ago#154
@emo777 said: There was a point in mcq, where they claimed that borrower can buy futures and then sell them, it was false, am i right?
I think I answered that all 3 are correct :(
GGvtftf11y ago#155
Olanrewaju, totally agree with you!
Jjenny354911y ago#156
@emo777 said: There was a point in mcq, where they claimed that borrower can buy futures and then sell them, it was false, am i right?
Can't remember the whole question but you're right - borrows sell futures then buy to close out.
GGvtftf11y ago#157
You cant buy futures and then sell them lol :D
IInam11y ago#158
29.00 in current term :)
Jjenny354911y ago#159
@afuyegallas said: Does that mean we would have had to inflate the selling three different times inorder to calculate 3 NPVs? All for 8 marks? I don't think so
No, we had to calculate the EV of selling price which was $29 then inflate that and the fixed costs - but not variable costs which seemed strange. The only other possible snags in Q5 were tax being paid in the year rather than I year in arrears and TAD on a straight line basis - so no balancing allowance in the final year needed.
GGvtftf11y ago#160
What about beta of debt and market segmentation?
GGvtftf11y ago#161
Jenny, so, not allowable balance in last year 4 in question 5?
Jjenny354911y ago#162
@emo777 said: You cant buy futures and then sell them lol :D
You do if you're a depositor and want to hedge against rate falls. You start the deal by buying futures (paper transaction only) and then, at the close out date, you sell. The gain or loss on the futures transaction offsets the gain or loss on the interest rate change.
JJanet11y ago#163
Theory was over half the paper..let's have some more theory :D.. What did you guys write for; Dividend growth model/ Earnings Yield merits? Sensitivity analysis? Marketing hedging situations?
Former userFormer user11y ago#164
I found this exam difficult...
Jjenny354911y ago#165
@emo777 said: Jenny, so, not allowable balance in last year 4 in question 5?
No, no need with straight line. The $5m less the scrap of $0.5m gives amt to depreciate of $4.5m - divide by four years will give equal TAD relief of 338 (rounded) in each year.
EElitsa11y ago#166
I think ACCA is expecting to drop the pass level with so much theory about markets.
GGvtftf11y ago#167
Yeah, Jenny , you are right. Guys, so, there is not allowable balance in year 4 in question 5. The same value for each year. Happy got this one right at least, though forgot to deduct scrap value from capital cost :/
GGvtftf11y ago#168
Jenny, I meant borrowers ;)
Jjenny354911y ago#169
@jimbob1212 said: Theory was over half the paper..let's have some more theory :D.. What did you guys write for; Dividend growth model/ Earnings Yield merits? Sensitivity analysis? Marketing hedging situations?
DGM/Earnings yield merits - left this til last and ran out of time so very little on this - so used to focussing on disadvantages!!! Think I said DGM good for minority stakeholder valuation and EY can incorporate growth. By the way, for the calculation of EY value - were we supposed to incorporate growth - I wasn't sure because it didn't say forecast to continue so did with and without. Sensitivity analysis - got a bit carried away (hence running out of time later) and calculated after tax PV of revenue for sensitivity to selling price before getting hold of myself and saying only really measure of change in variables etc, not way assessing risk but good for highlighting critical variables. Hopefully picked up some marks. Hedging wordy bit - explained how FRA works but again think I wrote too much (gave example) but it was for 5 marks so...
JJanet11y ago#170
Yup Jenny - I did reducing balance but I see you are right in hindsight.. I failed.
GGvtftf11y ago#171
Jenny, what about market segmentation kinks, financial intermediaries and point with the beta of debt as zero understating financial risk?
Ffahad11y ago#172
@jenny3549 said: No, no need with straight line. The $5m less the scrap of $0.5m gives amt to depreciate of $4.5m - divide by four years will give equal TAD relief of 338 (rounded) in each year.
how much will this bit be worth ? 2 marks ?
Mmanonaseriousmission11y ago#173
hi guys, personally i didn't have sufficient time to practice and revise and so i think that i could have done way better today - but hey, I will stay positive no matter what. As for a few comments re: venture cap's - Yes they are intermediaries however i think that they are NOT institutional investors/intermediaries. Pension funds, insurance companies are institutional investors. Not sure how the question puts it again but i think it asked for 'institutional investors' in which case Venture cap isn't a part of. IRR i think i got 17.2 (cant rememeber now, i know there were two figures with 17.something but it was the 17.something with the lower digit) Ev for selling price i used 29 as well... I immediately spotted my knowledge gap the moment i opened the question booklet and although not excusable, it was all down to insufficient question practices and no past question revision :/ best wishes
JJanet11y ago#174
Oh yeah..the capital structure question..(6 marks I think) Thoughts?
GGvtftf11y ago#175
Jenny, they did not require us to calculate sensitivity in the last question, as far as i remember
GGvtftf11y ago#176
Also, the second question just required to calculate earnings yield without growth, at least they did not mention anything about growth
Jjenny354911y ago#177
@emo777 said: Jenny, what about market segmentation kinks, financial intermediaries and point with the beta of debt as zero understating financial risk?
The financial intermediaries one - I think they all were - definitely pension funds and merchant banks but it did say VC ORGANISATIONS so I took that to mean a way of bringing VC together with companies - could be wrong though. The one about the market segmentation - that does explain the kinks so that was true, downwards sloping curve when rate falls expected, also true but didn't know about the other option - investors wanting real returns - kind of guessed they meant liquidity pref theory there - and the reference to real returns meaning higher yield to compensate for time value of money so said all three true - not sure if I'm right? I can't remember what the choices were for the debt beta one - think the other two were correct and I thought that was false?
Jjenny354911y ago#178
@emo777 said: Jenny, they did not require us to calculate sensitivity in the last question, as far as i remember
I know!! Like I said, I got carried away!
Mmanonaseriousmission11y ago#179
and by the way, was anyone else caught out (or nearly so) with 360 days to use for receivables calculation? I had gone a bit far into the calculation using 365 days before i realized at the end that examiner pedantically specifies 360.. The factor wasn't a viable option anyway... well, that's what i deduced. don't know if i was correct.
Jjenny354911y ago#180
@emo777 said: Also, the second question just required to calculate earnings yield without growth, at least they did not mention anything about growth
I had a feeling as it was only 2 marks so did with and without and then said, assumption without for comparison purposes - hopefully won't be penalised!