FM*** F9 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@jparker7 said: Cheers Jenny. I think the IRR MCQ one I figured out in my workings to be 18% so I went with the option 17.8%, but I know there was also a 17.2% option so not sure :s I agree with most of the other numerical MCQs, I got 48k with Baumol, but that's because I used 5% instead of the net 4% so I presume the 57k answer is right. Q20 was 2.10, the WACC was 8.8%, the exchange q (no gain or loss) was 1.418, 6% percentage growth correction option on one of the first numerical MCQs (option D). 96.94 for the value of the loan note, ROE was the incorrect option on one of the questions (used PBIT instead of Profit after tax and preference share dividends). NPV in Q5 I got 3,807. Q3, net cost of using factor or around 200-300k but I think I did this wrong. Q2 I was calculating the total values in a and b rather than per share, do you think I will be penalised? Good luck to all of you! Praying for that 50% mark!I also did total values - not per share - bugger, must have misread the question. I hate the exam pressure - makes you miss things you would normally see!
@emo777 said: Guys, in question 2 as i remember they asked per share, right? However, it is the same if you get per share or total values :)) but think they adked per shareUnfortunately not the same. Examiner has said before (when asked for total) - candidates did not multiply by no. of shares so lost a mark - so I assume same applies in reverse. Thought I did okay on 2a/b but now not so sure - know c wasn't great as couldn't really remember advantages - certainly not enough for 5 marks.
Yeah, actually i calculated values, then, it seems that i have read they ask per share, thats why divided by number of shares in the end
Q2 For Dividend growth model I got $11,10 or smthing like that price per share.. By applying a growth rate of 8.5%.. Is it right?
I got 9.71. And growth rate was 3.85% or smth like this, dont remember exactly
Borrowers buy futures and sell them, this statement was incorrect
OMG...qusetion 4 was the worst...
OMG question 4 was so haaaarrrddddd....
On MCQ 1, statements 1 and 3 were definitely wrong as they were mixing up monetary and fiscal policy. Statement 2 was the only correct one.
Has anyone else got P3 on Monday?
Question 4 was difficult and one of the very few areas I didn't practise in massive detail, in part b I got carried away and started doing some random WACC calculations for both before and after the rights issue, spending ages only to realise it said "Discuss".
So I started speaking about how WACC has increased because there is a greater proportion of equity making up the capital structure, but also that redeeming some of the debt has decreased financial risk.
Finally I spoke about traditional view, M&M and M&M with tax.
In question 4 part A i had two mistakes: i multiplied net cash raised by 100/104, instead of 100/(104*1.05 premium)...and when i got revised total earnings i divided them by old number of shares...though i expect to get marks for the right method and my workings were correct
Apart from a few before and after ratios and calculating the TERP is all I did. I got proper lost.
Did you get TERP as 3.37?
Yeap, Jamie :) at the end you compare new price with terp to see how it affects shateholders wealth
Dont worry, you will, get marks for terp
Jenny, how many marks will i lose on the following, your opinion?
In question 4 part A i had two mistakes: i multiplied net cash raised by 100/104, instead of 100/(104*1.05 premium)…and when i got revised total earnings i divided them by old number of shares…though i expect to get marks for the right method and my workings were correct
Someone on that true false question with borrowers and futures? Not sure about that one
@jparker7 said: Cheers Jenny. I think the IRR MCQ one I figured out in my workings to be 18% so I went with the option 17.8%, but I know there was also a 17.2% option so not sure :s I agree with most of the other numerical MCQs, I got 48k with Baumol, but that's because I used 5% instead of the net 4% so I presume the 57k answer is right. Q20 was 2.10, the WACC was 8.8%, the exchange q (no gain or loss) was 1.418, 6% percentage growth correction option on one of the first numerical MCQs (option D). 96.94 for the value of the loan note, ROE was the incorrect option on one of the questions (used PBIT instead of Profit after tax and preference share dividends). NPV in Q5 I got 3,807. Q3, net cost of using factor or around 200-300k but I think I did this wrong. Q2 I was calculating the total values in a and b rather than per share, do you think I will be penalised? Good luck to all of you! Praying for that 50% mark!I was beginning to think I was the only person that got $3,807K in NPV. I think you were right in calculating the total value of equity of the company! That's what the question asked for! You can check BPP text to confirm this.
No, but i think they asked for per share! Maybe im wrong though! Cmon, do you expect them to copy the same question from bpp?
@emo777 said: Jenny, how many marks will i lose on the following, your opinion? In question 4 part A i had two mistakes: i multiplied net cash raised by 100/104, instead of 100/(104*1.05 premium)…and when i got revised total earnings i divided them by old number of shares…though i expect to get marks for the right method and my workings were correctProbably no more than one mark for each, perhaps less. Until we see the ACCA marking scheme it's hard to judge but there were only 8 marks available and quite a few calculations needed so some of them might only be worth 1/2.
Thank you! Are you sure that the borrowers one was incorrect?
@emo777 said: No, but i think they asked for per share! Maybe im wrong though! Cmon, do you expect them to copy the same question from bpp?I did total value also as I thought it asked 'what is the value of X Co?' but I could be wrong. However - Gvtftf is right - questions are never going to be identical - they don't want people to learn answers, or calculations, parrot fashion, they want to know you understand the underlying principles so will always try to mix it up a bit to test this. This is fine - it's just, on this paper, I think they took it to extremes in Section A!!!
Jenny, and max one mark will be lost if you calculate total instead of per share and the reverse, right? You mentioned acca marker said smth about this
@emo777 said: Jenny, and max one mark will be lost if you calculate total instead of per share and the reverse, right? You mentioned acca marker said smth about thisExactly, they do try to be fair - so, if parts a and b were worth 5 in total I would guess could still get minimum of 3 for method if the figures were correct - perhaps more.
Great,! And finally, the one with borrowers was wrong, right?
@emo777 said: Great,! And finally, the one with borrowers was wrong, right?If the question said that borrows buy options that was wrong. Borrowers sell options and then buy to close out at the end of the deal. Don't know what the other options in that question were though to know the overall answer - but that option definitely wrong.
Yeah, it said they buy and then sell
Jenny, i think you mean futures...statement claimed that borrowers buy futures expecting increase in interest rate and sell them later on
don't remember anything
fed the alphbets in numeric in calculater alphabet values like
acbaa
13211 into alpha "A"
@emo777 said: Jenny, i think you mean futures...statement claimed that borrowers buy futures expecting increase in interest rate and sell them later onYep, futures is what I meant. Sorry, head slightly fried as trying (and failing) to forget about F9 and concentrate on F4 for Monday.
Good luck on f4!

