Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#211
this is my second attempt jus like the first time sooooo prepared but ratios sends me into a frenzy too much info
i did tsr, interest cover, roce, financial ratio

hope i get 50
Former userFormer user15y ago#212
@volvic said:
Just a query on Q3..I think...The one about Working Capital Policy...as i remember the question was something like:

Discuss factors incluencing the formulation of a Working Capital Policy (7 Marks)

So I talked about the inventory system in place (JIT etc) and whether Supplier relationships were strong enough to depend on quick, efficient deliveries, Credit terms that can be offered dependent on market conditions and competitors, and Supplier payables days being reduced so influenced by no. of suppliers the company has to choose from and whether they had scope to negotiate longer terms etc. I related all these back to the question for a few scenario marks.

...why would the question above lead us to talk about financing of Working Capital (aggressive/conservative) like others have suggested?

Would be a miracle if I've passed but I spent a little while on those 7 marks and was kinda hoping they were in the bag!

Don't know how to answer you
but initially I wrote like you but it was wrong
We thought they ask about Inventory + Rec- Pay
but they were asking wad factors that influence aggressive/conservative/moderate

I wrote about industry and capital injected (which were wrong due to wrong concept)
and i still managed to turn my last point of Organisation culture(behaviour) from irrelevant stuff and change abit to write smtg about the aggressive/moderate/conservative
Former userFormer user15y ago#213
@gillidy said:
this is my second attempt jus like the first time sooooo prepared but ratios sends me into a frenzy too much info
i did tsr, interest cover, roce, financial ratio

hope i get 50

doubt we need much ratios calculation to assist on
about maximising shareholders wealth
Former userFormer user15y ago#214
@tzxsean said:
the one you did is Present value ..not Net Cash flow before tax :S


well if you insist the question is asking for CASH FLOW only, then using the perpetuity formula is wrong anyway. what the perpetuity formula gives is the present value of future cash flows
Former userFormer user15y ago#215
@volvic said:
Just a query on Q3..I think...The one about Working Capital Policy...as i remember the question was something like:

Discuss factors incluencing the formulation of a Working Capital Policy (7 Marks)

So I talked about the inventory system in place (JIT etc) and whether Supplier relationships were strong enough to depend on quick, efficient deliveries, Credit terms that can be offered dependent on market conditions and competitors, and Supplier payables days being reduced so influenced by no. of suppliers the company has to choose from and whether they had scope to negotiate longer terms etc. I related all these back to the question for a few scenario marks.

...why would the question above lead us to talk about financing of Working Capital (aggressive/conservative) like others have suggested?

Would be a miracle if I've passed but I spent a little while on those 7 marks and was kinda hoping they were in the bag!


I believe your answer is correct, I've checked my notes, the others were wrong about the aggressive/conservative/matching approach, don't worry lol.
Former userFormer user15y ago#216
@eugeneksc said:
well if you insist the question is asking for CASH FLOW only, then using the perpetuity formula is wrong anyway. what the perpetuity formula gives is the present value of future cash flows


nope...the formula is not wrong...
when we use perpetuity formula..what we get is the estimated amount of cash inflow we will receive through the life cycle.

in order to evaluate business value, the cash flow amount we derived from perpetuity formula will need to be discounted to PV and sum it up with other PV to get NPV.
Former userFormer user15y ago#217
@eugeneksc said:
I believe your answer is correct, I've checked my notes, the others were wrong about the aggressive/conservative/matching approach, don't worry lol.

doubt u don't really understand about working capital policy. and the answer he wrote is more to working capital management
Former userFormer user15y ago#218
@rizenzo said:
Many thanksto txsean for posting the break down of the questions. I missed chunks of questions, panicked a little, and my hand wasn't connected to my brain for most of the session. Nevertheless, after putting my mark estimates next to the questions, I'm hoping to have scraped through.

If people are questioning whether they passed or not, I recommend doing the same. I've thrown the questins in to a spreadsheet here. Just knock out my comments, add your own, and see what lessons you can learn from the exercise.

For me, it was almost all time management. I thought the questions were very reasonable, but my technique was terrible.


can definitely finish all within 3 hours if you stick to 45 mins per question strictly
however our answers wont be too comprehensive considering so much theories there
Former userFormer user15y ago#219
In question two all you guys are trying to calculate the cost of debt....it gave u it in the question. Therefore you didn't need to know how long the bonds would last for.

I thought the paper was fine. And not time pressured if you were ready

And I mean before the new issue of bonds
Former userFormer user15y ago#220
@mcwilliams said:
In question two all you guys are trying to calculate the cost of debt....it gave u it in the question. Therefore you didn't need to know how long the bonds would last for.

I thought the paper was fine. And not time pressured if you were ready

And I mean before the new issue of bonds


Yes cost of existing debt was given, only had to calculate new issue which was 6.02% I think
Former userFormer user15y ago#221
@peldor said:
Yes cost of existing debt was given, only had to calculate new issue which was 6.02% I think

this is 1 of the silly mistake I made :(
Former userFormer user15y ago#222
@peldor said:
Yes cost of existing debt was given, only had to calculate new issue which was 6.02% I think


Correct
Wwaweru15y ago#223
Q3 Con't figure out what calculations to do, .'. had nothing to seriously discuss. Time pressed, Damn! Hoping for 50.
Former userFormer user15y ago#224
hope to get atleat 50.GOD PLESE HELP!
Former userFormer user15y ago#225
@rizenzo i do not remember 6 marks for exch rates question? i remember it 4 mrks.....because money mkt & forw contract was 7 mks, Work Capital policy was 7 mks and bulk purchase and early settlement was 7 mks, which leaves only 4 for exch rates.....from what i remember.
Former userFormer user15y ago#226
thanks grassrots...this means I wrote a page for 4 marks! Closer to the margin now, but still falling on the right side of the 50% ledger by my reckoning. That said, I think the analysis exercise use is greater for understanding ourselves in exams versus getting an accurate reading of the final results...based on my past results vs expectations, I think it depends how late in the evening it is when the marker is looking at your paper, whether they got out of bed on the right side, and how much wine they've drunk by the time they've got to your paper.
Former userFormer user15y ago#227
Exch ques was for 5 marks. Hedging and forward was 6 marks
Former userFormer user15y ago#228
it ws hell a hell paper.... :( tricky hell triicckkyy....:@
Former userFormer user15y ago#229
it ws hell a hell paper.... :( tricky hell triicckkyy....:@
Former userFormer user15y ago#230
oh yeh i think u are right mcwilliams, exch rate question was 5 mrks actually :) ......my mistake. Anyway i think the question pper will be online 2morrow so know for sure then.
Jjoevassallo15y ago#231
@grassrotts said:
oh yeh i think u are right mcwilliams, exch rate question was 5 mrks actually :) ......my mistake. Anyway i think the question pper will be online 2morrow so know for sure then.

I think Q1 (a) NPV was worth 13 marks. Did you get NPV $1,2m? If yes that would be a good start.

Also queston on working capital policy is to do with aggressive/conservative and management attitude to risk.

Scrip dividend I wrote about issuing shares instead of taking dividends - effectively still raising equity. I think this was worth 5 marks.


Former userFormer user15y ago#232
@joevassallo well i got 791000 for npv but that is because i did not incorporate inflation :( so i think ur npv is right.
i think work capital answer wuld b aggresive/conservative etc, but i also wrote abt expected Work capital needs for period such as debts to b paid etc and whether mgmt wants to improve liquidty position and to possibility 2 attract new customers with discounts or longer repayment periods etc. .....i hope i get 7/7 mrks here cause i wrote a lot :p
and yeh scrip dividends are issuing shares in lieu of dividend but i 4got 2 write it is an option, and not mandatory for existing shareholders. They choose between cash & new shares.
Jjoevassallo15y ago#233
@grassrotts said:
@joevassallo well i got 791000 for npv but that is because i did not incorporate inflation :( so i think ur npv is right.
i think work capital answer wuld b aggresive/conservative etc, but i also wrote abt expected Work capital needs for period such as debts to b paid etc and whether mgmt wants to improve liquidty position and to possibility 2 attract new customers with discounts or longer repayment periods etc. .....i hope i get 7/7 mrks here cause i wrote a lot :p
and yeh scrip dividends are issuing shares in lieu of dividend but i 4got 2 write it is an option, and not mandatory for existing shareholders. They choose between cash & new shares.

I think you wrote more about working capital management rather than policy. I hope you score good marks just the same. Do you remember how may marks it had? Also re NPV did you release the working capital in year 4? I did but I saw some comments that it should not. Not sure here. If released hope to get full marks here. I think you will only lose 3 marks for the inflation part.
Former userFormer user15y ago#234
@joevassallo yeh work capital ques was 7 mrks, im reasonably sure.

I interpreted the project as continuing so i didnt release work capital. They said the reason for using 4 yrs npv calcluation was because the exact cash flows were uncertain beyond yr 4, however the project was expected 2 continue beyond 4 yrs, just level of cash flows was uncertain. Project continuity seemed certain.....just my interpretation.
Hhilz15y ago#235
I messed up big time with question 1 and 3.Praying for a 50%
Former userFormer user15y ago#236
working capital had to be released in the 4th year because the project calculation was prepared only for 4 years (although the director expected sales after the 4th he didnt incorporate it into the calculations as they were too uncertain). and we had to reperform the director's calculations.
in part (b) WC had to be ignored (and also tax).
i got an NPV of 1,2 m USD.

in part (c) i wrote about liquidity and profitability as the question was not about working capital FUNDING policy.
Jjoevassallo15y ago#237
@adrienn said:
working capital had to be released in the 4th year because the project calculation was prepared only for 4 years (although the director expected sales after the 4th he didnt incorporate it into the calculations as they were too uncertain). and we had to reperform the director's calculations.
in part (b) WC had to be ignored (and also tax).
i got an NPV of 1,2 m USD.

in part (c) i wrote about liquidity and profitability as the question was not about working capital FUNDING policy.

I agree 100% with you - I got NPV $1.2m as well. My interpretation was NPV for a 4 year project.
Regarding WC Policy - you are right aggressive/conservative is FUNDING but again my interpretation is about funding. Because that is what WC is all about really, also management attitude to risk, previous policy decisions, size/organisation.
Former userFormer user15y ago#238
NPV
Selling price
V c
F c, all in current price term they all must inflated by 3%
For Example,
In calculation of profit year 3.
Selling price was 5 per box, so increase in selling price 3% , 3 times,
Variable cost in sales volume in year 3 were in current price, so increase vc 3% 3 times.
Fixed cost in year 3 was higher then year 2. Because sales volume increase in year 3. FC was increamental Fc, it was increasing with sales volume. Fc in year 3 increase by 3% 3 times. To obtain year 3 Fc.
Tax was 1 year in arear. 1 year tax take in year2.
Capital allowance 25 reducing method.
Working capital in year 0 was 750000. Increase 3% for 4 yr, ignore working capital recovery because buisness is cont aft 4 year mentioned in frst para.
Nominal discount factor use
Npv arrive
Jjoevassallo15y ago#239
@frank26 said:
NPV
Selling price
V c
F c, all in current price term they all must inflated by 3%
For Example,
In calculation of profit year 3.
Selling price was 5 per box, so increase in selling price 3% , 3 times,
Variable cost in sales volume in year 3 were in current price, so increase vc 3% 3 times.
Fixed cost in year 3 was higher then year 2. Because sales volume increase in year 3. FC was increamental Fc, it was increasing with sales volume. Fc in year 3 increase by 3% 3 times. To obtain year 3 Fc.
Tax was 1 year in arear. 1 year tax take in year2.
Capital allowance 25 reducing method.
Working capital in year 0 was 750000. Increase 3% for 4 yr, ignore working capital recovery because buisness is cont aft 4 year mentioned in frst para.
Nominal discount factor use
Npv arrive

I think you are wrong about Selling price - to me it should be $5+3% Year 1, then $5.15+3% Year 2, $5.30+3% Year 3 and $5.46+3% Year 4.
I agree with the VC/FC workings.
WC though has to be released in Y4 because the NPV was for 4years (and there was uncertainty).
Part b I thought was about project continuing for the foreseeable future.
Former userFormer user15y ago#240
Dec 2010 Q1,
About working capital,
project is continuing after 4 year, the point he share with us in question was his kind of persnal statement not related to the exam question, he said we believe may be the sale stop after 4 year, thats why he ask for perpetuity im q1 (b), four year calculation policy not the actual life of the project, so no need to be recover wc in year 4 must inflate in year 3% every year
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.