Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Cclaire198515y ago#181
i did not have enough time to finish it, really a lot of comment
Ttresor15y ago#182
U guys. What is the best exam technique for passing F9. It was abig challenge forme especially interms of managing time.
Former userFormer user15y ago#183
pray hard the examiner don't ask something out of the box

previous sittings don't have that much of theories compared to this time!
Jjoevassallo15y ago#184
@joevassallo said:


I thought the bond was redeemable at 5% premium - not at par. So not sure if I was correct. Also I think to gain marks it is important to show all workings because the final answer, although important, is not all that matters. This is my opinion.
What answer did you get for the NPV?
Jjoevassallo15y ago#185
@tzxsean said:
pray hard the examiner don't ask something out of the box
What do you mean out of the box?
previous sittings don't have that much of theories compared to this time!
HHandsome15y ago#186
@y.prananv said:
I think for the WACC part,I also got 8% something and then got a lesser WACC after the issue!!! :D .....but then when we were told what affects the market value of tradable bonds,what was we supposed to write??? :S


my theory = fairy tails :p only numerical question saved me every time (from T1 to F7) let see what happened this time
Former userFormer user15y ago#188
@joevassallo

out of box as something that is not expected?
This sitting does not feature Islamic Finance
which everybody is expecting

that is 1 kind of unexpected thing from the expectation we had LOL
Bbarky15y ago#189
For question 1, some people recovered the working capital in year 4 but as the project was continuing for years to come i did not recover on the assumption that there would be no recovery - just added inflated debits for the yearly increase in demand. came out with a positive NPV.
Talked about sensitivity analysis, EV's and aggressive and conservative approaches etc...

Question 2 i got a cost of debt as about 4.6% (didnt round it up) and then after the bond issue it was still the same!!
I used the redemption period of the new bonds for the existing ones although looking back i guess they could have been classed as iredeemable debt.... hmm....

On director's views, i said that he was right to assume the WACC would decrease but this would not necessarily raise the market value of the company as gearing may increase and interest cover etc so more risk. Discussed traditional, M&M theories and then realted back to the assumption that there is more to the argument than just WACC and theory and that external views were also a factor.


WACC came down by about 1% on my reckoning after bond issue.

Question 3 - god knows. Started to do some calculations, got a bit lost, wrote a bit of theory! LOL... not good.

Question 5 - forward hedge was better.

Think i messed up the second part as i said that the .5% discount was best. Got confused with the interest bit. I calculated that a reduction in payment terms would cost the company 60 days extra in overdraft but i have no idea why now!!!


Overall, i felt fairly prepared. This was my second sitting. Got about 44 last time and really hope for 50 but didnt answer two questions worth 10 marks so instantly down to 90.
Not sure if i did enough but hopefully the theory might pull something back. Pleeeeeeeeeease!!!!! LOL....
Former userFormer user15y ago#190
The questions seems good,but i don't belive any one can explicitly done such type of time consuming exam in three hour
Former userFormer user15y ago#191
The questions seems good,but i don't belive any one can explicitly done such type of time consuming exam in three hour
Jjoevassallo15y ago#192
@ejigsew said:
The questions seems good,but i don't belive any one can explicitly done such type of time consuming exam in three hour

I agree - time is of the essence here. But then I suppose you have to very brief about all the discursive answers, you do not have much time to go into detail. The theory you have to do in full, I suppose that's why the paper had more discursive than theory I think (maybe 60/40).
Former userFormer user15y ago#193
@tzxsean said:
someone asked me bout PV of cash flow in perpetuity ?

I just take the cash flow before tax on year 4 and divide with 12%
and minus tax of 30%

at first I thought of applying inflation of 3% onto the cash flow but at the end I din't do it. Should I inflate it?


I don't think so, the question said assume the PBIT is constant after that right?
I calculated the net cash flow for the 5th year, divide it by the cost of capital, and then further discount it to the PV
Former userFormer user15y ago#194
@redrose said:
Q4. Did we have to calculate EOQ for bulk discounts? i did the settlement part managed to do it but somehow messed up with bulk discounts. i have a feeling i mssed up money market hedging.. coz i got a somewhat a big diff btn money market and forward... it was all self study fr me..... i hope i can make it...


Dont think Q4 was about EOQ. If I remember correctly:
Option 1 - discount 0,5% on 900000 purchase is gain of 4500
Shorter payment of 60 days is cost of 60/365 * borrowing rate * purchase = around 6000 cost
Overall -1500 or so worse than base scenario
Option 2 - discount 3,6% = 32400 is gain
4 orders instead of 12 is 8*200= 1600 gain
Increased holding cost of (30000/2)*2,2 = 33000 instead of 10000/2 * 1 = 5000 so 28000 additional cost
Overall 32400+1600-28000 = 6000 better than base

Numbers might be a bit off. Anyone done it like that?
Former userFormer user15y ago#195
The paper was too long to be completed in 3 hours.. i just hope to pass...Dont wanna see this paper again...
Former userFormer user15y ago#196
@eugeneksc said:
I don't think so, the question said assume the PBIT is constant after that right?
I calculated the net cash flow for the 5th year, divide it by the cost of capital, and then further discount it to the PV


they only want Net cash flow after tax
Sssherazz15y ago#197
can any 1 tel abut q4
last part eoq
can any1 solve it in briefly
and tel abut working capital policy was it about agresive,conservative etc
Former userFormer user15y ago#198
@tzxsean said:
All I noe is I screwed up the early settlement discount

and first of all we need to calculate current total inventory cost before computing those 2 new alternatives


I did that but I think it was unnecessary. Question said pick better option, which can be done with just doing the above.
Former userFormer user15y ago#199
@peldor said:
I did that but I think it was unnecessary. Question said pick better option, which can be done with just doing the above.


same, I did that a.s.a.p as time is running out. So i didn't think of any shortcut
but it maybe safer to do that because who knows both alternatives do not offer financial advantage to the current policy?

It's longer but it's safer if the question is to trick you that actually both alternatives are not beneficial.
Former userFormer user15y ago#200
@tzxsean said:
same, I did that a.s.a.p as time is running out. So i didn't think of any shortcut
but it maybe safer to do that because who knows both alternatives do not offer financial advantage to the current policy?

It's longer but it's safer if the question is to trick you that actually both alternatives are not beneficial.

Youre right, glad I did it then. Was only 1 extra minute or so and better safe than sorry
Mmngwenya15y ago#201
the paper was fair but did not finish, too many calculations to be done, Q4 did not finish but found it interesting, I first calculated the TAC and the credit balance since the customer was paying in 90days, On the credit balance i then calculated the finance cost using the borrowing interest rate which i thought was a saving since the customer was using the trade credit to finance his operations. this is the part that i answered what do you think guys
Former userFormer user15y ago#202
To be honest guys yesterdays paper was the easiest of all the past exam papers ive seen for F9 but there was too much theory time was not enough they should have added some 30minutes more.It was too long for 3hours.I didnt even answer one question so there is no question i failed i am sure the December paper will be tough its unfortunate i failded such ann easy paper poor time managemnet.
Former userFormer user15y ago#203
@mngwenya said:
the paper was fair but did not finish, too many calculations to be done, Q4 did not finish but found it interesting, I first calculated the TAC and the credit balance since the customer was paying in 90days, On the credit balance i then calculated the finance cost using the borrowing interest rate which i thought was a saving since the customer was using the trade credit to finance his operations. this is the part that i answered what do you think guys

you kidding me? calculation is not alot although not easy(tricky) but not complicated except NPV

if we were to fail(hope we don't) it is our inability to score better marks in the theories area
Former userFormer user15y ago#204
@tzxsean said:
they only want Net cash flow after tax

@tzxsean said:
they only want Net cash flow after tax


So? Just calculate the PV of future net cash flow after tax using perpetuity formula (as if you are in year 5 now), and then further discount it to present value(in year 0)
Former userFormer user15y ago#205
@eugeneksc said:
So? Just calculate the PV of future net cash flow after tax using perpetuity formula (as if you are in year 5 now), and then further discount it to present value(in year 0)

stop right after u use perpetuity formula to calculate CF for year 5 and minus tax @ 30%.. No need to do further
Former userFormer user15y ago#206
well, either you're right or i'm right.
i assume they want the present value as at year 0 cause the project hasn't started yet, and it's weird to assume a perpetuity value 5 years later to be worth the same today, so i discounted it to today's value.
Former userFormer user15y ago#207
@eugeneksc said:
well, either you're right or i'm right.
i assume they want the present value as at year 0 cause the project hasn't started yet, and it's weird to assume a perpetuity value 5 years later to be worth the same today, so i discounted it to today's value.


the one you did is Present value ..not Net Cash flow before tax :S
Aaahmad5515y ago#208
hoping for 50
Yy.prananv15y ago#209
can anyone answer this question please...For number 1...we were given total Fixed costs....But when we do NPV calculations,do we take the incremental fixed costs that is fixed cost in year one is already given while for year 2,we have to take fixed cost in year 2 minus fixed cost in year 1????:S :S :S
Former userFormer user15y ago#210
Just a query on Q3..I think...The one about Working Capital Policy...as i remember the question was something like:

Discuss factors incluencing the formulation of a Working Capital Policy (7 Marks)

So I talked about the inventory system in place (JIT etc) and whether Supplier relationships were strong enough to depend on quick, efficient deliveries, Credit terms that can be offered dependent on market conditions and competitors, and Supplier payables days being reduced so influenced by no. of suppliers the company has to choose from and whether they had scope to negotiate longer terms etc. I related all these back to the question for a few scenario marks.

...why would the question above lead us to talk about financing of Working Capital (aggressive/conservative) like others have suggested?

Would be a miracle if I've passed but I spent a little while on those 7 marks and was kinda hoping they were in the bag!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.