Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#121
@alancong said:
pay or not pay both increase shareholder value , the only difference is in different kind of wealth. pay increase wealth now by cash, not pay increase wealth in future by the form of capital gain (i.e share price increase)--this is irrelevance theory.
relevance theory div policy will affect shareholder wealth. using div vluation model (share price will be decided by the future div discounted at shareholder required return) 2 more theories: signalling and cliente effect both prove div policy will affect share pric--ie company value.


The scenario given was the company was constantly performing worse than the previous year (PBIT and PAT was reducing EVERY year)
with constantly reducing PAT, paying the same dividend as last year will be not sustainable...
Share price is reducing every single year as well.
Lol i think i have to stop now and start revising other subjects, thanks for your input anyway :). Hopefully I get a pass
Jjoevassallo15y ago#122
I think Working capital attitude is management attitude to risk (aggressive or conservative), Previous policy formulation an size/organisation structure.

I think ratios to be worked are ROCE/ROE/Interest cover/Financial Gearing (capital)/ EPS/DPS/Total Shareholder Wealth. This is what i calculated though I did not have much time to comment on them. Time problem as usual....

Did anyone get NPV $1,2m for Q1 (worth 13 marks)?

DVM should be worked on "Past dividends" - I worked it out as 2.8? Anyone agree. Cost of debt was already after tax - so remain 7%.
Former userFormer user15y ago#123
One last question... If I worked out the retained earning for each of the past years wrongly, I would obviously get wrong ROCE, ROE and gearing ratio(though it shouldn't so different such that it would affect interpretation), would I be penalized for that...? I'm dead on Q3 if I will be penalised.
Former userFormer user15y ago#124
@eugeneksc said:
One last question... If I worked out the retained earning for each of the past years wrongly, I would obviously get wrong ROCE, ROE and gearing ratio(though it shouldn't so different such that it would affect interpretation), would I be penalized for that...? I'm dead on Q3 if I will be penalised.

i only calculated ROCE and why u need to compute retained earnings? just use PAT/total equity + LTL
Jjoevassallo15y ago#125
I think that was a bit tricky but not difficult. You just have to deduct the profit.

Problem is it will affect the ratios - both ROCE and ROE.

Good luck.
Ggriffith15y ago#126
this exam would be terrific to a well prepared student, which i wasn't.
Former userFormer user15y ago#127
@tzxsean said:
i only calculated ROCE and why u need to compute retained earnings? just use PAT/total equity + LTL


To compare it with the ROCE and ROE of previous years?
And dividend paid have to be considered as well isn't it, joevassallo?
Former userFormer user15y ago#128
f9 was relatively okay. even the examiner made i clear that one can't pass his course with the numbers alone. 'u just have to know how to communicate as an accountant'...he said in his comment i printed out from open tuition
Jjoevassallo15y ago#129
Not really - Dividends come out of profits. So the profit in retained earnings would already be reduced. @tzxsean
Former userFormer user15y ago#130
can any body give me the ans of NPV?
iz it 1.2m?
Jjoevassallo15y ago#131
Q1 - I made the NPV as $1.2m positive. Agree with you on this one @hassan1214
Former userFormer user15y ago#132
whats up peeps

a very time pressured exam

question 1 i totally messed up. my npv was like negative 5m....(dont ask how)

about incorporating risk i mentioned increasing cost of capital, using probabilities, etc.

second question i wacc was 10.9% and then after it was 10%

for market value of bonds i mentioned time period to maturity, expectations theory, liquidity theory and segmentaition theories

for the last part i talked about miller and modigliani and using an optimal wacc level

third question i worked out a few ratios and concluded company had a decreasing interest coverage ratio although dividend yield was increasing :(
debt finance was not a good idea and i think i recomended equity finance as a solution which will help build a better working capital policy and i also opted to freeze dividends.

dividend scrip? wtf is that? never came across it in my studies but i talked about the dividend theory and how in a perfect world its the investment side that brings optimal performance to a company....i guess i f'd up there.

4th question i talked about the 4 way equivalence model and how interest rates and exchange rates are linked together via it.

and forward hedge was better

question about order i didnt do

not sure if i have passed it. first question let me down
Former userFormer user15y ago#133
@joevassallo said:
I think Working capital attitude is management attitude to risk (aggressive or conservative), Previous policy formulation an size/organisation structure.

I think ratios to be worked are ROCE/ROE/Interest cover/Financial Gearing (capital)/ EPS/DPS/Total Shareholder Wealth. This is what i calculated though I did not have much time to comment on them. Time problem as usual....

Did anyone get NPV $1,2m for Q1 (worth 13 marks)?

DVM should be worked on "Past dividends" - I worked it out as 2.8? Anyone agree. Cost of debt was already after tax - so remain 7%.


dont know about NPV cos i f'd that question up. yes i used 7% for the first bond and then worked out the kd on the other bond via IRR.

damn i forgot to do EPS. i had dividend yield, capital gain, gearing.
Former userFormer user15y ago#134
Can anyone remember what there NPV of project was in Q1?? I had +4150
Former userFormer user15y ago#135
i attempted of 89 marks only :( hoping to get 50
Ppastymuncher15y ago#136
Seems my paper went pretty much like everyone else's. The exam itself wasn't so bad, I just needed another 3 hours to finish it. So much pressure!

Q1a I did ok on and the last question. It was downhill after that. Q3 was solid! Screwed up my WACC calculation on Q2, missed a load of parts out of other questions. Will be very very lucky to pass but I said that about tax and got 58.......fingers crossed.

I didn't do any past papers before I sat the exam so I'm blaming it on lack of practice.
Sstasi15y ago#137
I got NPV as positive 1.288 million
I only studied exchange rates yesterday....I got Forward & money market as same amount :(
For WACC before I got something like 10.98 or something then after about 10.4...not sure I remember commenting it fell by 0.55%
Crazy exam.... result should be interesting

Best wishes to everyone
Former userFormer user15y ago#138
v v v v v v v hard then last attempts so bad and disheart .
Former userFormer user15y ago#139
I messed up the perpetual cash flows part in ques 1b cause i could not remember.
Also, I do not know how to handle working capital in ques 1a. I just put in yr 0 and
left it there. Is that correct or is there more to it?
And in 2c i did not know how to analyse whether issue bonds decrease WACC.
Also, could someone also tell me how many marks are for ratio analysis of maximise
shareholder wealth in ques 3a? I messed that up too :(....i dunno why
Time pressured exam for me.
Former userFormer user15y ago#140
I saw the questions and said to myself...you know this...you did this....but why the hell I did't know how to start question 2...and why do the questions seem so familiar but i can't remember how to approach them......snap out of it and start writing, start calculating, never expected so much theory though.......alas nothing worked...and 50 seems unreachable.....so December it is.
Former userFormer user15y ago#141
stasi u did all gud
Jjoevassallo15y ago#142
I think the Forward hedge was better to use - it was cheaper than the Money market Hedge payment.
Former userFormer user15y ago#143
.....and how do you calculate the market value of the new bonds?
Former userFormer user15y ago#144
Too many calculations to do in the time though knew how to.
Gave up on completing them and concentrated on the discussion parts. Hope that is enough to pass.
Iiyer15y ago#145
Paper was absoultely good.. as usual time management was the key
Former userFormer user15y ago#146
did anyone cal an amount for working capital in yr4? by this i mean not releasing the 750 as the sales wld continue beyond the 4yrs used in the question.
Former userFormer user15y ago#147
q3 was indeed a nightmare for me not sure if i score any marks there guess i was extremely overwhelmed by having to do so much....my my the theory was awful i thought i was writing P1 at one point (lol)
Jjoevassallo15y ago#148
I think the answer is yes you need to relaese the full amount in Y4.

That's what I did at least.
Former userFormer user15y ago#149
tzxsean what did u get for question 1 part b i think it was...asking abt cal npv perpetual succession??
Iiyer15y ago#150
@05008967 said:
I also had (750) in year zero and recovered in year 4. There were no other adjustments to WC required.

In the question it was said Director was estimating with four year Horizon, and project was to continued further... so no question of working capital recovery....i think so

Do you remember on the WACC question, when including the bonds did you have these figures...

(250m/250m + 62.4m + 40m)*Ke ?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.