Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#151
@joevassallo said:
I think the answer is yes you need to relaese the full amount in Y4.

That's what I did at least.



but it will go beyond 4yrs
Former userFormer user15y ago#152
@iyer said:


omg i didnot release it as i thought because sales will continue beyond 4yrs then.....
Former userFormer user15y ago#153
@joevassallo said:
I think the answer is yes you need to relaese the full amount in Y4.

That's what I did at least.

y did u release it
Former userFormer user15y ago#154
in WACC it was (Ke*250)/352.4 + (Kd1*62,4)/352.4 + (kd2*40)/352.4
Least thats what I did...
Former userFormer user15y ago#155
hard, and too much room for interpretation. hope i am in the luck side:)
Former userFormer user15y ago#156
@peldor said:
in WACC it was (Ke*250)/352.4 + (Kd1*62,4)/352.4 + (kd2*40)/352.4
Least thats what I did...


MV of new debt was 40 mil? I thought that was par value? Im guessing u put 250 mil + 62.4 mil + 40 mil = 352.4 mil? right?
I put market value as sum of future cash flows, that is, interest + redeem value of $105 then discounted using cost of capital 7%. Is that wrong?
Jjoevassallo15y ago#157
I think the new MV of bond should be $42, i.e. $40/100*105.

The working capital should be all released in Y4. The continuation after 4 years of the project is for the 2nd part of the question where perpetuity comes into play.

I dont think 7% is correct - the cost of debt for the new bond needs to be worked by the IRR.
Jjoevassallo15y ago#158
@josey said:
y did u release it

Yes I released it in Y4 - cannot remember the exact figure but should $750 with the inflation for each year.
Former userFormer user15y ago#159
what growth rate was in Q2?
Former userFormer user15y ago#160
hi joevassalio, if the MV is $42, did you need to discount the 105 to the redemption date?
Former userFormer user15y ago#161
paper was not too bad, the time needed was nearer to 4 hours than 3 in my view, would be happy to get 50% to be honest...
Former userFormer user15y ago#162
for growth i did: dividend in 1st yr * (1+g)^n yrs = div in last yr.....cannot remember the exact percent i got.
Former userFormer user15y ago#163
Div growth I got 2,98%, rounded it up to 3%
Jjoevassallo15y ago#164
@shane2e said:
hi joevassalio, if the MV is $42, did you need to discount the 105 to the redemption date?
hi shane yes I discounted the $105 to the redemption date 10 years at discount rate. But I used Capital as $100 not sure if I was correct!
Also I worked the growth div as 2.98% rounded to 3% using the past dividends.
Former userFormer user15y ago#165
lack of time hope for 50
Former userFormer user15y ago#166
I'm abit confused......why did the examiner say that assume any funds used in hedging must be borrowed, I did include the borrowing interest rate in the money market hedge, but was my error to also apply the borrowing interest rate to the forward hedge making my money market hedge better????
Former userFormer user15y ago#167
hope for pass with 50%
Former userFormer user15y ago#168
Ran out of time, attempted Q3 on ratio analysis last
Former userFormer user15y ago#169
sigh ran out of time too. left a few of the 6,7,8marks theories question blank :( .. and i forgot to recover the working capital for Q1 and got NPV of 713k ..
Former userFormer user15y ago#170
someone asked me bout PV of cash flow in perpetuity ?

I just take the cash flow before tax on year 4 and divide with 12%
and minus tax of 30%

at first I thought of applying inflation of 3% onto the cash flow but at the end I din't do it. Should I inflate it?
Ssherlynlum15y ago#171
This time theory is more than calculation.

Hoping for 50 marks too... haih...
Former userFormer user15y ago#172
can anyone tell me if i wrote in q1c if i wrote irr,npv and profitability index if any is right
Former userFormer user15y ago#173
hoping for 50 as well!!!! Might have been disaster for me. not completed Q1 i, ii, Q2 ii, and others attempted but seem answers not complete. Hoping.....
HHandsome15y ago#174
you are the first one whose WACC is same like mine
@muzna88 said:
Q1 I inflated all cashflows n discounted on nominal terms , B part URGHHH i dn't seem to get any mark there , Part C i could'nt remember anything so thought of Capital rationaing,sensitivity anlysies and Probability .

Q2 Before Issue of Market WACC was 8.6
After issue it was 8 , probably m wrong bcz i cldn't figure out how to calculate growth :(
B AND C i left them all

Q3 DID ok , it was all theoryy huhhh

Q4 a) forward hedge was preferable
b) bulk discount was preferable

I hope m correct
Praying for atleast 55 marksss :(
Former userFormer user15y ago#175
@jaybhudia said:
can anyone tell me if i wrote in q1c if i wrote irr,npv and profitability index if any is right

i don't think u will get marks for that .
Nnavin12315y ago#176
theoretical part was complex than calculation.overall it was not easy.hoping for 50.
Rredrose15y ago#177
Q1. I was confused on what rates to use but since it asked for nominal rates so i used 12 %...i inflated the seling ,vc, fc. forgot to recover working capital in year 4 :(.... investment appraisal wrote about npv, irr.. i think i messed up
Q2. I think it was about the effect of cost of debt on wacc... i just hope i did the calculations right on wacc..
Q3. Was really running out of time... really time pressurizing .. keeping my fingers crossed><
Q4. Did we have to calculate EOQ for bulk discounts? i did the settlement part managed to do it but somehow messed up with bulk discounts. i have a feeling i mssed up money market hedging.. coz i got a somewhat a big diff btn money market and forward... it was all self study fr me..... i hope i can make it...
SSara22215y ago#178
soo depressed after studying the whole book whole kit in exam its like i m the dumb of all . This paper is not justified complex calculations and theory requires a lot to write n time is too less .
i left easy 10 marks theory parts coz i ran out of time .
can some1 tell what did examiner mean by saying calculate MV of WACC ? got confusd on dis part
Yy.prananv15y ago#179
actually market value of wacc means to take market value of equity and the market of debt when calculating the WACC and not their book values!!!
Yy.prananv15y ago#180
@handsome said:
you are the first one whose WACC is same like mine

I think for the WACC part,I also got 8% something and then got a lesser WACC after the issue!!! :D .....but then when we were told what affects the market value of tradable bonds,what was we supposed to write??? :S
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.