Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#61
@avinashbhatia said:
IN QUESTION NO 1 : I GOT NPV OF 981 POSITIVE
QUESTION 2 WACC:11.2 % AND 10.45 %
Q3:RIDICULOUS :D
Q4:FWD MARKET 390 MONEY MARKET 394$ SO FWD IS PREFERABLE
IN EOQ QUESTION : EARLY SETTLEMENT DISCOUNT 902700 AND BULKDISCOUNT 901600 SO BULK IS PREFERABLE

TELL ME AM I RYTE ?

Avinash Bhatia, Q1 was positive but a rather different figure at my end. Q2, i think its just a rounding factor, well done on Q3 and Q4 Same answer
Aavi15y ago#62
alifarooqi2000
you got the same answers of bulk n early settlement ?
Aavi15y ago#63
incremental w.c was
in year 1:22
2:23
3:23.5
4:750

is this right ?
Jjshields15y ago#64
Well I seem to have done something wrong on Q4 as lots of people seem to think that Bulk purchase was a viable option, I calculated that though it was better than the prompt payment discount it was still worse than there current method so they shouldn't take either option.
Aavi15y ago#65
for f.c i applied 3% inflation
1000x1.03 =1030
1800x1.03^2=1909
and so on . . .
does anybody of u have done this type of calculation
Uuid019115y ago#66
@avinashbhatia said:
incremental w.c was
in year 1:22
2:23
3:23.5
4:750

is this right ?


i thought 750 should be in year 0?
Former userFormer user15y ago#67
sooooo lengthy.......whats going to happened in f7...........afraid
Aavi15y ago#68
yea 750 in year 0

but working capital can never be consumed and it should be recoverd in year 4
750
Former userFormer user15y ago#69
Hope I can pass it.
Former userFormer user15y ago#70
Q2: For the first bond there was no interest rate or maturity date, did we just assume a rate and maturity?
Former userFormer user15y ago#71
@carmonkey said:
Q2: For the first bond there was no interest rate or maturity date, did we just assume a rate and maturity?
if no maturity date ,it should be an irredeemable debt? its interest rate = 100x nominal rate / market value
00500896715y ago#72
@avinashbhatia said:
yea 750 in year 0

but working capital can never be consumed and it should be recoverd in year 4
750


I also had (750) in year zero and recovered in year 4. There were no other adjustments to WC required.

Do you remember on the WACC question, when including the bonds did you have these figures...

(250m/250m + 62.4m + 40m)*Ke ?
Former userFormer user15y ago#73
maaaaaaan!!! thanks tho..! but there was no interest rate though? there was a cost of capital of 7% so used that as the d/f - oh its not looking good, thought i had WACC in the bag too :(
00500896715y ago#74
@alancong said:
@carmonkey said:
Q2: For the first bond there was no interest rate or maturity date, did we just assume a rate and maturity?
if no maturity date ,it should be an irredeemable debt? its interest rate = 100x nominal rate / market value


I had 104/100 x 60m = 62.4m
Former userFormer user15y ago#75
did anybody think part a of question 1 was to long for the time that it should have been done in, also question 3 was a nightmare.
Former userFormer user15y ago#76
a
@05008967 said:
I had 104/100 x 60m = 62.4m


Oh I did get £62.m for the MV but by using an assumed int rate and maturity rate! lets hope that pays off! Thanx guys :)
Jjaykhawaja15y ago#77
hoping to pass .mAY ALLAH HELP US ALL.
Former userFormer user15y ago#78
about wc, if not mention not taking back at the end of the period, it normally assume take back at year end. but if the project cash flow is perpetuity, it should not take back at year 4 ,i think. i did not sit the exam, i just based on all of your discussion.
Jjaykhawaja15y ago#79
JUST WENT Blanked before papper and everything was disaster
Former userFormer user15y ago#80
@carmonkey said:
a
did the question give you a balance sheet or not ? can u find the nominal rate of the debt over there?
Oh I did get £62.m for the MV but by using an assumed int rate and maturity rate! lets hope that pays off! Thanx guys :)
Uuid019115y ago#81
@alancong said:
about wc, if not mention not taking back at the end of the period, it normally assume take back at year end. but if the project cash flow is perpetuity, it should not take back at year 4 ,i think. i did not sit the exam, i just based on all of your discussion.


yes this was a diff scenario from pass yr papers...
they specified that directors thought of continuing hence i did not take back
Wwhathaveidone15y ago#82
I put working capital as (750k) in year 0; did not recover it in year 4; but i thought there was a requirement for an annual incremental increase of an extra (think it was 3%),,, so i had an outflow in year 1 of the extra 3% , etc, etc,

for the bond in the WACC question .. didnt they give us the after tax cost of debt?

Question 3 was a complete nightmare.. so much information!!!... didnt know what ratios to calculate... think i really blew this question....
Jjoevassallo15y ago#83
Too much calculations I thought. And discursive elements too.
Q1 - I worked out NPV as $1,2m. I mentioned Sensitity analysis, Expected values and Simulation
Q2 - About WAAC I wrote about Miller and Mogdilaini theories (tax/no tax). Srcip dividend is issue of shares in lieu of dividends. Cost of debt for new bond - put redemption as $105 and capital $100. - not sure if correct??
Q3 - Working capital policy- I wrote about aggressive and conservative.Choice of dividends I wrote about signalling and clientele effects?
Q4 - Forward cheaper than Money market. Interest/Inflation I wrote about IPRT and PPRT theories.

So on so many to talk about - time is a big problem in these exams no matter how much you practice! Any ideas and Good luck to all.
Former userFormer user15y ago#84
@alancong said:



No from what I can recall it just said xxx company has £60m in £100 loan notes. xxx uses 7% cost of Capital.
Former userFormer user15y ago#85
@uid0191 said:
yes this was a diff scenario from pass yr papers...
they specified that directors thought of continuing hence i did not take back


But the question specified "Assuming the production last for 4 years only", right on the beginning
Ssaidmezher15y ago#86
Q1
either ways would work, either apply inflation on each and individual inflow/outflow (do it this way and lose valuable time for other questions), or cashflows without appying inflation on any but discount at effective cost of capital (e) 1+e = (1+m/1+i) instead.(and u would have saved a lot of valuable time for other questions
Former userFormer user15y ago#87
@saidmezher said:
Q1
either ways would work, either apply inflation on each and individual inflow/outflow (do it this way and lose valuable time for other questions), or cashflows without appying inflation on any but discount at effective cost of capital (e) 1+e = (1+m/1+i) instead.(and u would have saved a lot of valuable time for other questions

i would not agree your points, as question specificly ask use Nominal rate. so u must use nominal rate.
Former userFormer user15y ago#88
@joevassallo said:
Too much calculations I thought. And discursive elements too.
Q1 - I worked out NPV as $1,2m. I mentioned Sensitity analysis, Expected values and Simulation
Q2 - About WAAC I wrote about Miller and Mogdilaini theories (tax/no tax). Srcip dividend is issue of shares in lieu of dividends. Cost of debt for new bond - put redemption as $105 and capital $100. - not sure if correct??
Q3 - Working capital policy- I wrote about aggressive and conservative.Choice of dividends I wrote about signalling and clientele effects?
Q4 - Forward cheaper than Money market. Interest/Inflation I wrote about IPRT and PPRT theories.

So on so many to talk about - time is a big problem in these exams no matter how much you practice! Any ideas and Good luck to all.

i donot know the calculation part, but your discussion parts did quite good. you got right theories.
Former userFormer user15y ago#89
@eugeneksc said:
But the question specified "Assuming the production last for 4 years only", right on the beginning

but wc is not only used to support production, it also used to support ie inventory, salary, in one words, for daily running of the business. i think it's better not take back
Mmuzna8815y ago#90
Q1 I inflated all cashflows n discounted on nominal terms , B part URGHHH i dn't seem to get any mark there , Part C i could'nt remember anything so thought of Capital rationaing,sensitivity anlysies and Probability .

Q2 Before Issue of Market WACC was 8.6
After issue it was 8 , probably m wrong bcz i cldn't figure out how to calculate growth :(
B AND C i left them all

Q3 DID ok , it was all theoryy huhhh

Q4 a) forward hedge was preferable
b) bulk discount was preferable

I hope m correct
Praying for atleast 55 marksss :(
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.