Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#31
@m391 said:
wht abt how to incorporate risk into investment appraisal?

you can talk baout:
1, probability
2.sensitivity
3,discount rate (wacc adjust)
4, or discounted payback
Mm39115y ago#32
@handsome said:
in Q1 do we need to add inflation? i mean in 3rd year it was written that variable cost is 3, then we need to add inflation 3 time (because it was 3rd year) is that OK?

what was the 1 way to incorporate risk in investment appraisal?

in question 2 we need to take 95 in year 0 and 100 in 10th year?? is that ok? or 100 in first year and 105 in 10th year?

I hVE EXACTLY THE SAME QUESTION!
00500896715y ago#33
To incorporate risk in investment appraisal I suggested using another cost of capital and then using the IRR to determine if it met with current objectives. I also suggested using sensitivity analysis but think that is the wrong thing to write about too.
Former userFormer user15y ago#34
@05008967 said:
I left the cost of capital as it was in Q1 because all other costs were on the same inflation rate - can someone please confirm that this was the correct thing to do? I ended up with year 5 tax at 615k.

Q2 for the WACC I ended up with 12.6% before the bonds and then 10% after bond issue. My cost of debt for the bonds was 5% Really worried I have done something way wrong on this question.

Q3 was quite hard too. I am usually good on ration analysis but having the info split all over the place and only part of the SOFP threw me out.

Q4 - panic about the interest rate question:( Then did my money market hedge but ended up getting the forward contract being more value for money.... i think that sounds a bit wrong!! Saved about £3750?

Q4 part B - I felt led into using the EOQ but it didn't seem to ask for that, so ended up calculating the current order cost, the current holding cost and the purchase price x annual demand and totalled up.

I hope for 50 :(


Q2 I got IRR 6,02%, WACC 12 and then 11 or so I think
Q3 Worst question by far
Q4 forward was better by around 4000, yes
part B wasnt about EOQ and choice with 3,6% discount was better with option 0,5% discount being worse even than current
Former userFormer user15y ago#35
@m391 said:
wht abt how to incorporate risk into investment appraisal?


i duno correct or not

but i said increase inflation rate estimation, shorten product life cycle years estimation and decrease estimation on customer demand and sales volume
Former userFormer user15y ago#36
@05008967 said:
To incorporate risk in investment appraisal I suggested using another cost of capital and then using the IRR to determine if it met with current objectives. I also suggested using sensitivity analysis but think that is the wrong thing to write about too.

@05008967 said:
To incorporate risk in investment appraisal I suggested using another cost of capital and then using the IRR to determine if it met with current objectives. I also suggested using sensitivity analysis but think that is the wrong thing to write about too.

using another cost of capital is right ,but not based on irr,.should talk about adjust wacc according to risk. sensitivity is right i think
HHandsome15y ago#37
@tzxsean said:
i duno correct or not

but i said increase inflation rate estimation, shorten product life cycle years estimation and decrease estimation on customer demand and sales volume

i did almost same, and i have added the time value of money too :-s lolz dong know it was correct or not :-s
Former userFormer user15y ago#38
@tzxsean said:
i duno correct or not

but i said increase inflation rate estimation, shorten product life cycle years estimation and decrease estimation on customer demand and sales volume

@tzxsean said:

all your answers i think is about the robutness of a project ,it refer to sensitivity of a project ,another two ways need to consider.
i duno correct or not

but i said increase inflation rate estimation, shorten product life cycle years estimation and decrease estimation on customer demand and sales volume
Former userFormer user15y ago#39
Expected values and adjusted cost of capital for incorporating RISK
I think payback, sensitivity etc are more Uncertainty but you probably get marks for those 2 as otherwise I couldn't think of a third?
Former userFormer user15y ago#40
very lengthy paper hope for 50%
Former userFormer user15y ago#41
paper was not hard but it was time pressured...one can easily panic in this disastrous exam..hoping for 50% =S
Former userFormer user15y ago#42
Hope for at least some marks for theories
Sometimes in exam we cant recall everything we learn
Eg. Sensitivity analysis
Former userFormer user15y ago#43
question 1 answer 1231,000 positive npv
question 2 wacc before 12 after 10.44
question 2 using irr to calculate cost of new debt 6.02
Former userFormer user15y ago#44
future better than money market rate
Former userFormer user15y ago#45
settlement discount not worthed but bulk is viable to accept on financial grounds
Former userFormer user15y ago#46
Is the fixed cost increment an incremental cost?
Former userFormer user15y ago#47
I just remember i din work to the nearest 1000 so how much i will be penalised
Former userFormer user15y ago#48
I work to nearest 1000 after every steps instead 1 final figure
Former userFormer user15y ago#49
It was a bit lengthy.Too many thinks to do in just 3 hours.
Yy.prananv15y ago#50
me too I wanted to know if we had to take incremental fixed costs for number 1 since we were given the total costs each year???
Jjay1415y ago#51
for incoporating risk, i wrote about capm and risk adjusted discount rate, expected values and simulation..pls was i just writing complete crap?..who knows?
Former userFormer user15y ago#52
Too lengthy indeed. I couldn't remember anything about incorporating risk and didn't write much about scrip dividends... hope to get 50%..
00500896715y ago#53
@tzxsean said:
I work to nearest 1000 after every steps instead 1 final figure


I rounded up to the 1000 when calculating the PV in the final lines.
Former userFormer user15y ago#54
@05008967 said:
I rounded up to the 1000 when calculating the PV in the final lines.

if asked to work to the nearest 000, for each step you need to round ,however ,penalty will not heavy, i think no more than 2 marks as long as you did it in the right way
Ggarygood15y ago#55
My IRR was aroung 8.something%, crap!

Far too much to write. And yes I started with working out the damn EOQ, then realised it wasn't that. Had to leave bits out. Started with Q4, whch I thought was reasonably doable.

Completely exhausted, fingers crossed for this one, but it doesn't look good for me, I must admit.
Ggarygood15y ago#56
For sensitivity, I waffled about beta, probabilities (EV) and sensitivity.

God, when I think back, I could have done so much better.
Aavi15y ago#57
IN QUESTION NO 1 : I GOT NPV OF 981 POSITIVE
QUESTION 2 WACC:11.2 % AND 10.45 %
Q3:RIDICULOUS :D
Q4:FWD MARKET 390 MONEY MARKET 394$ SO FWD IS PREFERABLE
IN EOQ QUESTION : EARLY SETTLEMENT DISCOUNT 902700 AND BULKDISCOUNT 901600 SO BULK IS PREFERABLE

TELL ME AM I RYTE ?
Aali_zia4u15y ago#58
Paper was easy but time pressured....

I made some blunders in paper so i will penalise surely....

1. In question 1, incremental Working capital is not taken as a consequence of applying inflation rate moreover i made calculation to "million rupees" instead of "000"


2. In question 2, i did (1-tax) with debt included in WACC but tax were already less in the rate moreover when calculation IRR, i didnot take interest after tax....

I made such blunders after great knowledge of F9, and i am not believing that what done even i known all.

Luck really really matters.

May God, i got 50....
Former userFormer user15y ago#59
Avinash Bhatia, Q1 was positive but a rather different figure at my end. Q2, i think its just a rounding factor, well done on Q3 and Q4 Same answer
Ggarygood15y ago#60
On hedging I think I got the forward rate cheaper than the market hedge.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.