Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 F9 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Mmuzna8815y ago#91
Alancong
will u tell me how growth was calculated n what was the growth in Q2
Wwasimkhanwazir15y ago#92
paper was average
Wwasimkhanwazir15y ago#93
paper was average
Former userFormer user15y ago#94
@muzna88 said:
Alancong
will u tell me how growth was calculated n what was the growth in Q2

hi, there; i did not sit the paper ,so i donot know what's the question. what growth rate they are asking for? was it using dividend valuation model to calculate ke? the growth rate should be 2 way to calculate: g=rxb OR using average growth rate 1. The averaging method

g=


Former userFormer user15y ago#95
for Q2 gowth, you take the last dividend paid, divide it by the first dividend paid, and then raise it to the power of 1/x years, i think it's 1/4 if i remember correctly.

what do we have to consider in formulating working capital policy...? i wrote a bunch about the nature of the business and the risk attitude of the management... is this correct?

by the way i inflated the working capital, which was wrong anyway... hopefully i get 1 mark for putting it in in the first place at least, lol
Uuid019115y ago#96
@muzna88 said:
Alancong
will u tell me how growth was calculated n what was the growth in Q2

they gave you div for past 5 years...use 0.20(1+g)^4=0.28 and solve g...

numbers i couldnt recall though
Former userFormer user15y ago#97
@eugeneksc said:
for Q2 gowth, you take the last dividend paid, divide it by the first dividend paid, and then raise it to the power of 1/x years, i think it's 1/4 if i remember correctly.

what do we have to consider in formulating working capital policy...? i wrote a bunch about the nature of the business and the risk attitude of the management... is this correct?

by the way i inflated the working capital, which was wrong anyway... hopefully i get 1 mark for putting it in in the first place at least, lol

WC POLICY I THINK you should talk about the 3 approach for funding: aggressive , conservative moderate ,as different attitude to risk will affect cost of wc.
Ssharon150715y ago#98
Paper was really hard:(
Hope i'll get 50%...too much theory...Revised a lot but when i started my paper,was as if i had not revised!!!
Oowais87515y ago#99
after sitting june f9 attempt,i cam to know 1 thing about f9,its intense n u have to b quick in calculations to save ur time to write down theory requirements......
Hhemakantha215y ago#100
Thanx Opentuition>>>>> I did it!
Former userFormer user15y ago#101
@alancong said:
WC POLICY I THINK you should talk about the 3 approach for funding: aggressive , conservative moderate ,as different attitude to risk will affect cost of wc.

imho ...it asked for 3 different factors

3 different attitude doesn't mean 3 different factors

I mentioned about smtg unrelated at the very beginning and when time is almost up I realised I misinterpreted the question so I quickly change my last point to the 3 different approach of WC without explaining it further.

and I mention bout interest rate, duration of bond and market condition as the factor which influences market value of the traded bond.

and about the dividend policy, i think they want us to explain accordance to the company in the scenario, not about the theoretical part of the policies alone
Former userFormer user15y ago#102
todays paper was really lengthy i prepared very much for f9 i knew everything but i made mistakes coz question 1 took me an hour and then i freaked out and made silly mistakes. this was my 2nd attempt just hoping for a 50 :(
00500896715y ago#103
@tzxsean said:
imho ...it asked for 3 different factors

3 different attitude doesn't mean 3 different factors

I mentioned about smtg unrelated at the very beginning and when time is almost up I realised I misinterpreted the question so I quickly change my last point to the 3 different approach of WC without explaining it further.

and I mention bout interest rate, duration of bond and market condition as the factor which influences market value of the traded bond.

and about the dividend policy, i think they want us to explain accordance to the company in the scenario, not about the theoretical part of the policies alone


I never had a chance to write much on this one but said that factors could be the risk of the company, based on the credit worthiness and the perception of the market, whether there was economic turmoil such as credit crunch... but thats about it.. 0 marks i imagine!
Former userFormer user15y ago#104
@tzxsean said:
imho ...it asked for 3 different factors

3 different attitude doesn't mean 3 different factors

I mentioned about smtg unrelated at the very beginning and when time is almost up I realised I misinterpreted the question so I quickly change my last point to the 3 different approach of WC without explaining it further.

and I mention bout interest rate, duration of bond and market condition as the factor which influences market value of the traded bond.

and about the dividend policy, i think they want us to explain accordance to the company in the scenario, not about the theoretical part of the policies alone

if u talked about 3 approaches (this is about risk and cost--2 facots )u will get full marks and you also need to explain about permanent current assests and fluctuating c.a. other factors such as size of the company will limit the borrowing ability and also the previous funding policy will affect the wc policy.
Former userFormer user15y ago#105
@05008967 said:
I never had a chance to write much on this one but said that factors could be the risk of the company, based on the credit worthiness and the perception of the market, whether there was economic turmoil such as credit crunch... but thats about it.. 0 marks i imagine!

I said interest rate higher..investor get higher return so higher value for the bond
then duration longer can collect more interest so higher value again. and when market is not gd, investor need higher value to compensate their risk in investing. not sure correct or not. i just simply write watever I can relate
Former userFormer user15y ago#106
@alancong said:
if u talked about 3 approaches (this is about risk and cost--2 facots )u will get full marks and you also need to explain about permanent current assests and fluctuating c.a. other factors such as size of the company will limit the borrowing ability and also the previous funding policy will affect the wc policy.


probably i will think of tat if I din wasted my time writing irrelevant answer until last few minutes of exam time I only realised. Just hope for pass. Even the calculation part is not tat easy.
Former userFormer user15y ago#107
@tzxsean said:
probably i will think of tat if I din wasted my time writing irrelevant answer until last few minutes of exam time I only realised. Just hope for pass. Even the calculation part is not tat easy.

how many marks for discuss facotrs affect mv of bond?
Former userFormer user15y ago#108
@alancong said:
how many marks for discuss facotrs affect mv of bond?


couldn't remember it's from 6 or 7 marks if not mistaken
Former userFormer user15y ago#109
@tzxsean said:
imho ...it asked for 3 different factors

3 different attitude doesn't mean 3 different factors

I mentioned about smtg unrelated at the very beginning and when time is almost up I realised I misinterpreted the question so I quickly change my last point to the 3 different approach of WC without explaining it further.

and I mention bout interest rate, duration of bond and market condition as the factor which influences market value of the traded bond.

and about the dividend policy, i think they want us to explain accordance to the company in the scenario, not about the theoretical part of the policies alone


Working capital policy is influenced by:
-Nature of the business
-Level of activity
-Certainty in supplier's deliveries
-Operating cycle length
Dang I only got 1 right

MV of the bond, I wrote about the interest rate, required rate of return, PV of future cash flows... hopefully some marks out of it.

The 1 about dividend I wrote bout signalling effect clientele and all those bullshit. Pay or no pay is the same cause of the really bad performance. Then I further bullshit about if there's a good reason to retain dividend then it might give positive impact on share prices (e.g, there's a profitable investment)...

Raising finance through debt is a definite no cause the gearing and interest cover was really dangerous already. And then a bit of bullshit about the redemption period for the previous loan was near blablabla.

Raising finance through equity I bullshit about how it would improve gearing, but it is likely nobody would take them up the cause it's earnings are going down, company failed to hit ROE required, share prices are going down, further share issues will dilute EPS and blablabla...

conclusion, I talked lots of crap in Q3, lmao
Former userFormer user15y ago#110
i think you could probably talk about: 1, the risk to debt holder (ie using gearing to assess the risk) 2, prevelling interest rate in the market 3, fixed return (no risk, ie government bond or invest in shares--dividend yield )
Iiruti15y ago#111
After exam I thought this paper is ok to get 50-60 marks but hard to get good passing score. However after discussions here I am finally confused. It was time pressure, due to it maybe wrongly understood some requirements, like question for WC policy formulation. Hope I past, can't imagine sitting one paper twice.
Former userFormer user15y ago#112
@eugeneksc said:
Working capital policy is influenced by:
-Nature of the business
-Level of activity
-Certainty in supplier's deliveries
-Operating cycle length
Dang I only got 1 right

MV of the bond, I wrote about the interest rate, required rate of return, PV of future cash flows... hopefully some marks out of it.

The 1 about dividend I wrote bout signalling effect clientele and all those bullshit. Pay or no pay is the same cause of the really bad performance. Then I further bullshit about if there's a good reason to retain dividend then it might give positive impact on share prices (e.g, there's a profitable investment)...

Raising finance through debt is a definite no cause the gearing and interest cover was really dangerous already. And then a bit of bullshit about the redemption period for the previous loan was near blablabla.

Raising finance through equity I bullshit about how it would improve gearing, but it is likely nobody would take them up the cause it's earnings are going down, company failed to hit ROE required, share prices are going down, further share issues will dilute EPS and blablabla...

conclusion, I talked lots of crap in Q3, lmao

your answer about wc policy is factors which determin how much to invest. i guess this question is asking for what kind of financing method they choose and what factors affect the financing methods
Ssunny8415y ago#113
Hoping to Pass InshaAllah :)
Former userFormer user15y ago#114
@eugeneksc

if u pay, u provide dividend return to shareholders
a lil compensation to them for their capital loss
4get whether i mention this clearly or not

if no pay, the money can be retained for emergency or survival
also can use to invest in project in other sector which has negative correlation
since own industry got problem
Former userFormer user15y ago#115
@tzxsean said:
@eugeneksc

if u pay, u provide dividend return to shareholders
a lil compensation to them for their capital loss
4get whether i mention this clearly or not

if no pay, the money can be retained for emergency or survival
also can use to invest in project in other sector which has negative correlation
since own industry got problem


but if you pay, the share price will react and drop by the approximate value of dividends paid out, is it not? only thing that is beneficial to the shareholders is that they get some real "cash", but they're still losing wealth...
Former userFormer user15y ago#116
@eugeneksc said:
but if you pay, the share price will react and drop by the approximate value of dividends paid out, is it not? only thing that is beneficial to the shareholders is that they get some real "cash", but they're still losing wealth...


i think MV ex div is not relevant here
Oousjallow15y ago#117
The paper was fair, however you may never know how the marker will mark you paper. I think ACCA should consider reducing to question for F9 to 3. I took me almost 20mins to think and know how the calculated the varibale cost in question 1. I hope and pray i get 50%
Former userFormer user15y ago#118
@eugeneksc said:
but if you pay, the share price will react and drop by the approximate value of dividends paid out, is it not? only thing that is beneficial to the shareholders is that they get some real "cash", but they're still losing wealth...

pay or not pay both increase shareholder value , the only difference is in different kind of wealth. pay increase wealth now by cash, not pay increase wealth in future by the form of capital gain (i.e share price increase)--this is irrelevance theory.
relevance theory div policy will affect shareholder wealth. using div vluation model (share price will be decided by the future div discounted at shareholder required return) 2 more theories: signalling and cliente effect both prove div policy will affect share pric--ie company value.
Former userFormer user15y ago#119
lol, i didn't think about ex div or cum div whatever,
i'm thinking of the consequences of paying or not paying as a whole.
that's why i hate interpreting, every1 have different interpretation, dang
Former userFormer user15y ago#120
@alancong said:
pay or not pay both increase shareholder value , the only difference is in different kind of wealth. pay increase wealth now by cash, not pay increase wealth in future by the form of capital gain (i.e share price increase)--this is irrelevance theory.
relevance theory div policy will affect shareholder wealth. using div vluation model (share price will be decided by the future div discounted at shareholder required return) 2 more theories: signalling and cliente effect both prove div policy will affect share pric--ie company value.


basically my answer is summary version of urs

dun hav much details and I try to finish within time frame of 45 mins per question
no mention of signalling effect and whatsoever

basically like wad I said earlier..straightfoward answer in accordance with the case rather than standalone explanation
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.