SBR*** P2 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
i think it said something about the impairment not being tax allowed so i wrote that this is a temporary difference and therefore no deferred tax arises..
sorry that this is a PERMANENT not temporary difference :)
This is the worst sitting ever! My fourth attempt. Feel so gutted. Guess it's resit for me in September.
@sovuthyoum said: Cannt imagine how the hell examiner think of such tough questions.I personally think the examiners are not humans,maybe some robotic scientific creature or an alien
I feel the same.
The thoughts of going back to it.
Strange thing is I liked the course! I learned a lot and it is so upsetting to get thrown like that with the NCI. I did not dwell on it. Knew I would not get it so made it up and moved on.
I do not want to sit this one but If I have to, then such is life.
The examiner lives on another planet. The scenarios he thinks up of!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
GOOD LUCK TO EVERYONE THIS WAS NOT AN EASY PAPER. First time at doing p2 and it won't be my last!!! A frustrating exam many parts were not hard just confusing, I'm sure many people lost confidence as I did and there are MANY parts that under different circumstances could be answered. The examiner wanted to catch us out and he succeeded it seems. there are many marks avaliable though, just writing out the pro for a balance sheet in q1, marks are avaliable just for trying every question in q2 and/or 3 so as long as you tried ever part you get a mark!
Q1 I only answered half. Oestensibly many parts were not hard. Establishing the value of the nci from a P/E ratio is neither hard nor unintuitive and was covered in f7. However, given that the past 14 exams did not cover it at p2 it was unexpected. I myself took about 5 minutes to figure out what I was doing. The examiner threw me off my game by presenting a lot of necessary information that was unexpected. I got confused by the disposal of the interest in niche, the partial,goodwill method was used I couldn't remember if I needed to include goodwill when calculating the investment.
Was the lease a sales type lease? I stated the residual value shouldn't have been included in the revenue and costs of good sold as this was not going to be realised, but I paniced and forgot how to account for a sales type lease so again, not a topic that is hard, but one that was certainly unexpected.
I messed up with the foreign property, I started treating it as a translation of a financial statement, trying to translate the impairment at the rate at the end of the period when everything should have used the historical rate. Was it a permenant difference? I got confused so much. What was the deal with the restricting of the pension arrangement? I saw the word restructuring and ignored it.
B on the UK stream was difficult, difference between frs102 and ifrs smes for when subsidiaries do not need consolidated accounts prepared. Wrote bout 2 lines.
C also challenging, I was hoping to critique ethical performance but there was no opportunity to do so.
Q2. No obvious principal market, Asia was most active but the entity had used Europe the most. All 3 markets had been used in the past. Assume Europe as most favourable market.
No idea on the discounted cash flows. Stated it was a level 3 input on the heirarchy, that ias41 requires argiculture to be measured at fv-cts and after harvest the assets are treated under ias2 but didn't write much more. Said the nominal rents shouldn't be included, don't know if that's true or not.
Cash settled share based payment, fairly straight forward.
Ifrs13 states use highest and best use, land couldn't be valued on basis of use for construction as there is no planning permission (legally permissible is a criteria for highest and best use etc) so treat as farmland.
Q4 ias1 requires soci to feature profit and lloss and oci under seperate headings and PCI should be separated into that which will be and won't be recycled.
Discussed cash flow hedges and Ppe revaluations and basics of recycling, nothing much. A line on the iasb dp.
About 5 minutes left... Objective of financial reporting, qualitative characteristics of useful information, the other headings of the conceptual framework. Didn't actually say what the cf is so marks lost there. Didn't really say why it wasn't any good, just that it isn't targeted at non investing stakeholders.
Gains on cash flow hedge should be recycled when inventory hits the income statement. Mentioned the change of basis approach but not sure if relevent. Ias2 lower of cost and nrv. Made some stuff up.
Last part was straight forward, excess depreiation from reserves to retained earnings, impairment loss first taken out of reval reaerve then retained earnings.
@hassan1989 said: Simply Ridiculous !!! I think this examiner needs to be changed now. The time has come to say good bye to him. Now he has started coming up with stuff outside of the syllabus...Really? what the hell is he upto? I did so much of practice for the very first time and i was forced to question myself whether did I leave these stuff or have forgotton at all I request to all the victims of today's exam, please fill up the survey from ACCA. its hadly gona take few minutes but we all must inform ACCA that we are not satisfied with today's exam. It was out of syllabus on a number of occasions.It is design to get the answer ACCA want and not to voice student's concern. Please write the administrator as I will do. Just imagine those who loose there passes and starting P's again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Seven years to complete - NEW rule for the professional level. Miracle - a colleague said: Preparation finish - praying begin!!!!!!!!!!!! Take heed!!!!!!!!
That exam was something else!...I know my consols so well and I got floored with calcalating simple nci's and panic!........I started to forget everything after that really frustrating experience.......did question 2 and 4.....question 4 was ok....hoping for the best!...but all in all the paper was a complete disaster!
The exam was really tough. I was quite happy that SOFP was being tested but when I got into the goodwill and the nci, I couldn't do any of it, so I just proceed with the adjustment which in this case not many and didn't carry enough adjustment marks to pass.
Question 2 and 3 were okay but I didn't managed to finish them all. I'm praying for miracle here, guys.
Anyway, has ACCA curved the grade or lower the pass percentage before? With this kind of paper, I hope there's some consideration from them but if not, oh well.
looks like we have mutual feeling about this paper.. this is my first attempt for p2 and i was really stunned by the questions. never thought it would be this difficult as the past questions look doable. hopefully i wont need to resit for this paper, but the chances of passing for me is slim :(
I got the same FV NCI as you = 19*3.6*20%= 13.68
I'm thinking this exam
Is just beyond me.. I'm on my third sitting and it's very unlikely that I will get it this time either.. Very frustrating..:(
@peshteman said: GOOD LUCK TO EVERYONE THIS WAS NOT AN EASY PAPER. First time at doing p2 and it won't be my last!!! A frustrating exam many parts were not hard just confusing, I'm sure many people lost confidence as I did and there are MANY parts that under different circumstances could be answered. The examiner wanted to catch us out and he succeeded it seems. there are many marks avaliable though, just writing out the pro for a balance sheet in q1, marks are avaliable just for trying every question in q2 and/or 3 so as long as you tried ever part you get a mark! Q1 I only answered half. Oestensibly many parts were not hard. Establishing the value of the nci from a P/E ratio is neither hard nor unintuitive and was covered in f7. However, given that the past 14 exams did not cover it at p2 it was unexpected. I myself took about 5 minutes to figure out what I was doing. The examiner threw me off my game by presenting a lot of necessary information that was unexpected. I got confused by the disposal of the interest in niche, the partial,goodwill method was used I couldn't remember if I needed to include goodwill when calculating the investment. Was the lease a sales type lease? I stated the residual value shouldn't have been included in the revenue and costs of good sold as this was not going to be realised, but I paniced and forgot how to account for a sales type lease so again, not a topic that is hard, but one that was certainly unexpected. I messed up with the foreign property, I started treating it as a translation of a financial statement, trying to translate the impairment at the rate at the end of the period when everything should have used the historical rate. Was it a permenant difference? I got confused so much. What was the deal with the restricting of the pension arrangement? I saw the word restructuring and ignored it. B on the UK stream was difficult, difference between frs102 and ifrs smes for when subsidiaries do not need consolidated accounts prepared. Wrote bout 2 lines. C also challenging, I was hoping to critique ethical performance but there was no opportunity to do so. Q2. No obvious principal market, Asia was most active but the entity had used Europe the most. All 3 markets had been used in the past. Assume Europe as most favourable market. No idea on the discounted cash flows. Stated it was a level 3 input on the heirarchy, that ias41 requires argiculture to be measured at fv-cts and after harvest the assets are treated under ias2 but didn't write much more. Said the nominal rents shouldn't be included, don't know if that's true or not. Cash settled share based payment, fairly straight forward. Ifrs13 states use highest and best use, land couldn't be valued on basis of use for construction as there is no planning permission (legally permissible is a criteria for highest and best use etc) so treat as farmland. Q4 ias1 requires soci to feature profit and lloss and oci under seperate headings and PCI should be separated into that which will be and won't be recycled. Discussed cash flow hedges and Ppe revaluations and basics of recycling, nothing much. A line on the iasb dp. About 5 minutes left... Objective of financial reporting, qualitative characteristics of useful information, the other headings of the conceptual framework. Didn't actually say what the cf is so marks lost there. Didn't really say why it wasn't any good, just that it isn't targeted at non investing stakeholders. Gains on cash flow hedge should be recycled when inventory hits the income statement. Mentioned the change of basis approach but not sure if relevent. Ias2 lower of cost and nrv. Made some stuff up. Last part was straight forward, excess depreiation from reserves to retained earnings, impairment loss first taken out of reval reaerve then retained earnings.Its amazing how you can remember all the questions...I couldn't even remember most parts of Q2 & 3 as at 1hour after exams...
Hi to anyone who took yesterdays paper P2..it seems to have been a bitch paper.. Please don't lose heart it is one of the toughest papers out there... I passed it on my 5th attempt last June so I know exactly how you are feeling and how it can take away all of your spirit if you let it...If you get bad news in August, dust yourself off and do it again in September, never ever give up.. That feeling you get when you triumph by getting that 50% is beyond words...
Well said and I agree entirely. Never give up. I have already started revising again for my resit in September. It was very challenging (and tough) yesterday to digest all the information, questions and then put your answers.... Time is also an issue, especially when you need to pause and think, before jotting down your answers. Sometimes I think this is overlooked when you have to complete the questions within the 3 hours. Not to mention the pressure.
On my way home I realised how certain answers should have been given (and what I did wrong), so it is not as if I did not know, but I am sure at times in the exam hall you do not remember everything and your mind gets blurred. But I suppose this is part of the exam skills.....
27 voters think the paper was easy.... really?
Yes but that is out of 1283 votes! It would be interesting to know whether these 27 will all pass???
well said people. I was a disaster myself. I only realised how easy this was after the exams. I can only hope for the best.
Q3
c I used IAS 16 on the basis that there existed already a drug and further cost/expenditure will either increase its economic value (Capitalised) or just and expenditure in respect of marketing etc. I dont know whether that will be correct
Prayer helps!
If ACCA want to do 4 sittings a year (and receive twice the exam entry fees) then they need to sort out the marking. 2 months for results is pathetic.No other body takes this long, it's a joke. 4 weeks max please (although 3 would be better!). Employ more markers if needs be. You have the money!
I noticed Open Tuition have posted suggested answers for F5 & F9, will this also be done for P2? I'm trying to figure out if I will be doing a resit in September or if I can start studying for the next module!
Thanks
Sarah
don't give up bro... be positive and just practice and study smarter not harder.
This is what ACCA stand for "Always Come and Come back Again. How could 4 questions that tough come out in same sitting for just 3 hours paper. Somemore, ACCA strict in marking. Guys, take the ACCA exam survey let them know our hard money is not so easy earn to resit exam again and again. Should be fair to students in each sitting...
The examiner has been changed and this was the first paper by the new examiner hence the differences in the styles of the questions.
@churches27 said: The examiner has been changed and this was the first paper by the new examiner hence the differences in the styles of the questions.He is terrible cruel and must be put aside. The paper is available on ACCA site at the bottom - just relax and redo same using the text. This helps to seal the principles that was tested. It is benefiting us - let put anger away and anxiously acquire knowledge. Regards,
I felt that the first question was very hard, unfortunately it made me panic quite a bit so I made a complete mess of my answers. There were some unusual twist in the question which didn't come up in past papers and in NONE of the question of the whole exam kit I used to prepare.
I didn't really know how to get the NCI figures :S I sat trough the rest of the paper hardly bothering to write because I knew I would not be able to hit the pass mark.
For my next revision in December I will take a different approach and try to put in more time.
I come to think this must be the hardest paper!! :(
Was the toughest ever.......attempted lots of practice questions.....Q2 was a classic....never seen one like that before. The paper was just generally tough.
I agree with all of you, a disaster!
But Q2, 3 and 4 were doable. I realised that afterwards. I should have started with B section first to get easy marks.
I spent too long trying to think on Q1 and I did not even tried the adjustments for timing issues...
Unfortunetaly I can't resit in September (exams not being available in my city). So hope for the best in December.
Best of luck to all of you!
This was my first p2 attempt and it was really bad for me. Consolidation adjustments were so confusing and not even 1 was straight forward. However i could manage to write few relevant points for part b and c for ques 1. section B was again bad. I am sure i had put in a lot of efforts before i attended the exam and did go through many past papers as well...but everything was in vain :(
Key to passing P2 is to realise you cannot cover every single adjustment. If you need to work out an adjustment and you can't do it.. just write the theory behind it and how it is applied. You get some credit for that.
It is a monster paper and also don't think it is just about numbers because the theoretical aspect will save you when the figures let you down.
Also never leave any questions blank, even if you don't know..just write something relevant. There are is 1 mark just for attempting every question...could be difference between 49 and 50..
Never give up..ACCA is hard but you passed till now so you can pass P2 as well!!!
Good luck!!!
@kassy said: I agree with all of you, a disaster! But Q2, 3 and 4 were doable. I realised that afterwards. I should have started with B section first to get easy marks. I spent too long trying to think on Q1 and I did not even tried the adjustments for timing issues... Unfortunetaly I can't resit in September (exams not being available in my city). So hope for the best in December. Best of luck to all of you!Me too; I am now working the paper and recognize the examiner intention - professionals MUST thrive under ALL circumstances. This is what build confidence - accept our ill and remedy it immediately. Please work same and share answers @ green_452@yahoo.com; we'll be better come December - WORLD PRIZE!!!!!!!!!!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

