SBR*** P2 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Is it just me not good enough or is the paper is really tough?
I feel this sitting is very tough. I hardly attempt each of the question.
I felt this exam was harder than last sitting that I failed at 46% :(
Consol additional information was tougher this time and the NCI! how in the hell were we suppose to calculate with PE ratios given? Never attempt this sort of question yet..on the bright side, it seems I am not the only one who felt it was tough.
Was a tough paper - lots on FV and agriculture, question 4 was also a very odd one! God I hope I pass!!!
Q1 was the hardest question from beginning to end.
Cannt imagine how the hell examiner think of such tough questions.
Some parts in question 1 were very different from any previous p2 paper. Hate being a guinea pig for new tough sections to questions
Diary of a P2 Exam:
Question 1
It was a typical Balance Sheet question with two subs and one disposal. The group accounting was OK for me and did it within the time allocation.
Contingent consideration
Further consideration was payable if profit reached $4m but there was 20% chance of this. I ignored it as it was not probable.
NCI
There was a twist in the NCI. The value had to be calculated using the P/E ratio. The share capital was 13m. PAT was $3.6m. I got the EPS and used adjusted P/E ratio of 19 to get share price and then using that, calculated FV of NCI.
Lease
There was a lease question that I messed up. Something about leasing out assets and selling assets where a sale was recorded as $50 revenue and $40m COS ( reflected in Financial Lease receivable of $50m). Didn't have a definite idea but tried taking it out of receivables and payables. ???
Pensions
Messed this up as well. Could not think straight so just made an assumption and moved on. The factory was being closed and employees were being made redundant. PV of obligation was 8 from 10 before. FV of asset plan was 7 before. Did not know what to do so assumed (8-7)=1 was net pension liability.
This included a cost of $6m which I assumed was provision.
Foreign Property
This was a typical foreign property with impairment.
Sub Disposal
Had to calculate good will and the profit/loss on disposal. We were given net assets at acqn of $44m and at disposal of $60m There was also an impairment of goodwill. It was partial g/w. One mistake I made is allocated this to the NCI when it is parent only when calculating NCI at y/e. Therefore got a loss on disposal instead of profit. How many marks lost?
Section b:
Can't remember! But I gave as many points as there were marks for.
Section c:
This was about rules based standard vs principles based standard. I gave definition of accounting standard and explained both rules/principles based. Weak conclusion due to time strictness, had to move on but gave it a good go!.
The P/E ratio was 19--- it was adjusted to Fair Value. They have mentioned a profit of 3,6 Mil if you divide that by the number of shares if i remember well was 26 mil it gives you an amount. Then the formula will look like this :
Price/Earnings per share (computed above)=19.
You can find in here the Price for a share. We know that the controlling was 80% which means NCI was 20% of the shares. Then i have multiplied 20%* number of shares* price per share and i have the NCI fair Value. It seems to make sense what i did. Anyway this will not be enough to pass the exam. It was my first attempt but it had no similarities with previous ones.
Question 4
This was on SPLOCI, recycling and had integrated reporting.
a(i) Describe current presentation of SPLOCI (4marks)
I said it is a performance statement, two sections, P/L tries to classify operating performances (gave example), OCI has two sub sections- reclassified to P/l and not reclassified.
b(ii) Talk about reclassification with example and argue for and against (5 marks)
Explained how it occurs and used cash flow hedge as example. Argument for was it shows total effect of the transaction=more understandable to users, against: same gain recognised twice.
c(iii) principles and key components of IR and concerns (8 marks)
Just gave all I know! Concerns I gave as IT costs and staff costs.
b) Hedging gain was $3m in OCI. I calculated impairment loss as $2m and loss on transaction as $0.2m. Then explained why P/L would only be charged $0.8. (Thinking back my explanation should have stated recycling but didn't!)
PPE impairment reversal was similar with impairment reversal from OCE and excess charged to P/L.
Fair value of a share of unquoted company (Mach) is PE ratio of the similar quoted company 19 times multiply by the EPS of the unquoted company (ie.3600/26000)
I did it like this FV per share = 19 x 3600 (profit for the year) / 26000 (number of ordinary shares)
I dont know whether I am correct or wrong. Any way it was a hard question I only managed try 80 marks.
that was a hell of a paper, I am at my 4th sitting for P1 - am giving up...
I feel was hard and starting with Q1 made feel that I am going to fail by not even starting to attempt the paper. I didn't know how to get the Nci on P/E ratio was really hard never expected such a thing
I started you Q4 , I made it good but not excellent.
Then I did Q3 , it is fine
Finally I started in Q3 it was fine , I attempt one part A but the time wasnt with me I make all the working except for foreign exchange last point , I didnt complete the consolidated FS.
I wish to pass , this is the second time to attempt P2 .
Question 3
Section a was on operating segments. Two segments. I firstly explained operating segment, reporting segment, 10% rule, 75% rule, aggregation rule and then applied it to scenario.
Lab 1 I thought was not an operating segment as revenues were not earned independently and chief operating decision maker did not review performance and allocate resources.
Lab 2 was a reportable segment. I explained how it met the criteria.
No no don't give up this is what they want us to do! You never know when u get lucky with these papers
I didnt know how to get to my nci figures. So i just carried on with the rest of the workings. what they are marking is your working and understanding of stuffs. will be happy to retake it since i did a lot of studying. Hope to gain marks even though my figures are wrong but the concepts and working were right.
A really tough paper. I've done mock papers and been able to most of them.
I calculated FV NCI was calculated using EPS which can be worked out earnings (3.6)/shares then PE = Market Value of shares/EPS. You use that to formulate the basis on NCI.
Nasty trick to put in.
Large part on agriculture which was predictable because it's new to syllabus but horrible to deal with. Didn't do this.
Q3 really worded very oddly in terms of the contracts particularly part c. Could quite get my head around what the examiner wanted.
Q4 was an odd one agreed but if you studied the technical articles should have been ok.
Overall one of the hardest I've seen.
I said the same on the laboratories
Yes I agree with all the posts so far.
Q1 I thought it was very time consuming to work out, especially the NCI's.... no textbooks covered these methods for calculating NCI.
It was a tough paper, with very long details on the questions, where there is a lot to digest, before attempting to answer.
Not sure about a pass....
You get the earnings per share and work out the price per share. That threw me off because they gave the P/E ratio for both subsidiaries.
I didn't calculate EPS, i did like this:
P/E=19
hence earnings is given calculate total market capitalization
P/3.6 =19
P= 19x3.6
p=68.4
hence NCI will be 20%of 68.4
NCI = 13.68
As usual, this exam is difficult because the wording of the question is hard to understand so you have to read it 5 times to figure out what to do.
I got that too :)
I got that too :)
@dontetze said: I didn't calculate EPS, i did like this: P/E=19 hence earnings is given calculate total market capitalization P/3.6 =19 P= 19x3.6 p=68.4 hence NCI will be 20%of 68.4 NCI = 13.68This is what I got.
@puritee said: Question 3 Section a was on operating segments. Two segments. I firstly explained operating segment, reporting segment, 10% rule, 75% rule, aggregation rule and then applied it to scenario. Lab 1 I thought was not an operating segment as revenues were not earned independently and chief operating decision maker did not review performance and allocate resources. Lab 2 was a reportable segment. I explained how it met the criteria.Yes. I did the same. The rest of Q3 is bs
Me too only that i believe that is not enough to pass the paper.
Absolutely hated this exam, Q1 was ridiculous!! I don't know about you all but I find it really hard to determine what the appropriate standards are from the description given. The exam kits all seem to be able to give a specific answer but on reading the scenario about 3 times and starting to write something I then changed my mind part way through! I am definitely going to be retaking this exam in September :-(
Hi! Same here. Exam was so difficult. So much unexpected. I really don't feel like I'm gonna pass. This was my 1st attempt. Really hoping good for all of us.
I think Q4 was the easiest q in the whole exam.
Q1 was quite difficult.
the exam has covered too many areas
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

