SBR*** P2 June 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I thought the paper was fair but a lot to read and think about and with your pulse racing it all merged in to one jumble of words and numbers!
Prior to starting I had decided I wasn't going to do Q4 but after reading it, thought it was a good question so choose to do it. If you had read the technical articles on "Concepts of Profit or Loss and OCI" and "Integrated Reporting" you would have been able to answer it.
Hopefully done enough to pass............
I did it like this too,
Fv. = 19*3.6then *20%
Hi @all,
I did not prepare at all for the paper as I had no time, meaning I read maybe 3 hours old papers. I wrote F7 not too long ago and also sat P7 this June, meaning I had some basic knowledge.
I cannot assess whether it was difficult, I just went there knowing that I will fail for sure and did what I could do and saw it as good chance to get a real test. Never had such a relaxed ACCA exam ;)
What's good: I also calculated NCI as most of us resulting in 13.68 mio.
What's bad: my asset differ from my liabilities by 50 mio...
I wish you best luck to pass!
I found this paper quite tough... I knew there was a trick to the P/E ratio but I couldn't remember for the life of me how the P/E ratio is built up so I just used 19 as the NCI which I knew was wrong but I couldn't dwell on it as I could do a few of the other bits e.g. the foreign property impairment.
Despite screwing up the NCI working I hope I've done enough in the other bits to pass this....
September 2015 guys! lol
At least we don't have to wait 6 months
Completely and utterly demoralizing. I know I faltered over the last week with my practice and revision. After P5 I was just on overload mode. But felt like I had practiced a significant amount over the past 6 weeks. That consolidation question was bonkers. I saw nothing like this in exam kits or pass papers. I felt like all the preparation was in vein for Q1. Q3 was okay but I barely made it through Q2. Think this is definitely a resit. Sigh!
I think September is looming.... never mind better luck all next time.
I was wondering next time study the Technical Articles well. Q4 was all there really and the examiners love to test these areas.
Q1 - I reckon you needed more than 90 minutes to complete it all (that of course if you knew all the answers), which was not the case as it required a lot of thought, which with the time constraint, there is not much I am afraid.
Its a disaster paper, I only managed to attempt 75% of the marks which I don't think will be sufficient to pass,
Good luck everybody, I will start prepare for the new September 2015 sitting
It looks like a disaster for everybody so far.... I only saw one positive post on a possible pass.
It will be interesting to see the pass rate for this sitting. I think it was not easy at all.
This paper was very challenging. Felt the examiner was too focused on trying to catch us out with clever wording in Q1. I had prepared myself to deal with some unknown issues however this paper seem to be a completely different style to all previous papers. I think I've probably lost some of the marks which I would have hoped would have been a given - ie NCI!
Also Q1 consisted of a lot of different standards - took me longer than 1.5 hrs needed but felt the time was well spent so I should hopefully get the ethics marks!...Chose Q3/Q4 as options and think i made the right choice - hope they get me to a pass mark.
I did exactly like you - and had the same problems with time. But not sure if I pass. I tried to write as much as I can but again not sure if they hot the right answers. Good luck.
I guess paper of consolidation will be decisive in pass and failed status.....above all pray..... Pray....pray....
Total Disaster,, but i blame my preparations Damn
After, reading the first part of the paper, I was not sure whether I'm sitting for the right exam. So, I rechecked the cover.
It took one and half hours for the part A question (Only consolidation part). So, I couldn't manage time for answer others. I didn't spent time to read all questions in part B. I just attempted Q 2 and Q 3. But, now I feel Q4 would be easier. Could be score for part B in some extent if sufficient time available.
So, there is no option other than to resit......
@Sangria9
funny that we have the same difference :-D
I just ignored everything I had no idea on... and that was much!
Not only for Q1 but for the whole exam.
I am really excited about result, I bet on 30%... and thinking about taking September exams...
I did the same thing i hope it is correct
3.b. I talked about how it was akin to research expenditure and should be expensed
3.c. I talked about how future economic benefits are likely, technology feasible, and there are resources to take advantage of the drug in development. Therefore should capitalise development costs.
Rgarding $10 fee for drug payable to other company I just said this was going to be a normal costs. I think I was wrong
The biological asset with its cashflows and discounting screwed me up. i know hoe to value a biological asset = FV less costs to sell but the inflow/outflow of cash threw me
also what did people write for finding a FV for 150 vehicles?
Tricky consolidation with continent liability consideration, NCI calculation of Mach ltd. Balance sheet figures stood at 533.6 M, narrowly tallyd :).
Messed up in question 2.
Question 4 was a piece of cake for those who read the articles ;))))))
Effectively I missed 25 marks here and there.
@reshou said: The P/E ratio was 19--- it was adjusted to Fair Value. They have mentioned a profit of 3,6 Mil if you divide that by the number of shares if i remember well was 26 mil it gives you an amount. Then the formula will look like this : Price/Earnings per share (computed above)=19. You can find in here the Price for a share. We know that the controlling was 80% which means NCI was 20% of the shares. Then i have multiplied 20%* number of shares* price per share and i have the NCI fair Value. It seems to make sense what i did. Anyway this will not be enough to pass the exam. It was my first attempt but it had no similarities with previous ones.Colleague - you're excellent to remember ALL of this. This exam is telling me I should l should quit - The paper was extremely DIFFICULT!!!!!!!!!!! I tried to start with the mandatory questions and it just block me out. ACCA know how to make money!!!!!!!!!!! I managed to work some aspect and fill the answer without completing - hope they have mercy and favour me with the requisite grade to PASS. There is a miracle for everyone of us who attempted this paper - give thanks!!!!!!
For the 150 vehicles. I said that they had chosen the Europe market because if you took the price and deducted the transaction costs and transport costs, you arrived at the figure they had chosen. So that meant they had chosen the most advantageous market. Because you can deduct Transa Costs and Transp costs. But I had they should have chosen the principal market for FV which was the Asian market (assuming they had access to that market) because that was the market with the highest level of activity.
Having that said, I didnt do part c as I just couldnt think about that one and made a poor attempt at part a. Half of Q2 was on Fair Value Measurement really.
What did anyone say about choosing the SBP or FV? I said it was equity settled but now I know there was a choice, between cash settled and equity settled. Employee had the choice. Just got in a muddle :-( I cannot think fast enough. Knowledge is there but the questions were so ANNOYING!!!!
On a whole, I dont feel too confident. I know I did the best I could have done.
I studied a lot across the whole syllabus.
I mean I do not get some of the intricacies of the questions. If someone knows the knowledge .... why make it so difficult.
And why throw people on Q1 . I made up the NCI. Dwelled on it for 3 mins at most and said no, to hell with it. I am making it up. Took me awhile , Spent one hour on it and moved on. Felt I could make a good stab at the last few workings but moved on as my time was up for Q1. Didnt want to spend time on something that may just be a few marks.
I started the exam with Q1 parts b and c so it was good to be able to move on to Section B after I had gained a few grey hairs over the consolidation :-(
Overall, not expecting a pass. Be lucky to get in the high 40s.
@determinedciara said: For the 150 vehicles. I said that they had chosen the Europe market because if you took the price and deducted the transaction costs and transport costs, you arrived at the figure they had chosen. So that meant they had chosen the most advantageous market. Because you can deduct Transa Costs and Transp costs. But I had they should have chosen the principal market for FV which was the Asian market (assuming they had access to that market) because that was the market with the highest level of activity. Having that said, I didnt do part c as I just couldnt think about that one and made a poor attempt at part a. Half of Q2 was on Fair Value Measurement really. What did anyone say about choosing the SBP or FV? I said it was equity settled but now I know there was a choice, between cash settled and equity settled. Employee had the choice. Just got in a muddle :-( I cannot think fast enough. Knowledge is there but the questions were so ANNOYING!!!!For the vehicles one I calculated what the costs were for the other markets and said that using the 39,100 from the Europe market is not complaint because that is not the price they would receive at an arm's length transaction in the other markets and they should be using the other values... also mentioned that while it was good that they used external data rather than internal that they should be consistent with how they apply the rule and that using the 39,100 was not compliant or ethical. For the other one I said it was cash-settled (share appreciation rights are cash-settled) and did the calculations and said it would be revalued at fair value every year, showing the expense for each period.
Yeah it was definitely cash settled, realized it after the fact. Which sucks! Probably get a mere one mark attempt for that.
It was a very technically challenging time pressured paper.
My heart breaks at the thought of a re-sit. considering I put SO MUCH EFFORT into it.
Endless amounts of time into this paper.
As long as you showed your workings and did proformas for all workings e.g. retained earnings, other components of equity and added horizontally for current assets and showing the share capital etc you'll get a lot of easy marks so you might have passed it... I've heard it is marked very generously so if you say something relevant you'll get credit.
Thanks Sean. I definitely did all the basic workings. And finished them off an slotted them in. Actually did that in the last 5 minutes because 'thought' I may have time to go back to Q1 , didnt so went back to it and finished off the workings. Put in the %'s and all that sort of stuff.
I really do not know. 50 marks is a lot to lose but its looking that way. How about you?
@determinedciara said: Thanks Sean. I definitely did all the basic workings. And finished them off an slotted them in. Actually did that in the last 5 minutes because 'thought' I may have time to go back to Q1 , didnt so went back to it and finished off the workings. Put in the %'s and all that sort of stuff. I really do not know. 50 marks is a lot to lose but its looking that way. How about you?I did the basic workings as well and slotted in the figures as I went along ... I struggled with quite a few different bits actually in Q1 and wasn't sure at all if what I was doing was right. I think parts b and c made up for it though so I am hopeful for a pass!!! I really do not want to resit this paper!
@chullbulla I like that quote "preparation finished praying just started" :-D
Does anyone remember if it was a deductible tax asset in question 1.i think the question hinted that future profits would be available??
This is my first attempt so I think no matter how much you prepare for a paper like this, the examiner will always throw in a lot that students 'should' know. Seems like he has the approach of 'professionals are expected to know how to deal with such transactions' ---- 'read around the subject' ----- err well I am not a thinker like the dudes in Enron!! Just want to prepare accounts and deal with issues. :-) Mark easy examiners please!!!!
@carrolj said: Does anyone remember if it was a deductible tax asset in question 1.i think the question hinted that future profits would be available??I got a tax asset as well... was too tired at that point to wonder if it was a red herring or not so I just took that as a hint .. think it was 25% x 7 (the difference between the two values) or something?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

