Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FMJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F9 exam!

?Take our F9 exam survey
https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-f9-june-2010-exam-survey/

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here poll results
Pplatinumkp16y ago#151
Finance cost on the bond would not be included because it is included in the WACC. Including it in the NPV calculation would be "double counting" the interest. We used the WACC because the project had same risk as our company.
Former userFormer user16y ago#152
The question stated that the project had already been undertaken didn't it. I thought it did so I used real WACC as the interest on loan should already be in there shouldn't it? If it was a proposal I think I should have used the discount factor in the form of loan interest rate and then the company would have to adjust the WACC. Depends on whether or not it was proposal. Mind is too fuzzy on the detail. F5 Monday!!!
Former userFormer user16y ago#153
well these were interest payments on Loans (200,000 per year) not on bonds, sorry for mistake in my above reply...
M
Former userFormer user16y ago#154
Erm sorry I'm muddling up questions 2/3 in my mind lol. Re-editing my post.
Former userFormer user16y ago#155
yes I did same - used real WACC (nominal WACC x general level of inflation)
then didn't include interest calc.
Former userFormer user16y ago#156
Q3 was my best answered question in the exam ok:
development cost had to be deducted from the fixed overhead and had the balance multiplied by the inflation rate 6%.
Selling price increased every year by the inflation 3%.
Variable cost increased every year by inflation 4%,
Interest should not be included because it's been taken into account in calculating the WACC
Depreciation not included non cash flow item,
Tax was one year in arrears.
Capital allowances on reducing balance basis and deduct the scrap at year 4 and multiply by tax rate,
include scrap in year 4 as cash will be received by end of project,
Discount rate in real discount rate x general inflation rate
That's what I could remember I may not be right please correct me.
Former userFormer user16y ago#157
I was shocked when I saw question number 1 and 4, I studied really hard , worked out the Bpp kit twice and still didnt feel I was prepared for that exam paper... I encourage everyone to fill in the ACCA questionnaire so the exam board will take into consideration our feedback... Thanks
Good luck to all ....
Former userFormer user16y ago#158
@rafa2302 said:
Hi everyone,a friend has found a link on the ACCA website which offers an examination feedback form on specific papers. If you feel that the paper was unjust and the examiners language unnecessarily complicated please complete the form. The examination board use these feedback forms when setting marking schemes, before exam results are published. it could result in a few extra marks if the board agrees – so definitely worthwhile.
The link is noted below:
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ2/News/3331775



I will surely do and encourage everyone who felt the paper was unjust to do so.
Thanks
Former userFormer user16y ago#159
i did same calculations for Q1 as cporteus did...but i found the whole paper quite difficult as each question was balanced with a higher levl of difficulty...Q having easy theory part had tough calculations and vice versa...well now i hope i can get through as i attempted 80+ of the paper with responsibility...and rest is up to the God...
Jjshields16y ago#160
Many of you may disagree but I thought that the examiner had put in probability calculations for easy marks and am surprised that a lot of people are complaining about it as everyone who has posted their results for the probabilities has got the same results.

I thought the 'sunk costs' was a red herring and ignored it it is relevant to F5 and not F7. We wanted to know the NPV of the project, F7, not if we should continue it now it has been started, F5. Of course If I am wrong I will hopefully only miss out on 1 mark.
Either way, I will be resitting in December as my mind went totally blank on question 2 which was really annoying as it was the last thing I looked at before going into the exam and with 0/25 for that question its highly unlikely I will have got a pass.
Former userFormer user16y ago#161
@jshields

by incorrectly assesing those sunk costs, you would have only lost few marks. Anyway it is up to the marker to decide how he/she will be marking ..
Former userFormer user16y ago#162
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ2/News/3331775
This link only lets you leave fed back for Dec 09 examination any comment?
Pplatinumkp16y ago#163
its a typo. just fill it out anyways.
Former userFormer user16y ago#164
I quite agree with the person who said "What the Hell" this is exactly how I felt when I saw question 1 & 4. The other two question wheren't so bad. I could not for the life of me figure out question on for the 13 marks.

God help us all.
Former userFormer user16y ago#165
Hope for 50% is decreasing for me...I think it's not worth working past papers or exam kit...non of these help me for f9
Former userFormer user16y ago#166
I would not say it was too hard...But I am very dissappointed with my personal performance on the exam. While preparing for F9, I was sure that I'd score above 80%, now I hope for 50%...
Former userFormer user16y ago#167
the paper wasn't really that difficult. i prepared using BPP book. didn't really solve the kit either! but i think i did well!
although question 4 was pretty bogus.
Former userFormer user16y ago#168
as far as i remember probability in period 2 of balance being negative was 20%, coz regardless of the outcome (even if there was positive flow it was insufficient to cover negative flow in period 2) in period 1 in 20% cases in period 2 balance wud have been negative. So we needed just state 20% probablility:)

counting expected values was easy, so i just missed the part with counting probability of balance becoming more than 2500 overdrawn
Former userFormer user16y ago#169
I think all in all the exam was fair. But I was not familiar with no. one Q (Probalilities), I haven't got it while I was preparing on exam. But I tried my best with my past experience on statistic field.
And wish u all the best with ur leisure time and good pass mark i.e over 50.
Former userFormer user16y ago#170
i dont know why everyone is jst stuck with those 13 marks perhaps if u have done the i think june 2009 or dec 2008 question on cash budget u can have a very well idea how to with cash budget .
i think the paper was easy but due to its unpredictably make it tough also the time constraint was their.
bu overall easy paper and examiner had done well being creative nt jst giving simple straight forward npv or wacc to calculate sory i hope best for everyone but its how i saw the paper
Former userFormer user16y ago#171
I can not say it is hard at all. If you go through the last 4 papers, you will find similar questions on every single question! Think I will pass :
Jjudith1216y ago#172
the paper was difficult on my part.so different from the past papers.no business valuations,risk management was looking forward to something like that.i did my best in the theory questions to get more marks.am just hoping for that 50 to cross the boarder.
Pplatinumkp16y ago#173
Paper is out on ACCA website for those that are interested in a second look. The last question seems to be okay in terms of mark allocation for DGM. The probability question (1) seems to be alright as well if you had a reasonable go at it and provided some analysis to at least i and ii you would have picked up most of the marks. Other than time pressure, seems reasonable. I hope we get a pass mark. I'll definetely be thinking about it until Aug 23 comes around but my approach is going to be to start studying for other papers and if I do fail i'll have the time to pick it up where I left off and still keep up with my schedule.
Rrvrvrv16y ago#174
what did people write for question 1 b) about the factors for trade receivables? i out stuff like credit control, credit system and collection etc, was this wrong?
Former userFormer user16y ago#175
@tejal said:
Q1 - I got the closing account balances for period 1 and 2 that was pretty straightforward i think..but then the other two questions about calculating the probability of a negative account balance and calculate the probability that the account balance will exceed the overdraft limit or something (i dont remember it properly) those confused me so i skipped them..then there was a that part about trade receivables management policy. In that question I just waffled on about how they should assess the credit worthiness of customers and the usual debt collection procedures they should adopt...the last part of the question was about the importance of liquidity and profitability in working capital management and i wrote that a company need to strike a balance between the two...I was surprised at the 13 marks for the EV calculation..Didnt feel like it was worth 13 marks lol..
Q2 - Um..this question didn't seem two difficult but it was a bit confusing. I calculated the after-tax cost of debt. Then we were so supposed to explain the effect the bonds issue had on the WACC..i wasn't sure if the WACC should be calculated using the book value of the overdraft (4.5m) or were we supposed to use the new limit on overdraft 500,000? Anyone have any ideas? Or how did you people solve it? So yeah that part confused me a bit. The other part was interest cover and gearing if I remember correctly..I calculated the interest cover before the bond issue and after the bond issue and then compared them both the the sector avg. Same thing for gearing...Hmm I think that was it right? I dont remember the rest of the question...
Q3 - The trainee was quite retarded obviously :P included depreciation, didnt adjust for inflation rates..part of the fixed costs were already committed (therefore irrelevant)..used a DF of 10% instead of the WACC..The one thing I wasnt sure of was was the mentioned the REAL rate of WACC and then they also mentioned the rate of general inflation..I calculated the nominal rate of WACC using the formula (1+1)=(1+h) x (1+r)..but I'm not sure if i was supposed to or if we were just supposed to use the given WACC..anyway after using that formula I got a rate of appx. 12% so I used that..but my NPV was was too high to be true lol..I think i mightve messed up the calculationgs somewhere. Overall though the answer seems to be that the NPV is actually positive and the project should be accepted...The other part of the question about how to overcome certain difficulties in project appraisal (different asset life cycles, several IRRs, business risk), I kinda just guessed..wrote whatever came to my mind..again alot of points for that part, unfortunately :(
Q4 - While doing past papers I never felt the need for more time..3 hrs was basically enough to finish all the questions and review my answers but during the exam I found myself under a bit of time pressure when I got to Q4..I didnt really answer it as well as i probably couldve if I had more time..Used the formula for TSR and dividend yield is pretty easy to calculate..i forgot to caluculate capital gain though..oh well...and the rest of the question I answered what I could in the 15-20min I had left so yeah..I think Q4 was kind of a lost cause.....
Anyway..overall I was disappointed with the paper..It was so totally different from the usual question types..I bet even if we could solve all the past papers without any problem - like totally mastered them - we still wouldnt have been prepared to answer the questions on this exam..it was just so different. I just hope I get a 50. I dont think anyone is looking forward to taking this paper again..good luck to you all :)


For the Idiot trainnee question, I think the NPV was quite high , I got something that I cant remember but had the impression that the return was like lottery.lots of laughs.........guess we must have been right.

the second part of the question was a blessing for me..........

1 Assets with different lifecyle....issue is comparism of costs.so u use Equivalent Annual Cost which is equal to PV of cost divided by teh annuity factor. The annuity factor would take the lifecyle into consideration and make the costs comparable.
2. Projects with different IRR............u use NPV, that its main superiority over IRR . Just discount at teh firms cost of capital instead of looking for their internal rate of return, just check that the project will increase the wealth of the firm.

3. Project with different risk.........u cannot use WACC to discout thus u need to find the beta of a firm in the same industry as the project u are diversifying into, ungear the beta by using the Beta asset formula, regear the beta to reflect the gearing of the firm and teh calculate the cost of equity with CAPM , u can then calculate the WACC and then appraise the project.

I guess EAC wasnt well answered last diet, that is why Tony Head tested it again.
Former userFormer user16y ago#176
@maggie said:
I Did , so glad someone have the same doubts. I think both development cost and investment financing should be included if the project would be undertaken as both costs should be capitalised.


I distincly remember reading that sunk cost is not relevant in NPV, apart from that, if u use common sense without exam tension, u should realise that the money has been spent already whether u undertake a project or not, its spent, so its not relevant.

The Kaplan text also stated that interest cost is not relevant as its already subsumed into the Cost of Capital of the firm.

The idiot trainee was really interesting.
Ssuejune798116y ago#177
i think you are quite right there. what they asking is about how to manage trade receivable, that is the way doing it.
@rvrvrv said:
what did people write for question 1 b) about the factors for trade receivables? i out stuff like credit control, credit system and collection etc, was this wrong?
Former userFormer user16y ago#178
I think this time the paper deviates from past examples. Practically half the syllabus is not there. It is not a fair representation of F9. Was very dissappointed and 100% agree with Neil 249 on the communication gap between the examiner and tuition provider. Anyway, let's just keep our fingers crossed.
Former userFormer user16y ago#179
what abt the first num on prob? how to calculate them?? last question abot cap gain n shareholders return too did not attempt!
Ttejal16y ago#180
@happytbaby said:
Quote:
For the Idiot trainnee question, I think the NPV was quite high , I got something that I cant remember but had the impression that the return was like lottery.lots of laughs………guess we must have been right.
the second part of the question was a blessing for me……….
1 Assets with different lifecyle….issue is comparism of costs.so u use Equivalent Annual Cost which is equal to PV of cost divided by teh annuity factor. The annuity factor would take the lifecyle into consideration and make the costs comparable.
2. Projects with different IRR…………u use NPV, that its main superiority over IRR . Just discount at teh firms cost of capital instead of looking for their internal rate of return, just check that the project will increase the wealth of the firm.
3. Project with different risk………u cannot use WACC to discout thus u need to find the beta of a firm in the same industry as the project u are diversifying into, ungear the beta by using the Beta asset formula, regear the beta to reflect the gearing of the firm and teh calculate the cost of equity with CAPM , u can then calculate the WACC and then appraise the project.
I guess EAC wasnt well answered last diet, that is why Tony Head tested it again.
I saw some other posts on this thread saying they also got alarmingly high NPVs so I think we are all in the same boat..I have to admit though, when I saw my answer in the exam I was tempted to laugh coz it just looked ridiculous. I was 120% sure I messed up the calculations somewhere along the line lol..
I agree, the NPV question was interesting. After seeing your points Im kind of relieved now. I managed to get those three points down, but because I left that part of the question till the end I didnt really elaborate much on them. I mentioned the EAC and the formula, using WACC instead of IRR(s) and ungearing and regearing the asset beta. I just hope I can get a few marks in there :)
When I left the exam I was really disheartened, but now that I see some of the other peoples answers are similar, a little ray of hope is shinning through all those black clouds..Im really really paying for a 50 at least..Why do the results have to take so long!!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.