Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FMJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F9 exam!

?Take our F9 exam survey
https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-f9-june-2010-exam-survey/

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#91
@sidrashahab said:
paper was very conceptual. im impressed by the examiner. one who just study the bpp study text could do it easily. in many questions examiner just judged our common sense and that is required of an accountant.
sidra shahab


Are you having a laugh? The paper is not there to test our common sense as you put it but the syllabus. Hence why we study and just dont turn up to the exams. You are entitled to your opinion but you could you some common sense yourself.
Former userFormer user16y ago#92
One the most difficult and confusing F9 Exams as of late, the pattern of the paper and the topics examined have swayed away from the way it is in the pilot paper or the 2007 2008 exams. Whoever said Tony Head is fair, he's gone Head over heels this time round!. I mean 10 Marks for probability(which there were no practice questions or such scenarios in the book) and 60% theory!.

Let's just Hope for the best(which is getting a 50 :P)
Former userFormer user16y ago#93
My Review:
Q1)
req 1 and 2 were quite straight forward op-balance+(cashflow*probability%) = closing balance
i messed up with 3 and 4
Discussion was quite simple, ie e.v doesnt not represent actual cashflow, limitatons etc and a bit introduction to scenario planning which is better simple probability analysis ie it consider effect of variables on each other

And for the Factors to consider for reciable Policy Management:
(4 points , 1 mark for identification and one for explanation)
Current Financing Options (eg cost etc)
Working Capital Structure
Industry Norms
and few other

Q2)
Mistakes:
-Inflation considered for 1st year only
-Fixed Cost Included (rnd)
-Interest Payments Included
-Dep Deducted
-Tax Calculated on Accounting Profits
- Discounted @ 10%

- as at the start of the question it says that the new project have same risk , a hint that Nominal Wacc should be used to discount

-The NPV calculation were quite straight Forward

- Discussion Between Liquidity and profitability (eg effects of both on business)

Q3) Simple Bonds Calculation that are redeemed at premium
- Calculate Its IRR make sure to include tax effect and consider premium
-Wacc calculation and discussion:
-Take market Value of Equity 10000 *4 )
- M.V of Debt which is considered as trading at PAR because examiner has not give any discount rate(ie securities tarded with same Risk Features) rate and we must include it in our assumptions since the question requires it

- The Discussion Includes that it hardly changed the WACC because of the tax effect and a bit discussion about intrest cover and gearing and its effects

Q4)
A) Gain is Calculated as 2008 Share Price - 2007 Share price (same with 2009 and 2010)
Dividend Yield = Div/Share Price

And The Actual Share Holder Return (for comparison with capam) = (Capital Gain + Dividend) / Share Price At Start (ie last year closing)

Discussion would include the decrease in share price due to decrease in dividend (some theories)

:)
MKT Price on historic Basis (with growth
(Dividend in 2010 / Dividend in 2008) ^ 1/2 -1 (answer was around 4 %)

Price = CurrentDiv * 1.04/ 0.10-.04

ii) For New Policy calculate same price as before and discount it 3 years back @ 10 % also discuss the limitations ie (cost of equity may change)

The Last part was a bit easy here are some heading
- Main Object = Profit Max
- Investment Decisions to Achieve This Objective
- Financing Decisions To Make Investment (some discussion of soruces of finance)
- Dividend Policy To Signal Investor About +ve Npv of projects (some discussion about Traditional Theory MM etc)
Ssabrina194216y ago#94
Guys lets just pray for 50% and if we are lucky we would get 51%
Have a great June guys at least whats left of it that is *sigh*
DRdarunen runghien16y ago#95
What a hell paper.. I work out question 1, then try others and left after just 1.30hr in the exam hall... Acca is not working with its tuition providers.. I never expected those question... Shit...
Aadotkhan16y ago#96
Q.1 If u know probabilty simple with simple working capital theory.
Q.2 ok
Q.3 Easiest every tested for Investment appraisal . Piece of cake....
Q4. Tricky but the 12 marks theory was a bonus for this Q.

12.5 marks in every question will make 50 ...... I Hope this will not be difficult...


Did all, ppr tested concepts at a greater extent.....Examiner proved that rote learning is not enough , we have to use concepts and apply....Nothing was out of syllabus.....

Rest my GOD will pass me INSHALLAH !
ABantonio blaze16y ago#97
i have an ARREST WARRANT for the f9 examiner! he or she just commited a crime against humanity! lol. that was hot fire! question 1 was a complete disaster.2 to 4 wernt too good either.hoping for a major miracle,though
Rrvrvrv16y ago#98
what did people write for question 1 b) about the factors for trade receivables? i out stuff like credit control, credit system and collection etc, was this wrong?
Former userFormer user16y ago#99
i dont know to tell.. but i hope my mark after 50%, plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
ABantonio blaze16y ago#100
@ rv,for 1b i wrote some junk about the co having to considr debt factoring and invoice discounting,cost of financing receivables,cost of discounts compard to interest on overdraft etc.i couldnt just leave a blank space,hey! lol
Nnice3616y ago#101
I just hope get 50%!
Former userFormer user16y ago#102
It's a disaster, I think i have to try it again in Dec
Ssonalimadnaik16y ago#103
Can anyone plz tell me if the first q was an EV q or a simulation model q?? Coz i think i was a simulation model q..similar q is there in kaplan text,,
Former userFormer user16y ago#104
@sonalimadnaik said:
Can anyone plz tell me if the first q was an EV q or a simulation model q?? Coz i think i was a simulation model q..similar q is there in kaplan text,,


There would be no difference in ev calculation but you have to define scenario planning in discussion like it considers multiple variables and its effects
Rrmacconnachie16y ago#105
Question 1 part A threw me! I got positive cashflows in both years so assumed I got it wrong and moved on. Quite annoyed because this was hardly covered on the BPP courses and notes. Can't believe the examiner put that in as a 13 mark question!!!

Middle part of Question 4 dividend growth was also a problem - could work out how it worked with 3 years no dividend.

Not confident that I passed that. I thought the whole exam was a bit disjointed. It would be better is they changed the exam format to be like F7, with 2 specific questions i.e. WACC and NPV and the rest anything else from the syllabus.

Bad exam!!!
Mmeaow0116y ago#106
Seems like examiner Is changed....
Aaaah!
Former userFormer user16y ago#107
the paper was an ok one... all tht happend is tht the examiner changed the trend of askin the questions... i think all of you.. in the back of ur minds knew how to answer the qn.. its jst tht when u saw the question.. panic struck cz those were the qns noone really expected... but all one had to do was chill relax and think... lets hope to pass.. njoyy the world cup... pray england wins.. and lets hpe the markers are very happy with the victory and the pass rates shud go high :P LOLZZ
Former userFormer user16y ago#108
for the dvm second part , first we had to calculate 3rd year value of cashflows in pepetuity from fourth year vid a constant rate of 3%. i.e 1/1.331 * 70cents = 52.59cents

then v had to divide 52.59/ 0.1-0.03 = 751 cents or $7.51


question 1 , fist part answer was 2100000 in positive
second part answer was 3800000 positive
third part ,v hd to find probability of getting negative balance i.e 20% * 30% =6%
fourth part i am not sure but i think answer was same as in the third part
Former userFormer user16y ago#109
f9 once again shoked me and dont think so this paper was easy. but now we can only request to examiner for soft marking and just pass us.
guz what is your comments about paper
Former userFormer user16y ago#110
Having done a degree prior, I found the paper a lot easier than Revision kit questions. Looks like the f9 examiner adopted a degree question format approach.
Rrmacconnachie16y ago#111
Does anyone know the answer to the middle section of question 4?

Can we complain about the exam to ACCA?
ABantonio blaze16y ago#112
LoL @ complaining to acca about the exam! did the exam cover anything thats not in the syllabus? NO! So,relax,friend and start preparing for december re-write.im gona be doing a past exam paper every week til december.that shud at least get me a 50
Llouibee16y ago#113
No me to i did exactly the same i put about credit checks and limits the credit control and leagal action..... maybe offer discount to bring debtor days down. It was worth 8 marks so fingers crossed we were right.

@rvrvrv said:
what did people write for question 1 b) about the factors for trade receivables? i out stuff like credit control, credit system and collection etc, was this wrong?

@rvrvrv said:
what did people write for question 1 b) about the factors for trade receivables? i out stuff like credit control, credit system and collection etc, was this wrong?
Former userFormer user16y ago#114
The best think to do is wait for the results. Trying to tell us how you arrived at figures is worth nothing, just unsettling for the gittering. lets talk about how it was not how you answered,,, not interested. The exam was not good. Why? they left out 85%chunk of the f9 content. 5O% is all one prays for. Good luck guys.
Former userFormer user16y ago#115
I don;t know, this paper was prepared to test our knowledge or to failed our knowledge, I think examiner try his best to reappear every student in December. hope marking will be good.
Former userFormer user16y ago#116
i wrote some junk about the co having to considr debt factoring and invoice discounting,cost of financing receivables,cost of discounts compard to interest on overdraft etc.i couldnt just leave a blank space,hey! lol
lol.. i wrote the samething
Former userFormer user16y ago#117
Q1 answers were . . .

a) -500 + (1st amount x 1st probability) + (2nd amount x 2nd prob) - (3rd amount x 3rd prob) ... these amounts and their corresponding probabilities were for period1

b) (answer for part a) + (1st amount x 1st probability) + (2nd amount x 2nd prob) - (3rd amount x 3rd prob) ... these figures were from period2

c) 0.2 or 20%

d) 0.18 or 18%
Former userFormer user16y ago#118
i included interest cost in the NPV calculation.. i think i will lose 2 marks for it as i should have identified the stupid trainee's mistake in part (a) then should have calculated NPV correctly.. damn!
and in cost of debt.. i didnt include overdraft in my calculations.. should it have been included?
Ssharkskin16y ago#119
Im glad that is not my opinion - exam was unusual. One of the main examiner`s comment to past exams was the poor theory presentation in favor of usual calculations. So this exam solved this problem))) Hope for 50)
Pplatinumkp16y ago#120
Overdraft does not affect the capital structure (one of its advantages is it does not affect gearing). It is relevant to working capital management. Therefore, I would not have included it in the WACC calculation.

I think I messed up on the gearing calculation for the company that was considering an offer of debt. I stupidly used the book value of equity to calculate gearing instead of the market value. I'm wondering what kind of impact this would have had on my analysis of alternative sources of finance.

On NPV I forgot to reduce the salvage value for the WDA calculation hence my year 5 cash flows would have been off. From what i gather this did not affect the buy decision.

On the DVM i think the first one was easy. The second one was hard. It was a multi-period DVM which was a combination of DVM and DCF(NPV) analysis. I think that the tuition providers could have done a better job in introducing this. It was a way of the examiner to test the intuitiveness of the test taker. I offered the DVM at 2013 and calculated the Equivalent Annual Growth in the interim period 2009-2013 as being 15% (40c to 70c in 4 years). It really helped with the analysis part because I didn't think the Director was right in saying that they were in an economic downturn and they needed to conserve cash while promising growth of 15% of dividends in the interim period.

I did not make it to the final 12 mark question about the relationships of investment, finance and dividend decisions.

Probability analysis was 20 % negative balance and 18% probability of exceeding overdraft. Simple probability tree would have helped. It was a simulation created by experts so there is some degree of reliance but the output is only as good as the inputs. Also it seemed as though variability of cash flows was the main concern so I proposed that maybe other factors were more important. Also I said that you could not place complete reliance on the expected values and while its a good aid in analysis, contingency funds are needed to ensure that working capital requirements continue to be met. What I should have been thinking is Baumol or Miller Orr for volatility of cash flows.

Gearing and Ungearing of Betas was a long long discussion, specially with the examples they wanted. It was a test - "did you read my technical article?" If you did, it was probably a gift but the time pressure was high.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.