Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FMJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F9 exam!

?Take our F9 exam survey
https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-f9-june-2010-exam-survey/

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here poll results
Llouibee16y ago#61
Thats all i did for the probabilities i x each one by the % added them together and used this as my inflow with a starting balance of 500 odrawn.

In terms of NPV i got rather high but not to high i think it was about $1.9 mill npv which i was worried about but it seems like allot of people got the same! Its a shame they dont mark on average like they used to on AAT because by the sound of it everyone has struggled!

I missed out a part of a question also because time wise its just a joke i dont know anyone who has ever finished it with time to spare!
Im really worried but there is nothing we can do now! Just enjoy summer and wait for august






@raglem30 said:
I got a really high NPV too, but I expected this considering we were taking out 200pa. I thought this was about right given the amount of mistakes that Trainee made. It actually made me feel good about NPV for once!!

In terms of the probability I just X each amount by the % and used the combined total as my CF. I hope this was right. It is just a simulation so is just for guidance. Fingers crossed!! A lot of theory but not a bad paper. Only got about 82% of it done, but we shall see!!
Former userFormer user16y ago#62
q1 and 4 were unusual hadn't seen like them before I'v been practicing for the last month I don't think it's fair to have two ambiguous questions on the same paper
Pplatinumkp16y ago#63
last exam 4 me...now time for some sleep... :)

Good luck to those that still have exams left.
Former userFormer user16y ago#64
Different exam.. 2nd attempt.. wasted.. Q1 part a sucks... and Q4 huh!! i hope to get 50 marks.. but not sure :(
Former userFormer user16y ago#65
@johnnyn123 said:
1st of all....the question didn't ask for the expected cash flow at the end of each period but the ending balance, therefore the (500) had to be the opening balance for period 1 and the EV of cash flows at the end of period 1 had to be brought to period 2. can't remember exactly what closing bal was for period 1 but was something like 2100 positive.

I think we got the same answer
Former userFormer user16y ago#66
i hope you guys pass.. Fingers crossed examiner shows some leniency!
Former userFormer user16y ago#67
@tejal said:
how???

By multiplying the percentages of the situations
1) which give negative balance (10%+30%+60% for period 1)*(20% for period 2) for (iii) and
2) which give balance < - 2 m (30%+60% for period 1)*20% (for period 2) for (iv)
MSmoin shah16y ago#68
wat a hell paper it was i practiced a lot bt all in vain
Mmasiiwad116y ago#69
shear wast of time and money
Former userFormer user16y ago#70
I totally SCREWED de paper or should i say de paper itself waz made dat way ....

Expected value... =X WTH

Theory part waz pretty decent though .. HUH !!

Let it go better luck nxt tym HEHEHE :))
Former userFormer user16y ago#71
paper was too dificult,
Former userFormer user16y ago#72
i tried so hard but all the hardwork was in vain!!! the only proper question was for NPV, apart from that the whole paper was a mess.... i shouldnt have taken F9 this time.....
Former userFormer user16y ago#73
OMG. It's the first time i've taken F9 and at the new exam format and i've just remembered, i forgot to mark the front page of the question attempted!!! Do you think it matters so much? I'm so scared i won't get marked now... oh, i could cry.. :(
Jjshields16y ago#74
Q1 got the same 20% and 18% a lot of people had I recon I got 17marks on the first question.
Totally messed up Q2 but going of the comments I may have done better than I thought, I estimate only 3 marks on this one.
Q3 Loved this question but my NPV was $450,000 and everyone is quoting $2m+ (Did everyone forget the $2m spent on machinery at the start of the project?), I was estimating 20mark on this one.
Q4 Hmmm! I have no idea how I did but unfortunately I only estimate 4 - 10 marks on this one.
So I recon I have between 46 and 50% - See you all at Christmas!
Ttrisha16y ago#75
So basically Tax was a mess, F9 was a mess, I am holding my breath for F7.
Ppetelad16y ago#76
What a Nightmare!

Q1. 100% probablility I got it wrong
Q2. WACC a Day (Timmy Mallet style)
Q3. Easy, Traniee Accountant had it all correct
Q4. Your What's Itchy?
Former userFormer user16y ago#77
@trisha said:
So basically Tax was a mess, F9 was a mess, I am holding my breath for F7.


Same here...really depressing....... *sigh*
Ssidrashahab16y ago#78
paper was very conceptual. im impressed by the examiner. one who just study the bpp study text could do it easily. in many questions examiner just judged our common sense and that is required of an accountant.
sidra shahab
Former userFormer user16y ago#79
I thought it was considerably fair, and a lot of the stuff which came up was usual and kind of similar to past papers. The only unexpected stuff was the EV and probabilities which is more F5 related rather than F9 in my opinion. Everything else was covered under the F9 syllabus. Hope you all get the marks your hoping for. I really hope I've passed!
Jjohnnyn12316y ago#80
Fail to prepare....prepare to fail. Everything that was asked today was on the syllabus so had to be a fair paper, although there is a trend of examiners tending to ask the same things but in a different way (tax this time last year and f7 at christmas). Anyway, if the exams were easy everyone who wanted to be would be an accountant. Suck it up and get on with it people! (and best of luck in the results to all)
Mmoiraloisio16y ago#81
we need to work harder for next session now... lets forget about it, have a break and enjoy Summer now !
Lleemce16y ago#82
eh.. what was that paper all about.. I thought I was sitting a different exam completely after everything I studied!!! I'll be happy to re sit it though.. don't mind!!!
Yyazdavies16y ago#83
@maegabriel said:
OMG. It's the first time i've taken F9 and at the new exam format and i've just remembered, i forgot to mark the front page of the question attempted!!! Do you think it matters so much? I'm so scared i won't get marked now... oh, i could cry.. :(

Ooops, me too, Butterfly, although to be honest I didn't have the time. I'm sure that although not ideal, it should not be so bad that they couldn't mark our papers.
Ssabrina194216y ago#84
I am very disappointed with question one i was like IS THIS FOR REAL
I can recall probability and expected value was a topic in the F5 paper its not fair
And i know for sure that Question 3 i made a terrible mistake there goes another 2 marks down the drain.
Former userFormer user16y ago#85
@funshine98 said:
The f9 paper was really a disaster can anyone tell me in the npv question did we had to take the interest payment of the loan into account the stupid trainee accountant confused everyone lol and what rate did u guys use for discounting the nominall wacc of 12% or the reall WACC of 7%. And how the helll were we supposed to calculate the capital gains and total returns to shareholder. The f9 paper was a disaster really. Sad paper by the examiner.

the discount rate was indeed 12%
Former userFormer user16y ago#86
I was very disappointed with the standard of this exam. Tony Head (the examiner) is generally considered by many lecturers as being one of the fairest on the ACCA circuit.

However I feel the balance of this exam was a significant departure from his previous ones. I have spent the last 4 months focusing on the BPP text (twice), CD's and every past paper including the pilot but the 2010 sitting is nothing like any of those before it.

For those of you who felt it was easy I congratulate you - you clearly prepared well and also have a natural aptitude for adapting to unusual situations. For the rest of us who struggled and are simply hoping we have done enough to pass we have to accept Tony Head decided many of his past papers were too easy and he wanted shake things up a lot this time. This surprised me bearing in mind the pass rate dropped by 5% in Dec 2009 and I would thought he would want to move it back to over 40% asap.

The EV question was not easy nor covered like that in BPP - it is for an investment and not a cash flow. This question was more in application style and probably (no pun intended) more suited to the professional stage at level three intellect. I suspected EV would come up but not in a cash flow situation and I struggled with it myself. I also feel this has been used to separate the brighter candidates as a discriminator but could backfire based on comments on here. EV is also not very common in real world situations for many students and seems out of date in modern thinking.

Overall the easier marks like Miller Orr, EOQ, full WACC calculations, TERP etc. were missing and not enough on working capital structure and capital funding strategy on the paper. The requirements were also somewhat inferred rather than clear in many written parts. I am surprised the paper was passed by those who scrutinized it - I understand it goes through several re-reads and checks. i am left wondering how much - if any - moderating will be required when marking this time around.

I wish all those who sat F9 good luck (including myself!) and I hope we won't be required to sit it again.
Bbundi16y ago#87
I can't really remember what I did in the exam hall. I would'nt say the questions were difficult, It was just too easy to be expected. I hope for 50 marks
Former userFormer user16y ago#88
Questions were too easy but not answers.. LOL

Examiner should assess students concept not math........

ARIJ KAZI
Former userFormer user16y ago#89
I think the examiner really test the student understanding of the key concept and key syllabus area in the exams.

Except for examination condition and time pressure which may not work in some student favour, i feel an average student should be able to scrape a pass mark.
Former userFormer user16y ago#90
I felt happy with questions 1&2, 3 was ok, 4 was a disaster... until I read all these posts! Now I'm realizing I might not have done as much right as I thought! But I thought it was a fair paper, not as awful as I expected. Definitely hope I get a 50!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.