Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FMJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F9 exam!

?Take our F9 exam survey
https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-f9-june-2010-exam-survey/

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#31
hi

I think questions 1 and 4 were unfair. Total shareholder's return was not coverd in Kaplan Kit (In textbook yes,) also counting probability... (is counting probability part of the syllabus?)

One hope is that if someone was good at discussion part, could be scoring well in this exam..

M
Yyazdavies16y ago#32
As an exam it was ok, having said that, my hand still hurts from all the writing!. As an F9 exam, I'm not so sure it worked. From the very beginning i found it a bit odd, almost disjointed from the syllabus. Does anyone think that maybe it should be split into five questions so at least it can cover some of the core areas of the syllabus in a more complete manner?

Thanks trainee accountant for the extra work on the NPV question, lol!
Former userFormer user16y ago#33
I had to do Q3 twice because I messed up the first time lol
I got an NPV > 2000
Thought it made sense after adding back all of the nonsense that the trainee put in but I was still a bit iffy on having a return over 100% invested.Anyone else get anything stupidly high?
Former userFormer user16y ago#34
@samandrews said:
what did everyone do for the dividend valuation model where there was going to be no dividend paid for 3 years?

I calculated the share price with 70 c. and growth of 3%. I received something about $ 10. Then I discounted this number for 3 years with 10% and I received 7 point something. I don't know if this is the wight way?
Pplatinumkp16y ago#35
Yeah i got NPV of approx 2500. Stupidly high made me second guess myself but sure whatever Mr. Head.
Llouibee16y ago#36
arggghhhh good god that was the worst f9 paper i have ever sat and after sitting 3 you think i should be a pro! :(

for the DVM the first part i calculated the growth before which is current div / old div to the power of 1/no of movements which gave a 4% growth and $7. something then the second used the 70cents and then 3% growth and it gave me $10 something.

Can anyone remember what the last part of question 2 and 3 was?

Ta

Thw Wacc i got 11
Former userFormer user16y ago#37
I tried dividend growth over 6/5/4/3 yrs but no matter what I did I got g>coc so formula didn't work as denominator -ve.
I just couldn't see any logic in using the 3% at the time as it said assume 3% after 2013.
Ttejal16y ago#38
Q1 - I got the closing account balances for period 1 and 2 that was pretty straightforward i think..but then the other two questions about calculating the probability of a negative account balance and calculate the probability that the account balance will exceed the overdraft limit or something (i dont remember it properly) those confused me so i skipped them..then there was a that part about trade receivables management policy. In that question I just waffled on about how they should assess the credit worthiness of customers and the usual debt collection procedures they should adopt...the last part of the question was about the importance of liquidity and profitability in working capital management and i wrote that a company need to strike a balance between the two...I was surprised at the 13 marks for the EV calculation..Didnt feel like it was worth 13 marks lol..
Q2 - Um..this question didn't seem two difficult but it was a bit confusing. I calculated the after-tax cost of debt. Then we were so supposed to explain the effect the bonds issue had on the WACC..i wasn't sure if the WACC should be calculated using the book value of the overdraft (4.5m) or were we supposed to use the new limit on overdraft 500,000? Anyone have any ideas? Or how did you people solve it? So yeah that part confused me a bit. The other part was interest cover and gearing if I remember correctly..I calculated the interest cover before the bond issue and after the bond issue and then compared them both the the sector avg. Same thing for gearing...Hmm I think that was it right? I dont remember the rest of the question...
Q3 - The trainee was quite retarded obviously :P included depreciation, didnt adjust for inflation rates..part of the fixed costs were already committed (therefore irrelevant)..used a DF of 10% instead of the WACC..The one thing I wasnt sure of was was the mentioned the REAL rate of WACC and then they also mentioned the rate of general inflation..I calculated the nominal rate of WACC using the formula (1+1)=(1+h) x (1+r)..but I'm not sure if i was supposed to or if we were just supposed to use the given WACC..anyway after using that formula I got a rate of appx. 12% so I used that..but my NPV was was too high to be true lol..I think i mightve messed up the calculationgs somewhere. Overall though the answer seems to be that the NPV is actually positive and the project should be accepted...The other part of the question about how to overcome certain difficulties in project appraisal (different asset life cycles, several IRRs, business risk), I kinda just guessed..wrote whatever came to my mind..again alot of points for that part, unfortunately :(
Q4 - While doing past papers I never felt the need for more time..3 hrs was basically enough to finish all the questions and review my answers but during the exam I found myself under a bit of time pressure when I got to Q4..I didnt really answer it as well as i probably couldve if I had more time..Used the formula for TSR and dividend yield is pretty easy to calculate..i forgot to caluculate capital gain though..oh well...and the rest of the question I answered what I could in the 15-20min I had left so yeah..I think Q4 was kind of a lost cause.....
Anyway..overall I was disappointed with the paper..It was so totally different from the usual question types..I bet even if we could solve all the past papers without any problem - like totally mastered them - we still wouldnt have been prepared to answer the questions on this exam..it was just so different. I just hope I get a 50. I dont think anyone is looking forward to taking this paper again..good luck to you all :)
Former userFormer user16y ago#39
In the last part where we had to calculate share price on DVM.. I think that dvm assumes that dividends will be paid in perpetuity.... so, i dont get that 3 years without dividend part and how to calculate share price on dvm.. i dont know what i did but i got $5.8sp.
i got probability of 20% on q1 a{iii}.. and 18% on a{iv}

Would anyone please tell me whether the interest payments and tax savings on interest should have been included in the NPV calculation!!!
Ttejal16y ago#40
@fundamental said:
I had to do Q3 twice because I messed up the first time lol
I got an NPV > 2000

Thought it made sense after adding back all of the nonsense that the trainee put in but I was still a bit iffy on having a return over 100% invested.Anyone else get anything stupidly high?


ya I got something ridiculously high too..I was like what the...but i didnt have enough time to go and check through so i just assumed it was all right....glad to see im not the only one..
Ttejal16y ago#41
@decentguy185 said:
In the last part where we had to calculate share price on DVM.. I think that dvm assumes that dividends will be paid in perpetuity.... so, i dont get that 3 years without dividend part and how to calculate share price on dvm.. i dont know what i did but i got $5.8sp.
i got probability of 20% on q1 a{iii}.. and 18% on a{iv}

Would anyone please tell me whether the interest payments and tax savings on interest should have been included in the NPV calculation!!!


how did you calculate those probabilities? I was totally clueless about those..
I didnt include the interest payments because i think in NPV we assume that Interest is included when the WACC is used (coz the WACC already takes into considereation the interset on debt??)...Not sure if thats right though..
Former userFormer user16y ago#42
@decentguy185 said:
i got probability of 20% on q1 a{iii}.. and 18% on a{iv}

I got the same percentages :)
Former userFormer user16y ago#43
I think the paper was just a mere effort to reverse last sessions paper, completely opposite from december one... but i think they tried to make it tricky but easy if properly understood. Look at the probability part of first question, in que 4 look at finding out capital gain, no dividend for 3 years... points that we will never ever see in exam kit... but i had a much better paper than last time..... should be able to pass... but i think the view that paper was not a fair picture of overall syllabus... i think they should put one more question to make it 5 questions... but i guess they generally have their targets on how many students they need to pass...
Ttejal16y ago#44
@louibee said:
arggghhhh good god that was the worst f9 paper i have ever sat and after sitting 3 you think i should be a pro! :(

for the DVM the first part i calculated the growth before which is current div / old div to the power of 1/no of movements which gave a 4% growth and $7. something then the second used the 70cents and then 3% growth and it gave me $10 something.

Can anyone remember what the last part of question 2 and 3 was?

Ta

Thw Wacc i got 11



I got around $10.40 if i remember correctly..using the historical data and around $10.60 using the DVM..but I thought $10 seemed like a bit much..still confused :S
Former userFormer user16y ago#45
Like some others this was my third attempt at this paper.

I liked question 1 , which Was essentially asking for a weighted average.while this was not in the study texts it was in the bpp ipass cd so I am grateful for having that.

I'm also glad to see some of the numbers here making sense to me, I'm not optimistic of a pass but like someone else said- forget about it , it's summer!

There really does seem to be a pattern of examiner shifting from 'normal' questions to more unsual formats - in this paper the 'correct a trainees mistakes' question and the averages question. Last sitting it was the construct a sofp soi question which completely threw me. The syllabus for these papers is immense, ESP for someone like me with a demanding job and kids, and this trend to foilingquestion spotting is making life more difficult.

Thanks to everyone in the forum, it serves it's purpose in letting us know we are not alone !

R
Former userFormer user16y ago#46
never imagine that kind of paper ... :( ..
Ttejal16y ago#47
@1686844 said:
I got the same percentages :)



how???
Former userFormer user16y ago#48
@tejal said:
how did you calculate those probabilities? I was totally clueless about those..
I didnt include the interest payments because i think in NPV we assume that Interest is included when the WACC is used (coz the WACC already takes into considereation the interset on debt??)...Not sure if thats right though..

I was totally clueless at first and left the question for the end.. i made a table of possible outcomes that will give a negative closing balance for period 2..
i did something like this..
{2000} in period one and {9000} in period 2 will give a neg closing balance.. 5000 in p1 and {9000} in p2 etc.. multiplied there prob and.. added each outcomes prob.. it just struck me in the end i dont know whether its rite or not..
*..i quoted you thrice.. using this forum for the first time..sorry about that*
Ttejal16y ago#49
sounds about right..i had left those two for the end too..since you're not the only one who got that answer there's a pretty good chance what you did was right :)

i wish i had thought of that...
Ddrchok16y ago#50
That probabilities bit of question 1 was rediculous! I think there was enough marks elsewhere in the question to pass it though. 2nd time out for me - hope I passed!
Pplatinumkp16y ago#51
@1686844

me too... 20% and 18% :)
Llouibee16y ago#52
The Gearing question is this debt/debt + equity????
Former userFormer user16y ago#53
I also got 20% and 18% on question 1, and a high NPV around $2000 ( i can't remember exactly!) for q2
i left out the interest and the sunk fixed costs in q3 and used the nominal WACC - real rate x inflation rate rather than the 10%
I can't remember what I ended up with on q4 for the DVM it seems at bit of a blur now!!
Pplatinumkp16y ago#54
@louibee

No the gearing would be debt/equity. The yardstick figures that were given clearly said that it was based on a debt/equity basis so therefore you need to compare apples to apples.
Former userFormer user16y ago#55
THANKS OPEN TUTION FOR THE LINK TO INTELLIGENCE ACCOUNTANCY LTD NOTES. THEY REALLY HELPED ME WITH THE THEORY PARTS. I HOPE FOR A 50%
Pplatinumkp16y ago#56
@hayleyw1

I also used the fisher effect to get the nominal discount rate. I think I messed up on the Tax allowances though (I always forget about the salvage value)
Former userFormer user16y ago#57
I got cost of debt.. around 7%.. WACC >11.. Npv i remember was +2226 i think..
a{i} 2100 a{ii} 3900 (not sure 3100 3500).. Not sure about dividend yield calculation.. dps/mv of share... cum div share price or ex div share?.. not sure i used ex..thats all i remember.. if i at least get the calculations rite then i mite get 50..
Former userFormer user16y ago#58
@platinumkp said:
@hayleyw1

I think you deduct the scrap value from the balancing allowance in the final year before x by 30% to get the tax saving

I also used the fisher effect to get the nominal discount rate. I think I messed up on the Tax allowances though (I always forget about the salvage value)
Former userFormer user16y ago#59
I got a really high NPV too, but I expected this considering we were taking out 200pa. I thought this was about right given the amount of mistakes that Trainee made. It actually made me feel good about NPV for once!!

In terms of the probability I just X each amount by the % and used the combined total as my CF. I hope this was right. It is just a simulation so is just for guidance. Fingers crossed!! A lot of theory but not a bad paper. Only got about 82% of it done, but we shall see!!
Pplatinumkp16y ago#60
@decentguy185

Div yield = DPS / Mkt price of share

Any yield calculation is always over market price.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.