Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FMJune 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about F9 exam!

?Take our F9 exam survey
https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-f9-june-2010-exam-survey/

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper F9 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#121
Examiner has 25 years of teaching experience but he doesnt understand that students sitting for paper dont have similar mental level an experience like me .I think his only job is to make difficult papers and fail students as much as he can.
Ive solved 82% paper hoping and praying for 50% marks also praying for all of u.
God Bless all of u.
Jjaveriahabib16y ago#122
i teach F5 so expected value was not problem for me
Q1 a (i) expected value for $2600
(ii) expected value for $1800
(iii) m lil bit confused probability of negative cashflow of period 2 was 9000 x 20% = 1800 exceeding the limit of (2000-500=1500) 1800-1500=300 tell me guys m rite or wrong?
Jjaveriahabib16y ago#123
i hav already planned to attempt the NPV question first when i saw the the first part identfy the trainee mistake i get it what to do..... i first attempted part b which was restructuring. it help me to identify the mistakes done by trainee Q3 and 2 was a piece of cake but 1 was lil bit tricky but i face diffculty in question 4 i dont know wat i had done in that q
Former userFormer user16y ago#124
I includee 4,500,000 $ over draft in calculating gearing . is it right ? or the gearing is without overdraft?
Zzuiis16y ago#125
@decentguy185 said:
I got cost of debt.. around 7%.. WACC >11.. Npv i remember was +2226 i think..
a{i} 2100 a{ii} 3900 (not sure 3100 3500).. Not sure about dividend yield calculation.. dps/mv of share... cum div share price or ex div share?.. not sure i used ex..thats all i remember.. if i at least get the calculations rite then i mite get 50..

i also got the same results
Former userFormer user16y ago#126
ohhhhh allah plz help me passed this paper andp2 and p3by the way
Jjasmine161016y ago#127
when i saw the paper,i thought examiner wants us to get pass ...........but when i started writing....i felt completely at loss
Former userFormer user16y ago#128
the posibility for negative cash flow at the end of period 2 is 20 %, it only happen when cash flow in period 2 is -9000, hence its posibility is 20%
I just remember part iii in a of question 1
Former userFormer user16y ago#129
The paper took me completely by surprise but am sure glad to see i'm not amongst few who think they'll fail :P
But i'm optimistic. Time to partyyyy :D
Ccandijordan16y ago#130
It was.......................hoping but I think I will have to do over......
Former userFormer user16y ago#131
It Was Well except Q1. Q1 was too strange and non a q was in KAPLAN BPP Kits of this type.
It was challanging I Hope for 50.
Rrafa230216y ago#132
Hi everyone,a friend has found a link on the ACCA website which offers an examination feedback form on specific papers. If you feel that the paper was unjust and the examiners language unnecessarily complicated please complete the form. The examination board use these feedback forms when setting marking schemes, before exam results are published. it could result in a few extra marks if the board agrees – so definitely worthwhile.
The link is noted below:
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ2/News/3331775
Kkikah16y ago#133
i think ACCA is gradually becoming some thing else. paper format changed completely as compared to previous ones.
if i have above 50% i think offering a mass will be the best option. examiners please have a rethink on what you have done this sesion
Kkikah16y ago#134
i think ACCA is gradually becoming some thing else. paper format changed completely as compared to previous ones.
if i have above 50% i think offering a mass will be the best option. examiners please have a rethink on what you have done this sesion
Former userFormer user16y ago#135
@rafa2302 said:
Hi everyone,a friend has found a link on the ACCA website which offers an examination feedback form on specific papers. If you feel that the paper was unjust and the examiners language unnecessarily complicated please complete the form. The examination board use these feedback forms when setting marking schemes, before exam results are published. it could result in a few extra marks if the board agrees – so definitely worthwhile.
The link is noted below:
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ2/News/3331775

Hey Thanks for the link.. i will do it
SSmartperson16y ago#136
I was completely panic after reading the paper, which result in disaster for me in Q2 where i forgot WACC.
Vvalentinat17116y ago#137
@rmacconnachie said:
Does anyone know the answer to the middle section of question 4?

Can we complain about the exam to ACCA?


YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT, WHY SHOULD BE ALLOW THE EXAMINER TO TREAT US IN AN UNFAIR WAY???? LET'S ALL EMAIL TO ACCA AND COMPLAIN ABOUT F9 EXAM. IF THEY SEE MANY COMPLAINTS, THEY WILL HAVE TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT THAT!!!!
Vvalentinat17116y ago#138
@Antonio_Blaze said:
LoL @ complaining to acca about the exam! did the exam cover anything thats not in the syllabus? NO! So,relax,friend and start preparing for december re-write.im gona be doing a past exam paper every week til december.that shud at least get me a 50

QUESTION 1 ON PROBABILITY ANALYSIS: IF YOU CHECK THE BPP TEXTBOOK, YOU WILL FIND 2 SHORT PARAGRAPHS ON THIS SUBJECT AND ONE VERY SIMPLE EXAMPLE, THAT'S IT!!!!! I DIDN'T STUDY F5, I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S IN THAT SYLLABUS, I WAS EXEMPTED. WAS I SUPPOSED TO READ EXAMINER'S MIND? AND SOMEHOW ASSUME THAT SOMETHING THAT IS JUST MENTIONED IN THE TEXTBOOK WILL BE EXAMINED EXTENSIVELY?????????????????/
Former userFormer user16y ago#139
hahahhaaha i jus hope the examiner dont die laughin after markin my script
Ddureshahwar16y ago#140
i dnt have good experience with diss paper.i dnt know what examiner expect 4m us.it was worst paper ever. u r rite johnnyn123 i calculate all dat like it.but at the end of period 2 there were no negative balance but in part (iii) examiner askd the value of negative balance at da end of period 2.overall paper was rough n unexpected.jst question 2 n 3 was better of but alot of hell theory.
Oossamajamal16y ago#141
i think the xaminer is experiencing a diificult tym in his martial lyf and is daily beatn up by his wife n kids ...kia chutyapay ka ppr bnaya tha bc dalla gandoo xaminerr...
Oossamajamal16y ago#142
it was my forth atmpt nd if i dnt pass this tym i will start a campaign against the examiner nd acca...
Former userFormer user16y ago#143
what a surprise!
Here is some of my answers, please feel free to comment.
Q1, use the cash flow multiple the %, easy to get the results( I think it was a positive)
then use the 8000 combine with the outcome in question 2 which I had three results( I think 2 positive and the last one is -$4000000.

Q2, cannot remeber the IRR now. the WACC I got was about 24%, and interest rate coverage is 3.6 times.
the alternative investment option is discounted bond, original shares, rights shares, and venture capital.

Q3, Errors-
1, didnt take the inflation into account
2, sale and variable cost did not take the inflated rate
3, capitalised cost should include depreciation, developmt cost and finanicing cost
4, the fixed cost should be included also it's recovered
5, --cannot remember now

the npv is a positive I remember

Q4, I think is easy,
the capital gain and dividend an be easily calculated by using the formulae,
the dividend price in after apply the new policy up to 2010 should be $4, which g = 0
after 2010 g= what ever the rate in the question (cant remember now) --didnt get this one right

the three definition is easy enough to explain.
Former userFormer user16y ago#144
People, are you sure that we turn up on the right exam?:). Where were my risk, valuation models, working capital management, EOQ,WACC and so many other key areas..and I think that calculation of probablility should be for F5...I dont have any idea should I hope for passing or nor...:)
Anyway.. the summer is coming, let enjoy it...
Ddragon7616y ago#145
Hi everyone, do all of you include development cost in CF of investment apraisal?
Former userFormer user16y ago#146
I hope I get 50 % & Pass...
Former userFormer user16y ago#147
@dragon76 said:
Hi everyone, do all of you include development cost in CF of investment apraisal?


I Did , so glad someone have the same doubts. I think both development cost and investment financing should be included if the project would be undertaken as both costs should be capitalised.
Former userFormer user16y ago#148
gud johnnyn 1st yr balance is 2100(+) and 2nd is 3900(+).
3rd part ans z 20%.
Pplatinumkp16y ago#149
i would think development is a sunk cost and therefore not relevant.
Former userFormer user16y ago#150
development cost is sunk, therefore irrelevant,

financing cost (interest on bonds issued) should not have been included in NPV calculation, since it is included in our discount factor.

Please correct me if I am wrong?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.