FM*** F9 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Hello all
For question 4 (the NPV one), I though all sale prices and variable costs were supposed to be right and their only problem was that they were not inflated!
I mean for example for the 3rd year, I took the sale price of THAT year (NOT the first year) and then inflated that number 3 times , i.e Sale Price * (1+inflation rate)^3, or for example for the variable cost of the 4th year, I took the variable cost of THAT year (I think it was 13!!) and then inflated that 4 times! and so on for the other sale prices and variable costs !
It is wrong ?!!!!
question states that prices haven't been inflated, so you we should have inflated price, variable cost and fixed cost. I did the same
well, as for fixed costs, it should have been 154.5K in the first year (150X1.03) and inflated at 3% for all consecutive years.
his fix cost was 155 every year which is wrong. So I reworked the NPV from the start.
Had a look at the paper and have Just realised I completely f***ed up question 5, completely blanked on doing a IRR for the cost of debt and used the 6% and miss read part b ='[ so that is basically all of the 15marks down the drain. Think my only hope for a pass now is to ask Santa for a Christmas miracle
@basta said: his fix cost was 155 every year which is wrong. So I reworked the NPV from the start.yes, me too. that's where the trick was I guess, about selling prices. There was no mention of selling prices anywhere else other than the calculations junior employee did, so selling prices were 25, 25, 26, 27. Which should have been inflated from the T1. 25X1.042 ; 25X(1.042)2 ; 26X(1.042)3 ; 27X(1.042)4. thats what I did at least..
my only regret I misread question 5 part A I did only the MV of WACC, which I got right. But completly didnt read he wanted the book value :(. Free marks down the drain. And that may cost me pass or fail.
@basta said: my only regret I misread question 5 part A I did only the MV of WACC, which I got right. But completly didnt read he wanted the book value :(. Free marks down the drain. And that may cost me pass or fail.same here, I totally missed book value WACC, I noticed that when I had like 10 mins left and just wrote why book value and market value costs might have been different
@matsamary@yahoo.com said: same here, I totally missed book value WACC, I noticed that when I had like 10 mins left and just wrote why book value and market value costs might have been differentI did worst I didnt comment either on part A...5 B then was ok gearing goes down, equity more expensive etc But lets be positive from 9 marks we still can get 4 or 5 marks from part A only.
I got a lot of c 's for the MCQ as well hoping for the best
My NPV came up to 2 million and something positive....anyone else got their NPV to be around two million?
mine was almost 2.5M I don't remember exact number though, I'm pretty sure that I did right.
I got lot of As in MCQs, and I got lot of As in F5 MCQs also:)
Please guys,when is OT bringing out their answers?
I got $2,570,000 for my npv or something close to dt
F5 was last Monday, answers were published on Friday,
there are lot of other papers in a row, I guess they will do it chronologically. so by the end of this week we should see answers.
So by the end of this week we'll know our fate
what answer did you do to MCQ no 20?
Of course MCQs were hard. It's not F2 anymore. Why is everybody so surprised?
Guys if you inflate the selling price variable and fixedso gives the figures shown on the original evaluation. So where should you inflate exactly?the problem.was with the interest and the depreciation. Anyone agreeing on any of this?
@matsamary@yahoo.com said: same here, I totally missed book value WACC, I noticed that when I had like 10 mins left and just wrote why book value and market value costs might have been differentSame those few marks can make a huge diff not happy
@matsamary@yahoo.com said: same here, I totally missed book value WACC, I noticed that when I had like 10 mins left and just wrote why book value and market value costs might have been differentSame those few marks can make a huge diff not happy at all!
the mcqs are a great idea since it really tests your knowledge and not just learning stereotyped questions. This will really be helpful if want to do p4 later
I have done the MC answers below, of course, not sure whether they are all correct. It's open to discuss.
1. A
2. B
3. C
4. A
5. B
6. C
7. C
8. B
9. A
10. C (may be D, not sure)
11. D
12. A
13. B
14. C
15. D
16. C
17. A
18. B
19. D
20. D
Colleagues!!!!!!!! I have taken another look at the paper and my response to what I presumed I submitted to the examiner are:
MCQ's from 1 to 20 in the same order - A;A; C; A;C; C; C; C; B, A, A, D, A, B, D, C, C, A, C, D, A.
I worked under the exam pressure in the hall, but not at home. I laugh at what I remember I actually wrote for Q3, but these the thing we do when pressured.
The results are:
Cash Bal for Jan 370; Feb 710 & Mar 692. Current ratio - same period in that order are: 1:2.63; 3.2 & 3.1 I eliminate loan receipt on the basis that information lacking and thus rush my way to finish line - time constraint. Manufacturing business, surplus cash should not be invested on a long term basis - stock market, because of the cash requirement; variable overheads and wages are paid in the month they incurred. They should use short term investment options and maybe medium depending on the company operating cycle, management decisions and cash requirement of the business.
Conversion is likely at $131.12 and the Market price of conversion is $111.98; PE share price is $7.44 and I list some things past information and industry data
This is a Laughter as I did rubbish in the exam hall - it was the pressure to complete the paper, knowing that the MCQ's were no HOPE and the administration should reward us at least 12 marks extract.
This what I did; Calculate the spot and forward and compare them - selling rate is applicable here, because goods/services has to be sold for receipt of cash. Spot $285,171 & forward $281,650. The company will receive more now than going into forward contract. Lost $3,521 if go forward.
The applicable interest rate in foreign as implied by the rate of exchange are: 1.04 x 1.042080 less 1 = 8.4%; 1.04 x 1.043131 less 1 = 8.5%. Colleagues, I did not put the one before and you know the answer is wrong. I recognize after but time did not allow me to correct. It was evident the if interest is 4% for $1, the it should be in proportion to the exchange rate as the interest rate parity state. In the theory, I wrote that one way is to invoice in own currency - where currency risk will be transferred to the customers. This is a good way to maintain the value of receipt.
The BIG one - Favourate!!!!!!!!!! I presumed I cap the max here 14 or 15
Every figures with inflation should be corrected with the rate of inflation - presumed that current rate. Sales 1.042 to powers of the applicable year, then multiply by the price for that year. Same for cost and Fix cost.
The results are: Revenue 2475, 2714, 4412 & 4774; VC 1097, 1323, 2084 & 2370. The fix cost amount for the year are: 155, 159, 164 &169. All figures are rounded and the amount are from y1 to y4 or y5 where applicable. With the tax at 22% and capital allowance on the reducing balance basis of 25% (99, 74, 56 & 169) the investment have a NPV - positive of 2.574m
I address the issue of correctly apply capital allowance instead of depreciation; interest charges already accounted for with cost of capital been 12% and inflation effect MUST be accounted for in investment appraisal as it impact on cash flows.
Another Good one for me in the Hall - 11 out of the 15; I presumed or more.
Mkt value WACC is 10.9%. slightly higher than BK, because of the poportion of debt increases. Equity Mkt Value 2340 (200/.5 *5.85), cost 10.9 (4% +(1.15*6)); loan notes 207 cost 4.82%
I would love your comments and here you can do the same for assessing your performance. We should write to ACCA - demanding free MARKS for the MCQ's that was out side the syllabus - What do you think!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Regards,
Book value is what was stated in the question 850 and 200, and I apply the cost calculated early, which gives a WACC of 9.74
Hi Cardine,
I thinks the most strange MC questions should be MCQ 2 and MCQ 20, but you can find the relevant information in BPP textbook (I am not the staff of BPP), I just mainly use BPP for my self-study (again, I do not make any advertisement or appreciation for BPP). So, I think they are all within syllabus for MCQs.
@Cardine said: Colleagues!!!!!!!! I have taken another look at the paper and my response to what I presumed I submitted to the examiner are: MCQ's from 1 to 20 in the same order - A;A; C; A;C; C; C; C; B, A, A, D, A, B, D, C, C, A, C, D, A. I worked under the exam pressure in the hall, but not at home. I laugh at what I remember I actually wrote for Q3, but these the thing we do when pressured. The results are: Cash Bal for Jan 370; Feb 710 & Mar 692. Current ratio - same period in that order are: 1:2.63; 3.2 & 3.1 I eliminate loan receipt on the basis that information lacking and thus rush my way to finish line - time constraint. Manufacturing business, surplus cash should not be invested on a long term basis - stock market, because of the cash requirement; variable overheads and wages are paid in the month they incurred. They should use short term investment options and maybe medium depending on the company operating cycle, management decisions and cash requirement of the business. Conversion is likely at $131.12 and the Market price of conversion is $111.98; PE share price is $7.44 and I list some things past information and industry data This is a Laughter as I did rubbish in the exam hall - it was the pressure to complete the paper, knowing that the MCQ's were no HOPE and the administration should reward us at least 12 marks extract. This what I did; Calculate the spot and forward and compare them - selling rate is applicable here, because goods/services has to be sold for receipt of cash. Spot $285,171 & forward $281,650. The company will receive more now than going into forward contract. Lost $3,521 if go forward. The applicable interest rate in foreign as implied by the rate of exchange are: 1.04 x 1.042080 less 1 = 8.4%; 1.04 x 1.043131 less 1 = 8.5%. Colleagues, I did not put the one before and you know the answer is wrong. I recognize after but time did not allow me to correct. It was evident the if interest is 4% for $1, the it should be in proportion to the exchange rate as the interest rate parity state. In the theory, I wrote that one way is to invoice in own currency - where currency risk will be transferred to the customers. This is a good way to maintain the value of receipt. The BIG one - Favourate!!!!!!!!!! I presumed I cap the max here 14 or 15 Every figures with inflation should be corrected with the rate of inflation - presumed that current rate. Sales 1.042 to powers of the applicable year, then multiply by the price for that year. Same for cost and Fix cost. The results are: Revenue 2475, 2714, 4412 & 4774; VC 1097, 1323, 2084 & 2370. The fix cost amount for the year are: 155, 159, 164 &169. All figures are rounded and the amount are from y1 to y4 or y5 where applicable. With the tax at 22% and capital allowance on the reducing balance basis of 25% (99, 74, 56 & 169) the investment have a NPV - positive of 2.574m I address the issue of correctly apply capital allowance instead of depreciation; interest charges already accounted for with cost of capital been 12% and inflation effect MUST be accounted for in investment appraisal as it impact on cash flows. Another Good one for me in the Hall - 11 out of the 15; I presumed or more. Mkt value WACC is 10.9%. slightly higher than BK, because of the poportion of debt increases. Equity Mkt Value 2340 (200/.5 *5.85), cost 10.9 (4% +(1.15*6)); loan notes 207 cost 4.82% I would love your comments and here you can do the same for assessing your performance. We should write to ACCA - demanding free MARKS for the MCQ's that was out side the syllabus - What do you think!!!!!!!!!!!!! Regards, Book value is what was stated in the question 850 and 200, and I apply the cost calculated early, which gives a WACC of 9.74I defo got same pe ratio, npv and wacc as you :) however your MCQ are very diff from mine
My NPV precisely was 2510 positive.
Hello,
I would like to ask, question 3, information need not to be qualitative?
By the way I hope you answer is correctly provided...
can the moderator assist in uploading mcqs' answers
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

