FM*** F9 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Q1 should it invest?
Q4 revision means what?
Section A was very hard :(
@wayhern said: @vipulv , do you remember what your answer for MCQ " earn abnormal return by reading previously share prices." ?semi-strong i think
Yes i got a 3million something
Hong, re:q1 I said that should invest surplus as short-term like bank deposit, so can get it back when needed. I think they suggested to invest into shares, I thought it's not suitable.
Re: q4 - my understanding was to comment on two things you've done differently compare to analysis they had. I talked about fixed costs, interest and depreciation - all excluded from my calculation.
What about you?
What was the answer to the first MCQ? 3.71 or 3.50?
I also found that even by process of elimination I ended up with 2 options...
What was the treatment for interest of 150k in NPV question?
I am not happy with this exam :( :( :(
What did people get for NPV ?
Hey all, I'm relieved it wasn't just me who found the Mcq really difficult, some of those were pretty unfair i thought and covered knowledge maybe mentioned in the text in passing once or twice but not main topics, also a couple no matter how I tried I couldn't calculate an answer that was on of the options. In contrast in all the mock exams I could score at least 30/40 for these multiple choice, this was not consistent with expectations.
I think the 5 questions were in general easier but some of the discussion parts were pretty vague, like should company invest their cash in shares or why is the P/E ratio not always suitable, 4 or 5 marks each, like is any relevant discussion good here? Seems like there are an endless possible reasons to invest surplus cash or why a P/E ratio based on an industry average would be inaccurate. I find this annoying as these are subjective answers but you can bet examiner will have some F9 model answer in mind.
Semi-strong can not earn abnormal return if I not wrong, regarding text book and my lecturer's note...
Npv ... Selling price and variable cost needs to be inflated, fixed cost was 150000 plus inflation then calculate tax then tax benefits plus 1.8m investment i got a 3 million something for npv
@avnisapan said: What was the answer to the first MCQ? 3.71 or 3.50? I also found that even by process of elimination I ended up with 2 options... What was the treatment for interest of 150k in NPV question? I am not happy with this exam :( :( :(I couldn't work out the first question. Did drive me mad :( I chose 3.71 at the end. I didn't include the interest as thought it's already accounted for within 12% of WACC.
@vipulv said: What did people get for NPV ?I had 2million something like say 2457 or similar
Hi Fellow F9 Attempter's :P
Ok - MCQ were CFA Level - LOL
i mean wth was that ?? tricky as hell
its normally u feel 1 or max 2 answers out of 4
but this - felt 3 answers were right and 1 was wrong - LOL
Section B
The part where i gained back my confidence
Was fine in my opinion
And as for the MCQ question 1, one of u asked
I got it as option A = 3.50$
I hope i was correct
Now,
Back to Life !! :D
And off ACCA and OT for a while :D
Colleagues!!!!! MCQ's, extremely difficulty and calculations lengthy too. The work-out section - #4 and 5 was the best for me and the 10 marks questions (1 - 3) take more time.
Overall, I attempted more than 75% of the paper and hope by way of elimination; I will get the maximum 40 marks in the MCQ's. We asked the markers for mercy and love.
Regards,
Hahha... Mercy & Love !!
@kevikraze said: Hey all, I'm relieved it wasn't just me who found the Mcq really difficult, some of those were pretty unfair i thought and covered knowledge maybe mentioned in the text in passing once or twice but not main topics, also a couple no matter how I tried I couldn't calculate an answer that was on of the options. In contrast in all the mock exams I could score at least 30/40 for these multiple choice, this was not consistent with expectations. I think the 5 questions were in general easier but some of the discussion parts were pretty vague, like should company invest their cash in shares or why is the P/E ratio not always suitable, 4 or 5 marks each, like is any relevant discussion good here? Seems like there are an endless possible reasons to invest surplus cash or why a P/E ratio based on an industry average would be inaccurate. I find this annoying as these are subjective answers but you can bet examiner will have some F9 model answer in mind.I totally agree about mcq's - I did really well with exam kit, not on the actual exam :( I couldn't match some of my calculation with the answers provided. And I thought I knew them :( As for the vague requirements - it might be not a bad thing. They might give credit to any relevant points. At least I hope so :)
We needed! Because it provided us specific inflation rate!
@haroonraja said: Did we have to inflate the cash flows for the npv calculation?? As no general rate of inflation was giver to inflate the waccDiscount factor was 12 no
@avnisapan said: What was the answer to the first MCQ? 3.71 or 3.50? I also found that even by process of elimination I ended up with 2 options... What was the treatment for interest of 150k in NPV question? I am not happy with this exam :( :( :(I got it as 3.50. I left the interest of £150k - apparently i was wrong to do so?
Accountaholic
I think no treatment for interest Part Because interest is no relevant and also interest is incorporated into calculations through W.a.c.c which was 12%.
So i just do nothing with interest redraft statement and remove interest thats all
I got something like 4375 type NPV i think not sure
NPV what u all got for tax saving
Did anyone get the money market hedge question on the multiple choice, I could not get an answer that was on the list of options, so I picked A I think which was closest to what I could get. also I hate that it doesn't state if the are borrowing the money to do this hedge or if the have their own money to use.
@adamsibley said: Harder than expected! Some mcq's were hard and ambiguous but others were easier. Longer question were similar sort of standard to previous exams in my opinion. I don't think anyone would've expected the cash budget (q1) to pop up. The two 15 markers I found the most manageable. In the cash budget I had a closing balance at the end of March was 990,000 and a current ratio of 1.65. The mv of convertibles I got $111 after using the historical growth method to calculate the value of the conversion. P/E ratio was a very ambiguous question, I just said that the P/E ratio valued the shares at less than market value. Question 3 was about FOREX risk. I can't remember much about this but one of the easier questions I felt. I ended up with an NPV of around 2.5m. There were a few revisions that could be mentioned. Interest shouldn't be included It ignored t5 Only inflated 1st year Depreciation was done straight line rather than reducing balance. For WACC I got just over 10% but everyone's will differ as it needed IRR to be calculated to get Kd.Did you get 12 discount factor? I got 2510 NPV positive
@adamsibley said: I can't remember exactly, but something about that and I used 12% cost of capital for my discount factor.I used 12% too
Yes once you had attempted all papers of F level either passed or not you can proceed to P level and later on come back to F level if any paper got failed and not attempted after that ,,,,,,
I sat for f7 n f9. In both exams I faced same kind of MCQs!
Earlier exam style was good. To me pass mark will highly depend on no. of correct MCQs. Don't know what will happen!!!!!!!!
What was the answer to question 3 - hedging?
Is it A.320 something
Hi,
No you don't you have to complete them but you do have to show that you taking all the F papers first. For example, I did F7 and P1 last sitting even though I still had F9 outstanding. So what I had to do is pay for all 3 exams sittings but only attempted F7 and P1
Yeah and on the Mcq, Technical Analysis or Fundamental Analysis, wtf! this not even part of the course or relevant to anything,!?don't recall anything on this at least so I guessed technical. Then the Fiscal policy mcq , i could eliminate one that was to do with interest rate and knew that the tax change was one of the correct ones but then its giving the other two options on about borrowing forigen money or something to spend on public services wtf! No idea if this is Fiscal or monetary so annoying
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

