The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments
Please post your comments about ACCA F9 December 2013 exam
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

FM*** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
7 % for leasing should have been used, therefore leasing was cheaper
WACC gave me around 12 %
NPVs both around 3600 cant remember exactly but both positive
the research should have been ignored - is sunk cost not a cash flow item
the 2 mil investment goes in Y0
Can anyone tell me on the interest loans rates what you guys answered - i messed it up i said lower interest rates on short term loans.....should have been higher interest rates right ??? - just lost 5 marks !!! :(
@muneebbabar no no you cant ignore buffer !!!!! is part of the formula
@yaasir786 i beleive the DF (discount factor ) should always be under money rate 12% not the 7% but anyway by using the wrong DF will deduct max 1-2 marks , i might be wrong ...is only 1-2 marks, i asked my tutor.
hOW COULD YOU DISCOUNT THE LEASING WITH THE LOAN DISCOUNT FACTOR WHEN THE QUESTION CLEARLY STATED THAT THE LOAN WAS ONLY USED FOR PURCHASING PURPOSES..THE LEASE SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE LEASE AMOUNT FOR THE NUMBER OF YEARS..I THINK IT WAS 5 YEARS THEN PURCHASING AT THE LOAN DISCOUNT FACTOR.YAH I ALSO HAD A TOUGH TIME CALCULATING THE BUFFER STOCK,WASTED ALOT OF TIME THERE
@generations ok how can u calculate for 5 yrs time the total leasing cost ? 155* 5 - what about time value of money !! you make me laugh !
I said the same as you Christina85 regarding interest rates on longer term loans. I said debt holders expect to receive higher interest on longer term loans, because of the inconvenience of being without their money for a longer time, and also to compensate for the extra risk. In my opinion you gave the correct answer.
@christina85 glad some one made you laugh today..you seem to know it all i bet you will be passing F9 with flying colours huh
@neilsolaris - i hope sooo my friend did the same but i read in my tution notebook the other way around.....so i am not sure , i hope is correct and gain that 5 marks .....
@generations - i hope we all pass no matter how many silly mistakes we did is awfull to re take any paper ....i am not sure though - ignore me ....
best of luck to all !
The buffer stock was based on sales, and the question said that the sales were evenly spread throughout the year so i wrote the same buffer stock for each one... hope that was right!! i dnt think the amount of stock that was held would affect the amount sold each month!!!
Yah about the interest rates i too wrote about "Risk" "security" and other things i don't remember..on WACC/capital structure i wrote about Modigliani & Miller theory,traditional theory and threw in abit about pecking theory...under working capital talked about the objectives of working theory(liquidity and profitability) then conservative,moderate and aggressive methods for both working capital investment and financing(the marker can pick some sense out of all that LOL) then under the question in the lines of (what a company should do to encourage directors work hard towards the company's long term objectives) i think question 1.C..i talked about how the company can solve "Agency problem" where directors are offered shares,bonuses and Executive share option schemes...Then under Riba(i only read about it ounce ages ago and managed to remember abit about it..in that muslim law does not allow it for the 3 disadvantages it has towards the borrower,the lender and to the economy..managed to scribble something on advantages of leasing as long term and short term finance...I REALLY HOPE THEORY SAVES ME...
I made the same points as your in the theory questions generations. Except that I only mentioned that with Islamic Finance, it was considered immoral to make money from money! I'd forgotten about the three disadvantages. You did well to remember that.
Time management issue with me .
the exam is over now guys!!
i think i failed hard..... :S
i did the saem as bonerura
@generations, I thought the islamic question asked about how the system operates financially as interest is forbidden (Hope I didnot mis-interpret it).
I wrote about
1) There must be an underlying asset on which the funds are tied.
2) Profits and losses (on the underlying asset) are shared according to the contract except in mudaraba (equity finance) loss borne by equity owner.
3) Islamic finance therefor acts like a form of partnership and funds (loan) holders will be more involved in the affairs of the company until such a time the loan is paid back.
*Anyone answered along those lines or I'm I off track.
Did anyone use the three theories behind the normal yield curve shape (Liquidiy, expection and market segmentation) to answer the question about differences in interest rates between short-term and long-term securities (something like that)?
The rest of the theories, I think I answered as you did.
Pv @ 12% NPV = +3253
PV@7%NPV =+4803
EOQ current policy =4954
revised policy = 3328
net savings using the EOQ = $1626
discount settlement current purchase policy at 60 days
payable balance = $74958
finance cost @ $3748
revised policy with settlement discount
discount #4560
finance cost $1874
net value $1062
Invoice discount and factoring were also sweet to write on.
d. objective of working capital management i guess was profitability and liquidity with more explanation
question 2
cost of equity Ke: 13%
CAMP better than DGM be cos of it advantages
DGM is mostly base on assumptions.
cost of debt Kd 5.19%
WACC 11.4%
project specific cost of capital
Asset beta Ba = 0.841
Equty beta Be =1.037
cost of equity using the CAMP for the new project =9.18
Note i might be wrong this are the ones i could remember but overall it was a good exam . the theories were very good and easy to pass . but time constraint
Thanks you sooooooo much John .
you are man
9.18%
Q. if changing the capital structure of a company can lead to a reduction in its cost of capital
and hence to an increase in the value of the company
i used the M and M theory to Explain the question .
m&m with no tax No changes in Npv hence shareholders wreath not increase
M&M with tax will increase as a result of tax interest tax deduction Npv will improve.though the the theory has it limitations such as tax exhaustion
hey @neilsolaris....
are you sitting for P1 as well? Its killing. Done all past year questions. Wrote down the answers in notes form. Read technical articles. Now....Just Pray and Re read the written notes.
Good luck to you and anyone sitting for P1
Regards
Haseena
Hi Haseena,
Yes, my plan is to take P1 in June. Is it really that bad? Have you attempted it already? It's not a paper I'm particularly looking forward to, mostly because I suspect it might be a bit dull! Even the tutor here said in his lecture that he rewrote the notes, and before they were very very very boring, now they're just very very boring! It doesn't inspire me much!
F9 was splendid. Thank you Jesus, thank you open tuition and thank you Mr John for your outstanding lecture. God bless you richly. What I would have paid heavily for was given to me free of charge. Indeed the best things of life are free
I think the question is to evaluate so after calculating there should be a little elaboration to explain your answer.
That would have being a brilliant answer even though i did not do it like that.
I used the three theories behind the normal yield curve shape (Liquidiy, expection and market segmentation) to answer the question about differences in interest rates between short-term and long-term securities. But with M&M theiry in cap structure I don't know why I wrote about business risk financial risk and project specific cost. Silly me!
When will suggested results be out?
It was the easiest exam in the history of F9 past exams. I couldn't manage the Q3 part c and left 50% of part a. I am hoping that i will easily get at least 50. let see and wish good luck for all other students.
Who is Mr John? I need his assistance.
The paper was quite manageable Q1 which required nominal and real rate. I only had difficulties on Q2 am sure due to inadequate preparation otherwise generally it was fair, the June 2014 one may be tougher.
The suggested answers will be out in February!
Hey @neilsolaris...
I wrote a big article...I guess opentuition didn't like it. It didn't come up at all.
This is my rewrite. Yes, I did attempt it this december.
As I told someone earlier about F8.....but P papers are different level. Real professional. Vocabulary is important.
PRACTICE PRACTICE PRACTICE.........I only read opentuition notes and practice past year papers. Read technical articles as well.
Another one thing is .....if you believe in God. PRAY EVERYDAY. The one that is marking our papers are still human beings.
Only God Knows whats in their mind while marking LOL
Good Luck
Regards
Haseena
Without opentuition I'll be doomed.
My husband is the sole breadwinner with not enough pay and he still manages to pay my exam fees etc. Lucky there's opentuition, I don't have to spend extra to any colleges for classes. Though I don't have enough internet data to watch video lectures (feel bad) but the notes gave me an idea about the paper. An understanding about the subject.
Thank you opentuition. God Bless you guys. Please don't stop your efforts in providing us knowledge.
Regards
Haseena
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

