The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments
Please post your comments about ACCA F9 December 2013 exam
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

FM*** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
Can someone please tell me if the reasons for rise interest rates on bonds are liquidity, expectation and market segmentation theories? Also reasons for change on Wacc with in cap structure business, financial and project specific cost of cap?
Can anybody tell from when f4 exam will be CBE???
I did the same..
I thought the same as real term meant no lnflation?
Because working capital starts at To, the T4 value goes om T3 and then the overall reclaimed goes in T4. Not sure if that is true but it is what I did.
Did anyone get one positive working capital figure? I think in T2.
regard question 1)
for part (a), i inflated all the cash flows, calculated tax charge, capital allowances and working capital requirements (based on inflated sales). I discounted them all at the monetary cost of capital, t0 obtain a +ve NPV of USD 4,000,000.
For part (b) i used the revenue and cost AS STATED in the question, calculated all other cashflows (tax and all others) and discounted them at a REAL cost of capital of 7%....again i obtained a +ve NPV
Was i correct???????
messed this paper like hell, calculated wrong EOQ, wrote the correct formula to get the discount but got confused, in lease vs buy need to use the discount rate of the borrowing, used no discount rate at all, calculated the real cash flow wrong and as well as the NPV ( forgot to minus the capital cost and investment from the final figure). Did not know what to write in attractions of short or long term lease :/
I think the examiner was fair enough. Pity their was islamic finance involved. Never really focussed on it.
Ajaz: F4 will be CBE in the second half of 2014
I have underestimated f9 as it is similar to f5
So that i learned for f9 about 3 days
And I v done everything wrongly .Working capital for 1a , the whole 1b, ungear for 2 and no islamic finance
Just lost about 20 mark now
Hope for a marginal pass
@John Moffat And any idea about when are they going to announce 4 sessions per year?
Hey @duc169,
There was Islamic finance for 5 marks. I was happy because I was ready for anything islamic finance. It's a shame it was only 5 marks.
I got exactly 4m too. And 4.3 for part b. Im glad soneone else got the same answer!
When working capital is recovered?
I think Working capital is recovered at the end of the investment/project life. But if the question says that the project will continue ( i.e project evaluation was done over a period of time less than the life of the project) working capital will not be recovered.
or working capital is recovered if the machine is disposed off and not replaced. If the machine is replaced working capital will not be recovered.
Seriously must stop reading this forum I think I will be lucky to scrape 10%
I also read posts and find errors, but still hope to get enough marks. I found more theoretical questions than in June'13, or it just seems to me...also to calculate NPV twice was a bit monotonous activity...
Pls I had 2 different solutions for question 4a. Iheard from some acca experts that the examiner usually marks d correct one and ignore d wrong one. Pls hw true is this
in EOQ question i ignore buffer stock.my ans will b correct??
My understanding is that buffet stock should be included. It is permanent inventory, that has a holding cost. But I'm sure not including it would only lose a mark or two.
@muneebbabar No, you have to include it. The holding cost is always paid on the buffer stock plus half the quantity of the inventory ordered.
But don't worry, it is not like it is the end of the world. I am sure you will not lose a lot of marks, it is considered only one error and you will get credit for the rest.
Maha
in EOQ question i ignored buffer stock as i read examiner tutorial article that u may ignore buffer stock
m i right??
@muneebbabar - I am very surprised that you read an article that says we should ignore the buffer. As per what I learned, the buffer inventory is always included in the holding cost and it does make sense because surely you will be paying money to hold this buffer inventory.
Anyways, regardless of what is really correct, I wouldn't worry much about it, it is only one error, it will not mess up your whole answer.
Maha
No one has answered me regarding the issue of answering a question twice and will acca pick one
I don't know exactly what would happen if you give two different answers to the same question. But it seems unlikely to me that they'd ignore the wrong one and give you marks for the correct one. If that were the case, if I wasn't sure of the answer, I could give a whole range of answers, in the hope that one of them would be correct! My guess is that if you gave more than one answer, unless you crossed one of them out, then they'd both be ignored. However, if either contained correct workings, then I'm sure you'd be awarded marks for that.
However, that' just my guess, I don't have any idea.
thank you @neilsolaris and @haseenababu for the tips. I wish to clear all ACCA paper in the first attempt.
@clevergirl well i guess ill be seeing you around in the Ask F8 ACCA Tutor forum then next semester :)
Good luck with F8 nizarsalleh
my F* lecturer was one of the markers for ACCA, she always told us then don't waste time giving 2 answers for the same question, for example, while calculating after-tax WACC, but you calculated the before-tax WACC and you just realized that you're doing it wrong, and you make another calculation for the after-tax WACC, and did not cancel the wrong answer, the marker will just simply(did not mark the part) or give you mark based on which on you wrote first (like a FIFO basis ahaha), first in first marked.
thank you @neilsolaris, best of luck to u too for P1.
Thanks!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

