The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments
Please post your comments about ACCA F9 December 2013 exam
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

FM*** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
it was a fair paper, but i didn't manage to get the same NPV for question 1 a and 1b. i get a slight difference? anyone having a slight difference also in the net present value? but i got some same present value in year 1 and 3 i guess
Hi Guys,
do you know how the Q4 (a) was to calculate? It was a question for 10 points leasing vs loan. It was too less data given and could not identify which method was to apply to calculate sum of leasing payments....
Thanks a lot for your feedback!
I got a slight difference too, but I thought I was meant to! I can't see what I did wrong otherwise.
I thought the paper was much easier than I expected, but I hope I'm not tempting fate by saying that!
i solved that question by calculating the net present value of leasing and also purchasing the machine outright. using the financing cost which is 7% as discount factor.
I thought the same thing... :( Didn't understand how to solve it :(
I had a big difference for leasing payments and the loan....
For question 4, I just worked out the leasing costs, and then worked out the buying costs, and then stated which was cheaper.
ya, neilsolaris, i remember i did that type of question before and i get the exact same amount of NPV. i spend 15 minutes rechecking where did i went wrong, but i simply can't find it, so i managed to continue with other questions. Manage to complete all 4 questions. Hoping for 70++ or perhaps 80
The question had 10 points. It should have been something sophisticated.
And they asked to explain the method. I think it should have been s specific approach to it.
the leasing was cheaper right, about 600K++ and the purchasing was 700K++ can't remember the amount but i know it starts with 6 for leasing and 7 for purchasing
and the early settlement discount(ESD) was quite tricky, this time it's where to give ESD instead of whether to accept the ESD
For the leasing question where did you let get the discount factor from?
I found question 3 tricky on the buffer stock
It was manageable, the paper pertained the followings EOQ, buffer stock, npv cash flow calculation both on real and nominal cost of capital, asset beta factor, lease and buy and a lot of theory
can anyone tell me what the npv was it arround 3500 of 4000
I calculated the leasing option as being cheaper too. I didn't elaborate about my method (I forgot to), but I just mentioned that the leasing was cheaper and so was preferable. I think I might have mentioned that a pre-tax discount factor was used because tax was not involved. Other than that, I'm not sure what else could be said.
For q1 was it correct to inflate part a and not inflate for part b?
Yes I got that with leasing and that was the best option as it was cheaper.
For question 1 part a) I used 12% as discount rate and B) I used 7%.
Did anyone get WACC as 11.24?%
Also for question 3, can anyone remember what they got? I did 12xorder price.
the 7% of financing cost. it's stated in the purchasing option, it is the same as the question in ASOP Co, where you only take the financing cost as ur discount factor
@nizarsalleh: I did the same but maybe have chosen the wrong discount factor.
I had 155K*4years annuity for 7% for leasing.
Ok guys, it does not matter anymore.
lets hope for the best :)
7% for real discount rate is what I think I used (I'm no good at remembering numbers!). Basically, I calculated the real discount rate as 1 + mominal rate / 1 + inflation rate.
I also did 12 x order cost for the first section. For the EOQ it's something like 300,000 / EOQ x ordering cost.
I got thrown off with a Market research bit and so i put (200,000) in year 0 and (2000,000) in year 1. Not sure but I hate positive NPV!
I got a different NPV under a and b. i think i made a mistake when I calculate the rear rate of return. I took a nominal rate of 12% rather than 17%. accordingly i arrived at rear rate of 7% but the correct is 8%.
do we have to insert yr0 for npv and insert (2000)
I assumed the market research was a sunk cost, and was there as a red herring. I could be wrong though.
Yes, I used 7% for part B in Q1. I also didn't inflate it so used up straight values from cash flows. and I think I hate 477 something like that as NPV.
i think i get 11.43% (if im not mistaken) for the WACC, you should use 12% cost of equity instead of 13% you calculated in the require a). the mv value of the equity is 8m x 7.16, and mv of bonds is 5000/100x103.42 . the discount rate to calculate the irr should be 6% and 5%. the bonds will give interest of 8.5% which after tax is 8.5%(1-0.3).
for question 3, i got something like 5002 if using EOQ. and 5454 using the current ordering cost
8%??? I didn't get that!
Hmmm...
what was your WACC?
the market research cost is a cost that has already incrred, therefore it is a sunkcost hence, does not included in the NPV calculation
@ nizarsalleh I got the same :D I got 5002 and 5454 and did the difference for part iii). YES! lol
Part b) of Q3 I multiplied the price with 60/365 and then 30/365 and took the difference and multiplied with cost.
I think I was left with 1830.44 something..... Not sure if it's right?
And yes wacc o used 12%. wooohooo cos I thought I did wrong.
I think the trick is when you calculate the real rate of return.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

