The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments
Please post your comments about ACCA F9 December 2013 exam
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

FM*** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
Well I messed that in Q1 :(. But where did you all put 2000,000? I put that in year 1 :(
Still would get marks tho? right? dammm :(:(
My WACC was 11.43 too so I think it should be ok. As for EOQ, no one averaged the holding costs for the part a?? I did like [(300,000/12)* 140%] / 2 to get 17500 units per month. Was that right?
The investment should go in year 0. But I would think that only one mark would be lost per mistake.
For holding cost I did 25000/2 + 10,000(this is buffer as it said 40%) multiplied the whole thing by 0.10.
I did the same clevergirl
holding cost should be 25000/2 x 0.1 plus 40% of demand x 0.1 for part a
can any I tell what trearment was there for 200000 cost?????
In question 1, did you all reclaim the working capital? If so, did you add it as a cashflow into year 4 or 5?
I put 4, but I've been questioning it since... seems strange because there is then a working capital outflow and inflow in the same year.
what about the buffer @ nizarsalleh??
Yay " neilsolaris
Was that in question 1 gemini? The treatment was to ignore it, as it was a sunk cost.
It said 40% of sale if I recall. So if you are selling all the 25000 per month. then shouldn't you add 40% of the 25000 too?
I recovered the working capital in year 4. I didn't have any other working capital cash flows in that year though (unless you are talking about the beginning of that year, i.e. 12 months earlier).
@clevergirl i edited my post. forgot to mention.
@geteveryone, yes you should recover the working capital as in year 4, your working capital is reduced(recovered) hence, you should recover in year 5. again, if you state your assumption on working capital, you wont be penalized.
It's in year 4. :)
Did anyone get 4000 for NPV in question 1a?
@kaish ya we included the holding cost of the buffer stock.
clever girl i did the same in question number 3 . i did it with current 60/365 and revised 60/365 ........... and the difference wuld then be multiplied it with finance cost ....... and yeah the interest was 805% (1 minus 30%) gives 5.9 sunthing ...... but guess i did mistake in irr ..... i took discount rates of 10 % and 5% ...... and for question number 1 , i didnt inflate the nominal cashflows and the rate would be 12 percent ........ but in part b i inflated the sales and costs to general inflation .. and the rate was 7% .......... how was lease to be calculated ? kuz i came u with the decision of buying ... kuz it gives sumthing in positive ........ any buddy did same like me ?
I got 3000something for NPV part a). Probably messed up :(
How did you guys treat working capital in question 1?
i mean you also should recover the working capital in year 5, as the working capital is 10% of sales revenue, and in year 5, there's no sales revenue, hence, the working capital in year 5 is 0. so other than year 4, working capital in year 5 also should be claimed.
I got WACC of 11. something :D cost of equity of 13%, Leasing was cheaper and the buying option was like worse it had much more cost when compared to leasing, my net savings in EOQ question were like 200, and npv was highly positive as well
Damn, that's where I made my mistake. I knew it looked daft.
Had the working capital outflows in year 1-4 and the inflow in year 4, too.
Ugh.
In question 2, last section, we had to discuss the traditional theory and Miller and Modgliani model right?
Don't you'll think Q4 part a) for 10 marks was really easy???
Like it was simple NPV and leasing was lower like 677000something and buying was 745666 something. I thought 10 marks for just that was too silly,,,,
multiply by 10% of revenue for yr1 and deduct incremental amount in yr2 and yr3 and recover w/capital in yr 4
@kaish yes i discussed about the traditional, MM and pecking theory, and somehow relate your answer on how it can maximise the value of the company (longest part to explain, it took 2 full pages to explain)
On the read through in the first 15 mins I thought "yep this looks straightforward enough" and then when actually doing it, it was impossible. Lots of hidden info or info you had to work out yourself when normally you would have been given it.
I didn't even attempt question 1b or the last two parts to question 4 so that was 17% lost right there. No way have I passed. Soo annoyed.
@Kaish yes you're right.
@kaish yes thats the one!!!! As company gears up wacc decreases and al that.!
What was the written for Q3, Aside from objectives? I mentioned conservative and Moderate.... wasn't sure.
Nice nice. I hope I pass all my 3 papers. Well, catch you all in June. No one talks of question 3. Real easy I guess.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

