Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin12y ago
The topic is now OPENED, please reload/refresh the browser page and you should be able to post your comments Please post your comments about ACCA F9 December 2013 exam How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams? Vote in our Instant Poll *** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments *** poll results *** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments *** poll results *** F9 December 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments *** poll results
Ccardine12y ago#151
You and I did the same thing. This was the most straight forward question. The bank charge 7% per year, while the lease payment has a minimum interest of 0.0077; therefore the lease is more attractive - cost less when compare to buying the machine with loan and maintenance. I am asking the lord to grant me divine favour in this with a pass - 50 and over. I am tired of this paper; always failed marginally.
Rreeb135012y ago#152
I found lease a better option than buy. However, my mind went totally black as I forgot to inflate accumulatively! How stupid am I?
Rreeb135012y ago#153
A 50% will do, hopefully
Rreeb135012y ago#154
you don't need to recover it when the project is going on. the question tells you the machinery for example will be replaced. this means you don't need to recover the working capital. But today the project would terminate at the end of the period, so you needed to recover working capital. Hope you did!
Ccardine12y ago#155
It is not tricky - the value of the discount saved and compare it with the bank rate. The discount is preferable. 1/99*365/30* the Pbles. The savings out weight the BK.
Aalicjagodek12y ago#156
@cardine - so am I... F9 is unfortunate for me and I hope I can tick it out - I will see ;) Next time I'll get sick of this study text :D I have similar answers as you write here, so maybe a part of my solutions are right! :D I can agree that after 15min of reading it seemed doable and quite ok, but then I got messed with leasing a bit and I suppose my cost of inventory holding was not correct - this question seemed quick & easy at first sight but then I got stuck in average inv. God bless the examinator to be in good mood when checking our work! ;) Just give me 51 and I will be fully satisfied!
Rreeb135012y ago#157
Junekiarie: the company keeps 40% of the monthly supply for buffer inventory. so 10,000 units times $1 plus your holing cost based on EOQ
Rreeb135012y ago#158
Yes
Rreeb135012y ago#159
Hi all, Does anyone know what would be a good combination if you wanted to do 2 Professional papers in June 2014?
Former userFormer user12y ago#160
Twas a fair paper though. Thank you Mr Moffat
Former userFormer user12y ago#161
messed up in question 4. though i thought the questions were easy
DDiane12y ago#162
Did no one else think the examiner played word games on the written? When you first read it, it all seemed straight forward, then towards the end, I re-read again and it seemed he wanted an explantion for something completely different. Maybe I'm reading too much into it, and seeing what he asked for as more complicated than it was.
Ccaptmario12y ago#163
0.89 was the right answer because the company was very low geared, only 10% debt compared to industry average of 25%
Ccardine12y ago#164
For you - Reeb1350: P3 and P5, similar stuff, but nuff wuk!!!!!!!!!!!! Who is Mr John, is he the tutor on open tuition? Please work the paper on the week-end if you can. May this my you can achieve a better understanding which will help cross-over.
Former userFormer user12y ago#165
Easy! =)))
Former userFormer user12y ago#166
you have to regear it, 0.89 is ungear Beta
Former userFormer user12y ago#167
I'm using the book value, ie: 0.89 x 8000/ ( 8000+5000x0.7)
Former userFormer user12y ago#168
Correct answer.
Aammus12y ago#169
Q1.Isn't it positive NPV for PART(a) & (b)....and both acceptable ? Q2.The project specific WACC was much less than the actual WACC ? Q3.EOQ lead to cost saving ...right ? Q4.Leasing was the best option , but,which discount factor to be used ?
Mmahoysam12y ago#170
@umerkhayam I hope you pass this time :) Keep in touch and let me know about your results! Maha
SShavi201312y ago#171
I thought for NPV question since research cost of (200,000) was sunk cost so did not take it.
Aalexsargsyan8912y ago#172
I discounted leasing with 7% , which was given as an interest in "buy" option. There should be a discounting, as it was 10 point question. No discount rate was given for leasing....finding it via IRR I thought it would be not correct, in my opinion, so I discounted with 7 percent
Aalexsargsyan8912y ago#173
In Q4 , I discounted leasing with 7% In Q2 , I got betta something 0.88 or 0.89 do not remember exactly, but surely it was below 1.00 In Q1 there are two different NPVs, but both were acceptable for project Anyone solved like this?
Kkris12y ago#174
Hey, I noticed a few posts back someone mentioned results will be out on the 8th of January. Is this correct? The guidelines I read say 8th of February??
Former userFormer user12y ago#175
i think for question 4 part a, the examiner wanted us to identify the type of leasing maybe it was an operating lease and elaborate on it afterwards as there were not much info available..anyone agree?
Hhaseenababu12y ago#176
Hi @nizarsalleh. I did F8 last June. Passed exactly 50 marks. Just an average student. But read full notes of opentuition 2 times, practice past year papers 3 times and read the ACCA technical articles 2 times. I was late for the exam 30mins because of last minute change of venue. I left one whole question unanswered. Good luck Regards Haseena
Nneilsolaris12y ago#177
It's funny, when I left the exam I felt incredibly confident. After reading this thread I know I've made at least three mistakes! I want to get at least 60% in order to guarantee a first in the OBU, so I felt a bit of pressure for this one.
Nneilsolaris12y ago#178
I think discounting with 7% was correct for the lease/buy question. The reason I think so, is because I did a couple of similar practice questions, where they said to ignore tax (as I think was the case in question), and the answer said if tax is ignored, use a pre-tax discount rate (i.e. do like for like).
Kkris12y ago#179
Hey, I noticed a few posts back someone mentioned results will be out on the 8th of January. Is this correct? The guidelines I read say 8th of February??
Kkased5812y ago#180
The paper this time round was not time constricting...managed to do all the workings,but was really stuck in qsn 4..not sure which discounting factor to use!!!!(10mks)..but lets hop for a pass..
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.