AA*** F8 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
anyone remember the audit procedures in the subsequent event question? it was an adjusting event and the auditor was suppose to follow some procedures like reviewing post year end cash receipts, correspondence from customers and inquiring director about the rationale of not making any adjustment in accounts. can anyone confirm this?
@abbas7796 said: i agree it was very tricky. I am just hoping for 50. in question 5 there were two additional marks for the cover letter. were these 2 marks including already in the marking scheme or were they just bonus marks?These were a bonus two marks for presenting your answer in a report format.
@osamaumar said: Most of my answers to mcq's were either option 'B' or 'C' apart from one or two.Mine too! I have B/D/C/C/C/C/A/B/C/B/B/C Anyone else has their answers? I think the exam was OK...
Questions on ACCA Site - Think I went with B,D,D,C,C,B,A,D,A,B,B,A.
are these the correct answers?
I hope so!!!!!
No....I looked at the questions and put up what I think I went for in reply to a previous post of what did people put up.
the last one should be d not a
ha! ok cool. when are the answers available - does anyone know?
What the answer should be for 3 and 4?
3 was D
4 was C
this is what i put down doe
i think u are right. although i put down as A for the 3rd which i think is incorrect
(b) Describe substantive procedures the auditor should perform to confirm Hummingbird Co’s revenue
can anyone confirm these?
were they like 1) recalculate sales discounts and sales tax
2) select sample of sales orders, agree to invoices and GDN through to sales ledger etc
can receivables circularilization and reviewing credit notes goes in there?
I think receivable circulation will prove receivables not revenue.
I get what your trying to say. But I think the question was specific about the revenue which the company has got.
I talk about comparisons to last year
Also the budget
Tax and discount
Right period
But m sure you will be awarded coz the other entry for revenue is receivables. So fingers crossed.
Just quick question Anas what did you put down for th CAATs.
Mcq.
It was D right. Coz that sounds like a test of Control to me
yes because its test data. can you confirm the last mcq about going concern? i put that as d. what was yours? are you confident about that?
I put down D
I think it's right. If the directors are not giving assurance whether the company is going concern than auditors can't express an opinion so hence disclaimer opinion will be provided.
However, if they do say company is going concern, but the auditors are sceptical than that's qualified opinion
Finally, the directors have rightly prepared the FS on going concern basis, they have disclosed about possible going concern issue, that emphasis of matter will be given.
Sorry for the long wounded comment but that's how I understand it. In our case the first situation applies.
thanks for this comprehensive explanation. yes your points make perfect sense since emphasis for matter paragraph directs the attention towards disclosure and the question didnt mention anything disclosure. infact the question said that management refused to make an assessment of being going concern in first place.
what did u write on factors to consider when placing reliance on work of experts?
are these points valid for this
their independence (are they related to the company). their qualification, experience, reputation in their field of work plus licence to operate.
i think both were wrong
Yea
I put down the nemonics STRIP
scope of work
Technical competence
Independence
Report format
Professionalism
I used these but expanded on them
1. B
2. B
3. C
4. C
5. B
6. B
7. A
8. D
9. A
10. D
11. B
12. B
Sean
Is that your answers?
Don't agree with actually Q2, Q3, Q12 and few more
Yes, these are what I put down. I'm fairly confident on Q2 Q3 and Q12 though :p ...
Q12 I put down B. The FS are MM, therefore modified report and modified opinion. It didn't suggest the wording of the opinion paragraph e.g disclaimer or except for
Either way, a disclaimer or adverse or except for opinion is a qualified opinion.
@sam123456789 what's your answer be for 7,9,10
Q2 money laundering and terrorist offence is a legal duty not a voluntary.
Do you agree?
@usamaniaz said: Q2 money laundering and terrorist offence is a legal duty not a voluntary. Do you agree?Agreed. That's obligatory.
12 cant be b because the auditor will issue adverse opinion, not qualified opinion if the going concern assumption is inappropriate
Guys I'm not sure if my answers are right. But basis on what I understood from the question that's how I answered.
Q12 both statement s are wrong in my opinion
Option B is defo wrong. Coz they will give an adverse opinion not qualified.
Which will state FS are not true and fair.
Statement A
If they can't make a judgement than how can yiu give assurance on it. Only disclosures will be emphasis of matter.
@abbas7796 said: 12 cant be b because the auditor will issue adverse opinion, not qualified opinion if the going concern assumption is inappropriateAh, I see your logic
In my notes from my tuition provider:
Voluntary disclosure - an auditor may decide to disclose information if he feels it is in the public interest e.g. if the management are involved in fraud (I linked the money laundering sentence to this). They may also disclose information to defend themselves in a claim of negligence or if suing for unpaid fees.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

