AA*** F8 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
The question was benefit of not outsourcing...it was cost reduction
the answer to my mcqs were 4 A, 4 B, 3 C nd 1 D!!
overall it was a pretty lenghty paper, idk how people are saying it was easy, not for me!!
Overall I found the exam very easy. (Finished 30 mins before the exam was over) If you learnt all the past papers dated back from 2009, you would realise the paper we sat today, all existed in the previous papers. (Even the sub procedures for WIP etc)
MCQ were straight forward and easy bar two. The one about the disadvantage of the questionairr.
What did you guys put down?
Irrelevant controls, that was the answer for ICEQs/ICQs
@kolkleen said: Irrelevant controls, that was the answer for ICEQs/ICQsno, that was missing important controls
The answer to what's NOT the benefit of outsourcing was that it's ALWAYS the cheaper option. always was the key word here as it's not always the case
how do you think if the calculation of materiality was incorrect then the whole answer will not be marked?.....i applied wrong percentage
@aichi said: no, that was missing important controlscheck bpp, disadvantage says irrelevant controls. Missing important controls should be for narrative notes
@kolkleen said: check bpp, disadvantage says irrelevant controls. Missing important controls should be for narrative notesin bpp revision kit , mock exam 2 , question 6, page 370, disadvantage-missing unusual controls :)
exam was ok
The paper was too bulky, Question 6?
What was for revaluation of z land?
Title deed?
market value of z land?
overstated?
and how about the new warehouse?
@aichi said: in bpp revision kit , mock exam 2 , question 6, page 370, disadvantage-missing unusual controls :)Are you sure there was even such an option (unusual controls)? Not sure I remember seeing it though and bpp mentions both. So i guess its up to the examiner to decide then
@kolkleen said: Are you sure there was even such an option (unusual controls)? Not sure I remember seeing it though and bpp mentions both. So i guess its up to the examiner to decide thendon't know, maybe my answer is wrong
i wrote the following substantive procedures for revaluation and warehouse such as:
auditor needs to inspect valuers report and agrees the amount in the report to general ledger and fs.
ensure all classess of assets were revalued
ensure to recalculate depreciation based on NEW carrying amount
ensure the revalued disclosure is adequate.
anyone got these?
Guys Kaplan text book page 195 . disadvantage of IEQ " may contain a number of irrelevant control"
Which option was that B?
@mona1111 said: Guys Kaplan text book page 195 . disadvantage of IEQ " may contain a number of irrelevant control" Which option was that B?I think A
@abbas7796 said: i wrote the following substantive procedures for revaluation and warehouse such as: auditor needs to inspect valuers report and agrees the amount in the report to general ledger and fs. ensure all classess of assets were revalued ensure to recalculate depreciation based on NEW carrying amount ensure the revalued disclosure is adequate. anyone got these?Yea I also talked about revaluation surplus if applicable and transfer to undistributable reserves or something like that
Was not an easy paper though given that the content of audit is a lot. The issue with this paper is not exactly in interpreting the scenario, but putting down the answers on paper is a hard task. Its easy to know a deficiency exist, but how to prove that on an A4 to the satisfaction of the examiner is another thing.
I hope we will pass as the comments cite. Don't worry too much, God cares for you.
:)
Guys what was your answers regarding advantages and disadvantages of non-executive directors?
Simply put,
in my opinion, The MCQ's were OK... not too tricky but not easy either, u had to think, not the normal "tick and go to the next" type...(Most of them if I recall were B's and C's, I think more B's)
Section B - I have to say it may not have been very hard, but it sure was lengthy... really lengthy... I may have missed a question or two in between....
But guys, for substantive procedures I kind of changed my style of answering, because just before the exam I happen to come across Technical Articles of Way to Answer Substantive Procedures.. and it clearly stated the regular use of "Cast, Agree, Trace" as the way in which to begin
so it goes like this :
Audit Procedure, followed by reason of audit procedure & followed by the assertion which it is relating to (now that would be one of the 3 areas (Whether Transaction & events OR Account balances OR Presentation & Disclosure))
I hope my answers were satisfactory
Overall - It WAS NOT EASY !!! NOPE !!
It was Lengthy and at times Tricky and definitely a lot more than what one would expect after doing Mocks From BPP Rev. Kit
:)
@tauraiversatile said: Was not an easy paper though given that the content of audit is a lot. The issue with this paper is not exactly in interpreting the scenario, but putting down the answers on paper is a hard task. Its easy to know a deficiency exist, but how to prove that on an A4 to the satisfaction of the examiner is another thing. I hope we will pass as the comments cite. Don't worry too much, God cares for you. :)I quite agree especially because the examiner wants you to related the risk to an assertion and to the FS. Hard to keep that in mind given the time constraint.
Guys, sorry for funny question... Am I right that answers to questions should have been filled in the special table on the first page? I painted over answers on that table, but my friend told me that he wrote down figures from 1 to 12 and next to figure he wrote an answer O_O for F5...
Now I am worried that I made a huge mistake and my answers will be ignore :(
@Ilalandi .
May I enquire some more specific details regarding that friend of urs and his/her material mistatement. ?
@boringaccountant said: @Ilalandi . May I enquire some more specific details regarding that friend of urs and his/her material mistatement. ?hahaha your comment cracked me up
i agree with bill the butcher..
I think the question which took me surprise was Q3. this and internal audit were like 2 chapters i dint even cover (started paper and revision 2 weeks before exam). i managed to woffle on the first part like improving the financial reporting process, independence of auditors and also about share holder confidence.
but i really didnt understand the advantages and disadvantages about them 2 NEDs.??
that was a shocker..
guys there was an McQ about written representation...
what did you guys put down?
i think i put down D, regarding FS being prepared in accordance with framework and what not as i thought this was the pre-condition of the audit
anybodyy???
@bill the butcher
I think I made mistake putting answers in the table rather than simply write number and answer...
@usamaniaz said: i agree with bill the butcher.. I think the question which took me surprise was Q3. this and internal audit were like 2 chapters i dint even cover (started paper and revision 2 weeks before exam). i managed to woffle on the first part like improving the financial reporting process, independence of auditors and also about share holder confidence. but i really didnt understand the advantages and disadvantages about them 2 NEDs.?? that was a shocker.. guys there was an McQ about written representation... what did you guys put down? i think i put down D, regarding FS being prepared in accordance with framework and what not as i thought this was the pre-condition of the audit anybodyy???I don't recall this question... lol
i think it was question 3
written representation being the least relibale or something like that
@usamaniaz said: i agree with bill the butcher.. I think the question which took me surprise was Q3. this and internal audit were like 2 chapters i dint even cover (started paper and revision 2 weeks before exam). i managed to woffle on the first part like improving the financial reporting process, independence of auditors and also about share holder confidence. but i really didnt understand the advantages and disadvantages about them 2 NEDs.?? that was a shocker.. guys there was an McQ about written representation... what did you guys put down? i think i put down D, regarding FS being prepared in accordance with framework and what not as i thought this was the pre-condition of the audit anybodyy???i also answered D in that question...its not an audit evidence
this is what i wrote for advantages and disadvantages:
the first director Anthony
advantages:
already an NED in a listed company and was qualified so he had a recent relevant financial experience that is a requirement for NED.
his pay was not profit related so he wont be tempted to manipulate profits
disadvantage:
since he was already an NED so this appointment would have overburdened his responsibilities.
the second director was jacob
advantages
probably that he was from a small company that was not in competition to this company so he would not be seen as working for competitor
disadvantage:
he was brother of chief executive (serious independence issue)
he asked for fixed term 7 year contract ( again a self interest issue since he might not criticize companys work because of fear of not getting renewal of contract.
hope all above is right
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

