Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AA*** F8 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin11y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the F8 December 2014 Exam.

*** F8 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** F8 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** F8 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Please note, the ACCA have asked us to allow posting comments only after 5pm UK time.
Former userFormer user11y ago#91
@lbalandi said: @bill the butcher I think I made mistake putting answers in the table rather than simply write number and answer...
I'm not sure I get what you're saying. For the MCQs all you need do is shade in the circles provided. Thats all
Former userFormer user11y ago#92
@boringaccountant said: Simply put, in my opinion, The MCQ's were OK... not too tricky but not easy either, u had to think, not the normal "tick and go to the next" type...(Most of them if I recall were B's and C's, I think more B's) Section B - I have to say it may not have been very hard, but it sure was lengthy... really lengthy... I may have missed a question or two in between.... But guys, for substantive procedures I kind of changed my style of answering, because just before the exam I happen to come across Technical Articles of Way to Answer Substantive Procedures.. and it clearly stated the regular use of "Cast, Agree, Trace" as the way in which to begin so it goes like this : Audit Procedure, followed by reason of audit procedure & followed by the assertion which it is relating to (now that would be one of the 3 areas (Whether Transaction & events OR Account balances OR Presentation & Disclosure)) I hope my answers were satisfactory Overall - It WAS NOT EASY !!! NOPE !! It was Lengthy and at times Tricky and definitely a lot more than what one would expect after doing Mocks From BPP Rev. Kit :)
You have spoken very well, this is being misunderstood and not considered by many folks here.
Llbalandi11y ago#93
disadvantages of NED were something like: - does not have knowledge about retail company ( one of them sits in audit committee in bank or smth like this...) - chief executive director was a brother of Ned- close family relation - something about fee... It was linked to profit.. Don't remember now
Former userFormer user11y ago#94
@abbas7796 said: this is what i wrote for advantages and disadvantages: the first director Anthony advantages: already an NED in a listed company and was qualified so he had a recent relevant financial experience that is a requirement for NED. his pay was not profit related so he wont be tempted to manipulate profits disadvantage: since he was already an NED so this appointment would have overburdened his responsibilities. the second director was jacob advantages probably that he was from a small company that was not in competition to this company so he would not be seen as working for competitor disadvantage: he was brother of chief executive (serious independence issue) he asked for fixed term 7 year contract ( again a self interest issue since he might not criticize companys work because of fear of not getting renewal of contract. hope all above is right
I agree, I also made reference to the UK corporate governance code stating that directors of listed companies should be submitted for reelection annually. I guess it's really about making a valid point cos I felt that a fixed fee may make him relaxed; therefore his fee should be performance related. I also stated that if an audit committee were to be formed, he will be able to head such a committee given his experience. All I want is to pass and move on,,,,so help me God.
SSharjeel11y ago#95
High Cost/ It will not reduce cost.. however u will get more expert nd 2nd option i did not remember now.
SSharjeel11y ago#96
Mine were option C .;p
SSam12345678911y ago#97
i dunno what i was thinking there i wrote about their expeerinces, conflict of interest, risk of confidentiality and some familiarity. i hope i am rewarded for some marks
Former userFormer user11y ago#98
@tauraiversatile said: You have spoken very well, this is being misunderstood and not considered by many folks here.
You are right but you cant limit yourself to cast, trace and agree. You have to recalculate, inspect, reperform and carry out analytical procedures. You may also need to obtain written representations. Cast, agree and trace are usually for done for the completeness assertion. Check BPP and you'll see many diff words used. Even Sally's video on the ACCA website didnt use much of agree cast and trace cos they are limiting.
Llbalandi11y ago#99
@kolkleen Many thanks! that's what I did :)
RRoy11y ago#100
yes hopefullly pass is all i need
RRoy11y ago#101
did anyone manage to do Work in progress valuation? i wrote recalculate WIP using payroll records for labour cost. is that a substantive procedure? what about reviewing aged WIP report?
Former userFormer user11y ago#102
20
TTrueJavan11y ago#103
most of my answers B n C,..... almost no A n D
Llbalandi11y ago#104
I didn't have time for WIP
Rrishi11y ago#105
Seems I completely missed question 6 out. Please could someone kindly tell me what was in question 6?
SSam12345678911y ago#106
Factors to consider before relying on independent surveyor. 5 marks Substantive land and building revaluation and warehouse purchased. 6 marks WIP substantive 4 marks Last part was hmm so audit amendment if I can remember 5 marks
Rrishi11y ago#107
Thanks buddy
PPaul11y ago#108
Hi all, Found exam was hard to do in three hours. I had done half of it after my 15 minutes reading time and two hours leaving me an hour for question 2 3 4 and 6 so 50% of marks in an hour. So did each in 15 minutes so had to rush four questions to make sure I finished. MCQs were ok think got 14/20. Was too busy making my letter presentable for the two marks on question five then realaisedd got an hour left for 50% of paper doh. Th advantages and disadvantages for the two neds was ok. Both wanted fixed salaries but remuneration should be based on profit, one had a brother on the board so familiarity. etc etc Probably failed added up marks and got 47% lets wait and see...... Question six was very tough at least u missed the hardest question out.
Rricardo11y ago#109
Can any 1 remember which questions about the benefits of an internal department came in. Or what the scenario was about?
TTez11y ago#110
Guys what did you do about the WIP sub testing in q6?paper overall was tough I thought mcq were meant to boost for a pass but the volume of it was massive. Also does anyone recall if none of the deficiencies was that payments are received after goods are despatched(q5)? Also does anyone remember sub testing for revenue?I put down as forecast and investigation of any high deviations.any sales rmitances received after year end to ensure cut off does this sound correct to you?
Rricardo11y ago#111
Also which question on benefits of outsourcing came in
RRoy11y ago#112
sub testing for revenue were: perform positive circulirization. cuttoff testing post year end cash receipt testing credit notes testing plus recalculation of sales discounts and sales tax does anyone agree?
Rrishi11y ago#113
Everyone has different answers so let's see. I know I would have prob at least got 5-7 marks out of question 6 from the surveyor question and sub procedures for revalue. I answered 80 marks and I know I got a few mcq questions wrong, got confused with auditor responsibility, confidentiality, internal control mcq questions. So prob got around 20 marks to play with does not seem likely I will pass this and this is my 3rd attempt. I prepare for it and I miss the last question.
Rrishi11y ago#114
I did post yr cash testing, receivables circulation, compare customer contracts to what is meabt to be sold and can't remember last one.
TTez11y ago#115
With regards WIP I put down labour costs recalc! And raw material. Also comparison to last year's WIP balances to establish trends.WIP completely threw me out. About deficiencies does anyone remember if they put down supplier and customer reconciliations not being in place?also sales system does not cover for two different revenue streams?? About the opinion on q4 do you remember if you got qualified/material? Also there was something on q6 about opinion if you remember what please let us know!!!:-)
Former userFormer user11y ago#116
easy exam
HHong11y ago#117
Sorry, I can ask some question? What's is the audit opinion for question 6 part c? The valuation was an error and client do not wish to amendments...
RRoy11y ago#118
in the opinion question the audtor was first suppose to determine whether or not the error was materiel since the question didn't mention about materiality. if materil then qualified except for opinion. if immaterial then no reporting implications
Ccardine11y ago#119
Colleagues, the exam was NOT easy!!!!!!!!!! We know that the examiners are looking for lots of writing and pressure us at all times; we may just mist the points. #3 and 6 was lengthy and time consuming; but I tried to cover 80% of the paper - hoping to cap the required pass. There were two VERY tricky MCQ's - which I believe was set deliberately. Practicing was the key to have knowledge flowing under the pressure. This paper always fairly set with time pressure - nuff writing!!!!!!!!!! Over all; it was more than previous years. If you have done your best - it is good enough for the passing grade (50). This is what is required and we all appreciate the brata!!!!!! The paper should be available online within the next 24hrs - just confirm you grades by doing this paper before you go to bed. Success for all who wrote something - favour from the markers - thank you for mercy!!!!!!
Former userFormer user11y ago#120
yes it was....20 marks
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.