AA*** F8 December 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Thanks Anas!
But I only wrote for material and qualified opinion!
I thought it mention is material...
For test of control, you Inspect, observe, reperformance and recalculation, testing and enquiry
@wayhern said: Thanks Anas! But I only wrote for material and qualified opinion! I thought it mention is material...The question said it was material so yes a qualified opinion. I also indicated that an except for paragraph will be included (my opinion tho, I may be wrong) but the examiner said we should not use the scattergun approach so I made up my mind to go with that.
Was the outsourcing questions a mcq or written. Some 1 please reply
where was the question about wages? Did I missed it?
Yes Anas
I done the same thing for Q6 part C as we were not told about the materiality so we had to speak about both.
I also mentioned towards the end, if matter is material and the directors refuse to amend, than they should consider resigning as the FS are material misstated and therefore do not give a true and fair projection.
its risk of mm+detection
@saajid said: Mcq's seem to be easy considering there were questions as follows : Audit risk consists of two components : Control risk and Inherent Risk (A) True (B) False -,-its risk of mm+detection risk so false
@saiga said: What is not a benefit of outsourcing internal audit?the beleif tjt it will bring the costs down coz u have t restaff or redundancey,,,
@rcc002 said: Darkeye 1-I choosed Observe the staff is following the Counting instruction 2-Inspect the counting intsruction something like that options...to obtain count istructions is before counting so wrong its observe for damage stock
@claremmorgan said: There were the 12 MCQ's in Section A, and 6 Questions in Section B. Question 6 was worth 20 marks. It was on the back page of the question booklet :(lol i i saw it in last 10 mins and wrrote 15 marks,,,,
Does somebody knows how was the structure of the marks in yesterday's exam?
Thank you
does anyone remember what Q3 was abt in section B?
Section A
Q1 20 marks
Section B
Q1 10 marks
Q2 10 marks
Q3 10 marks
Q4 10 marks
Q5 20 marks
Q6 20 marks
You have to gain time in section A, just as well I was done with MCQ using reading time & 10 minutes into exam I was in section B, the 10 markers took the longest, between 20 and 25 minutes per question, it should only take 18mins. Left me 1 hour and 20 minutes to do Q5 & Q6.
Q5, the sales system took me 40 mins and Q6, took similar time...just got in on time...
@aitezazshah said: to obtain count istructions is before counting so wrong its observe for damage stockObserving for damaged stock is not a test of control. It's a substantive test, I think the question asked for tests of control
the question said "during the count" plus the option said observing the client staff noting damage goods so it is test of control. substantive would be things like reviewing invoices for cost and sales nrv etc. basically anything where you test the balance on bal sheet.
Anyone need free ACCA F8 kit 2014 PDF version can contact me here:
[email protected]
does anybody remember the eng letter mcq? i think it asked us what not suppose to go in there.
@usamaniaz said: Yes Anas I done the same thing for Q6 part C as we were not told about the materiality so we had to speak about both. I also mentioned towards the end, if matter is material and the directors refuse to amend, than they should consider resigning as the FS are material misstated and therefore do not give a true and fair projection.Resigning? That sounds extreme though
yes you are right since resigning comes if there is no option and that happens after the report is singed. i think the question gave us info that report wasn't signed yet. can you confirm plz?
@aitezazshah said: to obtain count istructions is before counting so wrong its observe for damage stockI still believe that guy is right though cos ure observing that the counting is being done as instructed. Doesn't matter anymore though. We wait for Feb
@abbas7796 said: yes you are right since resigning comes if there is no option and that happens after the report is singed. i think the question gave us info that report wasn't signed yet. can you confirm plz?Yes you're correct; we were asked to consider the effect on the report.
overall it was okay but did't touch qn 6
@giftchowa said: overall it was okay but did't touch qn 6You should be fine if the other sections were cool; but it's always good to at least attempt every question; you never can tell..
great. do u remember the advantages in q3 of audit commitees? were we suppose to put just generic advantages like it strengthens the independence of external auditors, improves control environment and internal control and so on?
also there was a question on importance of planning? was the answer like it devotes more time to important areas of audit, manages and organizes audit effectively, assists in selecting team members etc?
i agree it was very tricky. I am just hoping for 50. in question 5 there were two additional marks for the cover letter. were these 2 marks including already in the marking scheme or were they just bonus marks?
@abbas7796 said: great. do u remember the advantages in q3 of audit commitees? were we suppose to put just generic advantages like it strengthens the independence of external auditors, improves control environment and internal control and so on? also there was a question on importance of planning? was the answer like it devotes more time to important areas of audit, manages and organizes audit effectively, assists in selecting team members etc?I think I tried to relate it to the scenario; not sure if that was really feasible though cos there wasn't much info about the status of things. Yea planning was about right. Question 6 you mean the question was 16 marks (14 marks for identifying deficiencies and providing recommendations and 2 marks for presentation.) I didn't really bother with the letter cos it was 2 marks and i was pressed for time
Effect on report on valuation being incorrect,
I said - if not material do nothing, if material, ask directors to correct, if they correct, issue unmodified report, if they didn't correct, consider the reasons and get written representation as to why they remain uncorrected, evaluate response, decide if its persuasive or not, if persuasive then - issue disclaimer of opinion, if not persuasive, issue modified report based on qualifying opinion.
I tink qn 6 mentioned the wip estimate amount is material ...and asked to discuss the effect on the opinion.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

