Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

Topic 8: Financial Statement Problems - Dates, whether they can be compared etc.

Aacnca12y ago
Say i am doing a 3 yr analysis for a company for my submission and the annual year for the company is August 2014;August each year. Would it then mean that obu expect me to use the 3rd quarter analysis for my report and not the full year? or should i just use three year analysis and ignore the 9 months results in my report? Another example :Annual report is for year ended dec 2012,2013 and of course 2014 is not finished and i plan to submit my rap in may (or november i dont get ready by midnight today :-D ).what is the best approach??? thanks A
Former userFormer user11y ago#121
I am comparing two companies. Both are US based. In one's report the name of the entity is "XYZ inc. and its subsidiaries" while the other has two annual reports. one named "ABC inc." and the other named "ABC group". Please guide me as to which two to compare in for me to make an apple to apple comparison?
Ttrephena11y ago#122
Inc is the equivalent of company so you either have to compare at the company "Inc" level or Group level (Inc stands for incorporated )
Jjoeackim11y ago#123
@trephena - thanks so much for your guidance....
MMi11y ago#124
Hi, I was searching a suitable competitor for Samsung electronics which is the basis of my RAP.I am conducting research on topic no 8( Financial and Business analysis of a company). I found out that SONY and other companies like Toshiba, Panasonic( these have got similar business structure) all have march financial year end, where as Samsung electronics has December year end. Can anyone guide me how to use the data for ratio analysis. Is it possible to deduct the annual figures[finanacial statements] from the previous quarterly[ Q1,Q2 and Q3] reports to get the last quarter figures ? Thanks!!
MMi11y ago#125
Hi, I am conducting research on topic no 8. The company i have chosen adopts IFRS whereas all major competitors use US GAAP.I understand that I can use them by explaining the limitations.However I am unsure about how much descriptive should it be. And, there is one company which uses IFRS but does not operate in one of the business segment as the main company.The segment comprises around 22 % of total revenue and more than 40% of operating profit. I am confused which one should I pick up as a competitor. Thanks!!
Ttrephena11y ago#126
@accadubaistudent - sorry I am away at the moment and unable to answer queries in detail. I have reposted your queries to this forum as you will probably find answers to similar queries if you look back through the posts
BBRUCE11y ago#127
please help i am in a foreign country having difficulties in finding the organization to use for my OBU. Are they any international organization that i can use.
Ttrephena11y ago#128
You can use any organisation provided the information is publicly available in English. The same also applies to the comparator company You now need to use an OBU listed mentor (otherwise you CANNOT submit your work) so you will need to go on the OBU mentoring website to find one. Being overseas is not a problem if you check they can do the meetings via Skype (or use our recommended mentors The Learning Luminarium)
BBRUCE11y ago#129
I also want to use topic 8 for my research may you please advice me the companies that publishes their accounts on internet and that i am free to use please help.
Ttrephena11y ago#130
@bruce2015 - I don't like recommending particular companies as it's best you choose ones that interest you. However you could try Google and Microsoft for example, Sony and Samsung or two international airlines. Just put the name of the company in a search engine and annual report 2014 or go to their websites and look for the Investor Relations pages to find their latest reports
Ssebina1110y ago#131
Hi @Ali Farooq OBU Registered Mentor, Thank you so much of your advice. I have some questions about Topic 8 and selected company. 1. if the co.'s year ended day is 31 dec, for Period 32 May 2016, i would only study annual report from Year 2012 to Year 2014, right? 2. Should I also refer to company's quarterly's report of year 2015 and 2016? 3. I would like to choose China Eastern Airlines as my selected company and the competitor will be choosing Cathy Pacific, besides to consider their financial year end, financial reporting standards what else area should i pay attention? Thank you for your kind advice in advance. Best Regards, Hellen
EEmmanuel10y ago#132
thanks a lot sir- Mr. Hammad and Farooq Mr. Farooq, for my project mentor we are yet about to have our first meeting; i think at the first meeting i would open up these issues to Him for his advise i guess your advise for me to study Verizon vs at&t will be OK with me if only i can get their individual financial statements rather than consolidated financial statements. please can you write to me their websites- Verizon and at&t my second worry now is that i have read through the Information pack and assuming i now have my company, please what is the way forward...... because my sheets are blank as at now- i mean how do i start now that i have my company and topic? hope to hear from you quickly. thank you
AFAli farooq - ACCA member USA Chapter, CPA USA & BSc Registered Mentor10y ago#133
Hello @sebina11 & @Hellen, As per my knowledge you prepared your project in 2014. Anyways please find your answer. 1. if the co.’s year ended day is 31 dec, for Period 32 May 2016, I would only study annual report from Year 2012 to Year 2014, right? 1) You should confirm publication date if reports are available till end of Jan, you must use otherwise you are advised to use from 2012 to 2014. Please read pg 42 of Bsc info pack. Addition, you must provide reasons for using annual reports from 2012 to 2014 in your part 2 of RAP. 2. Should I also refer to company’s quarterly’s report of year 2015 and 2016? 2) If you are using annual report from 2012 to 2014 then you do not require to incorporate quarterly or half yearly report of 2015. As per my experience you may use latest information in your business analysis (optional). 3. I would like to choose China Eastern Airlines as my selected company and the competitor will be choosing Cathy Pacific, besides to consider their financial year end, financial reporting standards what else area should i pay attention? 3) I advise you to select Public listed companies for your RAP because the amount of information is available online. Most of students to expect to be able to find information quickly and easily. You should do research smart and hard to obtain reliable information from different sources Finally, you can not rely only on Annual Reports / CEO / Director Reports. You must use different sources during analysis such as Business newspapers, Press release, Chamber of Commerce, Regulator reports, State Bank Reports, Industry specific reports & any other reliable source. Regards, Ali Farooq
BBRUCE10y ago#134
good day TREPHENA i have selected two companies in telecom industry but the problem is do with the dates my main company has a financial year which ends at 31 MARCH and the one for my comparotar ends at 31 DEC three months difference please help me
Ttrephena10y ago#135
This isn't normally a major problem - please read the answers above on this. However I recognise that you may not have the 31st March financials for the comparator. Mention this in limitations and for important ratios if it were me I would use the GP ratio and net/ operating profit from the 3rd quarter from the 3rd quarter unaudited financials to compare with main company (not the raw figs because you would only have 9 months). You should be able to get the share price on the same dates from a good stock exchange website -and the trend in this is important. For current ratios etc you could use 31 March 2014 as again the trend over the years is important
EEmmanuel10y ago#136
dear trephena the company i am studying with its comparator(pharmaceuticals) are all listed companies on the Ghana Stock Exhange- but their latest financial statements available on the annual reports for listed companies is 2013- no 2014 and 2015 can i therefore do the RAP with 2013, 2012, 2011 secondly there is also a difference in the year end; 31 dec for the main company and 30 sep for the comparator...... i have read your responses to similar questions but i dont get it clear can you please give me an clear elaboration on how to go about it thank you, hope to hear from you soon
Ttrephena10y ago#137
You must be certain that nothing more recent than 2013 is available as the marker is bound to question this as basing a report and submitting on such old data in 2016 has negligible worth. If they find more recent accounts were available in accordance with the rules in the Information Pack you will get an instant fail. Otherwise 3 months difference is negligible.
Ddarkangel510y ago#138
For calculating the ratios are we suppose to take the amounts from annual report?
HAHammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#139
@darkangel5 Yes from financial statements including notes to accounts. Also note that amounts can also be from other authentic websites such as PE ratio from any stock exchange website. Regards, Hammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor.
AFAli farooq - ACCA member USA Chapter, CPA USA & BSc Registered Mentor10y ago#140
@darkangel5 I encourage to students to compute ratios by them self and you may find difference between your ratio and their ratios. you should not be worried about it. Ratio differences can occur because of different assumption/judgement used by company. you should highlight this matter under the heading of limitation and inform examiner you are following your approach or the company, If you select public listed company then you can get financial information from stock exchange and annual report. I would like to highlight one issue here. some business newspapers publish research report on companies but you may find differences in financial figures & ratios. I recommend you to focus on annual reports to extract financial figures because it is audited :) Regards, Ali Farooq OBU Registered Mentor
AArsalan10y ago#141
I have a question regarding the use of IT as part of preparing the RAP. I just copied the financial statements of my chosen company into excel and did some formatting etc. Do i have to show formula's in my excel sheet or is just simply copying the data on to the sheet sufficient?
Ttrephena10y ago#142
How are you calculating the ratios? Presumably too you will be producing some graphs for your RAP (report and Presentation) ? Ensure that these are all included on the worksheets in the same excel file.
AArsalan10y ago#143
I am calculating the ratios on the excel sheet. I am talking about the balance sheet and income statement items like do i have to show the formula for lets says total assets on the balance sheet ( SUM(D1:D5)) or can i just use the copied figures. I am definitely going to show formula's for the ratio's.
AFAli farooq - ACCA member USA Chapter, CPA USA & BSc Registered Mentor10y ago#144
@arsalanullah1122 You have to apply formula on the excel sheet while preparing financial statements and ratios , Examiner can easily review by using the "insert function" in excel I strongly recommend to my students to compute ratios and apply formula. You can provide Ratio formulas in the separate excel sheet i.e Gross profit margin = gross profit / revenue = ( revenue - cost of goods sold ) / revenue Hope the answer of the question Regards, Ali Farooq OBU Registered Mentor
HAHammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#145
@huzaifa.abdurrauf Huzaifa, you should use March 2014, March 2013 & March 2012 for inter-temporal comparison of company A and for competitor (bench-marking) with company B: Use latest available accounts of company B and you may adjust their financial statements for example for year ended June 2014 of company B, you can deduct quarter ended June 2014 from annual financial statements until June 2014 and add quarter until quarter until June 2013 for aligning year ends. You should do this if you feel that there are different rules, economic situation etc, which effected during difference of 3 months. Otherwise, you need to write different year ends under limitation of bench-marking and information gathering, also you need to tell how did you overcome this. Regards, Hammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor.
Former userFormer user10y ago#146
Hi, I'm doing T8 for my research. The problem i'm facing now is the main company n the competitor r using different accounting standards. The main co. includes results of its JV &associates to arrive at operating profit while the competitor doesn't. Shld i adjust the competitor's accounts to be consistent? Please help.. Best regards, Denise
HAHammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#147
@denise87 Yes, you can compare but mention it under limitation of information gathering and your analysis also state how did you try to overcome this limitation. You may give an idea that whether different frameworks doesn't affects heavily or if they do so then your analysis highlight it. Regards, Hammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor.
Former userFormer user10y ago#148
Hi everyone I am currently doing topic I have a problem regarding the year end for my comparator it has the year end up to 31 DEC and my main company year end is up to 31 march. The comparator has only intrims results up to June and no quarterly results It is correct to adjust the comparators figures month by month to come up with annual results for three years? The other option is using another company which is fourth in the competition line ?
HAHammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor10y ago#149
@sipo Hi, Sipo, Hope you are well! Answer to your questions are: If you have monthly figures then it is right to adjust it by absolute available authentic numbers, if you don't have any then search on internet that how much political, economic and other circumstances changed between Jan To Mar. So, you use Latest Dec available for competitor and Latest March statement for main company and write different year ends in limitations of information gathering section of RAP, then in response that how you overcome this limitation write that political and other circumstances were quite stable and references. There is no restriction in info pack over not using companies which have different year ends for comparison purpose. Regards, Hammad Ahmed Qureshi - OBU Registered Mentor.
AFAli farooq - ACCA member USA Chapter, CPA USA & BSc Registered Mentor10y ago#150
@denise87 I am understanding your question. Suppose If your main company is using IFRS and Competitor is preparing Financial Statements under GAAP. first question should be raised in your mind whether both accounting practice are acceptable? Answer is yes yes. If both are acceptable then you will not find major variances, significant difference. but for save Otherwise you can share link of financial statements I will review and try to give you my best advise how to handle situation. Whatever option you chose please write appropriate reason under limitation heading in part two to make your report understandable for examiner and inform them how you overcome this issue. Hope the answer of the question, Regards, ALI FAROOQ OBU Registered Mentor
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.