Say i am doing a 3 yr analysis for a company for my submission and the annual year for the company is August 2014;August each year.
Would it then mean that obu expect me to use the 3rd quarter analysis for my report and not the full year? or should i just use three year analysis and ignore the 9 months results in my report?
Another example :Annual report is for year ended dec 2012,2013 and of course 2014 is not finished and i plan to submit my rap in may (or november i dont get ready by midnight today :-D ).what is the best approach???
thanks
A
Topic 8: Financial Statement Problems - Dates, whether they can be compared etc.
hi everyone
I have a similar question related to the financial year ends.
I am doing a RAP on topic 8, comparing the results of 3 years for Co A(main) to 3 years results of Co B (competitor).
The year ends for both are:
Co A: March 2015
Co B: December 2014
Is it alright to use the above for my RAP highlighting the 3 months timing difference in the limitations section.
Regards
Huzaifa
Yes that's fine no problem at all with that.
@trephena the main company has a Dec y/e while the comparator has a June y/e should I prorate the comparator's fs to correspond to that of the main. Considering that the comparator is 6 months ahead.
Thanx
The company i have chosen it has discontinued operations in 2015 and year 2014 was restated in order to be comparable. But how can i assess the company's performance over a 3 year period since year 2013 have not been restated to take into account discontinued operations and how they will be comparable with the another company in the industry. Should i ignore discontinued operations for the year 2014 and 2015?
should i restate 2015 fiqures to include discontinued operations?
@jpco - normally this isn't a problem unless the sales are seasonal so prorating is not necessary. These things are mentioned in the limitations of data section and if appropriate mentioned again in the analysis if it has affected the results.
any ideas?
@savvas - Depending on the what operations were and why they were discontinued is the main factor here. Was this a subsidiary that was sold off? Was it making a loss or was it something outside the normal core business that did not fit in with the company's strategic portfolio?
You say that 2014 was restated to make it comparable with 2015. In essence these being the most recent years will form the greater part of your work so go with these. So your years 2013-2014 and 2014-2015 have the adjusted figures and you want to know about 2012-2013? This year will be the start of your analysis so use it as it is, as I imagine it would be virtually impossible for you to restate this anyway. However in your Limitations you will need to mention that the figures for 2013-2014 and 2014-2015 have been restated and briefly why and that in your analysis you will try to assess how this may account for some of the differences in your trends subsequent to 2012-2013.
The main thing to understand with T8 is that you are using the figures and ratios to HELP do an evaluation and analysis of how the company has performed over the period (the figures and percentages themselves are merely tools!). The markers want to know what has gone on and in particular they are interested in the strategies the company has taken, so in many respects rather than be a hindrance to you this might actually be an opportunity for you to get behind the figures and see the management rationale. Below is a comment (from some actual marker feedback to a failed student taken from elsewhere on one of the other topic forums) that sums up exactly what is required to pass this topic and explains where the focus in T8 should be. It emphasises that the strategies are very important to producing a good analysis. I am repeating the full paragraph here (although perhaps only part of it is particularly applicable to your case) as so many students lose sight of what T8 is really about and tend to focus on the numbers to the exclusion of the real issues :
"The role of evaluation and analysis in the RAP is to research sufficiently from a variety of sources using trade and industry articles as well as the financial statements so that you can present a balanced view of the company performance. You need to discuss and explain rather than present descriptive statements and you must use supporting references to add validity. Try to link your SWOT /PESTLE factors to the financial analysis and use the CEO /directors reports to see what factors and strategies have impacted on the results and influenced management decisions. Ratios on their own without proper explanations of what has actually driven the changes in the movements is insufficient to pass the evaluation and analysis assessment criteria. Use graphs to show the movements and your words to provide the detailed reasons and factors that lie behind them rather than just describing increases and decreases and making obvious comments about differences between the two companies"
So do not get so hung up on the figures themselves particularly for the earliest year - it is why the decision to discontinue was taken and how the company has performed subsequently that are more important.
(Note: I shall be moving this post to a more appropriate forum topic in a few days as the issue in general goes beyond discontinued operations and therefore affects more students)
I am ACCA Affiliate, currently preparing for my RAP and facing a issue, i have selected Topic 8 and my main company has year end on June 2015 but the next competitor has year end in December 2014.
Kindly let me know the implication of the above on my RAP and if i can adjust competitor's IS with six month financial to make a realistic comparison with main company.
Main company is PSO Pakistan
Competitor is Shell Pakistan Limited.
Your earliest response will be highly appreciated.
Hello,
Please, can anyone share any detailed guidance on how to use weighted average rate for translating income statement to another currency?
Thank you.
@trephena
First of all, thank you for your response.
Is not sale of a subsidiary but a sale of a segment of the subsidiary.
The sale was made in order for the organization to focus on its remaining activities.
My company's year end is 31 March.
1)Correct me if I am wrong, but the analysis i have to do is 31/3/2013-31/3/2014 and 31/3/2014-31/3/2015 and also analyse the overall trend from 31/3/2013 to 31/3/2015.
2) Year ended 31/3/2013 has not been adjusted and is impossible for me to restate it.
So I will not be comparing like for like when making the comparison with 31/3/2014 and the same applies when analyzing the movement up to 31/3/2015.
i.e Lets say for example that revenue is:
2013 =2m
2014 =3m
restated-2014 =1.9m
2015= 2.2m
Should i use restated-2014 and say that there was a decrease in revenues due to the sale of some operations but the real movement was an increase in revenue....?
@Yama - This is not an issue as you should be working mainly in ratios. The only times you might use absolute figures is when discussing revenue and even then it is the year on year increases that are most significant, or share prices. With the latter it is the importance of the effect of performance on share price where you should be focussing. So don't feel you have to translate currencies as it is unnecessary - there are ways round this and arguably translation does not add anything and probably masks some factors. As I keep trying to tell students it is not the numbers and percentages themselves that matter but their significance.
@savvas
1. Your 3 year study is from 1/4/12 - 31/3/15
2. As I have already tried to emphasise is NOT the figures themselves that are critical but the factors that lie behind them - so please re-read my answer above and try to see the problem in this light
So the company sold a segment because it did not fit their core business portfolio. Move on - has this sale proved to be strategically sensible? What have the directors themselves said about the sale? Are they 'consolidating the business'? Have profits increased much subsequently or has there been little impact? Have the funds received been reinvested in the business (further expansion in the core activities, modernisation of plant etc?) or used to inflate dividend payouts to shareholders? (Bear in mind it might take a few years for investment to really impact so you may need to do further research -analyst / business reports).
If you can, use broken lines in your graphs for 2012/13 figures to indicate the figures have not been restated, if you can't do that then put an asterisk after the year on the x axis and write "unrestated figures" underneath.
My main concern is that you are making the common mistake of students of focusing on figures for the sake of it so please read my article on Evaluation on our homepage www.opentuition.com/obu so that you do not fall into that trap. And remember the words of the marker above where they directed the failed student to the importance and effect of management decisions on performance. (So stop worrying about this issue :-) )
Dear Trephena,
I'm planning to submit on P31. I choose a confectionary corporation (snack-food manufacturing specialized) which has year end in December 2012/2013/2014.
The problem is that: in the end of Dec 2014, this corporation sold their core activities (80% of snack food) to other company, in order to invest to a whole new industry (cooking oil and instant noodle). They were one of the leading businesses in snack food industry for more than 20 years, and now they change their strategy, focus on essential living foods.
1- Their main activity (manufacturing snack food) discontinued, and they change their main industry to cooking oil + instant noodle. I wonder how can I analyze this situation? Is it ok that I analyze their performance as normal for 2012+13 and then in 2014, I state this situation and give more analyzing about this strategy change/reasons to change/new industry's threatens?
2 - Do I need to mention this situation in Limitation of part 2 - as they are no longer operate in this snack food industry so the information is in the past and analyzing ratios doesn't help to improve future performance in snack-food industry?
3- Their FS is consolidated FS, which include all of their activities such as trading agriculture products, producing juice and water, other services. Is it true that we just need to analyze their core activity which brings the most income for business (snack-food)?
4- Can you give me some advice :) is there any point I need to focus in this situation?
Thank you in advance : )
In a word @linda you can't do this company for T8. There is no way that you can make any suitable and meaningful comparisons with another company so your evaluation would be pointless.
That means that you either choose a different company if you want to do T8 or you keep the company and change the topic. You might be able to use the scenario you describe for T14 'An appraisal of the business and financial objectives of a strategic investment decision made by an organisation and its impact on key stakeholders'. Selling off a core business to focus on another activity would fall within this as no doubt there has been a significant amount of investment in new plant and equipment (or re-investment of the proceeds from the sale). Possibly though (unless this has been immediately successful in the first year) you might really need at least 2 years of accounts post sell-off to be able to assess the full impact of this radical management decision. Were all the proceeds of the sale re-invested in this new business or some distributed to shareholders? Did the directors have to raise more capital/ secure more finance? What was the reaction of shareholders then and since? Can you assess yet whether this was a good or disastrous decision by the management.
It might otherwise be possible to do T7 which is about restructuring. It depends on the circumstances of whether manufacturing locations were changed, staff laid off and whether new marketing strategies and approaches were needed to sell the new product(s) as its customer target market has also changed.
With these topics you have to assess the impact of the changed position of the company and its stakeholders rather than just describe what happened.
Thank you so much for your reply @trephena
I have decided to choose another confectionary company for T8.
May I ask whether I can use the mentioned one as competitor to compare with my new choice of company or not? (financial ratios, SWOT,...)
@liinda - sorry liinda - having re-read your original problem as the latest accounts would be up to Dec 2014 I realise that you could use this company for P31 as the figures would be still relate to the original business :-D
Check though when they normally release their annual report - if you are lucky and this normally is after Feb each year which would mean that if you failed and had to resubmit in P32 the latest accounts would still be Dec 2014. Your problem would be that from P33 (potentially your 3rd attempt - worst case scenario) you would be into year end Dec 2015 and that would start to throw everything out and make your comparisons meaningless.
Apologies about the confusion.
@zain - this problem has been dealt with previously so please read the replies above
It's fine, don't worry Trephena :)
I have re-read their FS about the specific time of selling off decision of original company. It said that "in 1 Dec 2014, the company's shareholders approved a plan to transfer 80% equity interests." Otherwise, the online articles say the selling proceeds is completed on July.2015
I'm confused with these timeline, so I think I may go on with a new company :(
Thanks Trephena. So you are saying it is not required to convert my comparator's financial statements to my main company's currency? If that is so, then it is really a good thing.
I will get in touch with you in case I have further question.
Thanks a lot for your help, much appreciated.
Hello all,
My question is about ratios. If the company has provided the ratios in thier website, can we use it or we should recalculate them?
@Yama - yes you may use these but you must make it clear in your work that you have done so. I would suggest mentioning it in the limitations section as well as perhaps including the company table of significant ratios in your Appendices together with the referenced source.
You should show that you are capable of using a spreadsheet so calculate some year on year percentage movements - these would probably be useful to you anyway when explaining your analysis as long as you explore the real reasons that lie behind the trends rather than just producing percentages and figures
Hello I hv a problem the main company am using its financial year end is may 2015 but the comparator company end Dec 2015. so do I use 2012 -2014 since the annual reports is available. How ever I just discovered that the main company as just published its audited statement for 2015 which is the latest. But the comparator as not issued its annual account for the year
@stevr and @kellann - The Information Pack clearly sets out 'The 90 day Rule', meaning that any annual report published before 1st August 2015 MUST be used for the main company. You have to use the most appropriate competitor's statements and explain any limitations. Markers will always check and if you have NOT used the latest for the main company it will be an instant fail for out of date statements.
What constitutes the most appropriate with airlines (particularly low cost airlines) would be that they both covered the same peak summer season so Mar 2015 for Ryanair and 2014 for Easy Jet would be appropriate. You must however think about how this might skew your results and consider these limitations when interpreting them.
The important limitations of the comparisons here would be that Ryanair's FS also include the 2014/15 Christmas/New Year (second peak period) whereas EJ is 2013/14. Also oil prices have fallen significantly over the last year and this would favour the more recent results,as fuel cost is a major airline cost. Remember your marker wants a sensible analysis explaining how the various SWOT and PESTLE factors have impacted -what they don't want are monotonous ratios that tell them nothing they cannot see from the FS or graphs for themselves
(All students doing T8 should ensure that they read Bassanio Broke's forum "Top Tips for the RAP" at the top of our Forum page and the article I wrote on 'Evaluation and Analysis' on our homepage www.opentuition.com/obu. )
Thanks ma u are good
Thank you very much Trephena, this is very useful indeed! Ok I get your point here , it really does'nt matter on the YE as its 12 months considered but MUST include in my limitations.So I can use the below YE accounts per below as comparison.
Ryanair Easyjet
Yr1 - 31 Mar 11 to 31 Mar 12 30 Sep 10 to 30 Sep11
yr2 31 Mar 12 to 31 Mar 13 30 Sep 11 to 30 Sep 12
Yr3 31 Mar 13 to 31 Mar 14 30 Sep 12 to 30 Sep 13
Yr4 31 Mar 14 to 31 Mar 15 30 Sep 13 to 30 Sep 14
Issue number 2: Is that both have different currencies, RY is in € and EJ £, if you looking at revenue trend or debt gearing , I need to refer to % rather than absolute numbers but graphs are the issue.I could use the close rate to convert.The alternative is that I choose a competitor of same currency but this is not RY main competitor/rival.Any suggestions Trephena?
thank you for all your help , this site is really a god sent!
Regards
Kelly Anna
@kellann
1. Yes but you only need to analyse 3 years and produce graphs for those 3 years. However it would be useful to look at the management reports for the earlier year to pick up any strategies that may influence the subsequent periods.
2. You could show the revenue trends either on separate graphs side by side or by having one graph with € on the left (y axis) and £ on the right one as it is the slope of the line that is more important since the steeper the curve the greater the year on year increase. I don't understand why debt to equity is a problem as this should be a ratio maybe I am missing something.
With bar charts explain up front that there is a 6 month difference but with line graphs I think you should be able to plot Ryanair as Mar 20xx and EJ as Sep 20xx and although the lines will be slightly offset as I have mentioned it is slope that is usually more significant
Thanks Trephena , it all makes sense.Ignore the bit on debt gearing -error on my side sorry.
Regards
Kelly Anna
@kellann - As few tips for your specific Topic Kelly Anna and above all - DO NOT TAKE A TEXTBOOK APPROACH:
1. Try to do some ratios specific to airlines - the Quck Ratio is a total irrelevance but passenger load factors, revenue per passenger mile (kilometre) are the sort of KPIs used in the REAL world by airlines
2. Think about the actual business environment airlines operate in - their business models are in fact very complex (take a look at one of my posts on this in connection with T15 by searching using the key words Topic 15 airline). So debtor and supplier days etc take on a different dimension (in other words don't try to explain them in the same way as you would a smaller less complicated business - rather tell the marker you are aware of the limitations in interpreting them because of the complexity of their operating environment (this is not a cop-out but shows your appreciation of the nature of their business).
3. Show in principle in your business analysis that you understand the importance of concepts such as currency hedging and fuel price hedging on the industry. Also why a major decision is whether to lease or buy new aircraft (or purchase older less fuel efficient planes secondhand). These decisions will impact significantly on operating costs and profit so may account for major apparent differences in performance.
What I am saying is, don't miss the big picture by focusing on the routine at the expense of the commercial reality. Some students make the big mistake of thinking that T8 is about ratio analysis. No it isn't! The brief for T8 is a BUSINESS and Financial Analysis and the role ratios play in this is (or should be) only about 20%.
A routine approach overall at best will get you a C but what they the markers really want is a sensible business analysis and a financial analysis (of which ratios is just a part) that links back to the business analysis. Students need to tell them what they can't see or read for themselves if they look at the graphs or look at the notes to the accounts (markers aren't blind or illiterate!!)
And finally ensure your graphs are clearly labelled - ensure units are correctly shown both in terms of m (millions) or 000's and currency and colours for each company shown in a legend/ key. This is a semi professional report and the reader should be able to read it and KNOW what it means and not have to assume that revenue expressed as 25,000 something is meant to be USD 25,000 m !!!
Good luck!
Trephena
Hi Trephena,
What can I say!! This is invaluable information & so very useful.I was'nt expecting this.I cannot thank you enough , I felt very stressed these few days but now after reading your recommendations , this is so solid advice .
Thanks again :)
Regards
Kelly Anna
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

