Say i am doing a 3 yr analysis for a company for my submission and the annual year for the company is August 2014;August each year.
Would it then mean that obu expect me to use the 3rd quarter analysis for my report and not the full year? or should i just use three year analysis and ignore the 9 months results in my report?
Another example :Annual report is for year ended dec 2012,2013 and of course 2014 is not finished and i plan to submit my rap in may (or november i dont get ready by midnight today :-D ).what is the best approach???
thanks
A
Topic 8: Financial Statement Problems - Dates, whether they can be compared etc.
@shangrila26 There should not be a problem using the Mar 2014 for main company and Dec 2013 for the comparator as long as you state this in the Limitations (which you intended to do anyway). I would probably also include a note with the first graph (I trust you have read my posts and appreciate the importance of graphs and charts! :-) ) - maybe use the designations 'Year 1, Year 2 etc and explain that Year I refers to year end Dec 2011 for the comparator and Mar 2012 for the main company and Year 2 is ... and so on and that this convention will be used through out your analysis section - then everything should be clear. :-)
hello ,
I need your advice about f/s. Company i have selected is LUCKY Cement in Pakistan, and Its competitors are Fauji Cement Company ltd and Bestway cement ltd both in Pakistan. The problem is the Lucky Cement hasn’t issued their annual report yet but only unaudited quarterly statements, same is the case with Bestway cement but Fauji Cement company ltd annual report 2014 is available.
Now my question is can i use 2013,12 and 11 reports or i must use 2014??
@awais21 Well as your main company's financial statements are not available before the 90 period up to 1 November then you are not expected to use them. So you would have to go with June 2013. Regarding your comparator then I suggest that you choose the nearest reporting date to this so that the time difference between them is minimised. I would suggest mentioning this as a limitation in Part 2 as markers are quite strict in applying the 90 day rule and so you need to remind them that with the best will in the world you could not comply and produce an analysis that included 2014 :-)
You could however perhaps mention anything significant (if applicable) that has happened since year end 2013 (that you have discovered in the quarterly accounts or from business articles) e.g. if there has been a major interruption in production / closure of a plant / material government contract but re-iterate and say that as the financial information for 2014 was only made available DATE (it will no doubt be available by the time you submit so use the auditors' report date) you were not apply to analyse the full impact on the company performance.
Hi
I have chosen to undertake topic 8 but my question is it possible to compare two companies one which manufactures explosives and one which manufactures copper wires
@silunjilicrayno This depends whether they are operating in a similar market and have similar customers and are subjected to similar operating conditions. The whole idea of a comparator is to put your company into a relevant and appropriate context. Personally I think you should attempt to find two companies that are better matched if you are doing T8 as you are expected to make meaningful and reasoned comparisons between the two companies' performances not just state that one's GP is greaterr than the other or that it's liquidity is better -you have to state WHY this is so. (Such explanations need to look beyond just the annual reports and bring in SWOT & PESTLE factors)
If you cannot do appropriate analysis like this then you will be failed on Evaluation. Markers tend to take the view that as a student has a complete choice of companies it is the student's responsibility to choose two well matched companies. The Evaluation and! analysis is critical for a pass - so don't make life harder for yourself
Your question should have been posted to the more relevant Forum we have called 'Comparator company' and will be moved together with is answer in 48 hrs.
I have choosen Topic 8 where i need to have a comparator to come out with the ratio analysis. But then the financial year end for both my company is different (one is June and the other is Dec)
I have failed my first submission and marker give me the feedback to use pro-rating technique.
Is that any idea of what is pro-rating is? Totally can't find " Pro-rating technique" online. Can share with me some link related to pro-rating.
@jancoolleeteng - Thank you for this post, I have found it most interesting. In my opinion if you used the latest Financial Statements available for both companies at the time you submitted, then you should not be failed on these grounds alone. :-(
I suggest that you contact OBU with your query above and ask for further information on what they expect for this 'pro-rating'. If you do it NOW you should get a reasonably prompt reply. If this was the only cause of failure point it out too.
It says nothing in the Info Pack about apportionment and adjusting the financial statements for a comparator and so I think to be failed solely on this would be grounds for an appeal. It is fine for it to be recommended but in my opinion it is not mandatory. Please seek further clarification from OBU (the contact details are in the Info Pack) and tell us all how you got on
@trephena -the year end for my company is 31 march 2014 but now its first quarter financials are also available at june 2014 which is also the competitor year end date.
i have used Annual report for the year ended 31 march 2014 and for competitor june 2014, so do they appear to be the latest financials??? or am i to use 1st quarter financials (very less information has been provided in those)??
@wajiman this should be fine.
I want to see the reply from OBU to jancoolleeteng as I think the marker was wrong. I have known students to be failed for out of date statements (and I think it is one of the most frequent grounds for an appeal as it is not academic judgment here, the date of publication is an issue of fact)! Page 39 of the Information Pack sets out the ground rules for which statements to use. I can understand OBU for querying any statements that have a date that is more than 6 months different between the 2 companies as normally 6 months is the maximum gap there can be.
@wajiman - Thank you for this :-) I have read through the attached files - the most significant of which is the second one. They are not actually saying that you MUST do pro-rating it actually says:
"If students choose companies and comparators that do not have similar financial year ends, that is no problem and students will not be penalised for such a decision. However the process of comparing unlike time periods has to be addressed correctly.
Pro-rating is one technique for making accounting periods comparable. Students will need to consider the limitations of such techniques, of course, especially if the company's activity is seasonal. For example: Were the additional months during a period of relatively high or low annual activity?"
What this means is that you must address the difference in your limitations section and also in your analysis. Somewhere on one of my posts I mentioned that it was important if using retail companies that the accounts should cover the same Christmas and New Year periods as that is the busiest period in terms of turnover.
With an airline again it may be relevant here. Probably not much of a problem if one has a year end in Sept and the other Dec for European airlines as they will both have covered the main holiday season from June through to September. However if one was July and the other Dec this again would have to be accounted for as in this case the first airline would only be including part of the most recent summer turnover in their results whereas the the second company would have included the whole season. (Not much of a problem either if one is Dec and the other March as again they would have both included the same Christmas period).
It is a case of thinking about whether the companies you use are affected by this or any other significant factors. Companies such as mobile phone operators would probably not be much affected by seasonal sales (normally there are no seasonal factors that make people change their tariff). However if you think rationally about these companies there could be other factors that would impact e.g. the latest iphone could see a jump in their revenue - but this will impact on their current year figures mainly so would not come into play until the year end 2014 FSs are released (so this will be a factor for anyone possibly submitting a RAP for a mobile operator in P30).
So do not panic everyone - just calmly consider whether there are these sorts of reasons that can account for some of the differences in the performances of the two companies and ensure that you cover this both in the limitations sections in Part 2 and when discussing performance in Part 3
However I would still be interested in hearing the response to any enquiry made by @jancoolleeteng to OBU because in view of the statement "If students choose companies and comparators that do not have similar financial year ends, that is no problem and students will not be penalised for such a decision" if @jancoolleeteng had adequately discussed the limitations then I still think any failure if it was for this alone, was wrong.
Dear Trephena
Thank you so much for your message.
I understand I do not need to use FS 2015 Mar as long as there is no significant issues.
However how do you judge the news is a significant or not.
I heard the news that the president of the company announced that hundreds million yen (do not remember exact amounts but )in red (Loss) going to be appeared in FS 2015 year.Does that sort of news count as a significant issue ? (In the past, they are making reasonable profits but never loss then financial terms, do you count as a significant event or result ?)
Thank you
@pinkmonkey - I think you should use 2014 statements and base your RAP on those but mention this new fact (and reference it) in your analysis and say that this profit warning will impact on the next financial year statements. You may be able to access the actual share prices for example round when the time the announcement was made and see whether it affected the share price (did the price fall significantly when this was made?). Including little snippets like this (this one would go in the section where you look at Investor ratios) show that you are doing as full an analysis as possible and again you may bring up the profit warnings in your conclusion.
Hi
I have chosen company for whom FY ends in 31 march and my competitor's FY ends in 31 December.So my mentor suggested me to assume that both company have FY end in 31 December and write this down in appendix. so I will do my research from 2011 to 2013.
is this ok
Thanks
@redoy300. You need to choose the statements that are closest together so these will probably be March 2014 for main co and Dec 2013 for competitor. Do not fiddle dates - the marker if they discover would roast you - just mention the difference in your limitations section and at the start of your ratio and financial analysis section explain that there is a 3 month difference between the companies throughout because of their year ends.
If you use 2013 for both you would probably be failed as you MUST use the latest Financial statements. Markers are hot on this and usually automatically fail if you don't. (Don't know who your mentor is but hope you haven't paid over the odds for their dud advice )
thanks for replying! Now I can explain this time difference situation in 3 sections as u have mentioned and can do my regular analysis after that. So under 2014 can I also do my ratio analysis for my competitor al;though it's FY end is 31 December 2013.
I am grateful for this replies
@redoy300
[ First can I ask that everyone uses the search facility or look at a few of our more recent pages before they open a new topic? I try to keep our Forums organised (please see HELP KEEP OUR FORUMS TIDY!!!) otherwise former really good advice (such as we already have on this particular topic) gets lost and then the same question gets asked again and again. (Also I have to confess it is one of my pet hates seeing an unnecessary 'new' topic has been opened simply because no one bothered to look!!! ) This being the case I want to have everything under 'Different Financial Years - are they comparable?' as we have already had a good long discussion there on the problems of different years.]
However back to your query: the way I would do this myself is by having a footnote. MS Word will allow you to insert one at the end of the graph title (if you do the title outside and above the graph) and in the footnote itself I would use bold type to point out that 2014 represented year end Mar 2014 for company A but Dec 2013 for company B but these are the closest latest accounts as in essence there is only a 3 month gap. This way you have (a) covered yourself (b) made life easier for yourself and (c) complied with the OBU requirements.
I suggest you now consult the Forum topic mentioned above (on page 2) and post any further queries on this topic there. (As moderator I am closing and will be merging the this topic you have opened with it in a couple of days) :-)
i chose a company where they have financial statement for 2013 and 2014 where done in similar groupings but it was less detailed in balance sheet of 2012 and more in notes..
so is it ok to use financial staements for other groups that do comparisions like... themoneycontrol,com in india? it is so hard trying to break down and compare...Also it doesnt add up the same.Pls help
@riteshgrg82 - The rules are on p.39 of the Information Pack. If the statements are not available in accordance with the table then you use the latest that were available and in the public domain by 1 Feb 2015
hello
i choose a company with year end 31june for topic 8 now for last 3years do i have to take FS 2012 june and 2013 june and 2014 june
or i have to use 6 months july to december 2014 which are published as half year report if yes then i use last 6months of 2014 separately ??
@zee90
For a P30 submission you need to take the 3 statements ended June 2012, 2013 and 2014 (in accordance with p.39 of the OBU Information Pack). You are not expected to use more recent financial statements so do not need to use the half-year report. When discussing EPS it may be relevant to mention in passing if there had been a subsequent profit warning for the half-year however (as EPS is an important investor ratio and profit warnings usually radically affect the share price at the time they are announced).
Also if there was a significant event that might be relevant to the financial statements you have used (such as investigation into financial statement fraud e.g. as has happened at Tesco) then you are expected to mention this - probably the most appropriate place is when discussing the limitations of ratio analysis and possibly again when setting out your conclusions.
@trephena Thanks so much for your reply and assistance!
1. I have to use the latest financial statements to update my failed Research Report, so I wanna confirm with you if the 2014 annual report was released on 9 April 2015, then I wonder whether there is no need to use the 2014 annual report for the period 30 (re-submission) according to Page 39 of information pack?
2. Where and How to explain the fact that I do not use the 2014 annual report within my Research Report for the period 30 to the marker?
@will1982
1. It is entirely up to you if you choose to use the statements of April 2015. It is a case of you will be penalised if you use out of date statements but using more recent than those prescribed on p.39 of the Info Pack is NOT a problem at all.
2. If can't remember which topic you have chosen but unless it is T 8 which covers a 3 year period it is of no consequence if you use 2015 in preference to 2014 so there is no need to explain anything :-)
PS Can i ask you a favour - to stop opening a new topic each and every time you have a query and wherever possible use an existing relevant forum? - this is because (a) I find myself having to repeat myself when the same question is asked (b) I am trying to keep everything tidy and have it all in the appropriate place (c) a degree is about researching and finding things out for yourself so a bit of searching on the Forums is good practice and (d) nothing personal just my own idiosyncrasy - being totally honest it annoys me intensely :-) !!!
@zeest- this is something you mention in the Limitations Section. You then need to mention it again in the sections that are most affected when you are explaining differences. Where the restated amounts are not material then their effect can be largely ignored.
You should however consider the reason for the restated figures when approaching your analysis and their potential impact overall - how did the stock market and business analysts react? Their comments could be insightful.
I want to know how important are EPS and p/e ratio in rap?i had previously included those in my rap but on advice of my mentor i deleted those as my company has been working in loss and earning had been negative.I have less time left kindly help me out if i should include it in my financial analysis or not?
@husnafzai - normally I would recommend students include these as the Investor section is normally an important section. However in the circumstances I would focus on how the losses are being dealt with- have retained losses been reduced or are they increasing?; gearing to see if loan capital is being used for long term investment to turn the company round; whether there is an increase in the short term funding and is liquidity a 'problem'.
The important thing is NOT to view the ratios in isolation - see how the company is planning to recover from the current situation - read the CEO and Directors reports and supplement with articles from the business press wherever possible and take a quick look at how all of this has impacted on the share price.
Hello, I am due to commence my R&A project towards the OBU degree this summer (for the November 2015 submission) and I am considering using my former employer and topic 8 (Financial and business analysis over a 3 year period).
My former employer is a public company in the United Kingdom so there is plenty of financial information available.
The company's Year-end is December. However, they will be issuing interim/half-year results for in July for the first 6 months of 2015.
My question is for submission in November, which will be the most recent sent of accounts that I will need to use in my R&A project:
- Year end Report and Accounts 2014 (12 months at 31/12/14)
- Half year Report and Accounts 2015 (12 months at 31/12/14)*
- Half year Report and Accounts 2015 (6 months at 30/06/15)
* comaprables, if restated since 31/12/14
Thank you.
James
@jamest -you will see that I have moved your topic to an already existing forum that we have on this topic. I suggest you read the answers above as they probably answer your query (I am actually on holiday right now). It might also depend on the availability of your comparator company FSs too.
If you have further queries on this topic please post here or use our search facility to find the most appropriate topic (and please only open a new topic if absolutely necessary)
(Sun is shining where I am :-D ! - Trephena)
@fiazhnd - p.39 of the Info Pack refers to the full year's statements (or at least it is meant to!). There is nothing wrong with making any comments from the interim / quarterly accounts if you really want to as you have them for both companies. Otherwise it is not necessary to refer to them unless something significant has happened in between the year end and then - if there was something like a profits warning it might be appropriate to mention this. More emphasis is usually put on good overall evaluation that really explains what has gone on over the 3 year period so that is what I would advise you should focus on. However in the end it is your choice if you want to continue your comparisons using the very latest quarterly accounts - if you think it will enhance your evaluation then do it, if it does add anything then maybe save yourself the effort :-)
Hi
I am working on the topic 8 project and I have chosen two companies whose reporting currencies are not same, one is in Sterling, one in Swedish Krone.
How to go about it when converting the swedish krone to Sterling? any acceptable good practice?
Thank you.
@Yama - in most of your analysis you should be comparing ratios with ratios so absolute figures in different currencies should not be a a problem. You might mention currencies in the context of currency fluctuations affecting sales demand if this is appropriate or its affect on costs etc
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

