Say i am doing a 3 yr analysis for a company for my submission and the annual year for the company is August 2014;August each year.
Would it then mean that obu expect me to use the 3rd quarter analysis for my report and not the full year? or should i just use three year analysis and ignore the 9 months results in my report?
Another example :Annual report is for year ended dec 2012,2013 and of course 2014 is not finished and i plan to submit my rap in may (or november i dont get ready by midnight today :-D ).what is the best approach???
thanks
A
Topic 8: Financial Statement Problems - Dates, whether they can be compared etc.
Hello ma I hv a question to ask the main company YE is 30 may 2014.
Now how do I make comparing should it be 2012 vs 2013 and 2013 vs 2014.
Because I hv 2012-2014 annual report do also need 2011 annua. report and I h v written almost written 4400 words thanks
@stevr - see the answer to kellann Sept 16 at 1.01
Hello this my second time sending my questions pls help explain how I should pro rate the date between the main company and comparator.
Main company date is. 1 June - may 30
Comparator is 1jan - Dec 31
Do I porate it porate or use it like that that and if am not could u pls explain in detail thanks alot
Hello I read the part were date differ and I hv to po rate I just want confirm if this is the right way thanks
Main company YE is 1 June - 31 may
Comparator is 1jan - 31 Dec
So there I hv to adjust like this
7 months June 2013 - Dec 2013
5 months Jan 2014 - may 2014
So I can juSt use the annual report from last year and this year to determine the adjusted revenue cost of sale and even for the balance sheet to determine the adjusted asset and adjusted liability
Thanks
@stevr
I am not sure why you feel you need to do this (read my further comments below). I am reproducing the discussion about the timing problem on this forum from a year or so back for your and other students' benefit.
First though in direct answer to what you have asked: You could as you say, take 7 months + 5 months of the income statement but for assets and liabilities you would need to use the latest quarterly balance sheet which more than likely will be unaudited. So you would need to explain the limitations of your approach in Part 2 and again in Part 3 in any places relevant to your analysis.
This was a comment from OBU on the problem you are focusing on:
"If students choose companies and comparators that do not have similar financial year ends, that is no problem and students will not be penalised for such a decision. However the process of comparing unlike time periods has to be addressed correctly.
Pro-rating is one technique for making accounting periods comparable. Students will need to consider the limitations of such techniques, of course, especially if the company's activity is seasonal. For example: Were the additional months during a period of relatively high or low annual activity?" End of quote
So what this means is that you must address the difference in your limitations section and also in your analysis. Somewhere on one of my posts I mentioned that it was important if using retail companies that the accounts should cover the same Christmas and New Year periods as that is the busiest period in terms of turnover.
With an airline again it may be relevant here. Probably not much of a problem if one has a year end in Sept and the other Dec for European airlines as they will both have covered the main holiday season from June through to September. However if one was July and the other Dec this again would have to be accounted for as in this case the first airline would only be including part of the most recent summer turnover in their results whereas the the second company would have included the whole season. (Not much of a problem either if one is Dec and the other March as again they would have both included the same Christmas period).
It is a case of thinking about whether the companies you use are affected by this or any other significant factors. Companies such as mobile phone operators would probably not be much affected by seasonal sales (normally there are no seasonal factors that make people change their tariff just a bit of extra activity in handset sales leading up to Christmas perhaps). However if you think rationally about these companies there could be other factors that would impact e.g. the latest iphone could see a huge jump in their revenue - but this will impact on their current year figures mainly so would not come into play until the year end 2014 FSs are released (so this will be a factor for anyone possibly submitting a RAP for a mobile operator in P30. (End of earlier discussion)
If you have been following my posts @stevr and reading my articles you may have noticed that I stress that to pass the RAP for T8 a student needs to focus on the business context and use this to guide their evaluation. I have also made the comment that most students who undertake T8 are under the misapprehensIon that this topic is about ratio analysis which it most certainly is not (which is why it only has an average pass rate and few students in recent periods ever got an A and why I would put a weighting of about 10 to 20% [max] on the actual ratios to the rest of the business and financial analysis). If however students looked at company strategies and the inter-relationships in the ratios (e.g. increased gearing may be part of a capital expansion strategy to actually bring future greater returns to shareholders) rather than just trotting out graphs, ratios and routine comments they would fare a lot better.
I end by re-iterating the OBU comment "If students choose companies and comparators that do not have similar financial year ends, that is no problem and students will not be penalised for such a decision" - and I would add PROVIDED THEY DO A SENSIBLE EVALUATION BASED ON AVAILABLE INFORMATION
Thanks ma I get it now God bless u . u are great now I can breath thanks
Thanks again I wish u were mentor but all the same thank u ma. Still have questions when u say I use ur quote
However the process of comparing unlike time periods has to be addressed correct
Do u mean that I have to address the fact that there is a time difference in my part 2& 3in my rap
Thanks again ma u are great stay blessed
Hello Trephena,
My main company a large bank is listed on the local stock exchange while the comparator i chose also a large bank and my main companys biggest competitor is not listed on the local stock exchange. Is this going to be a big problem in comparing the two. other banks listed on the local stock exchange are very small and cannot be reasonably compared with my main company.
kindly help with this.
Thanks in advance
Hello ma I got a mail from obu that I have to porate my financial statements. So now just want to be on a safe side on how it works.
You said is OK if I use 7 months and 5 mon months for the income statement now do I have to porate the financial position. If yes how will I go abt. This really making me tense.
The yea end for main company is may
While comparator is December
Thanks ma
If the main company has a May year end, use June 2012 - May 2015. Not so sure it really is necessary or really going to work for the comparator but 7/12 of one income statement and 5/12 of the next for the comparator from 2012 onwards . ( So for 2015 you would need to use 5/6 of the half year unaudited).You can do the prorating on a spreadsheet. For thebalance sheet the easiest thing is to take the latest half year unaudited balance sheet for 2015 and the 2013 &2014 Year end balance sheets. And you will need to explain what you have done and why.
(All a a bit dreadfully messy and I am not convinced of its overall worth as a good application of the SWOT and PEST and linking the business analysis to the financial performance are of far greater importance in getting a pass grade. But it's your RAP so your choice in deciding what to do).
I have copied the mail for to see ma thanks God bless you
Dear Steve,
Thank you for your email.
There is no problem in using different year ends, and as you have noted you will have to use some some of pro-rata technique to resolve this.
These are techniques that you should have learned in your ACCA training.
Kind regards,
John Scholefield
Programme Administrator
ACCA BSc (Hons) in Applied Accounting Office
Oxford Brookes University, Faculty of Business
Room E109, Wheatley Campus, Wheatley
Oxford OX33 1HX, UK
Mr Scholefield is a senior and respected Administrator on the OBU RAP programme. However at the same time my moderator contact has told me that as long as the latest financial statements in this case those for YE May 2015 were used, they would accept the comparator statements for Dec 2014 provided the businesses were not seasonal . They would expect some mention of the date difference along with any other factors that might explain differences in the statements themselves (possibly different treatments like depreciation policies foe example) to be set out in the Limitations Section
For graphs it would be possible to show trend lines from June 2012 to May 2015 and for Jan 2012 to Dec 2014 on the same graph with a different colour line for each company as it is usually the trends in the data (year on year increases) and therefore the steepness of the curve that are important and the reasons lying behind these trends that need to be discussed in the evaluation.
@dorothyk - the main problem could be the availability of the financial statements. Whereas extracts are acceptable for listed companies as the marker can go to the main website if need be, you may have to provide the full statements for the unlisted companies. There may in this case be a problem with file size so suggest before you start your work you scan them and check the file size against the submission limits (details in the Information pack) first
Thanks ma again for answering my question however they latest information is not available which is 2015 because main company just published its account but comparator company account is not out yet so that leaves me with using 2014 statement.
Since I will be using 2014 statement I think is appropriate to porate ma.
Thanks ma
Dear Trephena,
Thanks for your prompt feedback. So are you saying that it is okay for me to use a non listed company as a comparator for a listed one? they both have a big market share and are by all means head to head in competition.
I would really appreciate your clarification on this key issue.
Best regards,
dorothyk the problem is not the unlisted/ listed issue but the availability of the Information both for you to work with and to provide to the marker (the logistics of providing it). How do you propose to acquire the unlisted company financial statements? You MUST be able to do a decent comparison so you need good data sources for this and the marker will in the absence of being able to go to the unlisted company investor relations website need detailed financial statements.
If using these companies you would only be able to discuss the EPS and share price for the main company so you would need to explain this in both your limitations section and in the investor ratio section.
Good morning,
How about using information made available in June while FY for the 3-year period ended March?
Tnx
Hi everyone,
I also have a quick question in relation to my resubmission for period 31. The reason for not passing mentioned in the mark sheet was mainly lack of referencing.
The comparator company has a year-end different to the main company. The 2015 annual report as at 30 June 2015 is available for the comparator. However, the year-end of main company is December and only the half yearly unaudited accounts are available as at 30 June 2015.
In this situation which of the following option is acceptable to OBU:
Option 1: To ignore these financial statements and do not change the analysis which I have already performed in my Thesis, i.e., December 2014 Annual Report of main Company and June 2014 Annual Report of comparator. However, only insert an explanation in the
limitation of information gathering section in the RAP and focus on the referencing only.
Option 2: To use the June 2015 annual report of comparator against the December 2014 annual report of main company and insert an explanation in the limitation of information gathering section in the RAP.
Option 3: To use the June 2015 annual report of comparator against the half yearly unaudited accounts of main company as at 30 June 2015. However, it will lead to increased complexity as six months financial statements of main company will not be comparable to competitor.
Do I have to change the whole analysis?
Your suggestions are highly appreciated.
Hi, i need guidance. I have faild my RR which was based on topic 8. Now i am inteded to resubmit the revised RR but there is issue with financial statememts of the companies i used for project. I choose toyota as my target company and honda as comprator, this year honda prepared its fs according to ifrs but previous year fs have been prepared on the basis of US Gaap. Toyota still follows the US GAAP. Honda fs changed from previous year even previous year results also changed. Please guide how i should tackle this situation.
Hi there @twinkle7
I suggest you go with Option 2 and explain well both in the limitations section and the analysis about your choice. If you only failed on Referencing see my article on this (all 3 parts) and also the Evaluation & Analysis article (all on our homepage www.opentuition.com/obu )
The Learning Luminarium tutors have also produced an excellent article on why students fail which is well worth reading.
https://learningluminarium.com/2015/07/03/5-main-reasons-failure/
Read and apply all of this sound advice and also read The Resubmission statement - why a good one is your key to success (also on the homepage) and you will be well on the way to succeeding next time :-)
Dear Trephena, I do apologise for asking another question regarding financial year ends. My main company has FY in September whereas my comparator has FY in March.
The latest statements for my main company is September 2014 whereas my comparator has their March 2015 statements filed. Am I to do my comparison of Sep 2014 with Mar 2015 or should I keep the FY dates the same with 2014 and 2014; 2013 and 2013 etc. I understand this will have to be in my limitations regardless.
@rebecca2 - it is a similar case to the ones above. Always go with the latest for the main company and the nearest most appropriate for the comparator. Personally I would go with the latest of both companies. You can usually construct the bar charts so that the labels under the columns show the dates and with line graphs you could offset them on the x axis (it is the trend and slope of the lines that are the important things).
Remember the comparator is there to put your main company in a business context and anything that would affect the validity of this comparison needs to be explained. Normally the six month gap is not a major problem unless the businesses are seasonal or something material has happened in the business environment of just one of them e.g. the FTSE was just steadily rising between Sep 2014 and Mar 2015 so not a problem if you are using UK companies and making comparisons during this period. However it has fallen considerably since so the PE ratio for the main company in Sep 2015 could not be fairly compared with the comparator's in Mar 2015.
@asad010 - sorry I missed your query as I was on holiday. This is a bit difficult for me to answer as I don't know how significant the differences are. The good news is that your main company is still consistently using US GAAP. It all depends on how great the effect of the change from US GAAP to IFRS has impacted on Honda's figures and which results have specifically been affected. Where it is only one year I think you could still probably justify using the same companies as you used them for your first submission as long as your explain all of this in your limitations section and also point out if the change of the basis has compromised the validity of any particular comparisons.
Dear trephena, im re submitting my research for november submission . my problem is, my main company s year end is june 2015 where as my comperator is september. I will use the most recent for my company that is 3 years to june 2015. Whats the best option for my comperator can i use 3 years to september 2014 ?
@trephena - many thanks for your helpful reply! I have started my analysis using both companies latest statements, I just wanted to check before I continued :-) I'm just having a little trouble working out how best to construct my graphs so the labeling is clear but not overloaded. I have included the issue of the six months gap in my limitations section.
@rebecca2 - if there is a problem with putting both companies on the same graph you may be able to insert them so that they are side by side or underneath each other. It is important that you label graphs correctly and that includes ensuring that the currency and / or units are correct.
It is important too that you analyse your comparator in the same section as the main company rather than going through all the ratios for the main company and then doing them for the comparator in a separate section.
Hi Trephana,
Am faced with a scenario where by the cashflow statements of my two chosen companies (banks) are prepared in two different methods.
One has used the direct method and other indirect method.
This has paused a problem to me as am failing on how to lay them side by side in my appendix - Cashflow Statements.
Their financial year end is the same.
What should I do?
I have chosen a company with year end 31 Dec. While the comparator has year end of 30 Sep. I want to know if I would be able to compare these two companies for T8 effectively. When will annual report 2015 will be available for the company with year end 30 Sep.
PS: Both are UK based companies with Euro as reporting currency.?
Any response would be highly appreciated.
@joeackim - this is a small part of T8 and you should not fret too much about it. Mention it in the limitations and discuss in your evaluation why they each may have favoured a different method. This discussion in fact gives you an opportunity to introduce critical thought a key ingredient to achieve a pass
@trephena - thank you for the advice above. Regarding graphs, do you suggest having one for the main company and then another for the comparison between main company and competitor? Due to word constraints and fear of repetition, I am leaning towards only having the one comparative graph?
Also, for T8 do you have to include any work on cash flows? For example, I have used dividends paid from the cash flows but have not analysed anything from the cash flow specifically, e.g increase over the three year period in financing activities is due to.. etc
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

