Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FMPaper F9 Dec 2010 exam was

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share your comments about F9 exam!    
Jjay1415y ago#181
how did u have time to calculate your marks in the exam hall or are the answers out in ACCA Website?????????????
Former userFormer user15y ago#182
I just messed up my cost of debt question....
[li]NPV was negative around 720000[/li]
[li]I think the cost of 5000 buffer inventory was a common cost in the decision so it should be ignored[/li]
[li]200M fund can be raised by Right issue and i suggested Load notes secured as they had good fixed assets. Management of Working Capital can also release some cash and some fund as it was like 211 Million in current assets....[/li]
[li]Asset beta was something 1.2 i guess and after Regearing it was like 1.443 i guess a little highter......[/li]
Quote:
Just i got confused in calculating Net asset value and cost of debt in that question. Can anybody tell me the formula to calculate Net Asset value ?
Former userFormer user15y ago#183
Where was risk management and forex? None of it, mmm...in general it wasn't too bad... I liked the Q on project specific discount rate, very straightforward, and the Investment Appraisal Q was well structured. Q3 too much on receivables though! I thought there was going to be less discussion points but don't complain about it.
Former userFormer user15y ago#184
i'm not sure about the question---factors influence dividend policy.who know?
Ccarriebradshaw15y ago#185
@aasdias said:
Can any one tell me whether we need no consider WIC recovery in yr 4? I ws confused with Director's comment & did not consider it.
I'm not an expert - but I included the working capital because the director said he didn't - that didn't make right! I said that if the working capital remained in the project it would not give the correct npv,as the wc is still in and not a true reflection of the value of the project- I took out wc in year 4 and i rejected the projected. I'm not sure if thats right but thats what i did :)
Former userFormer user15y ago#186
eaze one and i m happy.
But not pleased with examiner as some topics like heding, forex, interest rates, etc were not even touched in the paper.
this kind of skewed papers are not appreciated.
rest is cool
Former userFormer user15y ago#187
What was the WACC
Former userFormer user15y ago#188
I think that this paper was a good one!!!.....I'm jus hopin that the marker isn't too harsh!!!
Ddurax15y ago#189
@april15 said:
i'm not sure about the question---factors influence dividend policy.who know?


Factors should be market imperfections- tax position of investors and potential market reaction to dividend policy.
Former userFormer user15y ago#190
yep f9 was fair, lets wait en see
Former userFormer user15y ago#191
Hi Ladies and Gentle men, I have been following comments on this year's F9 exam papers. I agree with most of the suggestions taht have been uploaded. To be fair, the paper it self was not very difficult from my personal point of view. I though I made enough preparation for the paper. But when the exam was finished I came out from the exam hall guted. Time was so short in relation to the questions asked. I could not put the things I know because of time. Especially Q2 ( the 15 marks) was a kind of open question. The have no idea what the examiner has wanted. If it was not for time, I could have kept on writing ...,
Sseacoral0315y ago#192
Saad009-is it Q1 you get the Negative NPV??
Sseacoral0315y ago#193
Saad009-is it Q1 you get the Negative NPV??
Sseacoral0315y ago#194
@saad0090 said:
lengthy bt easy paper! :)

negative npv scared me fr a while!


Is it negative NPV???
Ssabrina194215y ago#195
@adhina1acca said:
Hi Ladies and Gentle men, I have been following comments on this year's F9 exam papers. I agree with most of the suggestions that have been uploaded. To be fair, the paper it self was not very difficult from my personal point of view. I though I made enough preparation for the paper. But when the exam was finished I came out from the exam hall gutted. Time was so short in relation to the questions asked. I could not put the things I know because of time. Especially Q2 ( the 15 marks) was a kind of open question. The have no idea what the examiner has wanted. If it was not for time, I could have kept on writing ...,


Have to agree with you adhina1acca The paper was not so difficult but very time consuming.
Former userFormer user15y ago#196
I got -ve NPV as well. It scared me of course, especially when there was no working capital to claim back at the end of years 4.
Ttripo3m15y ago#197
i think paper f(7,8 & 9) where all fair, very passable, it just demands on how much time one did the revisions and Exam Techniques, otherwise the papers were very fair.
Former userFormer user15y ago#198
Hi all,

Can somebody tell me when the exam results are released?
Former userFormer user15y ago#199
Hi All; my take about this December 2010 diet on F9 is that the examiner did his job to examine about 85% of the syllabus and ensure that his questions matched the standards required to employers. In terms of the questions we saw in the exams; they are answerable but needs high thinking and lots of practice before 9th December 2010.
Ssosh215y ago#200
@shane2e said:
Hi all,

Can somebody tell me when the exam results are released?

Exam results are released w/c 21 February 2011.