Please share your comments about F9 exam!
FMPaper F9 Dec 2010 exam was
I took the wrong general inflation rate in Q1 but notified it at the end. I inflated the working capital by 5% per annum. got a negative NPV of 64 whcih scared the hell out of me :P
Q2 i sucked i just calculated some ratios and concluded that investment should be partly from equity and partly from debt. else parts went great.
Q3. i concluded no discount should be offered by computations (not sure its correct or not)
Q4. was perfectly done :D
Q2 i sucked i just calculated some ratios and concluded that investment should be partly from equity and partly from debt. else parts went great.
Q3. i concluded no discount should be offered by computations (not sure its correct or not)
Q4. was perfectly done :D
what als remember was the cost of debt
Market value cost
Long term bond 7% 103.5/100*20 =20.7 4.6% * 20*7/54.2 = 1.76
Perference share @ 8% 62/50 .....= 33.5 6% * 33.5/54.2 = 3.71
Kd = 1.76+ 3.71 =5.47
hope i was right :D
Market value cost
Long term bond 7% 103.5/100*20 =20.7 4.6% * 20*7/54.2 = 1.76
Perference share @ 8% 62/50 .....= 33.5 6% * 33.5/54.2 = 3.71
Kd = 1.76+ 3.71 =5.47
hope i was right :D
The npv was around 77 people reckon? Well I got a negative but it was a lot more that that! I calculated roce and payback and although both were outside of the expected return from directors I said that view still may consider if view had nothing else but would be careless to base their decisions on that due to the npv and that The two methods don't take account of future values me money, tax etc...
I got an NPV of -400,000 or so. Way off I presume. Not sure why at all. Thought I had that question down.
I also think I was off with the discount question. My calculations meant they earned quite a lot by giving the 1% discount, due to the 750,000 saving.(have a feeling i dealt incorrectly with this.). I calculated that they could give up to 4.6% discount and still come out on top.
Made a complete balls of the 15 mark q on how to raise the 2 mill. Only had 15 mins to do it.
All in all, easy paper but made a mess of it. Fingers crossed.
I also think I was off with the discount question. My calculations meant they earned quite a lot by giving the 1% discount, due to the 750,000 saving.(have a feeling i dealt incorrectly with this.). I calculated that they could give up to 4.6% discount and still come out on top.
Made a complete balls of the 15 mark q on how to raise the 2 mill. Only had 15 mins to do it.
All in all, easy paper but made a mess of it. Fingers crossed.
@derrickagyiri said:
but when computing ROCE in question one .... we got a 26% return even though a negative npv of (77+)
i loved the evaluation of the $200 million either by debt or equity to me
equity is acceptable because of no dividend payment and gearing
Was it necessary to calculate ROCE for part (b)?
And also regarding 2(a)
The co's debt level was already quite high and its due to repay its bonds in 2012
Also, for the equity part. The q stated that the company has not distributed dividends for the past 4 years so not sure if equity is the exact solution ;)
@derrickagyiri said:
what als remember was the cost of debt
Market value cost
Long term bond 7% 103.5/100*20 =20.7 4.6% * 20*7/54.2 = 1.76
Perference share @ 8% 62/50 .....= 33.5 6% * 33.5/54.2 = 3.71
Kd = 1.76+ 3.71 =5.47
hope i was right :D
Pref shares aren't debt. Think they are a seperate source of capital which should be dealt with seperately - wacc formula had three sections to it.
Cost of debt after my calculations on the irr was 15 if I remember rightly? May be getting percentages confused! I got 10 somewhere, 15 somewhere and I thimj I said wacc was 12.4
4152marky... what i read was that we should analyse the targeted business purchase .,..what does overtrading have to do here ... we are lloking for money to buy a company not looking for business expansion ...
if share holders have a capital gain but was not paid dividend ...they would accept ...something in their investment must increase ...so the funds of $200 million must be raised by equity ... secondly the company had a high equity gearing of 1.12+ so... going for another debt would reduce their PAIT therefore reducing the weath of the shareholder .... this is definateely an equity funded target for $200 million
if share holders have a capital gain but was not paid dividend ...they would accept ...something in their investment must increase ...so the funds of $200 million must be raised by equity ... secondly the company had a high equity gearing of 1.12+ so... going for another debt would reduce their PAIT therefore reducing the weath of the shareholder .... this is definateely an equity funded target for $200 million
razjoee..i feel you on that 1a!!!..u say disaster..i say double disaster!!..apart from that , F9 this diet was good..as it wasnt too abstract..at least one can relate to it...esp if u did try to do some reading..well done acca..more papers like this please...
Can someone help me with the question on the working capital policy on receivables? Is this to do with the way its funded e.g. long tern short term or is it todo with accessing credit checks and chasing the debt?
It was funny the way it was worded. :(
Also the Re-gearing one was the current company funded by 80% debt and 20% equity and the other funded 75% equity and 25% debt? Thanks
It was funny the way it was worded. :(
Also the Re-gearing one was the current company funded by 80% debt and 20% equity and the other funded 75% equity and 25% debt? Thanks
@boscobosco said:
Pref shares aren't debt. Think they are a seperate source of capital which should be dealt with seperately - wacc formula had three sections to it.
Preference shares are categorized as debt, I made a mistake in using par value instead of market value yikes.
@barky said:
Cost of debt after my calculations on the irr was 15 if I remember rightly? May be getting percentages confused! I got 10 somewhere, 15 somewhere and I thimj I said wacc was 12.4
what you are saying is a totally different question ... they asked for the Cost of debt
before the WAAC (cost of capital) which i got 11.56 or 12% for question 4
because the market value = 8.85 *(50m/.05) = 885
The paper was ok...well i mean as compared with Jn 10.. but still i thk correction will be quite strick.... :S :S
Yup... the negative NPV scared me too :S
Yup... the negative NPV scared me too :S
@louibee said:
Can someone help me with the question on the working capital policy on receivables? Is this to do with the way its funded e.g. long tern short term or is it todo with accessing credit checks and chasing the debt?
It was funny the way it was worded. :(
Also the Re-gearing one was the current company funded by 80% debt and 20% equity and the other funded 75% equity and 25% debt? Thanks
I know the factors that we consider the working capital policy are many; example trade credit , trade discounting , foreign exchange , the cash cycle , Cash management technique etc
hope i am right :D
i think its better than June 2010.also i cant remember if working capital in q1 was recoverable at the end of the period.was the debt irr or redeemable.
i think its better than June 2010.also i cant remember if working capital in q1 was recoverable at the end of the period.was the debt irr or redeemable.
please tell me should i have used the 80% 20% for gearing or the MV of target company... :((
i took MV for beta fearing and regearing :(
i took MV for beta fearing and regearing :(
I got 12.4% for WACC.
Pref shares are considered loans, and thus the WACCneeds to be split up into 3 segments- Ve*Ke + Vd*Kd + Vpref*Kpref,
Pref shares are considered loans, and thus the WACCneeds to be split up into 3 segments- Ve*Ke + Vd*Kd + Vpref*Kpref,
Does any one remember what the Kd was? I got someting high like 39% but thought it was a bit exxagerated...
you
you must first change it to beta asset before you factor the MV of the company investing in the new company
Note un-gear the beta equity of the similar company first before you find the equity beta with the current market value of the company investing in the new company
@aliboy9 said:
please tell me should i have used the 80% 20% for gearing or the MV of target company... :((
i took MV for beta fearing and regearing :(
you must first change it to beta asset before you factor the MV of the company investing in the new company
Note un-gear the beta equity of the similar company first before you find the equity beta with the current market value of the company investing in the new company
@derrickagyiri said:
you
you must first change it to beta asset before you factor the MV of the company investing in the new company
Note un-gear the beta equity of the similar company first before you find the equity beta with the current market value of the company investing in the new company
well i did not touch the target companty's % of gearing but used the MV its equity and debt for calculating its Beta asset.
then used it in own company using M.v of our equity and debt
Very straightforward - but time management very important.
@derrickagyiri said:
you
you must first change it to beta asset before you factor the MV of the company investing in the new company
Note un-gear the beta equity of the similar company first before you find the equity beta with the current market value of the company investing in the new company
Is the formula ba = be (e/e+d(1-t) do you use the % of the other company first ??
Then re-gear with the % of the company who is investing with there % then calulate capm?
Degear using comparative company debt and equity market values - with comp company Beta to get business related Beta or asset beta.
Regear using market value of expanding company equity and debt.
Regear using market value of expanding company equity and debt.
Can anyone please tell me what they wrote for the Working Capital Policy in trade receivables? Thanks
39 impossible, it was 4% - 4.23% like that
WACC was 11%
NPV was negative
EOQ was better
Q2 i made a big blinder :( i know ratio very well, but i wrote some thing else :( i wrote the method of raising 200 million :(
WACC was 11%
NPV was negative
EOQ was better
Q2 i made a big blinder :( i know ratio very well, but i wrote some thing else :( i wrote the method of raising 200 million :(
@lordoflords7 said:
Does any one remember what the Kd was? I got someting high like 39% but thought it was a bit exxagerated...
Paper seemed quite fair but the questions were, in my opinion, poorly structured. It must be very difficult if english is not your first language and you have to sit one of these. Just say what you want!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Q2 - I started with pecking order. Disregarded RE as per the question. Looked at Debt determined that gearing had already increased and interest coverage decreased over the past 4 years and currently seemed high although without comps it was hard to know for sure. Said if another 200m was raised at current coupon rate interest cover would be below 1 and gearing over 100% so debt really wasn't an option as even with input from acquired co. liquidity would be critical.
Then looked at rights issue. Saw this as very difficult to sell PAT growth was minimal and there was no divi. Mentioned equity market segmentation theory and that investors looked for high growth or high dividends and shares offering neither would be unlikely to find a buyer.
Concluded they should abandon the takeover attempt.
Then looked at rights issue. Saw this as very difficult to sell PAT growth was minimal and there was no divi. Mentioned equity market segmentation theory and that investors looked for high growth or high dividends and shares offering neither would be unlikely to find a buyer.
Concluded they should abandon the takeover attempt.

