Please share your comments about F9 exam!
FMPaper F9 Dec 2010 exam was
BoscoBosco - Mine would have been of that magnitude also.
louibee,,,,i wrote for my answer to working cap on receivables question,managing accounts receivable, debt collection admin costs, controlling credit to individual customers, extra cap required, additional finance required for increase in volume of accs receivable...... but maybe i read the question wrong..
@boscobosco said:
my EOQ was better by about 20 grand. Too much??
not remember :-s
i have wirtten that using EOQ was better than traditional
My WC receivables answer - had 3 main parts.
External - may be limited by sector and terms of trade offered by others. Mentioned potential loss of revenues from being more strict than competition.
Internal - management of accounts receivable and credit giving process
Financing - cost of funding, discounting for early payment, use of factors and use of invoice discounting if available.
External - may be limited by sector and terms of trade offered by others. Mentioned potential loss of revenues from being more strict than competition.
Internal - management of accounts receivable and credit giving process
Financing - cost of funding, discounting for early payment, use of factors and use of invoice discounting if available.
can anyone tell me how much marks would i lose if i recovered the working capital in last year? other working is correct.
secondly that last question.. what did we have to write in that dividend policy question? please do reply quick
secondly that last question.. what did we have to write in that dividend policy question? please do reply quick
i think the paper ws quite easy and passable..i got an npv of (721000)..hope thats correct or evn near to that..and there was no need calculate a roce and payback as that wasnt asked for in part a or (b).those who did that simply wasted their time.directors views were to be discussed in part (:) of the Qs.
also i took a balancing allowance in the last yr and no recovery of Wc as the Qs demanded that.
i got a WACC in the last qs of 11.6%...hope i pass
also i took a balancing allowance in the last yr and no recovery of Wc as the Qs demanded that.
i got a WACC in the last qs of 11.6%...hope i pass
dividend policy is affected by a firms investment policy and financing policy
there are many other factors that affect dividend policy such as its potential impact on share price,competitors policies etc.we could also discuss MM theory.there was a similar req in june 2010 u can see that if u want
there are many other factors that affect dividend policy such as its potential impact on share price,competitors policies etc.we could also discuss MM theory.there was a similar req in june 2010 u can see that if u want
@cuid3 said:
i think the paper ws quite easy and passable..i got an npv of (721000)..hope thats correct or evn near to that..and there was no need calculate a roce and payback as that wasnt asked for in part a or (b).those who did that simply wasted their time.directors views were to be discussed in part (:) of the Qs.
also i took a balancing allowance in the last yr and no recovery of Wc as the Qs demanded that.
i got a WACC in the last qs of 11.6%...hope i pass
As a matter of interest, what discount factor did everyone use for the NPV. I started with 20% as per director, but switched to 10%. Came out with Negative npv of around 400 grand. But it was neg of about 700 with the 20% factor so just interested
Based on past papers getting wc wrong by including recovery will probably only cost you a point. If you come to an incorrect conclusion they'd take another point or too I'd figure.
For dividend policy I included - M&M say it's irrelevant in an ideal world as investors can create their own divi. But this isn't an ideal world. Then discused alternative uses of funds number of +NPV projects available,equity market segmentation, tax treatment of divis for investors, ability to sustain divi and or payout ratio and signaling effects of divi cut.
For dividend policy I included - M&M say it's irrelevant in an ideal world as investors can create their own divi. But this isn't an ideal world. Then discused alternative uses of funds number of +NPV projects available,equity market segmentation, tax treatment of divis for investors, ability to sustain divi and or payout ratio and signaling effects of divi cut.
Q1) NPV negative so reject
Directors comments - wrote about project period being 4 years on all, payback and roce not included tax and cap all.
Beta Asset - get BA from othe companies debt to equity and then re-gear using investing company.
Q2) Raising 200 million did growth on profit etc and explained gearing already high so dont raise via debt as will increase gearing. Int cover also high and this debt would reduce again so risky. Rights issue bring gearing down but more expensive and harder to set-up.
Int on bonds- Lenth taken over the longer then higher int etc
Efficiency - didnt know
Q3) EOQ - Saved around £20k something like £70k with current and £50k with eoq
Receiveables - saved around $860000 and then settlement discount could afford to be upto 3%
JIT - waffled about the benifits i.e no wastage, no cash tied up stock goin out of date
Working capital policy of trade receivables - taked about the way it was funded and the cash managment and about the working capital cycle.
4) DGM and Net asset - got $7.55 per share and then $755 mill for cost
Cost of Debt only calculated for bonds not pref shares
WACC 11.6%
Dividen Policy YIKES didnt chat much about this just said to determine - look at reserves etc see how much is available (prob got 2 marks on this)
Directors comments - wrote about project period being 4 years on all, payback and roce not included tax and cap all.
Beta Asset - get BA from othe companies debt to equity and then re-gear using investing company.
Q2) Raising 200 million did growth on profit etc and explained gearing already high so dont raise via debt as will increase gearing. Int cover also high and this debt would reduce again so risky. Rights issue bring gearing down but more expensive and harder to set-up.
Int on bonds- Lenth taken over the longer then higher int etc
Efficiency - didnt know
Q3) EOQ - Saved around £20k something like £70k with current and £50k with eoq
Receiveables - saved around $860000 and then settlement discount could afford to be upto 3%
JIT - waffled about the benifits i.e no wastage, no cash tied up stock goin out of date
Working capital policy of trade receivables - taked about the way it was funded and the cash managment and about the working capital cycle.
4) DGM and Net asset - got $7.55 per share and then $755 mill for cost
Cost of Debt only calculated for bonds not pref shares
WACC 11.6%
Dividen Policy YIKES didnt chat much about this just said to determine - look at reserves etc see how much is available (prob got 2 marks on this)
For NPV used the company's cost of capital of 10% as stated in the question. Negative NPV of c.700k+.
and yes eoq was better offering a saving of about 20 grnd more or less dont remmber exactly..and offering a settlement discount was also net beneficial
In question 4 I valued the prefs as a perpetual bond and included them in the WACC.
hope I will get at least 50.I was confused with sale demands in Q1,Q2 wasn't easy.
Agree with bridmw... 10% cost of capital to be usedd...my pv of cashflows was 2779 less initial investment 3500
No fisher needed the cost of capital includes inflation.
@boscobosco said:
As a matter of interest, what discount factor did everyone use for the NPV. I started with 20% as per director, but switched to 10%. Came out with Negative npv of around 400 grand. But it was neg of about 700 with the 20% factor so just interested
I started using 9% that I had calculated using the 2 inflation rates....then I realised they told us it was 10% in the question!
I ended up with a negative NPV of 2.7m or something ridiculous. I must have majorly messed up on one part of it but the majority of it seemed right so I wont worry too much
Can anyone remember how much the discounting of receivables calculation was worth? I think I may have lost a couple of points here.
no fisher affect the stated cost of capital was already in nominal terms
Was it ok to do npv calculation to nearest thousand? Not sure why i did it like that, panicked a bit i think. Anyway, was gonna change it half way through but didn't have time.
@cuid3 said:
no fisher affect the stated cost of capital was already in nominal terms
when we say something is at nominal term = real terms and the computation added inflation ... there was a general inflation with must be factored in the computation.... if i may ask , which question are you referring ... i am referring to q1
Q 1 the cost of capital was in nominal terms therefore it already includes inflation. If it had been given in real terms we would have had to use the Fisher equation to figure out the nominal cost of capital.
i have used 10% as discount rate for NPV, am i OK na? i got negative NPV
did anyone write the answer to efficiency, ........weakform, semi strong form and strong form efficiency pls reply!
What did anyone do when it asked for the cost of debt? Did you jusy do the bonds or pref shares aswell???

