Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FMPaper F9 Dec 2010 exam was

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share your comments about F9 exam!    
Former userFormer user15y ago#91
@miniclaire said:
did anyone write the answer to efficiency, ........weakform, semi strong form and strong form efficiency pls reply!

yep, thats it
HHandsome15y ago#92
For Question 4 part B i used only Bonds, For WACC i used both

@louibee said:
What did anyone do when it asked for the cost of debt? Did you jusy do the bonds or pref shares aswell???
Former userFormer user15y ago#93
@louibee said:
What did anyone do when it asked for the cost of debt? Did you jusy do the bonds or pref shares aswell???


this is what i did

what als remember was the cost of debt
Market value cost
Long term bond 7% 103.5/100*20 =20.7 4.6% * 20*7/54.2 = 1.76

Perference share @ 8% 62/50 …..= 33.5 6% * 33.5/54.2 = 3.71

Kd = 1.76+ 3.71 =5.47

hope i was right :D
Aaahmad5515y ago#94
confused and doing mitake and mitake cutting and overriting because first time f9 my be very pressure on me
Former userFormer user15y ago#95
Q1) I got negative of around $700000 too, part b i talked about the disadvantages and advantages of payback period and ROCE. and part C i got aroung 12% cost of capital.

Q2) messed up, didnt know what to write so talked about equity finance and debt finacne and various calcs. part b i just guessed about lenght time off bond, amount of bond ect, part c i talked about Weak, semi strong and strong form? - not sure if correct?

Q3) i got aroung 20000 saving too which was a EOQ of 5000 instead 16000,
Discount i got something like $500000 better off to take discount as...

Current Rec 1.8m * 5.5% was 990000

With discount i worked it out as 25% of total sales something like 21.8m * 0.01 which was 218000 cost of discount less the benefit of 700000 or so being the 500000 better off as the overdraft int of 990000 remained payable even with discount?

and got around 3% as max disocunt.

part c i talked about Creditworthiness, credit limits, checks, reviews ect but think this is wrong?

Q4. part a i got around $700 million value, but with the net asset i got $94 mill?
Concerned why it was so big diff?

Part b- i got cost of Loan at arounf 4% using IRR, and aroung 11% for the pref as i did the 8%(Value per q)/MV (think about 67?),

Part C - I got around 11% total i think, got a total MV of aroung 880million?

Part d - didnt have a clue
Llouibee15y ago#96
@handsome said:
For Question 4 part B i used only Bonds, For WACC i used both

Yeah same for me thats what i did. Some people did both it that wrong?
Aaahmad5515y ago#97
confused and doing mitake and mitake cutting and overriting because first time f9 my be very pressure on me
Former userFormer user15y ago#98
@miniclaire said:
did anyone write the answer to efficiency, ........weakform, semi strong form and strong form efficiency pls reply!


yes .. under capital market question
Bbridmw15y ago#99
For cost of debt I just found the discount factor so that the PV of the bond cash flows was equal to the MV of the debt. BUT I included the pref shares in the WACC valued like a perpetual bond ((50 x 0.08)/67) was their current cost.

EMH - 3 forms
Weak - only historic information included in current share prices. Means investor cannot get abnormal profit over the long term from studying past price movements. Empirical evidence show this is true in developed stock markets.
Semi - strong - historic information and all publicly available info included in current share values. No bargains. Implications for analysis and takeovers. Developed markets approach this state according to research.
Strong - all info public and private. Doesn't hold abnormal profit can be made with insider information hence criminal to trade on this in many jurisdictions.
Bbossol15y ago#100
I went first for all written parts in questions... to get some extra easy points...but then... Q4 eh ... there was a problem:(
see u ... F7 is waiting for me
Mmrash15y ago#101
Any Idea on what q2a was all about
HHandsome15y ago#102
It was all abut ratios according to every one. but i has written about the methods to raise the cash :(


@mrash said:
Any Idea on what q2a was all about
Former userFormer user15y ago#103
For Q 1, was it mentioned that the WAC cost of capital was in nominal terms?? I thought it was the after tax cost of 10%? I dont remember it saying nominal... Can anyone clarify?
Bbridmw15y ago#104
I think it was a discussion on whether the company could/should raise the money via debt or equity. It was a discussion question that needed gearing and interest cover ratios as well as EPS and dividend information to answer it well. IMO.
Former userFormer user15y ago#105
Except Q2 rest of questions are straight forward n easy...inshallah will pass
Bbridmw15y ago#106
@soba said:
Except Q2 rest of questions are straight forward n easy...inshallah will pass


Why was question 2 difficult?

All praise the giant spaghetti monster and praise his wonderful pastaness.
Former userFormer user15y ago#107
it was ok i guess, got a negative npv in question 1 though but overall questions 1 and 4 was ok . question 3 i pulled through, question 2 (b and c) ok part a OMG i wrote smeting dont no if it was correct should get a mark for writing nd not boring d examiner
Former userFormer user15y ago#108
oh my god - A LOT of writing!! felt like my arm was going to break..

for Q2 - did anyone else write that they should first use their retained earnings to reduce the overdraft?? or was I talking complete rubbish..??
Bbridmw15y ago#109
@carolecreg said:
oh my god - A LOT of writing!! felt like my arm was going to break..

for Q2 - did anyone else write that they should first use their retained earnings to reduce the overdraft?? or was I talking complete rubbish..??


BS I'm afraid RE aren't cash, so can't be used in this manner. I think the question stated that the current assets didn't include a cash balance.
Former userFormer user15y ago#110
damn!!! yep - I think it did say that.. gutted!!!! hope I waffled enough to pick up marks elsewhere then..
thanks!! :)
Former userFormer user15y ago#111
q1- npv was (-700+) something. cost of capital 12.* something.

q2- (a)discussion part abt takeover, (b)bond interest rate- yield curve normal and inverse, (c)effiency weak semi strong and strong.

q3- eoq 5000units, there was saving using eoq.

q4- value of company $755m. net assets around $900m used market value of pref debt, bonds and ordinary shares and added all the other equity.
cost of debt 5.47%, wacc 11% or 12%
Bbridmw15y ago#112
@saadshakil said:
q1- npv was (-700+) something. cost of capital 12.* something.

q2- (a)discussion part abt takeover, (b)bond interest rate- yield curve normal and inverse, (c)effiency weak semi strong and strong.

q3- eoq 5000units, there was saving using eoq.

q4- value of company $755m. net assets around $900m used market value of pref debt, bonds and ordinary shares and added all the other equity.
cost of debt 5.47%, wacc 11% or 12%


Do you think you passed?
Former userFormer user15y ago#113
left 16 marks compeletely blank!! 10 marks of dividend policy and 6 marks of giving early settlement discount.. if other calculations are correct then i hope i can pass
Former userFormer user15y ago#114
I actually want foreingn exchange to come, i understand it really well now, Anyways, it was an ok paper. Q 1 had me puzzled tho but i got negative npv too. I hope ah pass. Prepin for F7
00500896715y ago#115
Question 1, please someone tell me if this was correct...
I worked out the inflated values of SP-SC for the first 4 years, then did the same for the VC using the other inflation rate as specified.
Took those figures as contribution per unit and multiplied by the 750000 for each year to get the income for yr 1 - 4.
Credit of 250k in yr0 for working capital, worked out what inflation on 250k was at 4.5% for each year and credited each year with the differences. Originally used the DF of 20%, but redone the entire question as also forgot tax!!
I didn't claim the working capital back in the end, thought that is what was requested. Overall got around neg 740k NPV

part b, discussed how payback is a crude evaluation suitable for screening out projects, ignores cash flow outside payback period. ROCE better but includes non relevant cash flow and ignores timing and time value of cash flows.

Q2
Can't remember the first part. JIT was easy.

Q3
For the raising of 200m, I suggested sale and lease back of the 300m NCA. Also tackling of the overdraft with its huge interest and on demand risk. Payables days was very short so discuss extending or making use of longer credit period.
Rights issue and offering to public but wary of dilution of control from insitutional investors.

Market efficiency, mentioned weak, semi strong and strong efficiency

Q4
Got a Kd = 3% from doing IRR
WACC = 11.4%
Ke = 12% as stated
vd: think was 52.4m
ve: around 830m

For receivables management wherever that was, discussed credit analysis, credit management and credit collection and use of debt factors.

Hope for at least 50!
HHandsome15y ago#116
You are the second one after me who said that you have written the methods of raising 200m, Where every one saying that the question related to ratio

i have written over draft, long term loan, right issue, etc
@05008967 said:
Question 1, please someone tell me if this was correct...
I worked out the inflated values of SP-SC for the first 4 years, then did the same for the VC using the other inflation rate as specified.
Took those figures as contribution per unit and multiplied by the 750000 for each year to get the income for yr 1 - 4.
Credit of 250k in yr0 for working capital, worked out what inflation on 250k was at 4.5% for each year and credited each year with the differences. Originally used the DF of 20%, but redone the entire question as also forgot tax!!
I didn't claim the working capital back in the end, thought that is what was requested. Overall got around neg 740k NPV

part b, discussed how payback is a crude evaluation suitable for screening out projects, ignores cash flow outside payback period. ROCE better but includes non relevant cash flow and ignores timing and time value of cash flows.

Q2
Can't remember the first part. JIT was easy.

Q3
For the raising of 200m, I suggested sale and lease back of the 300m NCA. Also tackling of the overdraft with its huge interest and on demand risk. Payables days was very short so discuss extending or making use of longer credit period.
Rights issue and offering to public but wary of dilution of control from insitutional investors.

Market efficiency, mentioned weak, semi strong and strong efficiency

Q4
Got a Kd = 3% from doing IRR
WACC = 11.4%
Ke = 12% as stated
vd: think was 52.4m
ve: around 830m

For receivables management wherever that was, discussed credit analysis, credit management and credit collection and use of debt factors.

Hope for at least 50!
Former userFormer user15y ago#117
it was easy but tricky. I will surely pass this.
00500896715y ago#118
I threw in roce for the current year and also the trade payables days but couldnt really put too much into it as there was no balance sheet figs for previous year for comparison. Hopefully there will be marks available for non ratio as it was still analysis and evaluation. I love ratio analysis, and would have preferred a different question :)

@handsome said:
You are the second one after me who said that you have written the methods of raising 200m, Where every one saying that the question related to ratio

i have written over draft, long term loan, right issue, etc
HHandsome15y ago#119
Ratio analysis is one of my fav topic too but i did not understand the question in exam and start writing the method of raising cash :(

i wish there would be hedging question
@05008967 said:
I threw in roce for the current year and also the trade payables days but couldnt really put too much into it as there was no balance sheet figs for previous year for comparison. Hopefully there will be marks available for non ratio as it was still analysis and evaluation. I love ratio analysis, and would have preferred a different question :)
00500896715y ago#120
I am sure the question did ask you to discuss methods that could be undertaken to raise the money required, so i think we are ok. half marks at least! F7 next week, awful.


@handsome said:
Ratio analysis is one of my fav topic too but i did not understand the question in exam and start writing the method of raising cash :(

i wish there would be hedging question