Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

LWPaper F4 Dec 2010 exam was

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share below with community your comments about F4 exam!

Take our F4 exam survey >>


Vote in our instant poll!
Paper F4 Dec 2010 exam was poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#91
Attempted f4 global!
my ppr was DISASTER!!
m jus sure abt 3 ans...q.3..q.6....n q.8!
wat was da last questn abt?? i jus wrote ALL i knew abt partnershp!! had no odr choiceL:-(!
n cn we pass if we right somthn jus relevnt to the questn?? cz i seriously need 2 pass!
Ssoniasameersohail15y ago#92
in question 8 i wrote abt intention to create legal relations..in case of ben the idea of other relations would apply and incase of chee i applied the concept of other domestic arrangement cuz i thut that chee was her friend..bth were liable to pay back..i also included the concept of service that they had asked for service and therefore they are liable to pay...its one of the exceptions to past consideration...

in question 9 i came up with the leftover profit of pound 1000..and so the distribution of total pound 4000 wasnt valid as it was a public limited company..in part two of the question i discussed the concepts that net assets should be more than issued capital and undistributed reserves....so lets c how much i score...

in question 10 i distributed the leftover 10000 to the partners..they had to forego the rest of their capital..

in economic financial liability of tort, i wrote abt volenti non fit injuria and contributory negligence..i think this is compeletely wrong..i shud have instead written abt but for test...but as they had asked for the liability, i concluded they meant remedies if losses are incurred....
Ssoniasameersohail15y ago#93
when can we get the answers from professionals?? and dont u people think that the results wud come out too late..they shudve been announced by mid jan..its soo unfair!!!
Former userFormer user15y ago#94
@morpher999 said:
Well. Think is was ok overall. Didn't revise unfair dismissal but knew about remedy.

Just some little precisions:

Primary legislation = parliamentary legislation (or does that include case law as well?)
Question 8, Was it about promissory estoppel or intentions to create legal relations. Not sure.

For the last question, didn;t understand anything. i do know some of the means of partnership disolution but the financial effect of it, nope.

Overall, i do believe it was a fair paper.



Well, I think it's a mixture of both!Here is my answer:
There is definitely a contract between both BEN,AMY AN CHE, however not legally binding for all..
First, there is an intention to create a legal relationship-one family agreement(ben) and the other commercial agreement(Che)..thus not legally binding for ben and legally binding for Che..then, comes promissory estoppel, which allows a person to recover on a promise already made to her if she already acted upon it..therefore, Amy can recover part of the consideration of 1000pounds from Ben..and full amount from Che..(that's my answers..but well for che am not sure if it's really commercial^^')...now hope most of my answers are correct!Any suggestions?..
Former userFormer user15y ago#95
@ailine_ng said:
Well, I think it's a mixture of both!Here is my answer:
There is definitely a contract between both BEN,AMY AN CHE, however not legally binding for all..
First, there is an intention to create a legal relationship-one family agreement(ben) and the other commercial agreement(Che)..thus not legally binding for ben and legally binding for Che..then, comes promissory estoppel, which allows a person to recover on a promise already made to her if she already acted upon it..therefore, Amy can recover part of the consideration of 1000pounds from Ben..and full amount from Che..(that's my answers..but well for che am not sure if it's really commercial^^')...now hope most of my answers are correct!Any suggestions?..


With regards to intention, it is a presumption of no intention between family members but it is rebuttable. I think that both Ben and Che (he may be a friend, but the work was done for his business - commercial) have to pay the full amount, but with this question you will get marks either way as a judge could decide either way.

With regards to promissory estoppel, isn't that only relevant when one party acted on a promise that they hadn't supported with consideration? Amy provided consideration by carrying out the design work, I think it was just a simple contract.
Ddianaa15y ago#96
hi kuzma2

how much did you managed to do last times, when took under 5?

I have mistaken the question with arbitration panel, registers and constitution.
in rest I have written quite well..don t know if enough

i dont know how to evaluate what i have done
Former userFormer user15y ago#97
People seem to be mistaken about Q8. Amy provided a professional service for both Ben and Che. The fact that they were related and friends is irrelevant. If you remember, the question stated that "Amy updated their BUSINESS websites". Thus this is a commercial relationship, the question wanted you to fall into the trap of suggesting no legal intention is not presumed (which you would have received at least a mark for). I don’t know where people are getting promissory estoppel from; the contract was updating the website for £1000, its simply a contract. All in all this question had a chance to gather a lot of marks; explaining what a contract is, what elements a contract needs, the legal intention presumption and the fact it can be rebutted and commercial intention. I expect to do well on this question, the rest of the paper I am unsure about....
Former userFormer user15y ago#98
*legal intention is not presumed
Former userFormer user15y ago#99
Guys
Question 8
was about the intention to create relationship and domestic & commercial contract
Former userFormer user15y ago#100
shaunboro
i completely agree with u that it was a commercial agreement as it expressly showed business reasons for the contracts made.
so it created legal relations. both were bound to pay ammy.
it was truly a examiner's trick to make students feel that these were domestic by showing that these both were brothr and sistr and for other friends....
so 100% sure that it was a commercial agreement...
Former userFormer user15y ago#101
promissory estoppel cant cme. coz in promissory estoppel a person cnt go back on his promise to accept a lesser amount as in central london trust ltd vs high trees house, as never mentioned in question that ammy has promised for accepting lesser amount and any of the condiotons of promissory estoppel. so no promissory estoppel at all.
Former userFormer user15y ago#102
It was overall Fine, but I am very amazed at what silly topics were examined or asked by examiner.. He could have asked more important topics of Law. He left many many important topics... May be they are again trying to bring the pass rate down... Statutory registers' question was amazing, examiner missed an opportunity to ask a discipline question instead. Totally Angry with examiner..
Oolayinkaoh15y ago#103
the paper was nice and i was able to attemp all questions to satisfaction...i only have doubt for question about shares, but if what sizzlin89 said is right then i'm made!
Aalihs15y ago#104
registers a bit unexpected wrote F7 stuff

pre-emption rights?
Former userFormer user15y ago#105
@alihs said:
registers a bit unexpected wrote F7 stuff

pre-emption rights?


These are rights that existing shareholders have..they have rights to be proposed any issue of shares or transfer of shares prior same is proposed to any third parties/public. These are also called sometimes right for first refusal
Ffionaacca15y ago#106
I found the exam intense! i had a lot of knowledge on the questions asked but writing and showing the examiner what i knew to get full marks was hard as time was tight!
There was 1 question which i read and thought 'What!?!' i can't remember reading about this?... it was the preemption shares and therefore i wrote nothing about it, so i decided i'd make more effort in other questions? i really hope i pass as i made a hugh effort to learn and understand this subject. i hope the examiner takes this question into account when marking :( good luck to everyone! Thanks to Mike Little for his Fantastic Lectures! they helped me understand the subjects far better than what is just written in the Text books.
KKwameSupporter15y ago#107
fionaacca, sorry to interrupt but i feel i also had similar problem during the exam. i had lots of knowledge about most of the questions that came up in the exam but to explain myself well to get the full marks. this was not easy for me.
Former userFormer user15y ago#108
fionacca you're correct...

had that problem too of how much we must write to get our points...
Former userFormer user15y ago#109
In general, the paper was easier than expected. The English Legal System question and the Shares question were perfect gifts!!. I think duties of Directors was OK, but I think that question 8 is a clear question on breach of contract and remedies. Question 9 might be malicious as the main element was only implied and appealed to our knowledge of basic accounting principles: dividends are only payable from Profits!!
Former userFormer user15y ago#110
i now i past with 70% are more
Former userFormer user15y ago#111
I have taken the GLOBAL stream, i dont see it to be a balancing paper, the question about "unauthorised payment" is very dissapointing.
IIrfan15y ago#112
it went well was an easy paper.
Mmichael1301199115y ago#113
LOOK ALL....i'm going to be very honest....the paper was the easiest F4 in years...if you had revised proerly question1,2,3,4,5,7, and 8 came in the past. Question 9 even though it did not came in the exact format similar to a past question, it came in a theory question. Question 4 however, even though it did not come in any past sittings (back to 1998) you could have written on it and gain some kind of marks-howevwer bonus issues came in a past sitting ( personally i hated it as it tested a very narrow area of the syllabus-also i could not have given a "perfect answer" in my opinion i.e; around a 7 or 8.

However! we are not all perfect...while question 10 you could have relied on basic knowledge....even though i correctly gived extensive knowledge on relevant partnership law...and said the external debt followed by the loan must be paid firstly and even gaved the proportion of any remaining capital left that would be payable...i though i saw 17000 instead of 7000 and hence in my conclusion i sad that no capital was left to be paid to any partner...clearly not a perfect answer..


MORAL OF THE STORY: we are not all perfect even though we prepare throughtly...(even though i swore i saw 17000) hence...dont beat ya self up...instead learn from your lessions and make sure that you dont repeat your mistakes in your next exams...in the meanwile enjoy the holiday and look foward to making the next session even better and proving your critics and yourself wrong.....
Mmichael1301199115y ago#114
oh and for all those concerned...question 8 was about intention to create legal relations...not pronmissary estoppel or consideration...it was about her brother and friend...domestic/social comes to mind!
Former userFormer user15y ago#115
It is clear and transparent that the F4 GLOBAL was UNFAIR.
Former userFormer user15y ago#116
@didieredmond said:
In general, the paper was easier than expected. The English Legal System question and the Shares question were perfect gifts!!. I think duties of Directors was OK, but I think that question 8 is a clear question on breach of contract and remedies. Question 9 might be malicious as the main element was only implied and appealed to our knowledge of basic accounting principles: dividends are only payable from Profits!!



With question 2 being specifically about breach of contract, I don't think it is likely the examiner would set question 8 on the same topic...
Kksaisonga15y ago#117
I didn't just prepare myself very well, but I attempted all the questions.
Former userFormer user15y ago#118
I wish to pass...! I attempted all the questions, but not that all detailed like the model answers in the Revision Kits.
Former userFormer user15y ago#119
hey guys, abt the breach of contract, how should we have asnwered? breach of a condition? or breach in contract in general? should we have mentioned case of Poussard etc??
for duties of i did not quote any cases =S
q8 was about everything in contract?? any1 can suggest wat should be the answer?
overall fair paper, concentrated too much on corporate though =S
gd luck :)
Former userFormer user15y ago#120
I am planning to have F4 global on June 2011 but I have the BPP study and exercise books of 2008.Is that ok or I have to buy 2011 edition?