Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

LWPaper F4 Dec 2010 exam was

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share below with community your comments about F4 exam!

Take our F4 exam survey >>


Vote in our instant poll!
Paper F4 Dec 2010 exam was poll results
Former userFormer user15y ago#61
In the case of Re McArdle though, didn't she perform improvements to the house, then the siblings said they would pay her for them out of the mother's estate - so it was past. Whereas here Ben and Che said they would pay her £1000 to design for them, and she subsequently did?

With Q10 how did you end up with £50k? As far as I can remember, the remaining net assets of the company were only £20,000, so when the creditors and loan were paid the only capital available to be repaid was £10,000 (in the 5:3:2 ratio)?
Former userFormer user15y ago#62
@ali_zia4u said:
Domestic agreements only exist between spouses (as mention in Kaplan.)


Kaplan Book covers all the questions of this attempt except preEmption rights......


I have never used Kaplan, only BPP. I may consider using Kaplan in the future now.

The impression I got from BPP was that there was a presumption that the parties did not intend to enter into legal relations with domestic arrangements (Balfour v Balfour), with that case concerning a married couple, except where property was concerned but that includes family...

Even though I mentioned this, I concluded that even so they may be considered as business agreements as they were for Ben's and Che's business, not personal use. In that case, as there was no express statement against intention (Rose and Frank v Compton) then intention would be presumed.
Former userFormer user15y ago#63
damn i thought Q 8 is consideration....
HHamza15y ago#64
The paper was as a matter of fact , easy but also kinda lame because certain scoring topics were excluded in this sitting.Overall I hope i'll achieve a border-line pass mark, this was my first ever sitting of this exam and it seems to be going down the drain :(

Dont know why the examiner decided to throw 10 mark Q's at us with virtually nothing to write about , honestly it beats my understanding that why 10 mark questions on statutory documents and issuance of rights, bonus shares were set ?

As far as Q8 is concerned , to me it seemed that two fundamental aspects of contract law were being questioned that is "sufficiency of consideration" and "intention to create legal relations" so I wrote along those lines , which I hope goes down well with the markers.
Former userFormer user15y ago#65
The tutors guess were so not accurate...i was really expecting interpreting statute, veil of incorporation and contents of a contract...Didn't think law of tort was going to come in the exam oh and question number 4 did anyone know about it...
Former userFormer user15y ago#66
i messed the whole thing up!! for the question about amy, i said brother not liable. i just saw the word "brother" and panicked, and said domestic relationship, so not binding and quoted balfour v balfour. then for the friend i quoted simpkin and pays and rose and frank v crompton. for tort, didnt answer properly, i just wrote all about donoghuev stevneson and anns v merton and proximity etc. i also didnt know the registers, i siad members, charges, directors, debentures(but not essential). i wasnt well prepared, and fell and split my head open on ice 2 days before. but no excuse. the only questions i likws were directors duties i think (s171-s177) and unfair dismissal, and a bit of delegated legislation. will def have to repeat. hope everyone does well
Mmask15y ago#67
what are the remedies of breach of contract?

i just wrote Damages (Liquidated & Illequidated - Measurement and Remoteness)

Overall paper was ok. Hope to score 65 marks Insha ALLAH
Bbunkiejm15y ago#68
question 8 is consideration
Former userFormer user15y ago#69
@gracetsiga1 said:
The tutors guess were so not accurate...i was really expecting interpreting statute, veil of incorporation and contents of a contract...Didn't think law of tort was going to come in the exam oh and question number 4 did anyone know about it...

What was question 4 again?
Aali_zia4u15y ago#70
@gracetsiga1 said:
The tutors guess were so not accurate...i was really expecting interpreting statute, veil of incorporation and contents of a contract...Didn't think law of tort was going to come in the exam oh and question number 4 did anyone know about it...

You can find exact answer of Q4 in Kaplan Chapter 3 (The Law of Torts) (Page 74-75, 85-86)
Ssoniasameersohail15y ago#71
i didnt write liquidated damages nd penalty clause in breach of a contract..rest i wrote all including damages, common law remedies nd equitable remedies..how many marks will be deducted
Ssoniasameersohail15y ago#72
i want to appear for f5 and f6 in the coming june 2011..can anyone please tell me what books to go for..ive heard that kaplan is good for calculative paper and bpp for theory..so please tell me if f5 and f6 are based on theory or calculations?? because then ill purchase the books respectively
Former userFormer user15y ago#73
it waas ok but as we know its all abt luck so hope for the best
Former userFormer user15y ago#74
well l tried
Ssoniasameersohail15y ago#75
@soniasameersohail said:
i want to appear for f5 and f6 in the coming june 2011..can anyone please tell me what books to go for..ive heard that kaplan is good for calculative paper and bpp for theory..so please tell me if f5 and f6 are based on theory or calculations?? because then ill purchase the books respectively



help neededdd..so please ppl reply asap
Former userFormer user15y ago#76
Question 7 on unfair dismissal was the easiest for me, I didn't prepare thoroughly so I think I missed quiet a number of easy marks.
Ssabrina194215y ago#77
Hi Can any tell me what was the Partnership Act for Q10.
Ssabrina194215y ago#78
@soniasameersohail said:
help neededdd..so please ppl reply asap


Hi sonia

I finish both F5 & F6 with 1st attempt and the text i used was Bpp
I never tried kaplan cus i heard Bpp was the best.
Ssoniasameersohail15y ago#79
but please tell me which one is theoritical and which one is calculative..f5 or f6??
Former userFormer user15y ago#80
the examiner took aspects of topics that we usually not tend to focus on...for instance, the contracts question, a lot of emphasis went in to elements and not remedies. he brought remedies. d shares question was shitty! the partnership scenario could have been clearer...did it really ask for financial aspect of the settlement?
Former userFormer user15y ago#81
Last 3 questions were easy to answer.......
Ssabrina194215y ago#82
@soniasameersohail said:
but please tell me which one is theoritical and which one is calculative..f5 or f6??


F6 definitely is a calculation, F5 its a bit of both theoretical and calculative. Check the pass papers on the ACCA website u will get an idea on how the paper is structured. I must say that when i wrote F5 i didn’t do any practice question cus its all about application of what you have learned and by all means learn it by heart and u would be successful. U can also go to both Bpp and kaplan site check the content ensure that all area of the study guide is covered.

I must say ACCA recommend both of these text so u shouldn’t go wrong.
Good Luck

So u wrote F4 how was it and i fig u used kaplan text huh
Jjoevassallo15y ago#83
Q8 there seems to be a mixed feeling of what it exactly related to.... consideration, promissory estoppel,acceptance by conduct, intetion to create legal intentions?? who knows?

Does anyone know what exactly it relates to?

I think remedies of breach of contract should cover Damages, Liquidated damages and penalty clauses, Unliquidated damages, remoteness of loss and measure of damages, reliance damages and finally equitable damages. A lot to say for this question -I think it should be worth mmore than 10 marks compared to some others!!.
Ssoniasameersohail15y ago#84
@sabrina1942 said:
F6 definitely is a calculation, F5 its a bit of both theoretical and calculative. Check the pass papers on the ACCA website u will get an idea on how the paper is structured. I must say that when i wrote F5 i didn’t do any practice question cus its all about application of what you have learned and by all means learn it by heart and u would be successful. U can also go to both Bpp and kaplan site check the content ensure that all area of the study guide is covered.

I must say ACCA recommend both of these text so u shouldn’t go wrong.
Good Luck

So u wrote F4 how was it and i fig u used kaplan text huh



thanx sabrina..and i used bpp for f4..i hope to expect atleast 60 percent
Ssabrina194215y ago#85
@joevassallo said:
Q8 there seems to be a mixed feeling of what it exactly related to.... consideration, promissory estoppel,acceptance by conduct, intetion to create legal intentions?? who knows?


Does anyone know what exactly it relates to?

I think remedies of breach of contract should cover Damages, Liquidated damages and penalty clauses, Unliquidated damages, remoteness of loss and measure of damages, reliance damages and finally equitable damages. A lot to say for this question -I think it should be worth mmore than 10 marks compared to some others!!.


Hey Joey Question 8 relates to Intention to create legal relation
and we would have had to differentiate whether it was social/domestic agreement or commercial agreement.
Former userFormer user15y ago#86

Please Help me out Mr. Admin
I hope to see some Comments on this By tutor

I hope to see some From friends to

i think question 8 of the paper f4 was related with the intention to create legal relation ship and with some ideas of consideration be used i suppose the answer will be complete
and refer to question number 9 i think it was the question on capital maintance which included the payment of dividend and restriction in capital reduction
the only thing is that we can't use reserve for the purpose of distributing dividends it is the part of capital and doing may require some special requirements, passing of the Special Resolution, if Model Article Requires so and if courts Approves you to do so, however it may be a requirement for a private company's but this is not allowed for the Public Companies and Strict Rules must be followed, and doing so may have serious consequences. hope so

On question number 5 what accounting record do we need to keep i classified into Statutory requirements and Stake Holders requirements and Mentioned that what accounting records are required to full fill this requirements

on Question number 2
is the breach of Contractual terms Breach of contract ? yes than its ok
no why?
Aali_zia4u15y ago#87
Kaplan is good. I will also take F5 & F6 in June 2011. But i always do self study. F2 exempted June 2010
F3 exempted June 2010
F1 passed 60 marks June 2010
F7 pass 57 marks June 2010
now i take F4 in December 2010

F5 & F6 will take in June 2011

Best of luck for all students for F4.

I request all F4 students that please give your comments on F4 when ACCA will ask about exams after 16 December 2010. ACCA exxaminers always consider these points before exam checking.

Ali Zia
Faisalabad
03338976065
Aali_zia4u15y ago#88
Q9 was related with distributable profits. Only dividend can be paid out of distributable profits.

It also relates with reduction of capital.

Distributable profit includes

Profit (for the year and past years accumulated)
Capital
less Depreciation but revaluation reserves not taken

By aplying above rules

Only *1000 pounds were available for distribution not 4000 pounds.

All directors and shareholders if knowingly involve were gulity of fraud and have to pay back dividend inculding penalty.


*Last year loss 2000
profit ds year 3000
only 1000 pounds available.


But i didnot write about reduction of capital because Capital amount was not available in question. I write only Distribualble profits.

I think examiner will give 5 marks. Hope so
Former userFormer user15y ago#89
Q9 - I did this...ended up with £1000 to distribute as dividend. As it was a PLC, this was illegal, the court is the only place that can authorise a dip in capital. I did mention (accumulated profit - Accumulated losses).
Q8 - I still think was to do with Past Consideration and Re Mc Ardle & Caseys Patents. Also maybe Williams v Roffey as there was a "practicable benefit"?.. Just a guess.
Llunix15y ago#90
Q8 was NOT about past consideration.
Past consideration means that promise to pay was made AFTER the act was done.
Here, clearly, we had a valid contract, and promise to pay was made BEFORE the act was done.
Also, promissory estoppel does not apply here.