Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** P5 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P5 March 2016 Exam.

*** P5 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about P5 exam below
OOlayinka10y ago#61
April 18th
NNikita10y ago#62
extremely time pressured! I chose Q1,2 and 4. The last one was really nice and discussable about PSO. I feel, that another 15-20 minutes would bring more marks to me. Hope to get 50... P5 - extremely challengeble option! don't ever give up, guys!
Former userFormer user10y ago#63
Hi all, I felt really bad after this paper. I'm still feeling bad because last diet, i failed with 47%. This time, I studied really hard and solve lots of questions and read practically all the articles. The answers to the questions I solved were on point, tailored to the scenarios. I was more confidence going into this exam, in fact, i predicted the areas to exam correctly VFM, Performance Pyramid, Building Blocks and Risk. I solved extra questions on these "particular areas" on Tuesday, as if i knew the examiners mind. Alas! it was the most cryptic exam I ever wrote from Paper P1 to P7. At the first glance of the questions, I was like, Bam!!! My oh my!!! I was on the moon...While delving into the scenerio, believe me, I was lost in the process. I answered questions 1,2 & 4. Infact, I hardly had time to pick points in the scenerio. I was reading the requirements every 5mins to ensure I was writing the correct thing. My strategy during the exam was intact, I managed to complete about 65% - 70%. I feel I'm losing confidence in P5.......... I'm pretty felling bad and couldn't help, but frustrated. Can someone tell me, who is the examiner for Paper P5. That guy/lady, I'm so sorry to say this, is a sadist. Yes! some people will pass, but then what skill have we got to learn that was demonstrated in the requirement. Very vague and requires critical thinking to the extent that scared times would have been lost. How can we channel our comments to ACCA with respect to Paper P5? Can we create a forum for P5 students and channel our thoughts about the examiner and his style of questions to the appropriate quarters? Don't get it twisted, I love Performance Management in practice and to study, but this exam really make me look like a "not-too-smart" guy! This is the final paper holding me from being an affiliate. I really need help....... Teskyman!
IImtyaaz10y ago#64
Freestyle paper. Questions seemed easy enough but there is no certainty in providing assessment of scenario. I listened to all of the podcasts available and I found it helped my inner-voice while reasoning with the text given. 1st attempt at this... Still quite optimistic
Former userFormer user10y ago#65
In december exam I scored 46%, did some studies and was coming to this exam more confident. I did Question 1, 2 and 4. I agree with most of the comments that Question 1 was horrible, I did repeat myself a lot and am sure it will not score a lot. I can't understand examiner's approach to this exam, what he wants to achieve with this approach? I understand and agree that accountants have to be able to discuss topics and they application, however I think that he has gone too far with this.
Kkhan.sarfraz10y ago#66
In terms of complaining I think we can email ACCA on this [email protected] and link the forum so they get feedback. In the email express our concern and say we wish for some action to be taken or we are changing the paper not sitting blah blah so at the very least they are aware of our concern. To those who are optimistic about passing, I wish you all the best but please don't think we are whinging...people pay money spend time to be treated fairly, for ACCA to show respect and address students needs and development. Passing this paper will not make you the best accountant nor will it make you ready for the real world. It does not depict reality...passing this paper will please the examiner the most. Out of the ACCA world you'll have to pick up skills and knowledge which ACCA don't teach you. ACCA knowledge gives you the groundwork for better understanding so when you do come across these scenarios you know what is going on even then you'll have to brush up on knowledge unless your very good at memorising. I have been working for a while and I don't even use my knowledge of ACCA to full extent it's not required....I hardly use it in a complex form...that's just reality of commercial working environment...maybe it's different at practices etc but I'm sure the training is more effective than knowledge for passing an exam as your practising constantly. ACCA are there to prepare us and not to ensure we mastered the knowledge techniques before we even learn how to do the job!
Former userFormer user10y ago#67
I sat P5 a couple of times, maybe even three I can't remember. I gave up and tried tax instead thinking it followed more logic. But not working in a tax environment (which the ACCA advises is required to pass that paper) I was unsuccessful in that too. I felt incredibly low about my exams, deciding I wasnt even going to continue. I will be timed out of ACCA in 2017 so have decided to give P5 another go after having a break, hoping things will have changed since I last sat it. Sadly, it looks like things have not changed and the pass rates remain incredibly low. After reading the above comments I already feel disheartened about my June exam - thinking it must be impossible :( :( :(
Former userFormer user10y ago#68
Hamilton001 - I also feel sick about the June exam :(
Kkhan.sarfraz10y ago#69
Exam results will be released week commencing 18 April 2016 For others don't give keep trying!!!!
Former userFormer user10y ago#70
Seemed like a fair paper, but still think I failed again. I know the topics, just not how to answer the questions I think. Maybe I should do P4 instead, I only have one left to go. any thoughts?
CGCrazed Guy10y ago#71
Not to mention... i definitely did all of the open tuition lectures, notes and revision lectures of p5. And the relevant ones of F5 as well.
Nnicki10y ago#72
@cpboon & @busbycat you no longer time out of ACCA, the rules have been changed in the last 6 months to make the qualification more fair to those that start at the beginning. You now have 7 years to pass P papers, the time starts from the 1st P paper you pass, so anything you achieve up to F9 is technically 'safe'. this is from the ACCA website "Under the new rules a seven year time limit will be introduced at the Professional level. Therefore, there are no time limits for passing the Foundation level exams as part of Foundations in Accountancy or for taking exams F1-F9 at the Fundamentals level of the ACCA Qualification. However, we do strongly recommend students take exams on a regular basis as this increases the chances of success. Students will have seven years to pass the exams at Professional level (P1, P2 and P3 and two of the options paper P4-P7). If a student does not pass all the Professional level exams within seven years, they will lose any passes that were achieved more than seven years ago and will need to retake. The seven year time limit starts when a student passes their first Professional level exam."
OOllie10y ago#73
@bhumika I feel the same, my last exam, it was my second sitting of P5, with my other exams I come out reasonably confident I know roughly what sort of mark I will get, have passed the others mostly in first sitting, but P5 is different. I am considering changing to P4 because I just cannot imagine ever coming out of P5 feeling confident even though I have done loads of practice questions, know all of the material etc
Ookuhle10y ago#74
18 April
OOlga10y ago#75
As far as I understand in Q3 (a) it was requested to evaluate the impact of stakeholders analysis (influense, power and risk) ONTO improving of performance management. - YOU don't understand? Read it again, maybe ten times. I still can't understand what I should have evaluated. Waiting for report from examinator with recommendations to answer the question asked. Time pressure was awful.
CGCrazed Guy10y ago#76
i agree about complaining! the acca people should see this forum. I personally feel that there is nothing more one can do than i did for this exam. I read the entire Bpp book, did the entire Becker e-book, read all the technical articles, did all the bpp exam kit questions! and serveral of becker question bank. I did 2 mocks under timed conditions(one the acca study school one) by writing out entire answers, i have never usually had too much time pressure problems in the past. Here i tried my best to finish it in time, but couldn't. I was left devastated and depressed in the end. The only way to finish this was if it was either a 75 mark paper(just a section A question and one section B question) or if we just wrote low quality generic answers. No way on earth could you write high quality answers for all of them. I have obviously failed multiple times before including scores of 48 and 49. How unfair is it to fail someone on 49? What is the difference between a student who gets 49 and one who gets 50? I even fear that students who actually get 50 or above, they just make them go to 49 just so they have to appear again. Arghhh.
Hhelloraj10y ago#77
I think personally that not the paper has some problem,the examiner has some issues.P5 passmark is everytime low.If you are given a syllabus and you know it well then you got to pass it.I have heard that syllabus covers only 30% of the knowledge..so the 70% knowledge is in the nature.Where?Any exact location.Do we have a complete syllabus??? We need to bring this to the attention of ACCA.I highly believe we must do a petition to make the current examiner out.As said above by a fren we cannot be so stupid and dull...passing so much papers and stuck wiz P5The examiner must be questioned..may be he is the problem and not the P5 exam paper.Friends think about it.
Iicedawn10y ago#78
For stakeholder question, if you didnt relate it to the performance prism model, you probably got it all wrong and the answer you delivered would probably fit a p3 question. You guys got 3 pms model in 1 paper lol.. there should have been a balance scorecard to complete the lot..
Former userFormer user10y ago#79
History of pass rates, P5 has by far the lowest pass rate, not only the lowest but in cases 5 or 6% below the next level. ACCA is not CIMA, Dec-15 Lowest 7th 6 % from 6th Sep-15 2nd Lowest 6th 6 % from 5th Jun-15 Lowest 7th 6% from 6th Dec-14 Lowest 7th 3% from 6th Jun-14 Lowest 7th 6% from 6th Dec-13 Lowest 7th 3% from 6th Jun-13 Joint Lowest 7th 3% from 5th Dec-12 Joint 2nd Lowest 6th 11% from 5th Jun-12 2nd Lowest 6th
OOllie10y ago#80
@icedawn does the performance prism link in to risk appetite though, that's the bit I wasn't sure about, the performance prism discusses considering stakeholder satisfaction and capabilities but not so much risk? It was also confusing that it mentions stakeholder interest which seems more mendelows matrix so I used points from the prism (stakeholder satisfaction and strategy) but used matrix more. F••k knows what the examiner wants!
Former userFormer user10y ago#81
So much information for a 25 Mark question
AAndrea10y ago#82
I agree with what everyone is saying about Q1. I think it was very unfair and unclear what he wanted you to do. For this reason I am going to put in a complaint to the ACCA as it is not giving students a fair chance to show him what they know, if they are expected to mind read what he wants. I urge other students to do the same as moaning on here isn't likely to get any changes, but if more than one student expresses their views via a complaint, ACCA are more likely to re-look at the exam.
Sseagoat10y ago#83
Many things can be said about P5 but I won't make huge post about - most of the things have already been said if not here then other posts. Guys I know what you feel. I agree that some of the requirements are cryptic and need to spend time to decipher. Some scenarios at first glance look awesome and easy but then they get really cranky and you feel dumb because you just don't know how to answer. P5 is so cranky that what I could say it was the easiest (yes the easiest) and the hardest paper to pass at the same time!
NNeha00110y ago#84
How on earth does someone answer this paper in 3h15!!? I took time in reading, analysing and understanding the content... It left me too little time to answer. Disappointed.
Ddarlene10y ago#85
Same here!!!! i went into this exam with so so much knowledge and it floored me!! Question 1 was a nightmare and it went downhill from there, i never have a problem with time management, have always finished my exams with time to spare, but this one....! I still praying!
TTGee10y ago#86
faye...yeah i know it was 5bucks per unit demand over production scrappage... but the poster before me was stating that they took out variable costs on that amount of units above the produced figure... so i commented that i think that would be double counting the variable costs for scrapped items...
TTGee10y ago#87
rst... i get you now... yes..; i think you are right, but partly... it would mean to take out the 'contribution' plus 5buck scrap cost for overproduced items and not the variable cost plus 5bucks...
TTGee10y ago#88
icedawn is right... the stakeholder question was a funny one, saying advice how this stuff could help performance management, and it is effectively covered by the Performance Prism; Stakeholder Satisfaction and Contribution leading into Strategies, Processes and Capabilities..; hahaha... how easy is that ??!! i answered it like a P3 question in the end, and i will be lucky to get about 5 or 6 od the 15 (?) marks :-( i still hope that i passed the overall exam... here's hoping :-)
Kkhan.sarfraz10y ago#89
I enquiries about complaining and about a questionnaire or a poll for feedback for P5 from students and this was the respone : 'ACCA students have the opportunity to provide feedback in the Student Survey that is expected to be issued week commencing 21/03/2016.' I suggest everyone who knows anyone doing P5 to fill it perhaps then they might take notice and suggest sitting another paper!!!
Tteknoc10y ago#90
I filled the survey the ACCA sent me today about the exam. I wrote them that we pay for the exam the same amount (or increased with inflation) as earlier, still we won't get all exam solution. From the fact that earlier we could read all exam solution, this means that the ACCA service level has decreased a lot. Why we pay the same amount? If You agree, and will You write the letter of complaint, pl. put into it this fact. Regards, teknoc
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.