APM*** P5 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
This subject has to be the most weird subject in any certification.
Q3 seemed really simple but it wasn't :/
@rawfay, Q3 really looked simple until u got to part B!
did anyone feel that in question 1, the first two requirements were almost similar!!? i ended up writing things for part (i) which was asked in part (ii) and then when i read part (ii) i went beresk!
how do u calculate anything apart from waste cost and quality cost?!
Extremely time pressured as always :(
Third attempt and this was the worst of the lot.
Just could not calculate anything in Q1 and what on earth did it want me to recalculate?
I know ACCA do not reveal examiner names anymore but does anyone have any info or educated guess on when the next new examiner will take over for P5?
Very time pressured, struggled on time in last question on part B
Very time pressured.
Time was a major issue. We are required to provide more detailed answers. I think we needed more time...
Found Q1 overdeamanding with the performs be pyramid. Especially part ii.
@kth056 said: @rawfay, Q3 really looked simple until u got to part B! did anyone feel that in question 1, the first two requirements were almost similar!!? i ended up writing things for part (i) which was asked in part (ii) and then when i read part (ii) i went beresk! how do u calculate anything apart from waste cost and quality cost?!I don't know exactly, but measure of productivity was given as operating margin. Although not wrong, but it was better to use the keyboard per minute measure..which was given. A figure for previous year production was also given so you could also use the increase in productivity. Rest all seemed appropriate to me. Calculated the waste and quality cost..thats it.
@kth056 and @rawfay I felt the same about Q3!!! Part B oh dear did not go so well at all.
Q1 well I repeated myself as well. Hmm.
First attempt so hoping I did okay and will learn from it.
I didn't use all of the performance data for measures in Q1, as only 4 quality, delivery, cycle time, waste relates to operational performance?
Paper was
Q1
Performance Pyramid - 8
Calculation & Evaluation - 12
Non Financial Indicators Reliability/ Sources - 8
ABC Costing - 6
Strength and Weaknesses of Incremental Budgeting and ABC Budgeting - 12
Structure - 4
Q2
Assess Performance using Fitzgerald & Moon measures - 15
Improvement using real time data, external data Integration - 10
Q3
Stakeholder Analysis & Risk - 10
Project Option, Expected Value/ Probability Estimates and Risk Evaluation of Stakeholders - 15
Can anyone post the possible solution for Q3 part 2? The expected profits were already given so the costing detail in the scenario was pretty useless except that each item unsold would require additional $5 to sell.
May be we had to calculate the losses after costs of these unsold items? But how?
Even part A of question 3 was not easy because it talks about risk appetites and performance management. When I saw "stakeholders" I jumped into it, and by the time it dawned on me that it is something else, it was too late to choose another question.
But when are they changing this examiner? He must be a real saddist
It was my second attempt. Last time in december i got 47%. This time i was completelly lost with those questions. I needed sometimes to read question several times and still some of them didn't get. I know all these theories and models by heart, but i really think acca need to reconsider approach to this exam. I can't believe that people who completed previous 12-13 exams are stupid and not able to pass this one. Pass rate extremelly low and this last exam for some students is the barrier from get certified... Doesnt make sense...
I also understood "operational" to mean the ones at the bottom of the pyramis
@izabolotna I agree, exam technique I think is good second attempt for me, have done whole revision book of practice questions, revision course, k ow the syllabus, got 40% in DEC, I don't think I will ever walk out p5 feeling confident!
@illmaqe, absloutely agree with u! i barely had time to read the scenario for q3 and jumped straight into interest and power! and then i read the appendix a which has already listed all the stakeholders and i went like bam in the face!
Hi all, it was my first attempt on P5.
Can anyone tell me how did they do Q1(iv) , its about the calculation of abc costing ?
I went on to do Q2, i tried to explain the performance indicators with the 6 subsheading on Dimension for moon model.
The part B was difficult with the unified thing. i didnt understand a thing and what to write for 10mks !
I choose Q3 ! i went on to draw MENDELOWS MATRIX and explain them via it. After that i remembered i completely forget about the risk appetite... i went on again to tell if they were risk averse, neutral or seeker... don't know if its good.
Q3(b) - Dude, i didnt know wat to do, i went on to calculate profit for each Demand of 20k, 25k and 30k... And then i explained it with these figures..
I really don't know if i have done enough to secure a pass :( :( , it was time constraint. When u need to understand the case study and then understand the requirement and then try to see what to calculate and what to write ... Wow.... it was the 3hr 15min the most rapid of my life ! lol
I've done so well in the other papers, got through them quickly. Passed P1, 2 and 3 first time and P7 on my second attempt. For the life of me I cannot seem to get over P5 the last paper. I have been trying for so long and it just seem to be getting more difficult. I am tired and frustrated and not sure what else to do.
My third attempt too,, I think will change option now.. Among my last 2 sittings, this one was tougher.
@akshay34u whats your other optional paper?
P5 is a total disaster there is so much info in the question it takes ages to read the u have a question that can be so vague what is going on with it. Sick of this paper now after failing a few times
Very time pressured. I don't usually have issues with time in exams. Sigh
its extremely time pressured and the questions have to be re- read!u also keep going back to read the question while writing your answer! how crazy can that get?
Comparing to Dec this exam is much much easier. However with this paper truth is always "out there". I do not even care how much marks did I collect. There is no any connection between what you think you think you know and what you get as a result, so let's continue this lottery till I hit these lucky 50 marks :)
Very time pressured. Big problem for me was to relate answers to the scenario since scenarios seemed so standard, that whatever sentence from study text you write is ok... In Q 1 calculated only missing rations due yo lack of time. Omitted calculations in Q 4 for same reason. Q 3 was crossed out after reading part b of requirements. Q 2 seemed very easy, but again I hardly used scenario information... I guess that this was a trap this time - this linkage to scenario :(
But anyway, this exam is much much much easier than Dec one. So let's get ready to next one being in "disaster" category...
It was so easy so hard actually do not know what to think of it questions are so easy at first glance but yet so cryptic I guess the examiner writes riddles for a living. I spent my exam reading the questions time and time again. In the end I handed up junk. Two things will come out of this 1. Marker will be easier on us. 2. Next exam will be easier. I'll give it to them though this is an exam of logic and 3d thinking. It is the only exam in acca that tests re as l logic and reasoned thinking so well
After all these sittings of wired exams that has little to do with real life situations I ask myself if certification itself makes sense...
I think this exam is beyond logic!
I get it, the examiner does not like students regurgitating textbook answers, however, I do not expect examiners to through in so much confusion, students are not expert like him/her who have spent years absorbing them self in such knowledge.
Its almost like, we have to think like the examiner in order to pass but that's going beyond the need for testing in this situation. We are students who require basic knowledge which will be developed through experience as well text books!!!
Extremely time pressured each question, had same amount of data to read, none of the other exams I sat in were this frustrating. I am sure this examiner would not do well in his own exam if he was in our shoes!!!!
ACCA should send out a "helpful" survey so that students can provide feedback....I do not feel I need basic knowledge to pass with 50% in business analysis, I feel like I need to have mastered the knowledge of deception within a novel to perform well.
Anyone up for petition to show ACCA that there is serious concern with how the exams portraited out......I guess ACCA defense would be "some pass". I don't know...its starting to feel like a money making exercise with more sittings and more failures lol.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

