APM*** P5 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Also that $5 for wastage....we are not even told how much waste would occur...I don't think its $5 per unit. We were not even told his full capacity, only how much units his planning to produce...then as usual....confused...am I suppose to calculated expected profit...if so why am I given the profit?
How do I calculate the maximin, mum, regret when the values are already confirmed lol ive lost the plot.....I need to revisit. I think Q4 was the easiest by far in this paper. Q1 was good standard but time management was a let down.
I think the teachers need to be more savy with the teach methods and approach with P5..the examiner is obviously trying to make us think outside the box a little.....not happening in an exam!!!
Can you believe that in my country, South Africa, ACCA is considered too easy and has no recognition, The local body undermines ACCA big time!!
Wait everyone seemed to have done not so well..what learning providers did you use? I found LSBF to be quite good for exam technique.
Super time pressured.
This paper required 6 hours to solve if examiner wants "quality" answers!
Examiner acts dumb every time in the examiner report saying "he is surprised by the quality of answers in last few attempts". Well, if you give us 3 huge scenarios, then we have to analyse them properly and evaluate, and then write all of it takes a long time. This exam was impossible. I felt like i was extremely well prepared.. knew everything almost and had practiced a ton of questions.. but so very time pressured. I left 26 marks untouched.. hope i did well enough in the 74 i attempted, but probably gonna make 40 something like i always do. Ugh.
If i study more, or if i study less, i always get 40 something.
today exam was awful, I felt more confident about the Dec one and failed with 47!
Q1 I had no clue what I was really doing and I felt the requirements didn't flow like they usually do. Couldn't think of enough points to warrant 8 marks on the performance pyramid without actually describing what it was.
part b) I just went through each one and said if it was a good PI or not and how it linked to snorts aims.
I can't remember the rest of the question, I felt like we were doing a lot for very little marks.
I done Q2, part a was quite nice, couldn't think of enough points to cover part b that warranted all the marks.
I looked at Q3 and saw stakeholder analysis and thought yes! I can do that but then read part b of the requirement and was like no way, plus the scenario was so long, I would've never had time to read it!
Q4 wasn't too bad, but I felt like I was repeating myself too much, so probably scored very low.
Roll on June!
This examiner is impossible, all he keeps on about is preparing us for the real world, but this exam is like me showing up for work on my first day and my boss saying you have to write a report for the CEO and you have an hour an half! Yeah right, never gonna happen!
Its so good to see all of your comments and know that we are all on the same boat here. This was my second attempt at P5 and I don't think I have passed.
Just to reiterate what some of you have already said, I took found this paper by far the most time pressured of all papers I've sat. There is too much information to take in, so much that I skimmed through a lot of it just so I could start writing.
I have read examiners reports, previous exam papers, attended the 2 hour webinar by ACCA/PWC on how to pass this paper and though the tips I'd picked up seemed good at the time, I don't feel I was really able to use them because they were not relevant and I was just so time pressured to think about them.
One more thing... the exam desks in Farnborough are TOO SMALL!!!! grrr....
Did anyone else find it weird that the requirements were in the middle of the scenario, I opened the script and saw one page of scenario and though huh? where's the rest, then found the appendix 1 & 2 on the following page, weird!
@Rst I got the same figures as you for Q3 but I didn't even get to begin drawing a regret table let alone conclude!
Faye - we had a leaking roof in Southampton, the dripping on the floor was driving me nuts! Fortunately it stopped when the rain stopped!
Oh no Nicki! Hope it didn't affect your concentration too much :S
i did not walk out of the exam hall
confidently. was able to attempt 88% of the paper. praying that i score 56% of that then i will barely scrap through.
Perhaps a serious petition should be started to highlight how impossible the exam is.
How on earth are you supposed to have time to write full sentences, let alone provide quality answers!?
I felt that in order to get anywhere near to completing it, i had to bullet point answers and write in almost note form. Even then i only answered about 70% as the rest of the time was spent reading through the text
Somethings got to give here- clearly the ACCA are making a lot of money out of this so perhaps we all just sit other options instead which will mean nobody sits the P5 exam and then they may make the exam realistic - hit the ACCA where it hurts most
I am going to be writing a letter of complaint
just a question for the payoff matrix table...
why would you take out variable cost + $5 for the scrapped units ?
the variable costs have already been taken out in the first part of the equation when the contribution per unit has been used, then the fixed cost subtracted then only $5 per unit scrapped subtracted from that, right ?
if you include variable costs with the $5 scrap cost, i think that for the scrapped units the variable costs are effectively being double-charged.
anyway, i got the regret matrix done as well, but it might have given me the same answer as the maximax and maximin, so i thought that i must have done something wrong...
did seem tough, but i have seen in some of these exams that some info is given later on, which you had to right up in previous sections, and yes part A was strangely written... it said advise how the analysis would help, but in the scenario it states to do the analysis, so best to do the analysis and state why its good to be done... i stated P3 stuff, about stakeholder negotations to get everyone ok with the required strategy etc...
the ABBudgetting made me freeze, then just started with the total of 520k and listed the 4 activities and split the total 520 figure by the % given for these activities... eg, 60% of 520k is 312k for that activity, and so on...
then under that, i worked out an activity based absorption rate for each activity, cos you could then have like $5.04/reworked reject, or $2,500 per week of quality seminars... that in itself was not a budget, but i added this stuff in cos the above stuff seemed to simple and i thought there must be a catch to it, and the absorption rates seemed like the only info one could get further out of the question...
the unified database stuff in 2b did state i relation to improving performance, so it seemed like a general common sense and not analysing performance management techniques but the business detail itself... like if it was unified you could have Division A holiday info on internet and push those customers to book online and receive their bookings via the innovative smartphone tech that Divi B used...
likewise, the richer people buying the DiviC city breaks could receive some offers for the DiviA exotic holidays near the time like last minute cos the Divi A had the time for it and the money to pay for the DiviA holidays which were like 5times the price of DivB or Div C etc..
also could use the smartphone tech to give customers headsup on DivB non-peak times or vacancies during peak times, so they could then get booking etc...
i thought the question in 2 partB, was asking for that sort of thing...
on top of centralised management being able to see what was going on in real time and not wait for year end to get all the info...
Hi TGee - The scrapped units incurred a further cost, the $5 scrappage fee per unit. So if the demand was 20,000 and the supply was 25,000, 5,000 would have to be scrapped which would incur a further (variable) cost of 5,000*$5 = £25,000 on top of the variable costs for making the units to begin with - does that help??
I emailed ACCA exam operation people perhaps if everyone got together then perhaps ACCA might take notice.
Yes it was good to know that I'm not the only one who thinks something is wrong with this exam paper....it's way too complicated and in real life you would use so much support from theoretical to mentor to senior management. No one not even CEO do the work by them self it's not possible otherwise it would be a one man team.
Anyway I thought Dec paper was better and I felt really confident and failed with 48%.
There is always that thought in my head somehow people have managed a pass, don't understand how. Like some people have already said, done the revision exam practise got the knowledge under my belt but I melt in the exam because it's twisting too twisting trying to decipher in 3 hrs.
One more attempting if I fail then I'm switching to auditing or tax and I think tax would be easier as the rules have to be remembered by heart that's all no room for deviant text......but you never know!
This was my 4th attempt. I literally got 44% each and every time before.
My overall comments - I agree, the time pressure is insane. I actually felt more confident going into this exam as opposed to my previous attempts. Hoping for the best but expecting the worse so im already back to studying. This also my final paper before being qualified. I resorted to just writing points and explaining where I could to help get marks. I tried thinking outside the box but i mean in such a short time frame, theres only so much analytical thinking i can do. I did attempt the world of ppqs and i was actually seeing my answers closer and closer to the examiner's.
Now...not so sure. :(
this looked like an open book exam without the open books. The first q was actually not too bad but the rest looked like some long forgotten ancient language that had to be deciphered in 3 hours it was very very long and the requirements were on the cryptic side even if you had the txt books in front of u it wouldnt of helped. The most cryptic confusing exam i have ever taken. My answer booklet looks like it was written by someone on cyrstal meth. I wouldnt expect june to b any different maybe marginally easier at best. We have to all adapt to the style of the examiner. If nothing he is demanding and expects a darn high standard. I would expect the markers to have sympathy so perhaps not all lost for you 46-49 percenters.
My 2nd time and I feel I did worse this time because of the 50% b***sh** in the scenarios, particularly in Q3, which takes up the scarce time you have. The implication is then an inefficient allocation of resources and decrease in the exam performance. The thing is that you have to read the whole scenario including the rubbish in order to find out where the examiner hide the important bits.
Q3 is quiet straight forward. Employees are secured not to be redundant and their bonus is related to profit so risk seeker and maximax for sure. Bank wants their capital repayment and interest back so risk averse maximin. Directors as stated in the question don't want to lose anymore so they choose the option of minmise regret. Leaving the neutral attitude towards risk goes to VC using expected value.payoff table is not that complex to design..
Going to change the paper...In this paper you dont learn anything new and in exam you cant produce any thing well....
I completely agree, the time factor is the main problem, there's so much demanded in 3:15mins. I passed all my ACCA first time snd with P5 this is the 2nd time I am writing with still no confidence to pass.
The questions are very trickish, with the time pressure there's no time to think.
The examiner needs to revise the rules governing P5. Is very sad I will pass all the ACCA papers but will abandoned ACCA because of just the last paper which is the horible P5.
P5 was horrible, Why even bother with ACCA, when there are other qualifications out there, I won't advise anyone to start ACCA, it is horrible to ask people to do the impossibility!!!
So much to do in 3:15 mins,
with all the scenarios questions how can you use just 15mins to read them!!!
Then comes the strickish questions you have to read severally in order to understand,
The demands are too much!!!
When are we expecting the March results!!
P5 exam was really really time pressured. Q No:1 was scenario based while Optional Questions were more than longer than Q No: 1 and there so many information in questions which was hard to skim within given time constraints.
This examiner makes this exam more tough and tough day by day. This examiner should be changed.
It was my second attempt. Last time in December i got 48%. This time was the disaster, on the first instance the papers looks simple but when I started the paper, so many things were mixed up, was unable to rightly answer or build the positive answer. rightly application of knowledge to the scenarios was the key and I missed that.
This is the last paper since 2012 i have been trying till now....my acca is going to expire soon....so sad?? seems like no way out...
You're not alone in that feeling. I spent over 2hrs on Q1 and could not even read the last question, Q4, just jumped into writing generic answers.
I'm tired! I'm sincerely praying my efforts in Q1 and Q2 is crowned with success. I did all parts in Q1 except the ABC calculation for 6marks.
God help me!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

