Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** P5 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P5 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P5 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#151
Please count me in on any petition to ACCA concerning the unfairness of the P5 examinations under Watt.

I was so disappointed in the December paper despite working so hard for the exam that I felt like quitting ACCA. I was talked into continuing with ACCA so I had another go with P5 ths time and worked even harder in preparing for the exam. Again, virtually impossible to do in the time frame set. I really felt cheated by the unfairness of this last P5 paper.

I will not retake P5 again and will try P6 or P7 unless ALex Watt goes before the December exam.

Personally, I don't think it will do any good complaining to ACCA as some other comments on here says, as it is a cash cow for ACCA when many students fail. It is in their interests that large numbers of students fail. If ACCA genuinely do not believe this to be the case, lets see some action then - replace Alex Watt now!

From reading some previous comments on this forum about the low pass rates for ACCA exams I just compared to other professional accountancy exams. For CIMA the % of those students passing at the same professional level were around 45-55% for each paper. For the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales the pass rates for the Advanced papers were 69% passing all (3) papers at the same time. The pass rates for the individual papers were:
Business Reporting – 77.4%
Business Change – 82.5%
Case Study – 73.9%

ACCA cannot really be proud of pass rates of 29% can they? What does this say about the ACCA exams, particularly the final professional ones we have to sit? We can conclude the folllowing:

1) ACCA genuinely allows far too many students to take the ACCA exams who simply do not have the intellectual ability to pass these professional exams (unlike the ICAEW and CIMA),
OR
2)The ACCA exams are far too difficult and unfair compared to the other professional accountancy bodies.
SShunmas14y ago#152
@darthvader001

For those of you who in the UK (or in Glasgow), why not arrange a protest...against Alex Watt....I don't think a letter would not do any better, they would simply consider it a piece of paper. On the other hand, a protest would at least show them that students are the main stakeholders and does have power to influence the decision of ACCA. Some one here also said that on the physical protest of a Big 4 firm, they re-passed the failed student. A simple group of 100 people and 2 or 3 channels cameraman would suffice. You know how media guys are.
Former userFormer user14y ago#153
Prior to dec11 exams my score for p5 hovered around 30%. I decided to read seroiusly Alex's notes on approach he wanted students to follow. Guess what, I scored a passing mark in dec 11 exam. For those who want the examiner to go, i think you are all losers! If you think the examiner will come down to your level to please you then you will wait a long long time with your PQ status!
Hhalbesri14y ago#154
I am in for the petition or what ever type of action to express my correct complain against p5 exam of this June.By the way some of the suggestions here need to be put in a careful way,that saying Alex Watt should do no use to us who sat p5 in June instead we must make clear that 1.the markings must take the situation into consideration so that there will be some change in the passing marks point
2.for all those who will take p5 in the future ACCA need to control the examiners and the examination questions set for a particular exam session and hence chnging examiners won't help(firing ALex) as the new comer may be the same so either ACCA must watch and review the examiners(which I believe it would do) or
if not doeble ,perhaps due to agreements,changing would be an option.so what we need now is our p5 papers be marked in a fair way due to failure of the examiner to set the questions right.

hence the group must take this into consideration when protesting or writing to ACCA or taking any feasible action ....
Former userFormer user14y ago#155
after reading the commments , i have several points

-changing the examiner is not the solution( personally i really hate alex 's style, especially dec 2011). the new examiner will be tough or even worse, the example is p4, The new examiner of p4 will not do any good, the questions are still horrible.

-ACCA is becoming harder and harder , the sole purpose is to prevent massive people from passing and qualifying.

-ACCA IS LOSING MARKET, hongkong CPA will not admit ACCA member, ALSO, US CPA-AICPA will not admit ACCA, BUT admit CIMA AND ICAEW member, why is that?

ACCA WILL admit students without qualifications and fail them , with surprisng pass rate, this can damage the reputation of the ASSOCIATION.

-AS a student of ACCA, I wish ACCA TO BE THE BEST, so I NEED TO SPELL OUT ours suggestions to ACCA to build strong brand in the accounting market.
Ggudluck14y ago#156
People here saying that ACCA passing rate being low will do them more bad than good, have to consider that a lower passing rate in their examination means a tougher qualification to achieve and hence its increase in value in the market.

Lets face it, an employer given the option of hiring a person who has passed a qualification with an average 30% pass rate as compared to a qualification having 65% pass rate is obviously going to hire the 30% pass rate candidate.

The difficulty in achieving a qualification only adds to its value.

And those saying that having a low pass rate means ACCA is having students with low intellectual capabilities must keep in mind that getting to the professional stage itself requires heck of a lot of capabilities, if you cannot get to the professional stage ur not fit enough to become an ACCA, and if you get to this stage you certainly have the ability.

I agree even my paper was pathetic and im almost certainly failing, but i have myself partly to blame for not practising by timing questions. And perhaps ill go for P6 in the next exam, judging by my habit of not being able to complete any paper on time.
Bbethwest14y ago#157
darthvader001 add me please
Former userFormer user14y ago#158
@gudluck said:

Lets face it, an employer given the option of hiring a person who has passed a qualification with an average 30% pass rate as compared to a qualification having 65% pass rate is obviously going to hire the 30% pass rate candidate.

The difficulty in achieving a qualification only adds to its value.



The reality is....

3 people are interviewees

- One is qualified ICAEW
- The other is part qualified ACCA, and has failed his/her last exam 2/3 times
- The third is ACCA qualified

The employer would, as I would, employee the first or 3rd person, not caring much about which qualification, just that they have one.

Employers dont know, and dont care, they just want someone who is qualified
Former userFormer user14y ago#159
@greenpepper said:
Hi DarthVader..

If you need some help compiling a formal complaint letter please let me know, am happy to help! I think rather than talk about individual questions and talk in detail about the issues with the questions, the focus should be on the wording of the requirements and how none of the questions in the BPP Revision Kit was worded in such manner.

There are websites where we can set up a online petition, where we can put up the link here and on other P5 forums and send out to everyone to fill in their details.

There is no harm in doing this... probably a 1% chance anything will happen but we may get lucky!

:)


Im a bit reluctant to add my name, due to not knowing what the content will be.

I dont think that the "sack Alex" approach will be accepted.

However, a more professional approach like "review the P5 exam setting techniques" may have a better chance.

It could & should be done, but in a certain way. As if your discussing a colleague, or a particularly difficult work situation - not a rival football team in the local pub.

Anyway, here is what PQ accountant magazine took fom our comments

https://www.pqaccountant.com/pmag-FFFF00500180008C02171957.html

Lots of ACCAs had strong views on P5. They felt that while the topics were easy the requirements were hard, if that makes sense. So there was nothing in the topics - NPV, MIRR, EVA, benchmarking, performance prism and 6 Sigma. It is the way Alex Watt asks the questions. Some of the comments on one site we saw perhaps went a bit far though - we don't believe he should be hanged!
Dd4gm14y ago#160
It was a crazy paper! Time was too little. Most questions were more than ten marks. Q5 was way too much read to even consider after Q1. It was an insane paper.
Having said that, if you had read the articals in the student account then you would have known Q1c, the question about bench marking and the question about the performance prism. I still had no time to even get nearly everything written down. I completely messed up Q1b. 14 marks gone!!

In my opinion the issues with Q1a was that the report contained too much detail info. It was info overload! There were also no external info, or forward looking info or non financial info. Those are the characteristics of Strategic management accounting. The report was afterall used for strategic purposes.
I dont know what else...

Q1c was that people only concentrate on things that get measured. this was also in one of his articles. Basically they are saying that if there are no performance indicators in place to measure the results, then staff don't bother doing it well. I think in the scenario they used they said the woman told the staff to smile at customers. They then said that she doesn't think they are doing it. She also asked them to switch of the lights or smething to preserve electricity. This they are doing. So basically you can measure electricity usage by the bill. But its hard to measure if staff are smiling at customers. So "what gets measured gets done".

As far as the benchmarking... it was tough and time was little... I am not sure what they ment by the status of the bench marking process or whatever... i think (but don't know!) you had to write down what has been done and what still had to be done... so they have selected what type of benchmarking they want to do... they have selected who to bench mark against... what to benchmark etc... i guess they still have to do the actual comparing and then learn from the results and then somehow still implement what they have learned and perhaps also find a way to measure if it is actually working... dunno.
Six sigma, i read briefly in preperation for the paper and I rambled a whole lot of stuff. That was thumb sucking so not sure if I actually got any marks... it was a tough paper forsure!
Time was tooooo little!
Former userFormer user14y ago#161
darthvader001 count me in please.
SSara22214y ago#162
ahh p5 :( i forgot the mirr calculation i looked at it two days back and in exam i was blank
the examiner should have done little mercy requirements should have been more easy to interpret all time i was thinking if what i am writing is right or not especially qs 1 part a and c and qs 4 part a n qs 5 was out of my reach GOD knows what was it.
Sswing198514y ago#163
@darthvader001 count me in .. thanks
Former userFormer user14y ago#164
smidsy said 4 days, 13 hours ago:
Maybe P4/P6P7 is more achieveable – seems to be what others are doing.


Excuse me, but P4 was the most disasterous paper I've ever sat for in ACCA. P5 i found was somewhat manageable. After sitting for a paper like P4, any paper is do'able.
Former userFormer user14y ago#165
darthvader001-count me in if its not too late!

I do agree that papers pre alex watts was much better
Former userFormer user14y ago#166
I agree with d4gm, the case study has just too much information, time wasnt enuf to read and answer the requirements.. Spend so much time on the first as Q1 had 40 marks altogether.

The question on benchmarking was tricky and confusing, could differentiate what was asked in part a and b, i could not attempt part b though... :(

I also opted for Question 5, again the case study was equivalent to Q1 - so much info and complex.. only one question and it comprised of 17marks.
Hhalbesri14y ago#167
candidates are you watching what the pole on open tuition on p5 showing?and where it is heading? I think some ......are voting against the majority to reverse our claim or what......will somebody talk?
Former userFormer user14y ago#168
Hi,
I have just seen F5 has an analysis of the paper by Opentuition due to the comments left on that papers forum, may we have the same thing for P5?
Thanks
Former userFormer user14y ago#169
I think the problem with this paper and the new style of questions is partly down to the fact that the tuition providers are yet to catch up.

The structure and wording is wildly different to the previous examiner. An example is BPP's revision kit, which includes previous exam questions and questions that they have written in line with this format. BPP, Kaplan etc need to completely rewrite their practice questions (although not sure how they will get inside Mr Watts head).

I stress i am in no way blaming the tuition providers, but there definately needs to be more dialogue between them and the exaaminer.
Former userFormer user14y ago#170
Hi,

this was my third attempt for P5. as always hope for 50 marks :)

I always read revision question book, read all articles, read all examiner's reports and his approach. However I am still here(((

I do not understand what examiner wants from me when I read questions in the exam hall. I always read requirements carefully, spend more than 15 minutes only for reading just to carefully read requirements and scenario. after that I must spend some time on planning the answers which is quite difficult when you actually have several requirements in one requirement, don't you think?

I am again very upset with Q1. part b - nothing unfamiliar - NPV, EVA, MIRR, other profit based measures, but the this awful report made me panicking and well nothing was calculated properly. However I knew MIRR formula and wrote it in the script. And now I am reading that this formula was provided in P4!! Should be vice versa, don't you think?
I also cannot understand what the difference is between Q3 a and b parts. but tried my best not to repeat myself in both parts.
Q4 was ok, but I completely forgot about VFM (3E) approach for evaluation of NFPO. blame only myself for that(( instead I wrote some comments about costs, costs drivers.
I did not attempt Q5 because of one single requirement. I find it very difficult to plan, to allocate marks properly. I thought that such requirements were in the past, but obviously I am wrong.

Some people and examiner himself wrote that we need to read requirements carefully. But prior to this exam everything was ok with our reading of requirements. Obviously we all cannot loose this ability by P5 ;)

I do not state that Alex Watt is a bad examiner. But he needs to state requirements more clearly. After reading the model answers I always think "Ah, that's what he wants? I learned it, but did not understand that was what he wanted to see".

good luck to all of us! :)
Hhabibla14y ago#171
lindencourt said 1 day, 7 hours ago:
From reading some previous comments on this forum about the low pass rates for ACCA exams I just compared to other professional accountancy exams. For CIMA the % of those students passing at the same professional level were around 45-55% for each paper. For the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales the pass rates for the Advanced papers were 69% passing all (3) papers at the same time. The pass rates for the individual papers were:
Business Reporting – 77.4%
Business Change – 82.5%
Case Study – 73.9%

ACCA cannot really be proud of pass rates of 29% can they? What does this say about the ACCA exams, particularly the final professional ones we have to sit? We can conclude the folllowing:

1) ACCA genuinely allows far too many students to take the ACCA exams who simply do not have the intellectual ability to pass these professional exams (unlike the ICAEW and CIMA),
OR
2)The ACCA exams are far too difficult and unfair compared to the other professional accountancy bodies.

I cannot comment on CIMA but I heard that admission requirements for ICAEW are quite strict unlike for ACCA. That's why I assume the pass rate is so high and employers value ACA higher than ACCA. So I would say conclusion 1 is correct.
Former userFormer user14y ago#172
I am choice easy in slection and the reason is I was take P4 in same time.
First I do Q2 first and then Q1,Q3,Q4.
Q2,question a is ask do performance review for Airline with others two use the inormation given,so it's typical and easy to answer.
Q2 question b is ask performance Prism,before test,I was feeling maybe it't will test since I check alex's examnation and find he like to choice article.So I just reply it use the knowledge in article.
Q1,question a is use the fiance inforamtion in report to do performance review,so just calculate some finance figure and then compare it;s performance.
Q2,I don't reas quesiton carefully since time limit,so I jsut calclualte NPV,MIRR,EVA within 3 years.from NPV and MIRR we can see project is not worth since it' negative result in 3 years just EVA is always positive so EVA provid a measure way.
Q3,what meansure what get done,I use builds block to answer this question since in order to imporve his performance,they should use bulid block to set up performance system as a service company.
Q3,6 SIGMA is easy and don't want to say anything
Q4,queston a is ask the process o benchmarking.pay attention to proces,
Question b is ask to use benchkmarking,I calculate the figure in given but we need use 3E to do performance so we need more information about economy and effective.
That's all.
Former userFormer user14y ago#173
@habibla said:
I cannot comment on CIMA but I heard that admission requirements for ICAEW are quite strict unlike for ACCA. That's why I assume the pass rate is so high and employers value ACA higher than ACCA. So I would say conclusion 1 is correct.

I think CIMA and ACCA is not really comparable because former is focused on management accounting and you can not be in practice with it and later is focused on Fin. Accounting and you can join audit firm with ACCA.

When comparing ACCA with ICAEW you should take into account:

option 3) Students mainly work in accountancy firms thus have more study support and employer/association interaction and actual practice with clients thus higher pass rates. ACCAs as I noticed mainly are accountants in business thus less study support and work environment doesnt have high pressure on completing qualification that is why I think lower pass rates.
Former userFormer user14y ago#174
@darthvader001 count me in .. thanks!
Former userFormer user14y ago#175
Oh my the comments here are truly accurate! this exam was not the old run-of-the-mill type exam. It took a lot of thinking. That MIRR thing was way above my head! I calculated an IRR and used that pft!

definitely too much to read and retain then to answer. Then they asked you to assess the performance of the airline in Q2 a. using appropriate calculation, but due to time over runs in other questions i started to write an intro to the building block model then to realise.."thats not what they want"

Argg i just need 50, please examiner just 50 after scoring 49 the first time i sat this paper i deserve 50
Former userFormer user14y ago#176
i take long time to do q1,q2,q3..but q4 i just left 15 minute,,so i write what i think..hope can pass examiner help me..50mark only..
Former userFormer user14y ago#177
i take long time to do q1,q2,q3..but q4 i just left 15 minute,,so i write what i think..hope can pass examiner help me..50mark only..
Rredrose14y ago#178
@darthvader001
Please can you update regarding the letter you were supposed to write on Tuesday as per your earlier posts......
Kindly enlighten....if possible post the letter on this site, we want to see it.
I can see you have many supporters including myself!
Former userFormer user14y ago#179
Hi everyone,

My apologies for the delay. I have been working until 12 every night. I will put the draft during this weekend, unfortunately I had some unexpected things to do at work.
Keep checking this site!
Someone suggested that we can make online on a site the petition.
Can you help me with the name of the site?
Thanks!
Bbethwest14y ago#180
@darthvader001 said:
Hi everyone,

My apologies for the delay. I have been working until 12 every night. I will put the draft during this weekend, unfortunately I had some unexpected things to do at work.
Keep checking this site!
Someone suggested that we can make online on a site the petition.
Can you help me with the name of the site?
Thanks!

https://www.petitionbuzz.com/ found this it may help?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.