Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** P5 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P5 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P5 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Bbvp12314y ago#121
I think ACCA should have a rule for when we are tested on lower papers or knowledge required from other P papers, that it should not carry more that 4-5 marks. Otherwise we are wasting time learning P5.
Can someone please tell me where the hell the article on Benchmarking is and when it was published as I have only seen on Performance Prism.
Also where can I find more information on Q1C, as this topic was not mentioned once in any of my P5 course or on revision.
SShunmas14y ago#122
@bvp123 said:
I think ACCA should have a rule for when we are tested on lower papers or knowledge required from other P papers, that it should not carry more that 4-5 marks. Otherwise we are wasting time learning P5.
Can someone please tell me where the hell the article on Benchmarking is and when it was published as I have only seen on Performance Prism.
Also where can I find more information on Q1C, as this topic was not mentioned once in any of my P5 course or on revision.


Benchmarking article is there but that is pure theory, it was a computational question more like ABC, given the 3 cost drivers...and cost pools. It was like taking cost pools and costs of other 2 universities and dividing them by their respective cost driver (coming up with a weighted average) and multiplying the same with the drive of GU (so like Flexing the budget thing).

Q1(c) is like:

How the quote "WGMGD" could apply to Metis can be assessed using performance pyramid, involving financial and non-financial indicators under the following headings:

And then the performance pyramid headings:.

You can notice the last paragraph pf the question relates to Part c, 2nd last with Part b, etc
Qqurrat14y ago#123
@darthvader001 said:
This passive attitude will not get us anywhere. Let me explain why:

On Dec 11, I failed the exam with 48 marks. I paid £75 in order for ACCA to re-check my marking. Re-check MEANS: adding up all the points and see if they were correctly transposed to my email !! THEY WILL NEVER RE-MARK YOUR SCRIPT! They just told me that I have pass rating on 2 questions and failed 2 questions. Not even the marks/question.

I made the second complaint, on the Appeal Committee, asking to see my paper or to re-mark it. ACCA reply was, after paying another £65: the exam result is the same, we will not revisit the script.

ACCA feedback online=0. Nothing will happen.

What happened in the past, real case. My company (a Big 4), after all the people in the Company, starting with Managers and below failed one paper several times, addressed an official complaint as a Platinum ACCA Employer regarding the way that an Examiner constructed the questions and ask for a re-marking of the scripts: 60% were granted a pass. This, of course, was not public knowledge.

The power is in NUMBERS. If we are writing a complaint about Alex Watt as a GROUP, we will be HEARD. Otherwise, ignored and have to take this exam over and over again. I have finished 13 papers in 4 years and got stuck with P5 for the last 3 years!!

Please leave me your username from this site, so we can make a complaint as a GROUP regarding Alex Watt and this examination.

WHY: if the pass rate is very low ( as I will expect) ACCA has to raise the bar and push the numbers up, in order not to have an image problem. If we act now, they will likely investigate this BEFORE the marking process will begin.

AFTER the marking is done, IT WILL BE TOO LATE. I don’t want to take another exam in Dec and wait until March next year! Because, ladies and gentlemen, THIS IS WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT: You will be qualified best case scenario NEXT YEAR IN MARCH !!!

i am joining your group too as i have been through same issue i missed the paper by 2 marks last time and paid for re mark too but I wa told I have passed 3 questions and still didnt get 50????

Qurrat
Former userFormer user14y ago#124
Please, count on me on the complaint, although I didn't take the exam this time I was unfortunate to sit twice under Alex and marginally failed. We have time pressure on all other paper and especially option ones but when I come out of exam I think of points I could've put but left because of time pressure however with P5 I came out twice thinking what a hell the qns was about.

Points I want to include in the complain is: 1. Pre Alex exam style is different so is the syllabus thus most of past papers are not helpful for revising. 2. Alex doesn't write enough articles to explain application of theories in real life situation. 3. Wording of Qn requirements are ambiguous.

Thank you, even if I won't seat this exam again I won't to help other people.
Former userFormer user14y ago#125
I ment I want to help other people! :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#126
Guys, just catched up on other bits of this forum and wanted to mention that if you google Alex Watt you can get his profile in linkin. Do you have any ideas why he put his period as being Acca P5 examiner as 2009 -2011? I thought his first exam was in 2010. Do you think we should include a question of his integrity in the complain :) ? An why it is till 2011? Do you think he could have been replaced and Acca forgot to inform us?
Nnishina14y ago#127
PLEASE INCLUDE ME AS WELL MR DEATHVADER!! Thank You
Aajmals2814y ago#128
I'm in. Ajmals28
Rredrose14y ago#129
@darthvader001.

Please include me as well.....
Former userFormer user14y ago#130
@darthvaderoo1

count me in too
Zzmukati14y ago#131
Hello,

Can anyone please explain me question 1(a)
Critically assess the existing performance report
What i did, i assessed the performance of the Metis.

Then The question continuation was: suggest improvements to its content and presentation;
Here, I provided few improvements (not many)

Please clear me, I did anything wrong :(

Worried

I am also IN for the petition against Mr. Watt.
Former userFormer user14y ago#132
@zmukati said:
Hello,

Can anyone please explain me question 1(a)
Critically assess the existing performance report
What i did, i assessed the performance of the Metis.

Then The question continuation was: suggest improvements to its content and presentation;
Here, I provided few improvements (not many)

Please clear me, I did anything wrong :(

Worried

I am also IN for the petition against Mr. Watt.


Yes mate, you were totally wrong.
Do not want to scary you: but you should have assessed the current report and not the performance of the company. You should have focused on the fact that it contans only financial aspects, over detailled, inward, enhances short termist, inappropriate for strategy, lacks of non-financial aspects such as quality, customer sadisfaction or employee motivation.

As improvements you could have come with ideas such: structe the report on a "balance scorecard" format and contan information on the 4 areas from that model and then discuss it/ or a "building blocks" model since it is a service company.

Hope we pass.
Nnishina14y ago#133
Omg then i was totally wrong!!! Hope i ve wrote something bout that too.. I hate myself right now :(
Oowaiskhan8914y ago#134
Hello guys.

Can someone please let me know about Q4, i mean were we suppose to do the calcution in part (a) where it says assess the existing benchmarking or in part (b).. I have done the calculation in part A and explaining of it in part b.

Please guys let me know about it.
Thanks
Former userFormer user14y ago#135
OK guys, I will start drafting the letter on Tuesday, as on Monday I have to travel.
Any suggestions are welcomed!
Mmountain12314y ago#136
@zmukati said:
Hello,

Can anyone please explain me question 1(a)
Critically assess the existing performance report
What i did, i assessed the performance of the Metis.

Then The question continuation was: suggest improvements to its content and presentation;
Here, I provided few improvements (not many)

Please clear me, I did anything wrong :(

Worried

I am also IN for the petition against Mr. Watt.



I did the same thing, hahaha

I hope markers would give 2-3 marks to show sympathy
Mmountain12314y ago#137
@virgilbucur said:
Yes mate, you were totally wrong.
Do not want to scary you: but you should have assessed the current report and not the performance of the company. You should have focused on the fact that it contans only financial aspects, over detailled, inward, enhances short termist, inappropriate for strategy, lacks of non-financial aspects such as quality, customer sadisfaction or employee motivation.

As improvements you could have come with ideas such: structe the report on a "balance scorecard" format and contan information on the 4 areas from that model and then discuss it/ or a "building blocks" model since it is a service company.

Hope we pass.



if you used balanced scorecard in (a), what was your answer to (c)?
Former userFormer user14y ago#138
@virgilbucur said:
Yes mate, you were totally wrong.
Do not want to scary you: but you should have assessed the current report and not the performance of the company. You should have focused on the fact that it contans only financial aspects, over detailled, inward, enhances short termist, inappropriate for strategy, lacks of non-financial aspects such as quality, customer sadisfaction or employee motivation.

As improvements you could have come with ideas such: structe the report on a "balance scorecard" format and contan information on the 4 areas from that model and then discuss it/ or a "building blocks" model since it is a service company.

Hope we pass.

Virgile, astept de 3 ani sa trec examenul asta. Cu examinerul asta nu se poate!
Trebuie dat jos! Are you with me ?
Zzmukati14y ago#139
@mountain123

Please dont say that you wrote balance scorecard in Part c , i have written Fitzgrald and Moon in Part c.

Hoping for sympathy in Q1 Part A.Critically assess the existing performance report , this is what its hurting me :(
Zzmukati14y ago#140
What you guys did in the following question:

Q4(a) Assess the progress of the benchmarking exercise to date, explaining the actions that have been undertaken and those that are still required.
Mmountain12314y ago#141
@zmukati said:
@mountain123

Please dont say that you wrote balance scorecard in Part c , i have written Fitzgrald and Moon in Part c.

Hoping for sympathy in Q1 Part A.Critically assess the existing performance report , this is what its hurting me :(


I did the same thing again...hahaha...but I thought about it carefully after the exam, I believe the examiner intended to address balanced scorecard in (c)...it makes more sense as it's very hard to apply building blocks to the case....but there is nothing wrong if you used building blocks, you can still get marks if you applied it to the case well...

The examiner could have just specified which model to use in (c), that would have made requirements clear... this is absolutely his problem...

For Q4, I feel it's the easiest question in the whole paper....the company has only compared with unis of similiar size.. it may consider using other benchmarking such as industry, internal, best-in-class etc...

I did some calculations in Q4(b) and explained each, hoping to gain 3-4 marks...

I did fairly poor in Q1...T_T
Zzmukati14y ago#142
@mountain123 said:
I did the same thing again...hahaha...but I thought about it carefully after the exam, I believe the examiner intended to address balanced scorecard in (c)...it makes more sense as it's very hard to apply building blocks to the case....but there is nothing wrong if you used building blocks, you can still get marks if you applied it to the case well...

The examiner could have just specified which model to use in (c), that would have made requirements clear... this is absolutely his problem...

For Q4, I feel it's the easiest question in the whole paper....the company has only compared with unis of similiar size.. it may consider using other benchmarking such as industry, internal, best-in-class etc...

I did some calculations in Q4(b) and explained each, hoping to gain 3-4 marks...

I did fairly poor in Q1...T_T



How to apply balance scorecard in that scenario.. it didn't had anything on internal processes or innovation :S
I said its a service industry, so Building block would be best for the company.

What Alex Watt wants from the students?

Hoping for a pass :)

Same here, I am also dis hearted with Q1
Former userFormer user14y ago#143
Please include me in any official group complaint to ACCA concerning the conduct of Alex Watt and his P5 examinations.

I am still so angry about that last P5 exam. I worked really hard for this exam (again!) and spent weeks practising many questions (2 questions banks) but this exam like the other P5 exams involving Alex Watt are simply unquestionably UNFAIR.

Yes, ACCA exams should be hard. As professional exams I would expect them to be hard, time pressured, but fair. P5 was simply unfair. Alex Watt really needs to go. If ACCA cares about their long term reputation they should take notice of a group complaint, but I won't hold my breath!
Bbvp12314y ago#144
@darthvader001 said:
OK guys, I will start drafting the letter on Tuesday, as on Monday I have to travel.
Any suggestions are welcomed!

Could you please have him Clarify the situation on MIRR formula, why not provided, was that not a mistake on his part? We lost time looking for it back and front of the paper and then panicking. Further not only time but also must have lost a couple of marks on calculation plus few more marks on explanation of the outcome.
I managed to pass one of the hardest papers in my opinion P4, yet I can’t understand why I cannot pass P5. FYI, the MIRR formula was provided in P4 exam.
My message to you all is that there are no right or wrong ways of answering questions on P5, there are several models that can be used to get the same answer, but more importantly DID YOU UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION???? That is the issue here so let’s all get together and get this petition going.
Former userFormer user14y ago#145
@mountain123 said:
if you used balanced scorecard in (a), what was your answer to (c)?



Mate, I haven't structured my answer useing bulding blocks/balance scorecard, just mentioned that it would have been useful since in part a) we are asked to suggest also improve to presentation and content of the report. I said that it lacks of all areas, except financial one, from building blocks and discussed the other areas in a general way but slighty applicable to the case.

In part c) - I was focussing on aspects that company should insist and also suggested reasonable KPI's as: quality/customer sadisfaction- KPI: surveys, no. of complaints and so on; emplyees motivation- staff turnover, trainings hours per emplyee and so on.
Basically I've suggested that if they manage to find a resonable KPI (which is a measure ) they could get improvements in these areas and support future growth.

As you can see answers were differently, although focused on same areas but from different angles.
Former userFormer user14y ago#146
regarding Q1 C what measured gets done.

there are several ways to answer this question, for example,

key performance indicator

balanced scorecard


if you donot believe use google to find out you can type both what measured gets done balanced scorecard
Former userFormer user14y ago#147
i did not apply any model in Q1(c) what gets measured gets done either. i just explained "what gets measured get done". i wrote how the performance report was full of financial data and there was nothing about the non financial aspects of the business including customer feedback, list of most and least favourite/profitable items on Metis's menu etc.......
and i dont remember very well, but i guess i did write a sentence that Metis could use balanced scorecard to include other non financial stuff in its report
Former userFormer user14y ago#148
@darthvader001
yes please do write about the absence of MIRR formula on the question paper. really super ambiguous question requirements, lengthy case studies, and the complete absurdity and abnormality of the Q4, benchmarking.
almost all requirements contained 14-15 marks on average i guess..... the marks were not split into shorter requirement and that made the paper very difficult to handle. i think there is no P5 past paper structured in such a manner.
Lliveson285197514y ago#149
My greatest worry is that the paper is turning to be a punishment than an exam. Question 1(ii) to me was unfair as the mark allocation was not equated to the requirements unless i missed the interpretation. The paper was tough in that eventhough some were in the articles but there seemed difficult to apply to the scenarios given. For those who will pass good luck!!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#150
Hi DarthVader..

If you need some help compiling a formal complaint letter please let me know, am happy to help! I think rather than talk about individual questions and talk in detail about the issues with the questions, the focus should be on the wording of the requirements and how none of the questions in the BPP Revision Kit was worded in such manner.

There are websites where we can set up a online petition, where we can put up the link here and on other P5 forums and send out to everyone to fill in their details.

There is no harm in doing this... probably a 1% chance anything will happen but we may get lucky!

:)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.