Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** P5 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P5 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P5 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Sspencerli14y ago#31
@barky said:
i honestly have no idea if anything i wrote was correct now.some things seemed to make sense at the time but fluffed it on Eva and mirr and on other calculations. at first glance the questions seemed okay but they were not straightforward. my main problem i think was writing my discussionsas they seemed tofly all over the shop.i hope i did just enough but it will be touch and go... roll on p6!.... not...!


Ditto.

Thought that was tough, but managed to write something at the time.

Could go either way.
Former userFormer user14y ago#32
i did not study six sigma and i had no idea what it was. i was familiar with benchmarking, and so i chose q4 over q3. but it was a disaster. i did not know what to do with it... and how to use the cost drivers and the other given information.

q1 was easily understandable. but i messed up in its second requirement. the 1st and 3rd were ok.
Former userFormer user14y ago#33
Q1(a) what is to discuss?!
Former userFormer user14y ago#34
Alex Watt should be hanged! Not to die, but just to evaluate the question: "should he be hang or should be not"? Please add improvements to this :)

He is ridiculous! 25 people after the exam, were still wondering: what was the question?

I want to officially start collecting names, in order to officially complain (as a Group) to ACCA. THIS EXAMINER HAS TO GO !! And never to be heard again!!!

HE HAS NO REAL LIFE EXPERIENCE (not one ! day worked, only as frrelance lecturer and other bla bla). He has no idea how a Company works. And his scenarios are just plain stupid ! Plus, the requirements, only him and his mother know what they are!! What was Q1 c) talking about? Performance Pyramid? Building Blocks? How they should be applied, given the HUGE amount of non-sense info from the question?

HE HAS TO GO !!!! NOT EVEN ONE MORE EXAM WITH ALEX WATT !!
Former userFormer user14y ago#35
Who voted "Easy"? I see 9 votes!
Please share with us what was easy and how you tackled the problems! People who "think" the am was OK, but, so bad, they did not managed to work all 4 problems, should vote how they did, not how they think they could have done !
Former userFormer user14y ago#36
1) What was the answer to question 1 a? DId have anything to do with non financial issues?
2) They ask to do MIRR in question 1 b, but the formula wasn't provided? I looked twice on my question paper and it wasn't there? In Bpp notes it says that formula will be given in exam.

3) What on earth was question 1 c about?

Finally, what was the answer to question 4, a and b, benchmarking?
Dduvor14y ago#37
I think Alex has done well this time,His articles prism,benchmarking and how to read the exam questions have help a lot. I hope to pass this time and qualfied.
Former userFormer user14y ago#38
I wrote something like 5forces n pestel to evaluate co performance in Q1a, dunno its work or not...nothing to talk abt the REPORT... and Q1c what gets measure get done? I rili gt no time to THINK wat kind of question is this!!!!
Ggudluck14y ago#39
@darthvader001 said:
Alex Watt should be hanged! Not to die, but just to evaluate the question: "should he be hang or should be not"? Please add improvements to this :)

He is ridiculous! 25 people after the exam, were still wondering: what was the question?

I want to officially start collecting names, in order to officially complain (as a Group) to ACCA. THIS EXAMINER HAS TO GO !! And never to be heard again!!!

HE HAS NO REAL LIFE EXPERIENCE (not one ! day worked, only as frrelance lecturer and other bla bla). He has no idea how a Company works. And his scenarios are just plain stupid ! Plus, the requirements, only him and his mother know what they are!! What was Q1 c) talking about? Performance Pyramid? Building Blocks? How they should be applied, given the HUGE amount of non-sense info from the question?

HE HAS TO GO !!!! NOT EVEN ONE MORE EXAM WITH ALEX WATT !!


Sorry bro, but your post cracked me up after dead sadness for the past 2 hours.
:D

That paper was the worst of my life. Only miracle can save me :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#40
It was as predictable as the technical articles published. Q2 and Q4 on benchmark. Performance prism in Q2.
In deed Q1 required to criticise the chief accountant and his opinion on using such measures on past performance. There is actually no point in doing such a thing. Did anyone noticed that the forecast was wrongly prepared by charging the full amount of the investment to upgrade the building in the next year income statement. I have to admint it was tricky. Overall the question was to debate a verry detailed income statement which was in deed poorly prepared. I to admit it that i was not able to associate the saying "what gets measured gets done" with a specific performance model but i tried something. Overall the Q1 tricky and easy to get lost from the requirements. It asked to compute relevant income statement KPIs from the most recent period available. This is because the income statement provided was for the previous three years and forecasted for the next year and past two quarters, This was scarry, one page of meaningless data.

Q2 was on airline company. It required to compute some indicators and to benchmark with two other competitors. And the application of a performance prism model to develop performance drivers and measurements.

The optional questions were on benchmarking, the steps taken in banchmarking process and evalution of the current details. The last question on a performance management issues in a new click to click business model,
More tricky than difficult.
Ggudluck14y ago#41
@jiupay123 said:
I wrote something like 5forces n pestel to evaluate co performance in Q1a, dunno its work or not...nothing to talk abt the REPORT... and Q1c what gets measure get done? I rili gt no time to THINK wat kind of question is this!!!!


I thought we had to assess the report format. The information provided therein, as in not analysis, but the headings, what further information was required, what was not right with the format of the report n stuff. Coz i've seen one very similar question in BPP relating to info overload.
Aangryhamtaro14y ago#42
Alex Watt's approach was you consider the big picture of the measurement system. What is it that is wrong? What measures are missing and do not add strategic value to the business? Question 1 states that the founders are overloaded with data, and ask you to simplify it. Question 3 was the benefits and problems of the benchmarking (as it compared to three universities with almost similar size and nature, and in which their benchmarking wasn't easily understandable and did not identify best practices for GU. It should be made clearer if data were segregated to economy, efficiency and effectiveness given that the govt is cutting expenditure to the public universities due to tough recession).

So Alex Watt's approach was 'Do you understand the model thoroughly?' and how you can use models to give more effective measures. Q1 was made tough beause there was no models indicated, so would have give room for thinking: Can I apply performance pyramid? Three founders are focusing on three distinct areas. Can I apply benchmarking? I see a product portfolio, isn't BCG relevant? I see a large area in costs buildup, should I use ABC to understand my cost drivers? The data were dominantly financial and quantitative, what if I use balanced scorecard? How am I doing good against my budget, since my gross profit has been constant 66%? Isn't it unfair to evaluate the performance appraisal of the founders based on responsibility areas that they have no control?

Question 1(c) was how employees can be guided to do work through measures - hence implementing the KPI system with rewards backing can help them achieve the measures to achieve the org's goals. The balanced scorecard can help structure this KPI system. However, there is the danger of measure fixation, and could lead to a dysfunctional behaviour of meeting measures to meet the bonus.

I agree, the question was dreadfully not specific. But it gives room for analytical creativity! And I hope it'd be translated to good marks, fingers crossed... :S
Mmountain12314y ago#43
I am so happy that I am not the only one who feels the examiner is abnormal...LOL!!!

Actually I felt this way before taking the exam...hahaha
Former userFormer user14y ago#44
1a. Critical assessment of a (an awkward) performance report prepared by some guys running a chain of restaurant. We r to criticize the content and structure of the report.
1b. The guy (boss) required that we (mgt accountant) calculate NPV (3yrs to date), EVA and MIRR (modified IRR) using those "awkward" data. And other profit-based measures of our choice using 2012 data only
1c. We r also to comment on "what gets measured gets done" mentioned by one of the guys in the scenario. I think those r the words of Peter Drucker.


2a.Performance appraisal of some 3 airlines. Listed, private and govt funded.
2b. Apply performance prism. Honestly there r loads of info about stakeholders in the scenario.


3a. Implementation of six sigma to address errors/mistakes in a telecom company. They have been accused of mis-allocating call costs to wrong numbers.
3b. Apply DMAIC approach in the implementation of six sigma


4a. Bench-marking of three universities (AU, BU and GU) that submitted information on their administrative costs to the govt. It was functional bench-marking, we r to assess the progress of the bench-marking process; what has been done to date and what actions to take next.
4b. Evaluate the bench-marked position of GU.
Former userFormer user14y ago#45
Q1 nothing to talk abt the case study~ except what gets measured gets done
Former userFormer user14y ago#46
still laughing at the alex watt must go lol tough exam flicked through it and thought this is gona be a breeze with the topics but when i actually started to think about it it was tough.. hoping for the magic 50%
Former userFormer user14y ago#47
I think the exam was fair. Q1 was the trickiest as there was a lot that you could say and could easily go off track and overrun on time.

I agree with other members on here that the articles published really helped for benchmarking and performance prism.

My difficulty was making enough valid points and not waffling. I hope I have done enough.
Former userFormer user14y ago#48
Q1a) was this not a evaluation of the report, eg to much info for report. So break down categories so alcohol for wine, beer and spirits. So easier to read. If want to drill roll down then can think mis and eis.

Manager salary should of been added to staff costs etc

Q1b) Npv, Eva, didn't know mirr
Other FINANCIAL indicators include RI and ROI and strengths weaknesses.

Q2) performance prism

Q4) benchmarking they had done only financial data no non financial. So had to gather info on say pass rates etc

They had no further info on revenue streams so need to get this also.

Q5) probable easiest question and noticed not many people did it, basically employees worked from home, couldn't control quality, think dimensions in building block.

Performance management, hard because little control over all processes.
Former userFormer user14y ago#49
For Q1 - I read the question thoroughly for 15mins, didn't know where to start from till I got inspired.
1) I criticized the way he muddled up the statement, like no addition or subtraction sign, he didn't deduct tax from PBIT, he was silent as to what constituted staff cost, an appendix should have aided his report to improve understandability by users of the report. When I was short of points, I had to include it didn't confirm with IAS1.
:) I could only calculate NPV, then I included Net profit margin, Gross profit margin, ROI, Operating cost to revenue ratio.
C) I wrote something about they didn't know their minimum order quantity, they should more planning and analysis, get their EOQ, Reorder Level and Reorder quantity right, They should approach a JIT system for food produce with perishable quality

2) I did fairly on the Performance prism, I wrote the five out then applied to the scenario. I identified the stakeholders as Investors, employees, booking agent and customers.
:) Appraisal of the airlines, I did sme analysis on their passengers, revenue, no of aircraft, Cheapo lifted more passengers, had lower profit and lesser aircraft. I calculated the percentage of this to others and some analysis I forgot to present on m examination shed but did with my calculator, I had 1hr left and I was still on No 2. So I had to write what u could.

3) I attempted DMAIC, I only knew the acronymn, and I was tempted to cancel and go for No 5 whic I didn't like eventually but it was late to cancel out.

4) I defined benchmarking to see If I can gain easy marks, listed types and pointed out this was external. I picked other point such as teachers facilities management, ratio of students to staffs, I wrote whatever came into my mind, what the marker needs to do is to mark what's relevant to him. No harm in trying. Then the information needed should have included number of students in each department, and about two more points I can't remember now.

:) Then to evaluate the benchmarked position, I compared the research cost to the research contract value received since I the revenue driver, GU didn't do more of research despite getting the bulk of the research contract value, then wrote some points also.

5) I had 15mins more, I wrote its a Internet based business and down time wouldn't have made them perform and some other points then the partners could encounter delivery delays and they might not meet the SLAs

I don't we t to write this paper again, I need to qualify... I pray God gives me the 51% of my dreams.
Mmountain12314y ago#50
what does Q1(1) ask? why did I see "assess existing performance...."

what's the 4 professional mark for?
Former userFormer user14y ago#51
I second to most of whats been said before me... Specially the fact that the scenario's were easy to understand but the requirements were confusing... n question 1 was probably the most difficult one with too much calculative info given and confusing requirements...
what i did in q1c) in 'what gets measured, gets done' is that i simply highlighted the mistakes/issues of waiters not smiling ,food not served at right temperature and food wasted and pointed out that according to the quote...if kpi were put on these issues than they would be resolved eg if questionnaire's were given to customers with such questions regarding service of waiter n stuff then the waiters would be mindful of smiling n serving food at right temp....Also the fact that electricity issue was resolved seconded my point as it can and is measured and therefore the target in its case was achieved so if similarly measurable targets are put in other issues, they would also be resolved just as the quote says... what gets measured, gets done...
This is probably the only part of my answers that made logical sense...:P
Aangryhamtaro14y ago#52
The 4 professional marks for report format - To, From, Date, Subject, Introduction paragraph, Headings, Conclusion, and Appendix.
Former userFormer user14y ago#53
..total disaster for me, Alex Watt is not fair at all........
Mmountain12314y ago#54
@angryhamtaro said:
The 4 professional marks for report format - To, From, Date, Subject, Introduction paragraph, Headings, Conclusion, and Appendix.



yeah I also think so...

hey guys I thought Q1(a) asked us to assess the company's existing performance??? so I compared 2012 figures with 2011 and 2010... the question says calculate something....if it meant the format, content etc of the report were wrong, why need calculations??? did I misunderstand the question???!! my gosh....definitely gonna fail....
Aangryhamtaro14y ago#55
Chillax, and move on :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#56
Hahahahaha !!!

Every answer on Q1 has its own logic and are in different direction, but all are "confident they passed" and "pray God". Well, pray harder, because logic tells me that 1 one you might be right, rest of you will read again "What Alex Watt means when he says the word "evaluate", which for him means to do 1,001 KPI's.

Join the Group ALEX WATT HAS TO GO !!

Seriously, how you feel about studying xx number of hours, paying xxx £ on courses and, 6 HOURS AFTER THE EXAM STILL WANDERING WHAT WAS THE CORRECT ANSWER AND WHAT YOU HAVE SHOULD APPLY!

This is OUTRAGEOUS, he is mocking us all!
I have lost 2 years trying to pass this exam !! ENOUGH !!
Hoe many of you noticed that last session P5 has THE LOWEST RATE OF ALL ACCA EXAMS IN THE LAST 8 SESSIONS !?!?
SSatesh14y ago#57
@mountain123 said:
yeah I also think so...

hey guys I thought Q1(a) asked us to assess the company's existing performance??? so I compared 2012 figures with 2011 and 2010... the question says calculate something....if it meant the format, content etc of the report were wrong, why need calculations??? did I misunderstand the question???!! my gosh....definitely gonna fail....


Ur rite... u r a deadman!!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#58
Question was not hard but confusing type of requirement,, and due to tym pressure it was difficult to analyse from different angle as question required. And another thing scenarios were too long for 3 hours question paper
Former userFormer user14y ago#59
q1 a) performance indicators / evaluate content and imrprovents to current report

this was easy - improvements, no non financial considerations, or benchmarking.used. Presentation no narrative summary to help people understand it, the two other people said didnt understand list of numbers etc etc

calculations - npv 3 year appraisal (mine turned out negative and i didnt include depreciation as wasnt incremental cash flow). MIRR simple calculation. EVA simple calculation, said depreciation i assume was economic and didnt add back marketing as it was short term. include ROCE too. then did adv/dis of each.

1c) the quote - i applied balance scorecard + mentioned a couple of things on top of it

2) kpi's airline. this was easy, and 3rd one was cheap airline so reasons for differences.

b) performance prism - i drew it and explained each element of it. struggled to apply it well though!


3) DMAIC - thought a and b were basically same. wrote alot and applied though

4) benchmarking, kinda ran out of time. tried to compare with what i had but said limitations of data etc, kinda combined a and b together again here too!
Former userFormer user14y ago#60
I made a complete mess of the paper.
Wasted a lot of time trying to figure out exactly what was being asked. I just gave up and blanked out after a while.
I'm so defeated right now.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.