Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

APM*** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P5 December 2015 Exam.

*** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about P5 exam below
Former userFormer user10y ago#61
@suhaybbeig22 said: Can anyone suggest what the hell were we suppose to do with the Porter's 5 forces in Question 4 i think it was! One of the threats identified of new entrants in the market was social media marketing to lower prices? HOW THE HELL ON EARTH WERE WE SUPPOSE TO SUGGEST A PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT MEASURE FOR THAT, I AM STILL THINKING ABOUT IT AND CAN'T THINK STRAIGHT ON THIS LOL I think it will be touch and go lol hopefully lol
This is so funny...we all seem to have the same problem. Lol
Former userFormer user10y ago#62
No illusions... this paper always has pass rate less than 30%, now I understand why :) Q2 was awful, none like this was in BPP revison kit... Q4 was for those on drugs. Read requirements 5 times, did not understand what the hell should be written... Q3 was more or less, but still you write smth and you understand that it is not what you should write about... I really liked Q1, even with total miss on EVA recalculations.
Jjerma10y ago#63
It was a total disaster for me. I didn't read the scenario for question 2 before deciding to attempt it with 30 mins remaining. I was left blank for a few minutes as I didn't know where to start. I am praying for 50. @seagoat is that the first time writing p5?
Former userFormer user10y ago#64
@zohaib8100 said: And in transfer pricing concluded that company would have taken more loss as moving to full cost approach suggested by govt
Exactly... there maybe some trick in terminology, like total cost is not same as full cost. All through the paper I was making funny conclusions and therefore left the hall in good mood :) will be happy to be back in March :)
Sseagoat10y ago#65
@jerma Yes Jerma this was my first touch with P5. Now I remember the pass rates for P5 so definitely March awaiting.
CChikumbutso10y ago#66
I think question 2 was the worst and thank God I told my friend before entering the hall that no way was I going to attempt a question on transfer pricing and when I saw it I just didn't bother reading it. Question 4 I couldn't believe it was the same Porter's 5 Forces I know...so terrible and I believe I wrote nothing sensible!!! surely this examiner has a way of making things difficult for others. Really??? the same Porter's 5 Forces we all know!!!!
Rrashid10y ago#67
any1 removed economic depreciation on the operating lease?
AAlexandra10y ago#68
@wan : you are right...in the rush to write I interpreted wrong the percentage ... It îs indeed 1:1 debt to equity , another mistake :(
Rrashid10y ago#69
i remember a question in bpp exam kit where the ratio of deb/equity was 30%. This question was asked on this forum not long ago as far as i remember. If it is 30% ,then ve +vd is 130 which means 100 for equity. If it is 100%, then it should have been 200% where 100% for equity. And btw a company financed 100% by debt is impossible lol.
Former userFormer user10y ago#70
@taisha said: No illusions... this paper always has pass rate less than 30%, now I understand why :) Q2 was awful, none like this was in BPP revison kit... Q4 was for those on drugs. Read requirements 5 times, did not understand what the hell should be written... Q3 was more or less, but still you write smth and you understand that it is not what you should write about... I really liked Q1, even with total miss on EVA recalculations.
@taisha hahahahaha I did attempt q4 and surely wish I was on drugs looooool
MMo10y ago#71
Lol!! Seems as though there were common areas which everyone tripped up on! Glad we get results in 5ish weeks! Onto Tax Tomorrow!!!!!!
SSean10y ago#72
Overall I thought Q1 was fair. Part (a) on EVA had some fairly standard adjustments and the 6 marker on CSFs and the weaknesses of the existing KPIs was fair too e.g. one weakness of the units per hour produced was that the product mix was different as they had some mass produced products and some specialised ones i.e. you'll get different throughputs depending on the mix. For Q2 I was hoping transfer pricing would come up where you had a typical scenario with spare capacity and the transfer price being the opportunity cost = VC + lost contribution ... this one was in an international context which I didn't really revise :| ... even still I think I bagged most of the marks in part (a) assuming its 2 marks per explained point and some working marks in part (b). Part (c) was ok as well. The balanced scorecard question had a lot of information to digest but overall I thought it was ok as well. Oh well, crossing my fingers for a pass for P5 and P7 .. I'll be done forever then!
Former userFormer user10y ago#73
Oh, I thought this was my falt that I didn't do well, as I had onlt practiced in revision mainly passed exam paper (this was my 2nd attempt), however as I read comments, I see that everyone has similar feelings from the exam. :( I wrote a lot but not sure that this was fully relevant, correct or enough :( But anyway, the hope dirs last. Wish I have scrapped to 50 marks.
Wwan10y ago#74
the wording of the question for q4 were really confusing. firsr they ask you how the 5 forces can be used to manage the forces. then they ask you to assess the difficulties im defining n measuring the forces. i mean, how the hell are we going to use the 5 forces to manage the existing forces. i have to read the question so many times but still unable to identify what is exactly the examiner want. is this an english paper or p5?...i'm wondering.
Mmehmood10y ago#75
Looked fine to me until I went through questions but when took the pen and started scenario, mind was completely black out. Completely shut down. I thought I know very well TP, EVA, BSC, Five Forces and but when started scenario, have no idea how to match them. Oon the basis of requirements and scenario data, I just started writing and not sure whether its relevant or not, even its an answer of the question or not? Did 85% and then time was up.
Former userFormer user10y ago#76
Did Q1 wasn't too bad.. not sure though that I addressed all parts of each requirement. EVA was higher debt/equity=100% thus they are equal the adjustment in WACC was to use the post tax cost of debt and I got WACC as 10.38% =(16× 0.5) +((6.8×0.7)×0.5) NOPAT think was 479.2 adjustments added back marketing for the two years, and the 40 for operating leases, used actual tax paid, added back R&D 10 expensed in the current year, took off depreciation for the operating lease 28.8 (115/4) Capital employed, think about 2406.1 used opening value capital employed added marketing for one year added operating lease less one year depreciation and deferred tax Q2. not my cup of tea. Q3 was okay, also got 540 more passangers for region A at peak times and was the only time it was overcrowded Q4 was so confusing in part a, part b has been examined before I think the changing role of the Management accountant. My main problem is time pressure... to read and understand the requirements then read the scenario, then when writing to ensure all parts of the requirements have been answered and all in good handwriting for 3 hours!! I think I've done enough but might be wrong
Ttsar10y ago#77
Paper was horrible today! Probably the worst I've seen from this examiner so far. Someone rightly said the requirements seemed like the movie 'inception'. I think I did okay with Q1a, messed up in KPIs and costing approaches part. How else would you measure innovation if not through the number of new products? Thought I did okay in 3a until I read 3c, then I was just doomed thinking what else to write since I covered all aspects in the first part. Q4 looked cake until I hadn't read and tried to attempt it. Lost a lot of time so I couldn't have switched to Q2. Crazy crazy paper.
Sseagoat10y ago#78
And now recall the pass rates floating around 30%...
Jjerma10y ago#79
I am trying my best to be hopeful that I got 50. It's amazing that everyone shares the same sentiment about the exam. I was really looking forward to a question on integrated reporting.
ZZohaib10y ago#80
Who is managed a 540 overcrowded ??? And please tell me about transfer pricing question .. did any one concluded that changing transfer pricing would have impact a increase in loss in Cleland ?
AAlexandra10y ago#81
@ruth12 said NOPAT think was 479.2 adjustments added back marketing for the two years, and the 40 for operating leases, used actual tax paid, added back R&D 10 expensed in the current year, took off depreciation for the operating lease 28.8 (115/4)
Why would you depreciate operational leasing as ownership is transfered in the end to the leasee? The leaser should account for depreciation as far as I remember
Llatoyah10y ago#82
625 for region A during peak (2500/4) less the 7*70 seat capacity (625-490) 135 passengers didn't have any seat. For the transfer price question using full cost would increase the profits reported by the RM divisional managers but those in Hoots cost would be even more since the will have a higher cost per unit plus 8% tarifs. the increase cost in a competitive market will mean loss of sales for Hoot.
CChico10y ago#83
Guys i sat this paper in glasgow today.... They were playing contineous loud dance music through out the exam ( from a party downstairs)... I ended up having a panic attack and for sure have failed this paper . Like many in this hall i have complained bitterly to acca in writing as this should never have been allowed to happen. It was such an awful paper and to have some party blaring music and i do mean blaring gave most of us no hope. Put it this way . Invigilators nearly had a riot on there hands and calculators were nearly launched as 120 of us struggled through this impossible paper .. Gutted absolutely exhausted and gutted
Llatoyah10y ago#84
@alexandrastanca said: Why would you depreciate operational leasing as ownership is transfered in the end to the leasee? The leaser should account for depreciation as far as I remember
for EVA all leases operating or finance are treated as finance. since a figure was not given for economic depreciation and it is can be assumed that the economic depreciation is 115/4, further assumption could be that the 40 charged as lease should be added back and the economic depreciation removed. (all that said - i honestly dont know if i did all that in exam)
ZZohaib10y ago#85
540 overcrowded I am not sure how did I get it . On transfer pricing moving to full cost will result in lost benefit of tax on the loss (sale690-cost 690) results in zero profit or loss hence no tax benefit or expense . Under marginal costing (price 629- COST 690) loss 61 (TAX BENEFIT ON LOSS (18.30) (61*30%)
MManuela10y ago#86
How did you all calculate Eva? It really sent me into a massive spin of failure thoughts, then run out of time because I overrun on Q1 and Q3 and Q4 were a lot more difficult than they first appeared. I rambled on about anything I could think of on the subject hoping to pick up random points but presentation was messy and due to time constraints I only attempted 80%.... Will I have done enough? I felt confident when I walked in the hall and felt crushed by the end of the 3 hours. :(
Llatoyah10y ago#87
Overall I believe that the exam is all that I thought it would be ( a very hard, time pressured paper, ambiguous requirements that can be interpreted based on the reader). The EVA calculation was a God send as at least i can receive some marks from that. the rest of question one CSFs and KPIs while it is somewhat expected i believe explaining then apply the three new manufacturing system to all three that's a bit time consuming. ran out of time for the final requirement Q2 and 3 where the other two i attempted. while Q3 looked easy enough as Balance score card was tested in F5 and P3 it was a bit difficult to put the points in as the CEO didnt want measurement but how it would improve the performance - it was quite easy to get off track again the calculation of the overcrowding issue was a saving grace. unfortunately i ran out of time before being able to do justice to the final requirement. i hope for a 50, wish the same for all of you
CChris10y ago#88
Frustrating that even though you can have a sound knowledge of the syllabus the examiner includes questions that are designed to confuse and to be completely ambiguous. Question4 was a prime example. This paper didn't test understand of the syllabus if only tested how dast you can read, write and interpret nonsense questions. Feels line a big brick wall in the way of ACCA qualification!!!
ZZohaib10y ago#89
@latoyah84 said: Overall I believe that the exam is all that I thought it would be ( a very hard, time pressured paper, ambiguous requirements that can be interpreted based on the reader). The EVA calculation was a God send as at least i can receive some marks from that. the rest of question one CSFs and KPIs while it is somewhat expected i believe explaining then apply the three new manufacturing system to all three that's a bit time consuming. ran out of time for the final requirement Q2 and 3 where the other two i attempted. while Q3 looked easy enough as Balance score card was tested in F5 and P3 it was a bit difficult to put the points in as the CEO didnt want measurement but how it would improve the performance - it was quite easy to get off track again the calculation of the overcrowding issue was a saving grace. unfortunately i ran out of time before being able to do justice to the final requirement. i hope for a 50, wish the same for all of you
540 overcrowded I am not sure how did I get it . On transfer pricing moving to full cost will result in lost benefit of tax on the loss (sale690-cost 690) results in zero profit or loss hence no tax benefit or expense . Under marginal costing (price 629- COST 690) loss 61 (TAX BENEFIT ON LOSS (18.30) (61*30%)
Rrodina8610y ago#90
also 257
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.