APM*** P5 December 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
I'm quite annoyed at how time pressured this exam was!
Q1 just had too much within it and took me way longer to complete. I chose option Q3 & Q4. Q3 was quite nice and i feel like it may be the only thing which switches me to a pass mark! Q4 was actually quite unfair and set you up for a fail, however the management accountant part of Q4 might've got me some decent marks.
Overall I felt there was just too much information to get through and too many parts to each twisted question which meant time allocation went out the window!! I can now see why this exam has such a low pass rate
Can anyone suggest what the hell were we suppose to do with the Porter's 5 forces in Question 4 i think it was!
One of the threats identified of new entrants in the market was social media marketing to lower prices?
HOW THE HELL ON EARTH WERE WE SUPPOSE TO SUGGEST A PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT MEASURE FOR THAT, I AM STILL THINKING ABOUT IT AND CAN'T THINK STRAIGHT ON THIS LOL
I think it will be touch and go lol hopefully lol
How did you guys calculated the wacc ?? I assumed the company was 100%. Geared and took 5% as wacc
.16*0/100+ .0476*100/100 =4.76% OR 5% AS round off wacc
The transfer pricing calculation were straight forward for me but I struggled last part of the q2,
6 marks for bsc was also managed quite well as online peak time overcrowded by 540 seats
I left the transfer pricing question and literally waffled on part 1 on question 1 of EVA so no idea about WACC, I just did some random add and subtract and came up with a +183.1 on EVA and then just commented on it hoping to get something out of that lol
I did not take the amortisation of marketing expens just added 46.2 two years expense as no time frame was given for marketing to amortize the expense
To be honest I didn't consider the WACC in question 1 - saw that debt/equity was 100% and left it at that, didn't want to confuse myself anymore.
Anyone remember the rest of question 1? Analysis of the CSF and associated KPI? And something about the introduction of a new IT system?
the wacc calculation needs some adjustment on cost of debt after tax as this was not calculated on the original wacc computation.
At least one good news is transfer pricing should not appear in March :)
for WACC I think debt needed adjustment for tax.
Please don't confuse me the resultant cost of equity should be zero if the company was100% geared
it doesn't make sense for a company to be 100% finance through debt. didn't they mention the cost of equity in the case. 100% geared means they don't have any equity at all.
Wasnt this 100% Ratio D/E? so like 1/1 ? so its fifty fifty - this is how I understood this.
nice to see that I am not alone in this cruel world of ACCA))))
Concentrated on Q3 and Q1, keeping in mind that the Q4 is ok..."oh, it is Porter, 30mins will be enough". Ended up with no comments made on the first requirement, some vague points on the second part.
My EVA was around 253, however, coming home I found mistake in calculation. I have deducted marketing expense from Capital OB.
In addition, Operating lease seems weird for me: P/L it is 40, in Capital 115? Who can explain why? What i did is assume 115 was capitalized by junior, so I added 40 to 115 and divided by 4 to come up to depreciation. I feel it is not ok.
What is required on p-level is time management. Too many requirements within limited time. In addition, the requirements are so confusing, trying to mislead you- so ACCA has chance to comment again "read requirements, answer to the question"))
Anyway, I am waiting for my first fail)
@seagoat said: Wasnt this 100% Ratio D/E? so like 1/1 ? so its fifty fifty - this is how I understood this.WACC is based on E/(D+E) and D/(D+E), therefore, 1/2 is right.
@Aynura
Thanks for confirmation at least half of mark in pocket.
I tried to keep my report format in q1 as professional as possible and get 4 free marks and hope to get them lol ???
operating lease is recorded the same for each year...then, the total operating lease would be 40x4 years = 160m. in capital employed, we only add back the remaining balance of future lease payment. As 40m has already being paid, the balance would be 120m in capital employed. this is what i did. don't know whether it is correct or not.
If the company has 100% gearing,it means it has no capital and so the WACC was going to be the cost of debt adjusted for tax only?surely this is wrong.
I used the 50:50 that they used in the calculation and stated my assumption.
Am I missing something..and practically speaking,is there a company that is 100% debt financed without its own capital?
@suhaybbeig22
I think not all 4 marks are for format. The marker is looking also for logical structure and flow so I imagine that 2 marks are for 'format' and 2 marks for you logical flow and structure.
Just guessing.
@wankhaidir said: operating lease is recorded the same for each year...then, the total operating lease would be 40x4 years = 160m. in capital employed, we only add back the remaining balance of future lease payment. As 40m has already being paid, the balance would be 120m in capital employed. this is what i did. don't know whether it is correct or not.Still not clear where amount of 115 in Capital Employed comes from?
@seagoat
Indeed where ever I can sneak any marks from will do the job! Wish you best of luck for your result! ??
How did you do Q2 I had no idea
i'm also not sure...too much time pressure to think where this amount was derived. i just assume it was wrongly recorded and move on...lol...it is not like the examiner will penalise you for any miscalculated figure.
@flexi said: If the company has 100% gearing,it means it has no capital and so the WACC was going to be the cost of debt adjusted for tax only?surely this is wrong. I used the 50:50 that they used in the calculation and stated my assumption. Am I missing something..and practically speaking,is there a company that is 100% debt financed without its own capital?I think 100% is not the portion of Debt in total capital. I find it like. e.g: if i have Debt -40, and Equity 40, then 40/40=1, and in percentage it will be 100%.Debt is equal to Equity. therefore, E/(D+E)= 40/(40+40)= 1/2
@wankhaidir said: i'm also not sure...too much time pressure to think where this amount was derived. i just assume it was wrongly recorded and move on...lol...it is not like the examiner will penalise you for any miscalculated figure.At least, I hoped that I will get 1/2 mark for it))))
Do not go with practicality in p5 . It was clearly mentioned d/e was 100% . Which means that company was financed by 100% debt
Utter disaster!!!!!!!!!! too lengthy an exam! i didn't even complete. sigh :-(
@zohaib8100 said: Do not go with practicality in p5 . It was clearly mentioned d/e was 100% . Which means that company was financed by 100% debtThen the whole question was wrong because we were calculating Eva and Eva is about increasing shareholder value...and the mission of the company was to increase shareholder value...so what shareholders are they talking about if as you say it was 100% debt financed?
if the company is financed 100% by debt, why they bother giving the cost of equity in the case? you need to look at the formula again..it is debt over equity. if equity is zero, how do you divide the debt say 10m/0....no percentage...if they get 100%, means that there is an equity value.
I am not sure I saw what I have assumed any way I have got Eva more then the calculated by junior .
What about the bsc seat accupancy I have got 540 more passenger in the peak time in region 1
And in transfer pricing concluded that company would have taken more loss as moving to full cost approach suggested by govt
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

